Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Loren Wearsch

GET UPDATES FROM Loren Wearsch
 

Underemployed One Year

Posted: 07/21/10 08:57 AM ET

I was recently denied an unpaid internship position to which I had applied. I could probably just leave it at that -- a sentence that sums up my self-worth, which has been severely damaged in the year since I graduated college.

Normally, I would have accepted defeat, disguised as a considerately worded e-mail, which stated that I "was not a good fit" for the organization. But I couldn't. I'm not sure if it was my outbox stuffed full of cover letters and resumes from a yearlong search for work. This was one rejection I was unable to process. Why had years of over-achieving translated into unemployment?

I abandoned my passivity and responded to the e-mail. I asked why I was denied a position for which I was clearly qualified given my photocopying prowess; all I saw was an opportunity that required the minimal effort of ten hours a week.

Surprisingly, I received an e-mail back that same day, openly explaining why they chose another candidate. It turns out I was not only a terrible fit for them; it was also apparent that I had not thoroughly researched the organization before applying. My contact at the organization was polite and even offered to distribute my resume for projects that were more aligned with my career and education goals.

After approximately thirty seconds, it dawned on me that I wasn't any closer to having that elusive post-graduate job, despite my aggressive emailing. And then I experienced an epiphany, though not a necessarily unique one: work plus education no longer equals a better life.

In today's world, one must add connections to this formula to be successful. As a small-town girl from Ohio, I was consumed by the original version of it, the one that supposedly
had proven results. Without believing in that formula, I wonder if I would have cared as
deeply as I did about becoming my high school salutatorian or graduating from college with honors -- a flurry of academic achievements that I was told would end in triumph with a great job, propelling me toward my real life, whatever that means.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:54 PM on 08/15/2010
Hey Loren. You received some really lousy responses from some old crotchety complainers below. Here's my advice: Don't wait for an ad to appear and then send your resume. Write a letter to a specific individual in an organization you think would be an interesting place to work. it doesn't have to be to someone in the HR department (Find out the name of a department head by calling the company). In the letter, mention your qualifications and what you would bring to the organization. Ask only for their advice. You are well-spoken and will do well in a face-to-face meeting. Your resume, on the other hand, will only look like a lot of others. If you can get someone on the inside of a company, in any department, to be an advocate for you, you may be able to create your own connection. You also might want to choose a city where the job market is better than L.A. Good Luck!
03:17 PM on 07/29/2010
Do not want to be a jerk and kick somebody while they are down and I am not sure this even applies to your situation, but your comment "Why had years of over-achieving translated into unemployment" speaks volumes about how poorly we have prepared young people to face adversity and the real world. I think it blows a lot of young peoples’ minds (especially kids form upper middle class backgrounds) who have been told for 22 years that they are brilliant and could never be considered average and the wrold should fall at their feet. This has been reinforced with a culture of grade inflation which provides a false feedback. Overachievement? Ask yourself just exactly have you achieved? Sorry I know I sound like a crotchety old jerk but, I would argue that your real “education” has just started. Study hard it does not get any easier
04:05 PM on 07/28/2010
"it was also apparent that I had not thoroughly researched the organization before applying"

With all your years of over-achievement - I'd have thought you'd learn that lesson. I'm afraid to ask what your major at NYU was. This reminds me of the Times story (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/29/your-money/student-loans/29money.htm) about the woman who graduated NYU with a degree in Religious and Women's studies - and can only get work as a Photographer's assistant in SFO.
12:31 PM on 07/28/2010
Wait, how did "you didn't do the research about the organization" translate to "it's all about CONNECTIONS!" Perhaps it's all about being more conscientious about your job search. (Well, no, that probably won't get you a job in this economy, but it might minimize the damage to your ego.)
03:29 PM on 07/27/2010
You got rejected from an unpaid internship and that makes you feel your self-esteem has gone down? Honey, I was rejected over and over for unpaid internships and my major is very marketable and I couldn't have given a damn. I finally landed an unpaid internship as well this summer and am extremely glad I received it. The job market is tough out there, it has nothing to do with self-worth.
06:54 PM on 07/26/2010
In todays job market, experience is more important than degree. A person witha medicore GPA from a mediocre college with 5 years of work experience (even if not in the exact field they are applying) is worth more than a fresh graduate from a top 50 school with a very good GPA.

The reason for this is simple, most jobs can be taught with training, very few jobs duties are learned in college, so anyone can be taught the skills needed fo the job. You can't teach hard work and commitment. A person who for the past 5 years has had a steady job or 2 with good work references, and hasn't been fired is invaluable. Many people are hired trained and either leave after 2 weeks, or come in late, do lazy work ect. A college grad is an unknown. For the most part if somene is at a job for a few years there were a good employee, or at least acceptable.

Now there are expections, some high tech degrees, post-grad degrees, specific degrees, will be needed for specific jobs. But the difference of most liberal arts degrees is minimal that most jobs will treat them the same. If you are with the company for a few years, and want to move up, or you have several years work experience, that is where your specific degree may make a difference.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:37 PM on 07/26/2010
Wrong epiphany. The forehead-smack should have been that you ignored (or were unaware of, having slept through it) one of the basics of seeking employment: learn all you can about the prospective employer and display interest in and knowledge of their product.

You're not going to be able to even get a job wearing a polyester smock and chanting, "You want fries with that?' unless you show some interest in the company.
07:03 PM on 07/26/2010
Exaclty, if you don't know much about the company, you will be looked at as a paycheck collector. I would hire a guy with a 2.0 from a botton rung college who knows everything about the company and job than a 4.0 from Harvard who is just looking for a job.
12:15 PM on 07/26/2010
When I was young, we worked so that we could eat and pay our rent. I'm not to sure how you are financially able to be working as an unpaid intern, but you may consider just getting a job as a waitress, a dishwasher, a barista, a messenger, a cashier, or any of the countless jobs available in NYC at any time.

Now you have a job (maybe two), you are paying your way, you are meeting people, you are networking more (yes Virginia, networking helps), and you are a much more attractive candidate for an entry-level job in your career of choice.

When I've hired people, I've always been more apt to go with the person who is working a real job, rather than someone fresh from college.

Good luck to you.
11:07 AM on 07/26/2010
My daughter was also a 2009 graduate from NYU, it took her 13 months to find a position. In those 13 months she applied for work each day, sending out thousands of resumes. She did land an internship, and started graduate school, (not full time, but a way to stay fresh for the job market.) She is an honors graduate from NYU and spent last year supporting herself babysitting, doing her internship and grad school. It was a tough year wiht lots of self doubt and tears. I called NYU to see if they were offering any type of guidance for recent graduates. The offices I spoke with, including the Office of the Vice President and the Career Office could not have been less interested. I hope their attitude has changed. Ask every family member and family friend to wrack their minds for someone that might have an opening or an internship or even an opening--- in the future. In this market recent grads need a connected employee looking out for them. I wish you the best in your job hunt. Do not give up hope that a great job is in your future, you just might have some in-between positions that you are not so crazy about.
06:39 PM on 07/25/2010
"It turns out I was not only a terrible fit for them; it was also apparent that I had not thoroughly researched the organization before applying." says it all... no wonder your outbox is stuffed with unsuccessful efforts if they were all similarly off-hand.

Why are you surprized that their lack of interest in you mirrors your own obvious lack of interest in them?

That said, I think unpaid internships are something of a scam... why not consider volunteering work- there are a LOT of potentially valuable jobs available with them, and they can help you build your resume as well as any dead-end internship doing photocopying and mindless clerical work for "experience"...
01:35 PM on 07/25/2010
I understand what you're going through. The rejection and lack of interest on the part of employers is a hard thing to adjust to coming out of school. If there is one bright spot in this recession, it's that submitting resumes for less than perfect fitting positions is a waste of time. You probably won't get selected, which frees up your time to focus on getting in touch with someone somewhere you'd really love to work.

Your best bet is to find an ideal fit and then tailor your resume and cover letter to show employers why they should talk to you. By just submitting a standard resume to anything out there, you'll end up shooting yourself in the foot. The recruiter or HR person reading the resumes will be able to tell you haven't researched the company and won't bother to learn more about you.
10:07 PM on 07/24/2010
If you have a Bachelor's degree from a four year institution you can become a military officer. All services have quotas for females and it is much easier for a female to become an officer. You will be paid about as much as a Sergeant in Officer Candidate School and when you are commissioned as a Second Lieutenant you will have a salary of about $45,000 plus benefits including full healthcare, food, and living allowances. This is the only realistic and valid ticket to the middle class with a liberal arts degree.

The responsibilities are not beneath you at all. You will not be much behind those who graduated from West Point or other academies. The branches treat women well because of affirmative action and you will always have opportunities for that next rank, more pay, more school, and more responsibility. Women are not allowed in combat either.

More importantly you will be someone not just another anonymous drone in the private sector. You will have your "place." There will always be others below you who look to you for leadership. There will always be those above you to look up to and to emulate. You will have a great looking uniform and a great foundation of experience for politics or whatever interests you. Do some research and get in shape. After twenty years you get half of your salary paid to you for the rest of your life. The Bushes, JFK, Nixon, and Carter were all lieutenants. Lead.
10:00 PM on 07/24/2010
students generally have become more intent on pursuing credentials while the market has gotten worse. There all these students and parents trying to go to new levels to get a leg up, but the crumbling system ends up dragging them all down.
05:46 PM on 07/22/2010
If I were you I'd make the small investment in a CNA program (certified nurse's aid) through a community college or something. It's usually just a few months, and you can work at a hospital, nursing home, etc. I know that job openings in all fields are hard to come by, but it should be easier to find an opening for a "dirty" job like this. Plus you get your foot in the door at a hospital, if you enjoy it you can continue on and become an RN.
05:19 PM on 07/21/2010
When you reach LA, sign up with the Temp Work Agencies. Good Luck.