More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lise Van Susteren

GET UPDATES FROM Lise Van Susteren
 

Psychic Pains and Spilled Oil

Posted: 06/24/10 02:26 PM ET

If it wasn't heartbreaking enough that the oil spill is fouling our nation's waters and coasts, there is yet another toll -- the suffering from afar as the oil spill fouls our nation's psyche. Never before, and I have been a psychiatrist for more than 20 years, have I seen a phenomenon poison people psychologically the way this ghastly oil spill has.

Under ordinary circumstances our darkest and most sinister thoughts are buried deep in our unconscious. But troubling outside events can remind us of what is buried -- "awakening" the nightmarish thoughts and allowing them to spill into our conscious awareness. So it is that the oil spill, with its disturbing themes and images - (in Greek mythology darkness and death are father and son) -- choking off life, violating beauty, unresponsive to protests, rage, our efforts to stop it -- is so much like the force of death itself. Some of us can handle the primitive thoughts that escape after such a throttling from real life events, but not everyone can. For some, the experience coalesces into crippling personal feelings of fear and defeat.

In a chain of associations starting with the spill, last week one patient of mine talked, for the first time, of various methods he would consider using to kill himself.

Eight days ago a respected and life long environmentalist and colleague of mine, committed suicide. Suicides are complicated, but we are sentient beings -- events affect us. I can no more rule out the oil spill -- on top of other conditions no doubt -- as a potential final trigger than I would automatically rule out illness, financial problems or relationship issues.

Two personal experiences don't make a trend. But ecoanxiety is real.

The psychological impacts of the climate crisis were discussed at a conference held in Washington DC last year. The conclusion was unequivocal: the consequences of climate change will exact a grievous toll on our mental health. From the floods, extinctions, fires, shortages, heat waves and all the rest -- will come deepening anxiety, despair, guilt, fury at this generation and those in charge, as well as real threats to our national security by people whose rallying cry includes describing our carbon emissions as an international act of aggression. The group making the predictions included a Noble Prize winner and expert on biodiversity, a four star General, a renowned bioethicist, the head of the American Psychological Association, authorities on Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, the founder of Anxiety Disorders Association of America, a prominent climate scientist and other environmental and mental health experts.

One of the questions asked was, "How do we get people to listen?

We in the climate community agonize about messaging -- "Maybe we are too gloomy...the public has Apocalypse Fatigue...we have to make it look fun to do the right thing..."

But not always matching the words with the intensity of our alarm can feel like we are only chatting or trying to jolly people into getting off the track of the train that is clearly bearing down on us.

And other messages aren't sweetened to disguise dangers -- we don't hear people saying, for example, that it's OK to drink and drive -- "Hey -- be optimistic -- you might get there safely". We warn with images of horrific accidents and present traumatized survivors to lecture. And if you are a teenager or a guilty driver you will be exposed to this repeatedly. Could never letting up be the solution?

And aren't we furious when we find out that people like the engineers at the Deepwater Horizon oilrig, have downplayed the dangers?

The U.S. Senate in the next few weeks will take up the debate about a climate bill that will likely determine just how exposed Mother Nature and our own psyches will be to all the environmental provocations and years of dithering. Our elected officials need to know that, we the people, are becoming emotionally raw at all the posturing.

And to all those officials "outraged" at BP -- and jabbing their fingers in the air on television - we in our living rooms want to know -- What are you personally doing in your home and offices to reduce your energy needs? How many of you, up there on Capitol Hill -- just for example -- are wearing suits in this 90 degree Washington DC heat? Y'all wouldn't be cranking up the air conditioners so you don't get too hot now would you? Not too many air conditioners running on solar in these parts.

Then there are the rest of us. We care, but we need to have a good look in the mirror to examine our anguish. Have we taken all the steps we can to reduce our energy use?

It may make us feel good to go after the villains in this story.

But it would make us feel even better to work on making new heroes.

To help wildlife hurt by the oil spill log on to: http://www.homeatnwf.org

Lise Van Susteren, MD is a psychiatrist in private practice in Washington D.C. She is member of the Board of Directors of the National Wildlife Federation and serves on the Advisory Board of the Center for Health and the Global Environment at Harvard Medical School.

Email: lvs350@verizon.net

 
If it wasn't heartbreaking enough that the oil spill is fouling our nation's waters and coasts, there is yet another toll -- the suffering from afar as the oil spill fouls our nation's psyche. Never b...
If it wasn't heartbreaking enough that the oil spill is fouling our nation's waters and coasts, there is yet another toll -- the suffering from afar as the oil spill fouls our nation's psyche. Never b...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
The Scientist
What fresh hell is this?
03:52 PM on 06/25/2010
We are a nation that has had a long love affair with the internal combustion engine. Indeed, it is what powered the industrial revolution, the westward expansion of the country, and serves today as the lifeblood of our entire economy and thus our quality of life.

From the foods we consume, the homes we live in, the clothes we wear, the places we go and the things we do with our recreational time, and the roads we travel, without oil, we would be living in a much poorer, less advanced and far less comfortable place.

While we can all look at the horrors of what's taking place in the Gulf of Mexico, it's important to recognize our own personal culpability and recognize that this is part of the cost of living in this modern world. Not in any way to minimize the psychic pain many are feeling, but simply to acknowledge that we are all --collectively -- as responsible for this tragedy as is BP.

While it's
08:44 AM on 06/27/2010
I'm not responsible. ..I don't own a car..I am a semi-vegetarian...I am a pacifist liberal.... I empty out my own trash can; even when I live in a city that does not.

And, I for a least the last 30 years; I knew that man was not capable of handling the technologies he uses in the modern world.

A man is only responsible if they choose the polluters, over nature.
10:13 PM on 06/24/2010
I'm sorry, but a few correct decisions made at the very top and everyone will immediately change their energy use habits. Highly unlikely, of course. But how much infinitely more unlikely is it that 100s of millions of people are going to make the correct decisions?
03:49 PM on 06/24/2010
Excellent article...I read your article as a breath of fresh air for me. Years ago, I would protest many of the things; that were happening to our environment, but were not seen.

But with oil...it's visible; so it is much more real...thus it will be a reality that people will have to deal with; but, though I am no trained psychologist; I do know that the psyche is a fragile thing, always having to make decisions – that can either break a person (make them insane) or help a person to be more free and creative.

Unfortunately, we live in apocalyptic times, and have been for at least the last 50 years; it is only now more blatant (the horror of it all) – then it was in the past.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lise Van Susteren
08:51 PM on 06/24/2010
I would not have thought of my piece as a breath of fresh air, but I can see your point, and someone else said the same sort of thing. It can be reassuring to know that others struggle with the pain of seeing what we are inflicting on our planet and ourselves - we should also be on the alert to help those who may be getting overwhelmed.
03:20 PM on 06/24/2010
Am I really the first person to reply to this? What Dr. Van Susteren has written is of crucial importance during this cataclysmic event - what may turn out to be the Hiroshima of our lifetimes. What horrific pain BP, our corporate-controlled government, and all of us consumers have done to the people of the Gulf! This is epitomized by the stories of those who have committed or think about committing suicide, having lost hope. But we are all affected psychologically.

Dr. Van Susteren writes: "So it is that the oil spill, with its disturbing themes and images - (in Greek mythology darkness and death are father and son) -- choking off life, violating beauty, unresponsive to protests, rage, our efforts to stop it -- is so much like the force of death itself. Some of us can handle the primitive thoughts that escape after such a throttling from real life events, but not everyone can." I am deeply moved by this: my father, who has had cancer for five years, is about to die within the next week or so. Yet this disaster has, I think, moved me more than even my own father's death. Why? Because to die at 82 is a natural event. The steep environmental downward spiral I have seen in my lifetime, and see spinning out of control for my father's great-grandchildren to suffer through, just so that Tony and all the other hungry ghosts can escape this Titanic with a lifeboat full of useless
03:36 PM on 06/24/2010
... with a lifeboat full of useless MONEY.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lise Van Susteren
08:41 PM on 06/24/2010
Thank you for your comments. It gives me great satisfaction to hear from like minded individuals.
I am sorry about your father, but like you and aside from the cancer, I do see that leaving this life at 82 is not an unnatural event.