iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Liz Ryan

GET UPDATES FROM Liz Ryan
 

Employers Demanding Facebook Passwords? Perfect!

Posted: 04/ 4/2012 5:01 pm

I was indignant and horrified for ten seconds when I heard that employers were requiring job applicants to supply their Facebook passwords during the selection process. Then I realized that if employers do that, it will be a wonderful way to signal to job-seekers, "Don't Work Here." I only hope that these employers make it clear in their help-wanted ads that they're requiring FB passwords from job applicants, so that the job-seekers don't waste time filling out applications and sending resumes to toadish organizations that don't deserve them.

If you have an ounce of faith in your company's leadership, would you really believe that you can't hire good employees without digging into their personal lives via back-end access to their Facebook accounts? How paranoid would an organization have to be, to doubt its own managers' instincts so severely that it doesn't trust them to hire smart people without resorting to KGB-type snooping tactics?

When you apply for a job, the employer has a lot of ways to check you out already.

They see your resume. They see your LinkedIn profile, and the endorsements on it and the people you're connected to. (You need one, in my opinion, if you don't have one already.) They can talk to you over the phone, and then can meet you in person, multiple times. They can talk to your past employers. They can pose real-life business problems to you. They can get you to create a writing sample.

What else do they need? If they can't make a decision about you by interacting with you, your branding materials and other people who know you, they're already way too obtuse to get any value from invading your Facebook account.

There are people who shouldn't be involved in the hiring process in any way, and way too many of those people are hiring managers and HR people. If they say they need your FB account to make the decision on whether or not to hire you, they're too stupid to be managing people. You don't have time to work among people like that.

It's brilliant that the worst employers, the most fear-based and uncreative ones, are adopting the employer-branding signal "We require FB login information from our applicants." That is an employer brand sure to bring them the fearful, please-the-boss-above-all sorts of applicants they seek. The more clearly an organization conveys the message "We talk about talent, but have no actual talent in the building" the better for everyone else -- the human, talent-worthy organizations and the job-seekers, both.

 

Follow Liz Ryan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/asklizryan

I was indignant and horrified for ten seconds when I heard that employers were requiring job applicants to supply their Facebook passwords during the selection process. Then I realized that if employe...
I was indignant and horrified for ten seconds when I heard that employers were requiring job applicants to supply their Facebook passwords during the selection process. Then I realized that if employe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:03 PM on 04/09/2012
I want to believe that I would say no. But having just gone back to work after three years, I don't know for sure. This is clearly a violation of privacy. But I feel the same way about about blood samples, hair sample and urine samples. I worked briefly for Target as seasonable help and each time I had to give urine and hair samples. To operate a cash register. Honestly, corporate obsession about these kinds of things is a absolute waste of time and money. It makes sense to test train operators, pilots, bus drivers, truck drivers. The vast majority of what I do at home has absolutely nothing to do with how I work.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
feelingdisposable
Obama 332 - Romney 206
11:51 AM on 04/05/2012
I don't have a Facebook page, but if I did, I wouldn't give my information to a potential employer until they had supplied me with theirs. After all, it might be a total dis-reputable company and I wouldn't want to be associated with such.
11:02 AM on 04/05/2012
Yes definitely agree that it is a violation of privacy. We also think that it wouldnt even be all that helpful. Checking out someones Facebook profile would just lead to a bunch of assumptions that are more deceptive than helpful.
10:59 AM on 04/05/2012
I personally don't have a FB account for the very simple reason my private life is my private life & I believe that it is morally wrong for any employer to ask for this because at the end of the day what has the persons private life got to do with their mental or physical ability to carry out a job regardless of this or background checks either which should be made law that any company or individual cannot do any background checks without the persons consent in writing and also such checks should only be restricted to either security, health, finance, people that work with children and the armed forces but for a normal office or factory job etc... NO this should not be allowed.

I know many talented people through various fields such as architecture, design, construction etc being turned down because of their background, OK what a person did in the past may not be good but they are still being punished & the sad reality is that people end up very frustrated and angry.

When someone says to me that a bad employer can cause a liability then the liability can only be done if that person has messed up at work and their private life has nowt to do with it, too many good people out their but rejected because of this, its all about reputation people trying to get perfect people well believe me there's no such thing

THANK YOU
photo
SoylentGreenIsPeople
You know how to use Google too !
10:17 AM on 04/05/2012
The US Department of Justice views entering a social networking site in violation of its terms of service as a federal crime. Since giving out Facebook login information is a violation of the site’s terms of use, employers requesting it are technically committing a crime.
03:20 AM on 04/05/2012
Completely disagree with this blog. You clearly don't understand that some employers need to protect their IP and assets at all cost. Also keep in mind that it costs a company tens of thousands just to hire one person. Why shouldn't they want to completely check the prospects' background and life? Newsflash, a poor employee can destroy an entire team and put the company at a liability for lawsuits.

This isn't true for all Facebook profiles but you can definitely get an idea of how reliable and intelligent someone is based on their Facebook profiles - especially an older Facebook account. Some people might cry about how Facebook doesn't pertain to real life and you shouldn't be judged from it - blah blah blah. It's the same as judging someone's ability by looking at his or her resume.
09:43 AM on 04/05/2012
Employers have many other effective vetting tools at their disposal so that fb profiling shouldn’t be necessary. Sure, a review of a candidate’s fb profile may provide more pointed information for what is often a tough decision making process. However, a vast majority of people find password sharing an egregious invasion of privacy and a huge leap from drug testing, standard personality tests and credit checks (practices which have also been under scrutiny). Are we are now so in thrall to the market that we are willing to engage in the kind of trade offs you are suggesting? Where does it stop? What if a technology for direct mind reading presented itself? I’m willing to guess that it would meet your approval as an employment pre-screening tool. Just out of curiosity, what are your personal limits, if any? A ridiculous but hypothetical question, would you allow a male hiring manager to view any part of your body as a condition of employment, if certain ones had been proven to be a highly effective pre-screening tool?
10:18 AM on 04/05/2012
They don't need my password to see my account. And since you're suggesting they have the right to access my facebook account, do they also have the right to access all my personal email accounts and possibly my college account? I'm sure both of those would also tell quite a story about who I am. Also, when you sign up for facebook you agree to the following:

"You will not share your password, (or in the case of developers, your secret key), let anyone else access your account, or do anything else that might jeopardize the security of your account."
12:23 AM on 04/05/2012
Very well put! There is an over abundance of inept "hiring managers" out there who are frustrating candidates and headhunters alike.