iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lloyd I. Sederer, MD

GET UPDATES FROM Lloyd I. Sederer, MD
 

Children as Caregivers: Saving the Saviors

Posted: 10/20/10 09:49 AM ET

Ellen was 14, in the eighth grade, in a Florida middle school, when she took a short questionnaire at school that asked about caring for ill, injured or disabled parents, siblings or grandparents. She was surprised when shortly after that she was taken out of class to meet with someone from an organization that she would come to cherish, who asked her, "Was it true?" referring to her responses about her responsibilities caring for her parents.

Not only was it right but it began Ellen on a path that now, four years later and a senior in high school, has her able to manage as a caregiver of her parents yet still build her own life so that she is preparing for college next year. The organization is called The American Association of Caregiving Youth (www.aacy.org), founded by Connie Siskowski, R.N., Ph.D., whose work won her a coveted Ashoka Fellowship as a social entrepreneur (see my post "What in the World Is a Social Entrepreneur?")

What struck Ellen, after speaking with the family specialist (a licensed clinician) who reviewed her questionnaire with her, was that being different was not something to be ashamed of. She could be proud of who she was and the help she was providing for her family. She was certainly not alone as a youth caring for other family members. She joined a group, run by "Dr. Connie," of eight other teenagers who are still together today, where information was liberally laced with support and where these youth grew more confident that their burdens need not derail their lives. The work of Caregiving Youth has spread from one school to more than 25 middle and high schools in Palm Beach County, Florida.

What Dr. Connie recognized were the changing demographics of families, with more women working, more single parent and multi-generational households, more grandparents as parents, and a broken health care and long-term care system that relies tremendously on families to take care of their loved ones, even if the caretakers are children. Estimates are that over 1.3 million youth ages eight to 18 are caregivers, with responsibilities for ill, injured or disabled parents, siblings or grandparents. Rates of isolation, anxiety and depression are high among these youth, and one in four has serious educational problems. These were the problems that Dr. Connie and Caregiving Youth sought to remedy.

The Caregiving Youth Project (CYP) delivers services in school, out of school and at home. Tweens and teenagers, from middle school and older, are taught skills in how to manage their personal and caregiving lives and their feelings. Sometimes tutoring, even in-home tutoring, is arranged. The youth gather in groups and help one another, enjoying planned activities, diminishing shame and delivering support, and sustaining these connections through all the electronic links we now enjoy. When needed, the program does home visits and helps arrange for special services, like respite, access to medical care and case management, for the parents, siblings or grandparents.

Getting an adolescent to do anything can be a challenge (adults are sort of like that, too), especially those already besieged by demands. Yet retention in this program is very high, with virtually every student who joined remaining in and engaged throughout high school and as long as they continued in their caregiving role. Program participants report better grades, improved family relationships, reduced isolation, more time for themselves, more confidence and hope for their futures.

Another youth, Jesse, joined CYP when he was 12, with falling test scores and grades, suffering from clinical depression and showing attendance problems at school. His family lived in a mobile home community and his father had a serious and chronic lung condition with medical bills that the family could not manage. His mom was disabled after a fall and had mobility problems and depression. Jesse attended groups in school that taught him how to better manage himself and his parents' needs; home visits resulted in the delivery of case management for his parents, household improvements and the provision of other resources that on their own this family had not obtained. With other student-caregivers Jesse was able to get out of his cloistered caregiving life at home and begin to rediscover friends and a world that had been shutting down for him. These interventions worked. His school attendance, grades and test scores have all improved -- as have conditions at home.

Basic principles of public health are at work here: Identify people at risk or suffering from a condition that can be improved by proven interventions, and establish ways to implement the known solutions for large number of people. But can CYP be "scaled up," a favorite question among public health professionals and policy makers? Can it go from a group of Florida counties to widespread application throughout this country? That is Dr. Connie's current challenge, and that of all people concerned about the future of more than one million deserving youth, their families and their communities.

I asked Ellen after we were done talking about her family and her plans what advice she gives other young people. She initially demurred, saying no words can quite express what it is like having an ill parent and providing care for him or her. But with some encouragement she added that in caring for others, "patience is the key ... don't give up on them. You would not be here without them. They did not give up on you."

Wise counsel from a youth whose experience has made her mature beyond her years, a youth whose life has been rescued by an organization that knows what needs to be done and how to do it. The future of many like her lies in how well this program can spread beyond its Florida beginnings.

The opinions expressed herein are solely my own as a psychiatrist and public health advocate.

Visit Dr. Sederer's website at www.askdrlloyd.com for questions you want answered, reviews and stories.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:41 AM on 11/02/2010
It's weird to see some recognition for child caregivers. I took care of my parents. My mom, who was a single parent, broke her already bad hip when I was 14, and I took care of her for a while. She never quite recovered, and I was left trying to live in a house that I couldn't keep clean by myself and with severe family and personal issues that I couldn't handle alone. Around the time I turned 18, my dad was diagnosed with advanced brain cancer. My mom took him in and remarried him so that he could have health insurance. She did what she could to take care of him, but I was the one she expected to do the rest. I went through my senior year of high school only mentioning this situation a few times to my closest friends. My dad survived, but with 1/3 of his frontal lobe removed. After high school, I took the community college path just to save money and in hopes that I could get a job sooner and provide for my family. Putting all this pressure on myself was too much, and now I'm finishing up my B.S. in my 5th year of college, and I have not had a job yet that pays enough for me to help my parents. I'm alright with where I am now, and I expect everything to be fine, but to say this kind of thing is depressing is a huge understatement.
11:44 PM on 10/26/2010
The Ad Council has a PSA on this subject. Their BoostUp campaign is designed to give student just like these the encouragement and support they need to finish high school despite difficult circumstances like caring for a parent. I thought this PSA really hits the nail on the head... http://bit.ly/cXwaUe
07:57 AM on 10/24/2010
If you are a caregiver for someone living with Alzheimer's, Download the new FREE iBiomed App. Manage & track a Prescriptions, Therapies, Nutrition, Supplements, Rx, Test results, Diets & Food Allergies, on your iPhone/iPad/iPod . It has journals, reminders, "emailable" histories & reports, AND a supplement supply tracker that tells you when you need to refill meds. There's also a health forum that brings caregivers and healthcare providers together. With iBiomed, a caregiver can also review their parent's treatment history and create customizable charts & graphs to track progress. iBiomed will soon be available online. Download it at the Apple App store. More info at www.facebook.com/ibiomed Finally a caregiver gets a break!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Priscilla Warner
Author of Learning to Breathe, co-author of The Fa
09:06 AM on 10/22/2010
Thank you for shedding light on this topic. Caregiving for people, at any age, is stressful, rewarding, depleting, character-building and challenging. We need to hear more about ways in which we can support caregivers of all ages. I was particularly touched by the recognition that children are vulnerable, no matter how competent and composed they may appear on the outside.
Naninwstock
Profoundly Liberal
08:53 AM on 10/21/2010
My daughter made the decision 2 and a half years ago to move in with my aging parents. She was 19 at the time. Once she moved in became every source they had for their needs. They depended on her for their shopping, doctor visits, frequent trips to the hospital when one or the other were sick. They became too dependent upon her for everything. Now, since she has moved out,my parents are extremely angry with her for wanting her own life now. They are accusing her of abandoning them and are trying to make her feel guilty for leaving. That seems to be a problem for many of these kids when they become primary care giver to geriatrics, the old folks can't let go. It isn't always a positive result, these kind of dependent relationships.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Livinginthenow
Social Justice
02:25 AM on 10/21/2010
Sad that some children have to care for their parents and never get a chance to be a child. And how amazing that Connie Siskowsk saw this and created AACY! There are too many people becoming parents without the necessary tools and resources to raise children.
photo
brooklyncitizen
Soror quaerens lucem
11:42 PM on 10/20/2010
Unfortunately not all kids have the luxury of being spoiled and indulged or simply being kids.

A childhood friend took care of her mother who was schizophrenic and often violent. Our parents gave her support and love and she ate dinner with us practically on a daily basis; her home life was so erratic she had no routine to speak of.

She turned out great but never learned to take care of herself.Seems like caregiving is her lot in life- after taking care of her sister who developed MS and was eventually moved to a nursing home, she took in her sister's children (father deceased) and is raising them.

She still remains my hero.
06:23 PM on 10/20/2010
Interesting and very informative article! Thanks! I admire these young people who are very patient and willing to take full responsibility when it comes to caring for their aging relatives. They are very mature for their age. Although, we have to admit that caregiving is not an easy job. It requires a lot of time and patience. Support groups will definitely help with their day-to-day caregiving issues. They need someone to help them or guide them. The Caregiving Youth Project is a brilliant idea! Here are some ways on how to care for the caregiver: http://www.ladolceliving.com/caregiving/care-for-the-caregiver.html which includes ways on how to make caregiving easier and more manageable.
08:15 AM on 10/24/2010
Hi Nice site Please share this info with your members:

If you are a caregiver for someone living with Alzheimer's or any multi symptom health condition, Download the new FREE iBiomed App. Manage & track a person's Prescriptions, Therapies, Nutrition, Supplements, Rx, Test results, Diets & Food Allergies, on your iPhone/iPad/iPod . It has journals, reminders, "emailable" histories & reports, AND a supplement supply tracker that tells you when you need to refill meds. With iBiomed, a caregiver can also review their parent's treatment history and create customizable charts & graphs to track progress/regress. iBiomed will soon be available online but you can Download it at the Apple App store now. More info at www.facebo ok.com/ibiomed
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Montreaux1991
06:09 PM on 10/20/2010
I was my mom's caregiver from age 11 until she died when I was 24. How I wish there were help like this available back then.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
rfshunt
01:52 AM on 10/21/2010
Even younger for me. Dad got MS before I started elementary school. I had the same reaction you did, Montreaux - something like this would have made a world of difference for me.
05:55 PM on 10/20/2010
While it is a wonderful thing for children caregivers to have acknowledgment and support, this article skips past some important aspects like the damage this early responsibility is doing to their normal psychological development. Sometimes it is unavoidable that a child should be in this role, but as much as possible other relatives and outside caregiving resources should be brought to bear. The effect on a child of having to be responsible for a parent in any way can be negative and can extend far into adulthood.
photo
brooklyncitizen
Soror quaerens lucem
11:32 PM on 10/20/2010
So much in life is unavoidable and we just have to play the hand we are dealt.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joseph J Schuler
Sic semper theocratus
01:42 AM on 10/21/2010
Please specify what damages you mean. While it may not be desireable children and young adults have been doing this kind of thing for millennia. Heck, one or two centuries ago many people were married and taking care of their own children at ages of 14-18. I am not ready to accept that acting as a caregiver at a young age is inherently damaging.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
rfshunt
02:01 AM on 10/21/2010
"Please specify what damages you mean"

Got a few hours? It's taken me years to sort things out and get to a state of mind that many other people take for granted. I don't know you, so I'm not going to go into specifics. Not whining - it was the hand I was dealt. But trust me, you don't know of what you speak.

Here's what's different from preceding millennia - we don't live in villages where help is right next door.

And raising children is far, far different than caring for an ailing parent as a child - take it from somebody who knows.
04:54 PM on 10/20/2010
Things That Every Caregiver Needs To Know
With more than 65 million people in the United States serving as informal caregivers, generally for family members, it’s important that they learn how to find their way through the entangled web of information connected to the cared person’s case. [...]

http://silverbuzzcafe.com/?p=12485
01:28 PM on 10/20/2010
This is the type of story that makes you stop and think. When we criticize the young people today, do we really know what their home life is all about ? When kids fall behind, when their grades suffer, when they do poorly on tests, there's probably more to it than meets the eye.
But at the same time, It's not such a bad thing to teach young people responsibility and empathy. My mother was the oldest daughter in a family of 13 and she had to stay home from school often to help care for the little ones. It made her a very strong and self-reliant person.
12:53 PM on 10/20/2010
More evidence that we should never underestimate children.
been2there
Facts have a liberal bias.
12:41 PM on 10/20/2010
At three I could change and fold diapers, at six I was caring for a new-born, and by seven I was giving physical therapy to a brain-injured infant. Tough doesn't begin to describe it, and I am really glad that kids have a chance at getting help with the load today.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fisher65
12:41 PM on 10/20/2010
this is the nicest picture i have seen in a long time, very nice!