Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lloyd Chapman

GET UPDATES FROM Lloyd Chapman
 

Top 6 Reasons Obama's Economic Policies Failed in 2011

Posted: 12/30/11 11:41 AM ET

Politically and economically, the U.S. in 2011 fell flat on its face. There are several reasons why our government miserably failed us this year but the most devastating reason is that it did absolutely nothing to help the economy. In fact, the Obama administration helped make matters worse. Here are my top six reasons why the Obama administration failed us in 2011:

1. Failed to realize that small businesses create all the net new jobs and instead directed most economic stimulus to large corporations that, according to the U.S. Census Bureau data and the Kauffman Foundation, most likely have not created one net new job in 30 years.

2. President Obama failed to honor his 2008 campaign promise to end the diversion of federal small business contracts to corporate giants. The federal government is required to award 23 percent of all prime contract dollars to legitimate small businesses but because of fraud, loopholes and lack of oversight, most of that money is awarded to Fortune 500 corporations and their subsidiaries.

3. Decreased transparency in federal contracting by removing the parent company duns number from the Federal Procurement Data System, making it easier for large corporations to misrepresent their size status in order to hijack small business contracts and for the government to misrepresent the true volume of contracts awarded to small businesses.

4. Announced plans to remove from the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) one of the largest and most effective federal contracting programs for minority-owned small businesses, originally established through the efforts of Martin Luther King Jr., and the passage of the Civil Rights Act. Dismantling of this program could cost minority-owned small businesses up to $25 billion annually and unemployment among minorities will undoubtedly rise as a result. It is ironic that minority communities were moved to tears when Barack Obama was elected president and now he is removing one of their simplest and most effective methods of economic stimulus.

5. He tried to create jobs by using tax cuts when most leading economists agree that tax cuts do not create jobs. Tax cuts will increase the deficit and ultimately harm the economy.

6. He will extend the Comprehensive Subcontracting Plan Test Program (CSPTP), which establishes anti-small business policies that exempt large defense contractors from disclosing whether they've met their small business subcontracting goals and also exempts large defense contractors from any penalties of non-compliance with congressionally mandated small business procurement goals. All evidence shows that this hurts small businesses.

Judging by his actions, it seems that Barack Obama is becoming one of the most anti-small business presidents in U.S. history. People need to stop listening to what he says and start watching what he does.

 

Follow Lloyd Chapman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LloydChapman

 
 
  • Comments
  • 376
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
12:34 PM on 01/21/2012
This article is speaking to issues that were promised to be addressed. It's not a party issue, it's an American issue and a problem in the government structure. Since we are now in an election year, many of this broken promises will come to the surface, but more importantly, new issues, posing as solutions will be pushed on the public. The SOPA proposal is just one of these power grabs. If you look carefully at other items on the table, specifically the recent attempt to close the small business administration as you've talked about Lloyd, there is more going on than meets the eye. The big banking power grab and tie-down from Summer and Fall of 2008 created a mess for the economy while padding the pocket books of many power players who should frankly be in jail. The underlying premise was control and political power. At the end of the day, its the American population who suffers when they don't take a broad look at what is really going on and the motivations behind some of these proposals.
09:21 PM on 01/02/2012
#1 statements is the kind of improvised logic that drives me insane . Congress is to blame for the gridlock . when the leaders of the GOP have only one goal in mind :to GOP ( get him out of power) )Obama ,what do you expect?
One thing the comment seem to forget : check your facts before posting please : almost a million jobs have been created in the private sector. do your homework .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
02:09 PM on 01/02/2012
Without profitable US businesses, US corporations, and US businessmen, there will NOT BE ANY JOBS for US citizens (to create wealth for those businesses), except for tax payer funded jobs which will also disappear if businesses stop creating NATIONAL WEALTH that can be taxed or CONFISCATED to pay for bureaucratic government jobs, government paid contracts and various free government services.

The US government must stop creating new legislation that drives US businesses and those US jobs to foreign countries.

The US government should repeal the laws that they created that caused and economically required that US businesses and their US jobs to relocate to foreign nations.

Nations need to make the things that they consume, not give title to in-country located farms, land, businesses, hotels, etc to pay for the things that they consume, especially when they consume much more than they create.
09:45 PM on 01/04/2012
Yes on all accounts! We are outsourcing jobs and importing things that Americans do not need! Must we purchase food, clothing, and many other consumable products from other countries....Really. I would like to know what is fair about giving tax breaks to newbee business owners while the born and raised american tax-payer is forced out of his or her small business due to taxes, insurance and other expenses and laws that certain business owners do not have to comply with. Americans, take a good look around and see who is fairing well in the small business world here....is it the Mom and Pop you kneew when you grew up????Hmmmm not to hard to spot...who will help change this????
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
02:01 PM on 01/02/2012
The Serial Job Killer President Obama has not a clue how to create a healthy business environment leading to job creation and growth.

Not a thing he has done improved employment.

THE MAIN REASONS FOR THE LACK OF BLUE COLLAR MIDDLE CLASS JOB CREATION BUSINESS ACTIVITY IN THE USA ARE:

US labor costs many times as much as Asian Labor according to the DOL website:
ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ForeignLabor/ichccpwsuppt01.txt

The increased cost of Extended Unemployment Benefits will be added to US company payroll costs.

The cost of National Healthcare Reform cost will be added to US company payroll costs.

The increasing cost of compliance with existing and proposed new environmental laws.

The cost of electrical energy that is generated in the USA in compliance with US EPA regulations is more than double the cost for the same amount (kilowatt hours) of electrical energy in most Asian countries.

Existing environmental laws, and the anticipated costs of future environmental legislation that will be "piled onto" our remaining US located industries if they elect to stay in the USA instead of relocating to overseas locations.

I live in Houston and we are still afraid that the proposed "Cap and Trade" will be created by the US congress in the future, and then our remaining petrochemical industries will ECONOMICALLY BE REQUIRED relocate to foreign countries.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
02:07 PM on 01/02/2012
How does anybody think that any of the big or small US manufacturing businesses, with balance sheets in good shape and lots of cash on-hand could ever possibly even consider creating and/or keeping any jobs in the USA (or Europe) if they are hamstrung with many times more expensive labor costs, many times more expensive electrical energy that is required to be generated in compliance with the EPA, health care payroll tax costs, unemployment payroll tax costs, social security and medical care payroll tax costs, environmental compliance manufacturing costs, fringe (holiday and vacation) benefit payroll costs, OSHA compliance payroll costs, union labor work rules, anti-business laws, and general anti-business attitudes that make manufacturing products in the USA many many times more costly than manufacturing the same product in almost any other foreign country as allowed by and economically required by the US FREE TRADE TREATIES?
12:36 PM on 01/02/2012
sounds like you want patronage instead of help. blame Congress for any changes
The 2012 budget will
Enhancing Small Business Access to Credit.
Eliminating capital gains taxes on investments in small business stock, enhancing the availability of ‘patient capital’.
Promote Impact Investment in Economically Distressed Regions.
Help Small Businesses Obtain Early-Stage Financing. The Innovation Fund - to address the capital gap many start-ups face between "angel investor" financing and later-stage venture capital financing.
Help Small Businesses Connect to Regional Growth. The Emerging Leaders initiative provides technical assistance to companies located in distressed economic areas. Broader small business participation in regional economic clusters
Strengthen Small Business Exports...$526 million for the International Trade Administration to continue implementation of the National Export Initiative, increase American exports and export...supports the activities of the Export-Import Bank to strengthen its efforts to promote small business exports and to meet increased financing demands at no cost to the taxpayer.
Enhance Regional Economic Competitiveness... support America COMPETES Act ... a new Growth Zone program and more streamlined access to government assistance to 20 new economically distressed areas. Replacing the Empowerment Zone program, the Growth Zones will include a mix of rural and urban areas that will be selected through a national competition that will judge their competitive strategies and their need and ability to attract investment and growth.
Support Community Banks. The Small Business Lending Fund (SBLF) administered by the Department of Treasury. Double the Small Employer Pension Plan Startup Credit
03:28 AM on 01/02/2012
I have to admit I'm completly mystified by this column. 5 of the 6 points he mentioned would be INCREASING Regulation even though small business reportedly wants less regulation. Then he says he's against tax cuts in number 5. WTF, hasn't small business basically been saying the EXACT OPPOSITE of this for the last 3 years??????

How the F is Obama supossed to do anything for you guys what YOU don't even know what you want????????

This also seems suspect with some of rhetoric involved in this. I'd really like to know what sort of "Small Business" advocacy group he's involved in.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
rtgmath
There has got to be a better way!
05:01 PM on 01/01/2012
"1. Failed to realize that small businesses create all the net new jobs and instead directed most economic stimulus to large corporations that, according to the U.S. Census Bureau data and the Kauffman Foundation, most likely have not created one net new job in 30 years."

Large Corporations are the ones who are able to create jobs quickly -- if they want to. A business with a manufacturing and distribution base, with export operations in place can quickly expand.

Small businesses cannot expand so quickly. A large order put into a small company means chaos. If the company cannot fill the order, it must expand to fill the order (time costs, and will expansion be sustainable?), farm out the order, or refuse it.

Small businesses can't compete on price. It costs more to run a small business. Small businesses cannot command the price breaks for materials, can't get loans from banks at the low rates large businesses do, and can't scale up and down quickly! Big companies have more clout, purchasing power and resources.

Small businesses do create the most jobs -- at lower wages. Large businesses have more stable business prospects and cash flows. They can afford larger salaries (though they, too, like to cut wages!).

Want to encourage small businesses? Instead of one-time contracts, provide help for scaling, loans for startup at good rates, and accept some higher costs for doing business with small businesses! And keep the contracts to work done in America by Americans.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
perrybones
07:22 PM on 01/01/2012
You are right in some of your comments about business, but some things dont pan out. Big companies do spend money, on automation. My work involves installing labor saving equipment, robotics, high speed package handling, truck loading, automatic picking systems, industrial process controls via computers.
Many of the large systems I install, cut the labor force of a 500,000 sqft warehouse by 30% in the first year. When that equipment shows that it pays for itself, they buy more.
Super blade servers and clouds have cut office workers by thousands, as well as offsite support and payroll systems. Unskilled factory jobs and white shirt office jobs are becoming dinosaurs. Outsourcing is king.
Small businesses like restaurants, cleaners, construction companies, bakeries, service industries are the only ones that are not wholely affected by the automation. We send our kids to college to learn what? to be a teacher? Arts? Social jobs? and other "hard to get a job" majors. No wonder you end up with OWS.
We need to re-think free markets and regulations. You are correct, it is getting very expensive to run a small business. Our government has, over time, crippled productivity inadvertantly. We cannot compete against the world market, and we should not have to.
oilfield
small manufacturing business owner
09:08 PM on 01/01/2012
small business actually pays the ridiculous 35% corporate tax.
03:29 AM on 01/02/2012
If any small business pay that 35% rate, they are run by the dumbest people on the planet and deserve to fail.
03:28 PM on 01/01/2012
I do not think Obama is sitting on his own America jobs Act and it was not Obama the small businessman in Georgia the one that rent cranes who said that he will not hire until Obama leaves office.So Chapman get your facts straight next time.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:11 PM on 01/01/2012
There is no point in arguing Democrat vs. Republican. Both sides have allowed big business lobbyists to poison our politics and destroy our economy. Until President Obama proves to be the anomaly in Washington, we the people will continue to suffer.
12:55 PM on 01/01/2012
A member of your own organization said gridlock was the problem.

http://www.asbl.com/showmedia.php?id=1937
12:48 PM on 01/01/2012
President Obama's jobs bill was blocked so we got GOPTEA meaningless bills instead of jobs bills. Tax cuts for the people that spend money creates jobs.

Your hyperbole is quite obvious.
02:58 PM on 01/01/2012
The government cannot create jobs, just shift them. That is, if the government extracts tax $$ from individuals and corporations and spends it "creating" jobs, what it really did is take that money away from the jobs it would have created if it was left with the individuals and corporations.

So the government gives us temp road workers building "infrastructure" and if we spent the money ourselves we may get more auto workers, or restaurant owners, or t-shirt makers, etc. Only the private sector can actually create jobs.

The government should focus on making the climate conducive to job creation and business expansion.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dcflush
The nickname is about poker, not politics
03:37 PM on 01/01/2012
Pure unadulterated nonsense.
03:30 AM on 01/02/2012
"The government should focus on making the climate conducive to job creation and business expansion"

Please tell me where this is authorized by the Constitution.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wayne Caswell
Consumer Advocate & Founder of Modern Health Talk
09:16 AM on 01/01/2012
1. The Scorched Earth policy of a Republican Congress intent on blocking anything Obama proposes at all cost to the nation.
12:19 PM on 01/01/2012
I think you have it wrong. They are blocking anything that Costs The Nation.
photo
chesswizard3
Truth can never be taken away.
06:38 PM on 01/01/2012
Did not seem to block a bloated defense budget now did they?
freerangevoter
Live Free or Raise Hell
03:41 AM on 01/02/2012
You nailed it Limp.

My father is a Kennedy Democrat and I'm an Ayn Rand/ Ron Paul kinda voter, but the one wise thing he pointed out to me is that we are all better off when the House, Senate and Presidency are divided.

It's an "Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely" thing.
BrighterStar
Let Freedom Ring
12:50 PM on 01/01/2012
He had two years with a democratic congress, where did that get him. Obama needs to stop blaming others for problems of his creation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
contrariandy
07:03 AM on 01/02/2012
The 2 best years since the Johnson administration despite the trea.son on the Right.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Elyriaohio
Stop the Monarchy
08:16 AM on 01/01/2012
Lloyd, How about "advocating" a national health-care system & eliminate the massive overhead ALL businesses suffer? No, I guess that would require some innovative thinking.
03:00 PM on 01/01/2012
What in the heck are you talking about? The government controlled health care would be an even larger bureaucracy than what we currently have. You think the government overhead would be smaller or less costly? That has never happened in the past.
03:30 PM on 01/01/2012
Health care for adults and kids is a right and non negotiable,period.Now get lost.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
contrariandy
07:06 AM on 01/02/2012
Medicare and Social Security are extremely efficient versus For-Profit private insurers; their administration costs are in the low single digits versus the 20-30% for the vultures.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
perrybones
07:09 PM on 01/01/2012
The government cant run anything efficiently, why do you think health care will be any different? They cant even work out the lousy Medicare without billions of waste. My state tried to run car insurance for those who couldnt afford it until they bankrupted the program then came after the rest of us for 200 bucks a year for 5 yrs to pay the debt!
08:06 AM on 01/01/2012
Small business= small jobs, no future for workers.
You prefer the mom and pop family business to a steel mill or Bath Iron Works.?
The wage and benefit levels are much higher in the MFG large business.
Also much lower in service and retail industries.
That is what is needed,lge mfg. industries.
03:00 PM on 01/01/2012
The bottom line is that small and medium businesses create the most jobs. If you want jobs that is where to stimulate.
freerangevoter
Live Free or Raise Hell
03:46 AM on 01/02/2012
If you want jobs you reduce taxes and regulations and get the heck out of the way.
07:02 PM on 01/01/2012
I have a small biotech company thats blowing up right now. Not because of anything the government did or didn't do but because we make really good stuff.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Elyriaohio
Stop the Monarchy
07:59 AM on 01/01/2012
Obama, being bi-partison, has given the GOP almost everything they wanted. Your complaint about tax-cuts not creating jobs should be aimed at the "trickle-down" party of NO. When Obama wanted a lousy $40/week tax-cuts for the middle-class, it was held hostage. C'mon, which party will actually help the little guy? Not the GOP.
freerangevoter
Live Free or Raise Hell
03:47 AM on 01/02/2012
Both partys are printing copies of Dollars and the inflation will bring on a much worse depression than that of the 1930's.

Ron Paul will audit the fed and stop the insanity.