iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Leo W. Gerard

GET UPDATES FROM Leo W. Gerard
 

Romney Economics: Cheat Main Street

Posted: 05/28/2012 9:46 am

Mitt Romney made a boatload of money for himself and his fellow fat cats. No doubt about it. Billions. But he made it the way Americans hate most -- Wall Street style wheeling and dealing.

Americans hate it because when all that scheming went bad, when the market collapsed, it was the 99 percent who footed the bill to bailout Wall Street. The same is true of Romney and Bain. When Bain bankrupted the companies it bought -- and Bain did that shockingly often -- workers and Main Street businesses paid the price.

Romney contends his money making as CEO of Bain qualifies him to be President of the United States. That's true if Americans believe money should flow out of their pockets, out of the cash registers of Main Street shops and into the Swiss bank accounts of Romney and his 1 percenter cronies.

Here are some of Romney's victims, Main Street businesses owed money by just one bankrupted Bain company, American Pad and Paper Co. (Ampad): Technical Coatings Laboratory, owed $125,191.20 and paid in bankruptcy $237.03; Services Plus Inc., owed $12,064.71, paid $22.84; Crown Vantage, owed $32,155.26, paid $60.89.

In the 15 years Romney ran Bain from 1984 to 1999, 22 percent of the companies it invested in went bankrupt or closed within eight years, according to a study by the Wall Street Journal.

In fact, according to the Wall Street Journal, the bulk -- 70 percent -- of the $2.5 billion Bain made for investors during that time came from just 10 deals. Four of those ended up in bankruptcy as well -- killing jobs and jilting Main Street businesses. Despite that, Romney and the Bain investors fattened their Swiss bank accounts.

More Main Street victims: Lakeway Container Inc., owed $47,143.56 by Ampad, paid $89.26 in bankruptcy; Olympic Adhesives, owed $6,566, paid $12.43; American Chain and Gear, owed $505.54, paid 96 cents.

Bain's handling of Ampad illustrates how the rich extract money from these deals and leave behind wounded workers and Main Street shops. Bain bought Ampad from Mead Corp. in 1992 and added SCM Office Supplies to the holdings two years later. Like many leveraged buyout deals, these were financed with loans secured by the purchased companies' assets.

Within hours after buying SCM, Bain fired every one of its 350 workers in Marion, Ind. Bain, through Ampad, told the shocked and terrified workers they could apply for their former positions if they wanted them back -- at less pay, fewer benefits and worse working conditions.

WATCH:


One way leveraged buyout firms like Bain make money is by taking it from workers -- slashing their pay, benefits and pensions. This also makes companies look more productive, enabling buyout firms like Bain to make money on taking them public.

Bain bought SCM early in July, 1994. Within two months, the workers went out on strike, seeking restoration of some of their pay and benefits. Workers sought help from Romney, who rebuffed them as he was running for Ted Kennedy's U.S. Senate seat. After losing that race, Romney returned to Bain, permanently closed the Marion plant and moved its equipment to other Ampad facilities.

More Main Street victims of Ampad bankruptcy: Green Bay Packaging Inc., owed $75,551.92, paid $137.37; Springfield Electric, owed $3,919.88, paid $7.23; American Coffee Break Service, owed $1,349.73, paid $2.56.

Through 1999, Bain continued to be the single largest shareholder in Ampad, and three Bain executives sat on its board of directors. Ampad struggled to meet the low price demands of big box retailers - like Staples, in which Bain had also invested and where Romney sat on the board of directors.

Ampad fell into bankruptcy in 2000. Companies besieged with debt -- as Ampad was -- because of leveraged buyouts often fail because they are too weakened to deal with normal business adversity.

More Main Street victims of Ampad bankruptcy: Economy Plumbing Co., owed $1,505.69, paid $2.85; Hohner Stitching Products, owed $2,095.76, paid $3.97; Mount Tom Box Co. Inc., owed $34,351.96, paid $65.04.

When Ampad went under, it owed $182.6 million to its suppliers across America. The bankruptcy left only $328,633 to pay nearly 1,300 unsecured creditors -- that worked out to 10 cents for every $10 Ampad owed. That's how a company liked Hometown Café & Catering, owed $600.60 by Ampad, got all of $1.14. And Hometown Café received that big fat check 11 years after Ampad filed for bankruptcy.

These Main Street shops and businesses are the heart of American communities, supporting the local United Way, Little League teams and Memorial Day parades. Debts never paid mean less money for them to hire their own workers, fewer dollars for them to contribute to their communities and a higher probability they'll be forced into bankruptcy.

Bain invested $5 million in Ampad and took more than $100 million out, through numerous methods, including fees. That $100 million would have gone a long way toward paying the debts Ampad owed to Main Street businesses across the country. It wouldn't be surprising if they felt a little like Romney and Bain robbed them at gunpoint.

But everything Bain did was legal. It's Romney economics, working for the wealthy while double crossing Main Street.

 

Follow Leo W. Gerard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/uswblogger

FOLLOW POLITICS
Mitt Romney made a boatload of money for himself and his fellow fat cats. No doubt about it. Billions. But he made it the way Americans hate most -- Wall Street style wheeling and dealing. Americans ...
Mitt Romney made a boatload of money for himself and his fellow fat cats. No doubt about it. Billions. But he made it the way Americans hate most -- Wall Street style wheeling and dealing. Americans ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 261
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
07:01 PM on 05/29/2012
If the world was a simple place this article would make sense but sadly it is complex and this article is written from the perspective of someone who clearly does not understand economics and the ever changing world and economy. America has had a great run but the world is changing and in the last twenty years, with the fall of communism,the world opening, trade expanding and new forces emerging America would feel the pressure especially seeing that America is over unionized and competitive countries do not have that burden to bear. What is also not mentions is the amount of money spent on these ventures, trying to save struggling and dying businesses as the world economy was changing radically. In some cases workers were laid off so that companies could restructure and survive. Bain helped a steel Mill survive for years during a time many steel companies were failing in America due to cheap Chinese steel flooding the market. In a competitive market companies fail and companies who are better equipped succeed, it has been like so for Millennia and sad that people believe a business, which never belonged to them should be forced to succeed, this is communism and it starved more men to death than good capitalism ever has.
photo
Gestas
Mountain Man
12:26 PM on 05/29/2012
The remains of a succesful Middle Class is in Pension Plans..Thats what Bain/Romney went after. Thats where the money was...Thats what they stole.
photo
Jimserac
ONE from Many ...
11:44 AM on 05/29/2012
"I'M A BUSINESSMAN!" SAYS "Mitt" !!

"Within hours after buying SCM, Bain fired every one of its 350 workers in Marion, Ind.

THE ABOVE IS A SAMPLE of "Mitt's" "business" experience.

There is plenty to criticize Obama about, but he has done a few good things, and been BLOCKED in everything else by Republicans hell bent on gaining control, control AT ANY COST, even at the cost of undermining the strategic position of the United States, even at the cost of undermining an economy already weakened by the actions of other Republicans and their "bailouts", (and their Demo sympathizers), even at the cost of destroying the futures of our entire younger generations while simultaneously profiteering from their attempts at higher education with loan contracts and rules that would embarrass a Mafia loan shark.

A foreign policy of treasury busting WARS coupled with make believe "security" coupled with the DEMAND that they keep their tax "cuts", coupled with an evisceration of the middle class who Republicans despise for their decades long upward mobility, their independent challenge to the corporatist interregnum of government protected freedom from competition, tax "breaks" and loopholes, special protected deals, and the establishment of a new neo-feudalist class exempt from normal laws and taxations while the rest of us are demoted to "serf" status. Oh don't worry, the Demos are not without sin either but...

THAT is the philosophy behind "Mitt" the "businessman". STILL want to vote for him??
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:09 AM on 05/29/2012
Thanks Leo -- great and important article!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
A1percenttaxpayer
09:05 AM on 05/29/2012
Don't know why I can't respond to Bella but he is calling for armed assault on the 1% H.P. is this allowed. Well if it ever comes I'm prepared enough food in my warehouse for 6 months for 20 people. And enough ammo and weapons for just as long I honestly believe the 99%ers will have groups that try this maybe 5-10 at a time it will be pathetic and end the movement for ever. Can't wait for the trials of these losers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dweav
12:19 PM on 05/29/2012
Disillusioned much?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
A1percenttaxpayer
08:56 AM on 05/29/2012
Warning atacks on Romneys history at bain capital are not working there backfiring according to internal Obama polling. Romney wasn't at Bain during ampad keep up the good work with your help Romney will definitely get elected. Do I think you will believe me or the stories that back this up NO. And I think it's funny as hell that your rhetoric is hurting your canadate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dev Austin
Haters are my motivators
09:46 AM on 05/29/2012
You didn't read the article did you?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
A1percenttaxpayer
10:10 AM on 05/29/2012
I went back and read article did not change my opinion when you by a buisness that's in trouble you can't expect to turn it around every time. Also if I was in his situation I too would limit my risk from the company's debt.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
09:47 AM on 05/29/2012
Um, no. Romney WAS at Bain during Ampad. He left in 1999. Ampad went bankrupt a few months later. You actually think he had nothing to do with that. Get a grip on reality.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Valko
08:02 AM on 05/29/2012
" when the market collapsed, it was the 99 percent who footed the bill to bailout Wall Street." Correction, it was Bush and Obama who extorted money from the 99 percent to bailout Wall Street. Let's put blame where it really belongs, on the politicians that are supposed to be looking out for the 99 percent. That's right, Bush bailed out the banks, and Obama bailed out big corporations with our money. You think there is a difference between democrats and republicans. Not a bit. They SAY different things, but once in office DO the same things, namely spend more than they take in.
08:40 AM on 05/29/2012
Let's be completely accurate. Politicians can only do what their corporate funding masters lobby for. The Republiclones do so willingly, the Democratic politicians with regret. And there is a difference. If there wasn't, big business would stop funding both parties. They love Republicans for a reason.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
09:49 AM on 05/29/2012
Again, NO. The Wall Street bailout occurred during Bush. Requested on his watch; approved by Congress on his watch. Obama used some of that money to rescue the auto industry instead of spending it all on Wall Street. So, here's the difference: Bush bailed out the 1 percenters; Obama rescued working men and women in Detroit after bad business decisions by their companies and by Wall Street sank 2/3 of the American auto industry.
photo
syrinx14
Grapes of Wrath page252
04:23 AM on 05/29/2012
legalized stealing. Sorry but I can't vote for Romney. I don't want America to be run like Bain.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Valko
08:03 AM on 05/29/2012
It already is. Obama spent 800 billion of our money bailing out big corporations.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dev Austin
Haters are my motivators
09:53 AM on 05/29/2012
Thank goodness.
photo
syrinx14
Grapes of Wrath page252
03:27 AM on 05/31/2012
How many billions did Hank and W have the Fed insure/buy up mortgages and securities to save the banks? A: The Fed was allowed to purchase up to $700 Billion. to the Banksters. W gave Billions to the Banksters.

The Stimulus Package? Which by many economists estimate was not big enough:
•$288 billion in tax cuts.
•$224 billion in extended unemployment benefits, education and health care.
•$275 billion for job creation using federal contracts, grants and loans.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jamie Schler
Writer at Life's a Feast & Huff Post blogger.
03:17 AM on 05/29/2012
GWB and his Harvard MBA also ran several big corporations and companies, yet people seemed not to care that he ran them all into the ground. Being a businessman in charge of companies seems to be all that matters to Republican voters. And seriously, does making billions of dollars for yourself (which you then avoid paying taxes on by sending it overseas) and stockholders at the expense of the workers really make you a great business person or translate into being an effective and caring President of the US? And obviously, running corporations does in no way make you an expert at job creation. I would rather have a former community worker who understands the real needs of real people in charge than a corporate heavyweight who only knows how to line his own pockets.
photo
ThankGodhesgone
Always Progressive and loving the CONs meltdown.
12:47 AM on 05/29/2012
Not only does Pres. Obama deserve to be elected again, he needs a Congress that will work with him. We've had 2 years of teabagger republicans (the minority) trying to tell the Pres. how to run the country. They have not created jobs as they promised and want to return to the deregulated days of Bush that caused the crash in the first place.

When are voters going to wise up that tax cuts for the rich do not create jobs. we've been told that for over 30 years, beginning with Reagan. We've had the lowest tax rates in 60 years for several years, so according to their philosophy, there should be a job for everyone who wants one. That is not the case. Too many people are unemployed, or underemployed working part time with no benefits. Those that can't find jobs have no medical insurance. Yet, the repubs want to overturn HCR.

We continue to give subsidies to companies that outsource decent paying jobs to 3rd world countries so that they maximize profits. Why? Are we willing to become a 3rd world country, so that the rich can enrich themselves even more? I'm not saying that every company is evil, but our country will collapse into the haves and have nots even if we do not have a fairer approach to economics. Lowering tax rates does not create jobs. Demand from people who have decent jobs with liveable wages who can spend money create jobs.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
moonlit
Ditch Mitch
11:09 PM on 05/28/2012
Why won't Romney run on his record as Governor of Massachusetts? It's the only experience he has that even comes close to being relevant to the job of President.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Valko
08:04 AM on 05/29/2012
For the same reason that Obama won't run on his record as president.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:50 AM on 05/29/2012
He is, and you're wrong,
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
moonlit
Ditch Mitch
11:06 PM on 05/28/2012
These folks have no shame. The NY Times had an article yesterday about a lawsuit involving Ann. One of her dressage horses, a $135,000 horse, known to be lame, was drugged with 4 tranquilizers which masked the lameness and sold to another person. The horses cannot be ridden. The buyer sued several people including Ann Romney.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
07:21 AM on 05/29/2012
You are right. No shame. They have $250 million and still cheat people! They'll never have enough money!
Bellla
Trans & Proud
08:07 AM on 05/29/2012
And one thought Ann cared about horses more than people. Plainly she doesn't give a poo about her ponies either!
Drugging a lame horse to sell is a crooked hoss trader trick!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
moonlit
Ditch Mitch
11:04 PM on 05/28/2012
More about what Romney did at Bain:
http://www.villagevoice.com/2012-04-18/news/Mitt-Romney-american-parasite/
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Callyson
Trying to come up with a new creative microbio
03:31 AM on 05/29/2012
Faved for a good link, fanned for a great micro - bio!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DuxMom
Wine merchant, parent, artist
10:37 PM on 05/28/2012
Shameful!
10:35 PM on 05/28/2012
I think that Mitt needs to be deported to Mexico........