More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Linda Kenney Baden

GET UPDATES FROM Linda Kenney Baden
 

Tebow and the QB Revolution

Posted: 01/12/12 04:32 PM ET

Tim Tebow threw the pass that shocked the football world. Tim Tebow's passing stats in the Denver Broncos-Pittsburgh Steeler overtime playoff game were supernatural. He completed 10 of 21 passing for 316 yards. In the "speed" overtime he completed only one pass -- for 80 yards -- a record setter. He had no turnovers. This meant that as a quarterback he had an enormous 125.6 passer rating for the game out of a perfect 158.3. This is a rating achieved only by the likes of those greats currently playing: Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers and Ben Roethlisberger. The legendary retired QB Kurt Warner was perfect three times out.

Yet the usual sports commentary naysayers were ubiquitous prior to the game. Some were saying Tebow could not play the game, his wins were freak accidents, that Denver would draft a quarterback in April and that on third down passing situations Tebow could be replaced by backup quarterback Brady Quinn. Instead, Tebow gave an awesome performance.

Tim Tebow is a winner as a quarterback. Many bettors saw it coming: The pre-game line went from nine points favoring the Broncos to approximately seven points on game day. What did that mean? It meant that many gamblers were placing large bets on Denver who believed that the Tebow team could cover the spread -- meaning the game would be very close. So what do the gamblers get that the usual sports commentators and the old-fashioned coaching staff do not? Gamblers bet on big picture reality, not just on what happened in the last game. They saw the ability of the Tebow led team to perform. Couple that with the scary possibility that the Tebow factor might again surprise -- take the points and go for it.

A great quarterback in the pros must exhibit leadership, athletic ability and the will to win. Denver has won four overtime games since Tebow has been the QB. That is leadership. Yet Tebow's abilities were clearly discounted by the Steelers' coaching staff who believed that against the NFL's top-ranked regular season passing defense team that allowed only two passes exceeding 40 yards, Tebow could not be competitive.

But there is a revolution brewing in the quarterback ranks. The new quarterback has to do more than just throw the ball. Some coaches get it too. Legendary college coach Urban Meyer, the new head coach at Ohio State University, helped start this revolution developing the free style of play in football at the University of Utah then carried it forth with even greater success at the University of Florida. The defensive linebackers going into the pros became quicker and faster while the rules have changed giving more protections to the QB. Cam Newton of the Carolina Panthers is a reflection of this new quarterback model. This past year as a rookie he passed for over 4000 yards, an unheard of record. But he could also move as reflected in his gaining an additional 500 yards rushing. Even though they ended up only 6-10, Newton kept his team in contention for many of the games they eventually lost -- although the Panthers came from the worst pro record of 2-14 in 2010, which allowed Carolina to acquire Cam Newton as the first pick in the draft. Newton is clearly going to be the Rookie of the Year. Other young quarterbacks like Matthew Stafford of the Detroit Lions and Andrew Dalton of the Cincinnati Bengals also led their teams to the playoffs. Andrew Luck who will be drafted number one in April is a throwback as a great pocket passer. But as in the case of Aaron Rodgers he can move out of the pocket, run where he has to and throw effectively on the move. Robert Griffin III of Baylor has it (ESPN reported he will forego his final college year and enter the pros) and will also be a tremendous new style quarterback in the NFL. These quarterbacks are natural leaders and can improvise when needed. They are bright young men who are changing the staid structure of an old rigid game.

The rule changes protecting quarterbacks from devastating injuries has also contributed to the new model. The rule evolution started in 2003 with restrictions on quarterback helmet-to-helmet contact in order to lessen concussions and resultant permanent brain damage. In 2006, the league required that rushing/ blitzing defenders had to consciously avert low hits on quarterbacks. As a result of a knee injury suffered in 2008 by quarterback Tom Brady, in 2009 defenders were clearly prohibited from making contact with quarterbacks below the belt. These rules, in addition to quicker defensive linemen, meant a multifaceted quick thinking and moving quarterback could take control of the game. This change is already making a definitive impact on pro football itself and it has left the analysts talking to themselves in many cases. Old line thinking will leave teams ill-prepared to be competitive in the new millennium.

Some of the savvy NFL coaches understand the quarterback revolution: Bill Belichick of the New England Patriots has always adapted on the highest level. Jim Harbaugh of the San Francisco 49ers
and Sean Payton of the New Orleans Saints also totally get where football is going. Still other coaches seem actually clueless.

Some in the peanut gallery still refuse to recognize the legitimacy of the Broncos win over the Steelers: saying the Steelers were not well, or the Steelers lost the game on a bad coaching call. As I saw Ben Roethlisberger running down the field he didn't look like he was hurting. Denver also did not have all of its first team starters. Then there was one referee call and one non-call: The lateral fumble that would have given the Broncos the ball in the Steeler red zone, and the failure to call a face mask violation on Tebow that apparently went unseen except on replay. But let us not dwell here on side issues.

The greatest obstruction to Denver's winning the game, in my opinion, was the Denver Broncos head Coach John Fox and his staff. Remember that the week before when the division title was on the line, Denver was anemic in the scoring column coming up with only one field goal in four quarters and a fifth quarter into the playoff game. The problem very simply is that John Fox is an old school football coach. He and his staff somehow are operating in the yesteryear. What do I mean? The best thing that happened for Denver is that Pittsburgh destroyed the Denver game plan in the first quarter, not only were they not gaining yardage, but they were actually losing yardage on many running plays. Denver was trying to run the same six or seven old plays they ran the last few weeks thinking that their great ground game was going to beat Pittsburgh. By the time the second quarter started there was no choice on what to do -- open up and pray that Tim Tebow would shock everybody including his own coaches. And before anybody knew what happened the score was 14-6. Pittsburgh never knew what hit them. At the half it was 20-6 with no holds barred Denver playing in a very aggressive offensive style. Then we came to the second half. The Denver coaches decided they were going to play a shocking three man rush defense and sit on the game score -- like that was going to stop Ben Roethlisberger. Pittsburgh loved it as they chewed up an earlier tough solid Denver defense. You do not win football games by going in to a prevent defense. That prevent defense nearly prevented Denver from winning. Top flight quarterbacks will tear you apart if given time to throw the ball. In a way it was a miracle that Denver's coaching approach on defense in the second half didn't blow the game entirely. This is all the more reason to realize how completely effective Tim Tebow was when Denver was driving with seven minutes to go on its way to making another score that would have put the game out of reach if running back Willis McGahee hadn't fumbled the ball.

But still with the Steelers' fumble recovery and subsequent touchdown, Denver fought on to get into overtime. The rest is history. There should be no more inane verbiage that Tim Tebow cannot pass and lead a team. The only limitation he will have is if his coaches do not come in to the 21st century. The more experience (only 15 games as a starter -- 14 regular season games and one playoff) and the more opportunities Tebow has with clever innovative play calling next year and acquisition of better receivers, Denver will even be more of a threat to the NFL of the future.

Whatever happens in these play-offs will not diminish the success of Tim Tebow. But which coaches recognize the football revolution will determine the successful franchises. There are two recipes for winning -- players that are coached in a progressive way and top team management from ownership, general manager and coaching staff working as one. It is a new century in football.

 

Follow Linda Kenney Baden on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kenneybaden

Tim Tebow threw the pass that shocked the football world. Tim Tebow's passing stats in the Denver Broncos-Pittsburgh Steeler overtime playoff game were supernatural. He completed 10 of 21 passing for ...
Tim Tebow threw the pass that shocked the football world. Tim Tebow's passing stats in the Denver Broncos-Pittsburgh Steeler overtime playoff game were supernatural. He completed 10 of 21 passing for ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dadoorsron
06:47 PM on 01/17/2012
You putting Tebow on a QB pedestal is premature at best. He had a nice streak that was broken. The Steelers did not respect Tebow at all in the passing game and the Broncos wideouts made the Steelers pay. Coaching and scheme was the downfall of the Steelers that day not anything Tebow did. Fox and the Broncos run the same formations and same plays because Tebow is unable to perform in the Pro offense that was installed during the Pre-Season. What you don't understand is the fact that the Broncos threw their entire plan away to allow Tebow to play. If that's not adaptation to your players I don't know what is. Also, The Denver Wideouts are good young receivers that need an average NFL QB to make them look good. Not a college option QB that can't throw into a stiff wind.

Bill Belichick's knowledge of defense has allowed him to adapt a spread offense into a hybrid and using large tightends that have speed to cause horrible matchups in the secondary. Sean Payton is using a version of the spread offense as well. Belichick and Payton are at the cutting edge of offensive strategy. The difference between this revolution and the Broncos issues is the QB position. The Saints and Patriots have QB's that will be inducted into the Football hall of fame and the Broncos have a college QB that can't throw.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dadoorsron
06:27 PM on 01/17/2012
Wow, I have to say it again. WOW! I guess the author of this article didn't do any research. The spread offense and versions of it have been around since 1927. In 1952 a true legend Dutch Meyer wrote a book called "Spread Formation Football" I own a copy of this book. Versions of this offense is run throughout college and pros. The Houston Oilers ran a version of the offense with Warren Moon at QB. So Urban Meyer by far is not a legend yet, He did very well at Florida. What will make him a legend is if he does it at "Thee Ohio State".

Next is the fact you think Cam Newton and Tebow are the only running QB's in the NFL. Warren Moon, Steve Young, John Elway, Fran Tarkenton, Randall Cunningham, Kordell Stewart, Mike Vick, Vince Young and thats just off the top of my head. The difference of all these QB's and Tebow is they have an accurate and strong throwing arm and they can pass from the Pocket. If the Patriots home field wasn't Field Turf PETA could of sued Tebow for kill earth worms and insects during the game for all the grounders he threw in that windy game.

Also Cam Newton, Matt Cassel, Matt Fylnn,Ryan Fitzpatrick, Travis Jackson, Eli Manning,Carson Palmer, Philp Rivers, Matt Ryan, Matthew Stafford and Mike Vick all hit over 120 this season.
05:00 PM on 01/16/2012
I hope Tebow appreciates you polishing his knob with this sappy article. As usual with Tebow's fans, it's everyone's fault but his, because little Jesus can do no wrong. This is the most veiled attempt at defending this guy yet. YOU SHOULD WIN THE PULITZER FOR THIS ONE, REALLY, ITS THE GREATEST PIECE OF FICTION I'VE EVER READ!
04:36 PM on 01/16/2012
"Tim Tebow's passing stats in the Denver Broncos-Pittsburgh Steeler overtime playoff game were supernatural." This comment could only be made about Tebow, t because he's so bad that what he did against Pitt is now classified as "supernatural" (i.e. God had a hand in it). Unfortunately for you Tebow nuts reality hit again and proved him to be the pathetic QB he is. The Steelers did one thing wrong, they disrespected the Broncos and paid the price. Tebow threw the only two passes he's been able to throw since high school, the deep pass and the skinny post. Unfortunately, that's the limit of his passing skills.

Nice try throwing Newton in to protect Tebow. Newton's first and foremost a passer, he runs when necessary. As he develops from a "rookie QB", which Tebow isn't, further in his career, he's going to run less, unlike Tebow who can't consistently compete pocket passes, NE took away the only two easy reads he can make and little Timmy looked completely lost.

Articles like these amuse me. You tout some revolution with Tebow-like QB's. HE CAN'T PLAY THE QB POSITION AS A PASSER! What's doesn't register with his fans about this. Cam can, thus the 4000yds passing. Reality once again set in early last Saturday against New England with Tebow and his fans; if you can't throw the ball from the pocket, you can't win in the NFL. What more has to happen for you idiots to get this!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cameron d
Don't blame me, I voted Smitherman.
03:29 PM on 01/16/2012
Shouldn't this really be entitled "Cam Newton and the QB Revolution"? He does everything Tebow does, but he's better at it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:25 PM on 01/16/2012
Tebow stunk. Deal with it. Not even Jeebus himself could change that.
09:09 PM on 01/15/2012
Um...wow. Don't really know the game, do you? There was nothing outstanding about Tebow in that game.

Completion percentages under 50% will never be considered outstanding. Running quarterbacks have been around for a long time--that's not a new phenomenon nor is it revolutionary.

The Broncos have a very good team around Tebow. It has a solid offensive line that provides room to run and time to pass. It has a solid defense that keeps opposing offenses from running away with the game. When it picks up a good quarterback, it will likely become one of the top teams in the conference. Until then, the team will have to do with a mediocre quarterback who can complete passes to wide open receivers in single coverage--and pray it gets lots of single coverage for the receivers to get open.
11:46 PM on 01/14/2012
Such crap should really edited before it is presented to readers with sports knowledge. Any NFL QB could have completed the 'supernatural' passes. The call was the right one made at the right time by the offensive coordinator. It wasn't like he checked off and made a remarkable play. Joe Montana, Steve Young, John Elway, etc. made 'supernatural' plays. No one wants to mention that the Steelers struggled all year with injuries. To make it as far as they did was a great effort. Tebow is garnering the attention because of his religious beliefs. He CAN become a great quarterback in the NFL but has much work to do. Someone said he is a great role model...there are a lot of great role models who are QB's - Rogers, Flacco. Let's get real....
04:47 PM on 01/16/2012
Agree with everything you said but he can become a great QB with much time. There's a little something called muscle memory that says you're wrong. On ESPN they had a sports scientists to evaluate Tebow's mechanics. This expert talked about muscle memory and how it's developed over a QB's career. He looked at Tebow's mechanics in the Buffalo game and back in high school; it was exactly the same. Remember all the training Tebow went through before the 2010 draft. He even skipped Pro Day in Indiannapolis to work on his footwork and throwing motion. He worked on it this past offseason when he thought he'd be the starter. Yet, when he's played in live games, he reverted back to his learned mechanics. This is what we call muscle memory, when instincts take over and you don't have to think about how you throw, you simply react from memory and throw the ball. The expert said it would take tens of thousands of reps for Tebow to retrain this memory. So the question for Denver is this; are we going to wait 5 to 10 years for this guy to hopefully develop and basically give up on the rest of the team, or are we going to give him a short try next year to see if he can develop enough to win a super bowl, because remember the goal is to win Super Bowls, not win some games, as Tebow's fans love to say he can do.
11:24 AM on 01/14/2012
I've never seen a quarterback praised so much for completing routine passes to open receivers.

I saw just a couple of minutes of that last game and he couldn't hit the broad side of a barn. He must of completed all the rest of those passes when I wasn't watching.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:16 PM on 01/14/2012
You think they might acknowledge at some point the Denver defense keeping the game close for all those "miracle" comebacks?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Linda Kenney Baden
Private Trial Attorney and Sports Fan
02:37 PM on 01/14/2012
This is my third blog involving Tebow. If you look at my first one you will see I did discuss the defense. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/linda-kenney-baden/tim-tebow_b_1120871.html

" He could not have done it if the Broncos had to come from way behind. But this defense clearly believes in Tebow so much they are playing like wild animals. They have been determined to keep Tebow within one touchdown in final five minutes because they know that he will somehow rally them to win."
04:49 PM on 01/16/2012
No, because that doesn't play into all the "miracle" talk. It's got to be about Tebow or else the God angle means nothing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
happyblackman
Gotta have more cowbell baby!
07:38 AM on 01/14/2012
Hogwash. Quarterbacks have been mobile since the invention of the game. Hence the name quarterback;one of the four backs in the backfield. They have always been a part of their teams running game. It's the passing that has been stressed for the last 25 years. I grew up watching Fran "the Scrambler" Tarkenton, and Roger "the Dodger" Staubach, run and pass. Archie Manning never sat in the pocket to pass! He was always running for his life! The thing that made them good quarterbacks was their ability to make a pass, usually from the shotgun formation. This mode of a rigid, drop-back, pass first quarterback, is myth due in part to justify not keeping any black quartebacks on the roster.

One of the reasons why I cheer for Teebs, is he has turned that myth on its ear. He has a lower skill set than Conridge Holloway, Joe Gilliam and Warren Moon, ever had. Gilliam was run out of Pittsburg. Holloway never got a chance to play in the NFL, and Moon had to toil in the CFL for years before he got a shot in the NFL.

Also, I started rooting for Tebow when I heard the journeyman of all journeyman quarterbacks, Sean Salisbury, criticize him. He has made a lot of ex qb's mad. They can talk all about how he has no skills, but you can see their faces turning green with envy as they talk about him.
04:55 PM on 01/16/2012
Good thing you posted this comment before Saturday night's game, cause you'd look quite foolish right now. If you're so upset that black QB's were kept out of the game with the same skill set as Tebow, why aren't you upset this guy, with less skill as you admit, gets a chance to play. Do you really think Tebows' playing will help black QB's in that area. It's quite clear you don't know football history. There were several QB's who were running QB's with limited passing skills before those black players came along, most notably Bobby Douglas, he played for the Bears. Check him out. Nothing he did on the football field benefitted black QB's during his time or since. He was a winning QB and yet the black QB was still held back. It should offend you that this inept QB, with less skills as you said, is allowed to play QB when the black QB's you mentioned weren't.
jhNY
Mercy.
02:29 PM on 01/13/2012
Enjoyed reading this, though a Tebow fan I am not. Good insights nonetheless!
11:35 AM on 01/13/2012
This is a highly subjective interpretation of almost everything raised. John Fox and the coaching staff are an impediment to Tebow? Who gave him the chance to play all those games and game planned their offense around what Tebow does and doesnt do well? Why doesnt Fox get credit for coaching the defense and were they not a factor in the team's record, or the games they won with Tebow at quarterback? You say the Steelers and Rothlisberger were not hampered in this game by injuries because you saw Rothlisberger "running down the field?" I saw him aggravating his injury during the game and limping a fair amount and he has been playing hurt all season. I am happy for Denver fans that their team is doing well, and I like seeing Tebow do well despite the know it alls on talk radio who insist he can't play at all. But let us get a grip here.
02:13 AM on 01/13/2012
Tebow is a classy guy and a natural leader. He's fun to watch and win or lose, he took a big step forward with that game last week. It's amazing what happens when you don't run, run, pass; run, run, pass. The play calling has been horrible and they finally mixed it up.

http://www.whatthehellbook.com/2012/01/05/fired-for-not-believing-in-hell/
08:37 PM on 01/12/2012
I watched the game Linda and I thought of you. Yes this was a great game and you could see the determination on Tim Tebows face. John Elway looked very happy at the end of the game :-) Thank You for bringing this new style to my attention. I have been watching football for many years, but do not often pay that much attention to rules and regulations. I think sometimes Quarterbacks come in classes, like the class of 82? (Elway, Montana, Marino) or was that 84? haha For a bit there, it was the class of Favre. haha Rogers, Brunell, Hassleback ect. I am sorry to hear that it takes up to 36 hours to moderate my comments. haha what are you worried about?
05:57 PM on 01/12/2012
Unfortunately, you don't expand on exactly what this "new model" is. In fact, you confusingly lump together the status quo of Brady/Brees with Tebow/Newton/Kaepernick. Those are very different models of how the game should be played. The changes in the rules that allow for the emergence of a Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers have forced defenses to become over-specialized in protecting against the pass. That opens room up for the rushing and improvization of Denver's offense. People criticize Tebow for not playing like Tom Brady, but Brady's success opens up opportunities for success by teams like Denver.
01:51 PM on 01/13/2012
I agree with Robert. Linda you do not delineate or even acknowledge the very different systems in place among the clubs (Saints/49ers/Patriots) that you claim are shaping this "new model" of play. Most of the teams you cite that "understand the quarterback revolution" share primarily one thing in common - they feature the best passers in the league running productive offenses.

The trend toward spread offenses in the NFL is league-wide, with schemes now designed to make defenses cover all 11 players. But the development of the spread resulted from the passing talent and accuracy of quarterbacks like Brady, who consistently disrupts and carves out defenses to create mismatches for receivers downfield. In other words, the excellent passing and accuracy seen in the past decade has been most critical to the league's transition into option spreads, with teams employing many variants based on their quarterbacks' characteristic passing and skill sets.

Retrospectively, it is difficult to understand how and why so many critics insistently downplayed Tebow's NFL prospects given the reality that he was one of the best college players to play the game, and always displayed an athleticism and vision far beyond the role of the stereotypical NCAA system quarterback. Anybody who watched Florida '07-'09 should have been able to conclude from #15's performance that his position/play type could translate into something special in the NFL. Tim Tebow succeeding at the NFL quarterback position was, and still is, not that too far-fetched of a projection.
06:11 PM on 01/13/2012
Josh McDaniel must have agreed with you because he traded up to draft Tebow in the first round.