iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Linda Stone

Linda Stone

Posted: June 3, 2010 01:28 PM

The End of the PC?

What's Your Reaction:

I'm a Neanderthal sitting in the audience at the Wall Street Journal D Conference. It's a sea of iPads and I have a MacBook Air in my lap. Steve Jobs is talking about the end of the PC era.

"When we were an agrarian nation, all cars, were trucks. But as people moved more towards urban centers, people started to get into cars. I think PCs are going to be like trucks. Less people will need them. And this is going to make some people uneasy."

One of the people most responsible for giving birth to PC's and to the personal computer industry, was saying: "It's over." I texted my friend, John: "Jobs is saying that iPads will replace PC's. What about for us? For people who write a lot."

That question was answered a few hours later. I ran into Chris Sacca at a conference party.

"I've switched to the iPad. Everything. I have a 3 book contract. I'm doing everything on the iPad now. Spreadsheets. Writing. Everything."

Incredulously, I asked, "You can type an entire book on an iPad??!"

"Watch me!" Sacca proceeded to demonstrate astonishing typing speed, using only his (two) thumbs.

In the morning, Katzenberg took the stage, and enthusiastically proclaimed that he'd given up his laptop and was only using an iPad. Speaker after speaker has confessed to Walt and Kara, "I just don't use my laptop anymore, now that I have an iPad."

In Walt Mossberg's March 31, 2010, Apple iPad Review, he predicts: "...this beautiful new touch-screen device from Apple has the potential to change portable computing profoundly, and to challenge the primacy of the laptop. It could even help, eventually, to propel the finger-driven, multitouch user interface ahead of the mouse-driven interface that has prevailed for decades."

A million iPads sold in the first thirty days. Not such a big deal since enthusiasts, developers, and competitors all raced out to get one. The bigger deal is that, in the second thirty days, another million iPads sold. Apple can hardly keep up with demand.

Lisa Gold, a Seattle-based researcher familiar with my work on email apnea, told me recently, "With my iPad, I don't have email apnea. I sit anywhere, comfortably, doing whatever I want to do. And I breathe."

Children have a natural ease with it. Louis Swisher, age 9, loves his iPad so much I wondered if he was going to eat it. He lives in it: playing both actively and passively with youtube, music, racing games, reading and more.

In the early days of computing, both Steve Jobs and Jeff Raskin had visions of an information appliance. The iPad appears to express that vision from decades ago.

At D, you know someone is talking about the iPad when you hear the words: "It's magical."

 

Follow Linda Stone on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LindaStone

I'm a Neanderthal sitting in the audience at the Wall Street Journal D Conference. It's a sea of iPads and I have a MacBook Air in my lap. Steve Jobs is talking about the end of the PC era. "When w...
I'm a Neanderthal sitting in the audience at the Wall Street Journal D Conference. It's a sea of iPads and I have a MacBook Air in my lap. Steve Jobs is talking about the end of the PC era. "When w...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:09 PM on 06/08/2010
great conversation

i'm an "iaddict". i had the iphone, the laptop, the desktop, the itouch...no way i was going to buy the ipad. no flash, no camera, no keyboard, nothing it did i couldn't already do....moreover, 1st generation, no way.

then i touched it, played with it and had to have one. it's not going to replace my laptop, yet. i think jobs went too far when he said it's "replacing", but eventually it will. it's not just a smaller, cooler laptop. it's all about the cloud and the apps. i keep my docs in the cloud so i can start with my phone, then add to it on the laptop then finish it off in the ipad. it's simply awesome and you need to experience it, but it helps to be an "iaddict".

more about my ipad. it's really made my laptop my desktop and converted my iphone back to a phone. i don't use the ipad so much around the house, it's just still easier to use my keyboard, but I almost never take my laptop with me anymore when day tripping and i took only the ipad to D8 and fiji (apple still has to figure out the ATT issue, though 3g worked for my iphone it didn't for my ipad there). also, the battery life is beyond belief, 4 movies on one charge.

i love this thing. i'll upgrade as soon as i can.

great post linda, thank you
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lightoftruth2
03:45 AM on 06/06/2010
4. Oops, don't drop that! An IPAD may be expensive, and what if you drop it? Let's get real. Handheld devices are mobile devices, and come with the risks of mobility. Therefore, they shouldn't be too expensive or fragile. The IPAD is both.

The IPAD is going to be like the Segway human transporter...it will carve out a niche, but not replace the main ways of computing.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lightoftruth2
03:44 AM on 06/06/2010
End of the PC? Not a chance. Let's start with some advantages the PC has over the IPAD:

1. physical stability. Using an IPAD in your lap, on the go, might be OK for some situations...but it's NOT productive when it comes to office work, or even home-office use. As I'm typing this message right now from my home PC, it's located on a DESK which provides foundational support.

2. The mouse. One of the main problems with computing devices is when they falsely assume you want to do something. The great thing about the mouse is it separates pointing from clicking. Touch-screen apps have the disadvantage of combining these two operations, which means you might accidentally do something you didn't mean to do.

3. Keypads. Even a lot of phones, such as the LG, now have keypads for texting, but not the IPHONE. Pathetic. All you Apple fans are missing out on a basic truth, which is that the keypad has survived from the typewriter to the old PC to the laptop and notebooks and now even phones. As long as we use a language that requires 26 letters, numbers from 0 to 9 and symbols, the keypad is going to be very needed. In fact, it made a comeback with texting. Who wants to hit CCC to when they can just hit C?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Linda Stone
12:48 PM on 06/04/2010
I'm appreciating the comments -- the contrasting opinions. Just caught up with Fred Wilson's post on the iPad http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2010/05/ive-changed-my-mind-about-the-ipad.html - From skepticism to curiosity, which is how I would characterize my own reaction.
10:06 AM on 06/04/2010
Well, the numbers are compelling. In less than 3 years, the I-Phone and I-Touch have 85 Million subscribers. When an I-Phone user uses their laptop or a Kindle it just is "so yesterday". So I am not at all surprised that people use the I-Pad for as many uses as they can.
12:07 AM on 06/04/2010
the end of the PC? not again!
07:38 PM on 06/03/2010
We have enough problems with repetitive strain injuries in this country without thumb-only word processing. As power increases and companies get the common sense to add little things to these devices (like USB ports for God's sake and drawing features) may become more conspicuous. But I can promise you two things: 1. The keyboard isn't going anywhere for the foreseeable future; it is too efficient and the least physically demanding text entry system short of voice recognition, and most people aren't going to want to talk to their computers all day; 2. the iPad and it's descendants will not be alone. If reduced size devices such as this are the future every manufacturer under the sun will get in, somebody will develop an OS that can actually run things designed by other people without monopolistic control over content (like a Windows 7 derivative or Google will do something or a true open source OS) and the market for these things will be rather similar to what we see now for PCs. This is not the dawn of the iPocalypse for these other companies, they aren't going to roll over and die.
04:38 PM on 06/03/2010
Oh goody, another "end of the PC" hyperventilation... dear iFad zombies, please answer this teeny tiny question: how exactly are you going to get much anything into or out of your magical, revolutionary iFad without one of those obsolete personal computers?
12:12 AM on 06/04/2010
And it never crossed your mind that one day this device won't need to be synced to iTunes? I'm sure you could cut out 30% of what you could do on a PC and it would affect 99% of the users. If the only limiting factor is the screen size I'm sure there will be a day real soon when you can hook it up to a monitor. Google will pushing these ideas as well with Chrome OS/Android tablets.

Show some vision. It's funny how people can only what exists now and not what could be 5 years from now. What could possibly limit this device from not having all the features of a Mac or PC?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
savvysearch
10:23 PM on 06/12/2010
If it had all the features of a mac or a pc, then, might as well call it a PC, because that's eventually what the future of this thing is going to be. Going around full circle and then saying "why did we do that to end up where we just were?"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blakej19
D.F.A.
04:26 PM on 06/03/2010
One more thing, I work In the IT industry have for 10 years, certified in MAC and MS and have no idea how the IPAD could be integrated with all the other technologies my company uses, until than there is no way the IPAD can replace a PC, not to mention not everyone digs touch.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blakej19
D.F.A.
04:25 PM on 06/03/2010
This article is absurd, I think apple did a great job with the iphone, however the fact that they leave out flash, and I'm no flash lover, just a logical person who thinks that if 80% of all websites use flash in one form or another, and some the entire site than you should include it. Until they have common sense things added to the Ipad like a camera, even the phone has that. USB would have been a great addidtion since pretty much everything hooks to USB and yea you can buy the dongle but if thats the case why not add it since were paying $500 for the dang thing? an no multitasking? what year is this? I give them credit where credit is due, but until they add some common sense features I won't be joining, I do however give them credit for highlighting the tablet market and making people interested as I would buy one if Flash and USB were added. theres no printing and everything has to be approved by apple, that seems like a ploy to make them more money not to help the consumer which irks me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:08 PM on 06/03/2010
Hi, Linda.
Here are a few more thoughts about my iPad experience. When I use it, I don't have email apnea because I sit or recline comfortably, I'm relaxed, and I breathe. When I'm sitting at my desk, in a chair, staring at my computer screen and clutching my mouse, I'm physically uncomfortable and I often find myself holding my breath and feeling slightly anxious. Instead of forcing my body to adapt to the demands of the computer, iPad adapts to me and the different ways I want to use it. My iPad can't completely replace my computer, but I find myself using iPad more and the computer less. And it has made me much more aware of how using a computer affects my body.
JWoode
yes.. my micro bio is meaningless
04:09 PM on 06/03/2010
Get a better chair.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
savvysearch
10:29 PM on 06/12/2010
I've had a completely difference experience with the ipad. You have to contort your position to accommodate the ipad. If you're in the sitting position, you lock your knees together to place it on your lap and your shoulders and elbows extend behind you to type. It's easy to use while lying down, but so is a laptop. The great thing about a mouse pad is that you rest your arm and move just the finger. With the ipad, you move the whole hand and sometimes the whole arm depending on how you hold it. It may seem trivial, but when you're on it for hours, it becomes physically exhausting.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Linda Stone
03:08 PM on 06/03/2010
Thank you for your comments. Camel54, heads up -- I don't own an iPad. Before the D Conference, I had no intention of buying one -- at least not for quite a while. It's hard for me to imagine that I would be willing to give up "the truck." When Jobs spoke on Tuesday night, my first reaction was, "yeah, yeah. Not in my lifetime." Twenty-four hours later, after watching and talking with people of all ages, with a variety of jobs/tasks (granted, all of them attending this fairly elite high tech conference), my view on this began to shift. That's what compelled me to write a post. This feels more like the tsunami the iPhone adoption has been, than I had realized.

It's not just about Apple. Dell and Kno also showed Pad products. Both interesting. Both offering some potential for certain audiences. Mossberg and Swisher indicated that we'd see many more Pad products coming.
10:32 AM on 06/04/2010
Thanks for your reply. My overall point is that HuffPo is excessively fluffing the glorious iPad, and it has gotten old. In addition, though, I'm not bashing the iPad or other pads as devices in and of themselves. I just think it's ridiculous to declare the death of the PC when slates couldn't possibly do more than a small fraction of what can be accomplished on more robust systems. I believe the iPad doesn't in any way mark the demise of the work-horse computers but marks a divergence. iPad users are a different breed than IT users. But that's been fairly true of the difference in Mac and PC users for sometime although Macs still offer IT and heavy computer users some fine applications. The slate market will no doubt change the way many end users access data, but it's not going to make any other product extinct any time soon.
02:42 PM on 06/03/2010
The ipad is better for people on the go, but the PC is and will remain better for people who create content. It looks cooler, but in reality, moving a mouse around within a 3in square is far easier than constantly moving your hand across a screen.
iridium53
Semper Fi
02:18 PM on 06/03/2010
iPads have real potential for lightweight PC users.

Except, of course, for those that find AT&T service unavailable.

For those of us that do, because of Apple's idiotic and obstinant monogomy with AT&T, we'll have to find other tools.
02:00 PM on 06/03/2010
And yet another fluff piece from HuffPo about the iPad. The problem with this article's premise all the way to the Twilight like finish of "It's magical," is the fact that there are still trucks everywhere. As soon as the iPad can be used to develop the applications that make end-users' lives so much easier, we might see the beginning of the end of PCs. As soon as iPads can be used to serve millions of users visiting the web sites it hosts, we might see the beginning of the end. As soon as the iPad can host and serve a SQL database and provide access to multiple users in real time, maybe...

I have nothing against the iPad, though I am one of those people who still views it as mostly a catalog for buying other stuff or a toy, but all this silly hysteria declaring it to be the killer of all things PC or laptop or desktop or what ever has gotten absurd. Beyond absurd.