Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lynn Toler

GET UPDATES FROM Lynn Toler
 

The Liz Taylor Lesson: Why Do Women Crave Marriage Even When It Doesn't Always Serve Us Well?

Posted: 03/24/11 12:31 PM ET

Liz Taylor was an icon. Talented, strong and beautiful, she had it all, including eight husbands. I always found that fascinating. I understand the first few. She was young and in love with extraordinary men. Richard Burton? Please. Not to mention that in the '50s and '60s it was clearly the thing to do. Besides who knows? She might have gone the distance with Mike Todd if he had not died.

Be that as it may, her last few marriages always confused me. After all those divorces, she kept on going, and I have always wondered why. Of course, it's not for me to know why she did the things she did. People do what makes them happy, and there is no way in the world I can even conceive of what her life was like.

Be that as it may, her constant pursuit of that state of being reminds me of so many women. You can say what you want, but when I am among women, we talk an awful lot about relationships. We like to get married. We make books on getting men to commit best sellers. And don't let a member of a royal family get married -- that's magazine cover gold for a year. And then there is The Wedding Fantasy, a fairy tale so deep and pervasive that it is economically viable to an abundance of magazines and televisions shows focused on this one event.

At work, when I ask women divorcing their husbands what went wrong, more than a few tell me a story about a man who was clearly ducking and dodging, doing everything he could in an effort to avoid the altar. Others regale me with tales of a unions designed to fail from the start: Yes, he cheated on me while we were dating. No, he didn't have a job when I married him. Yes, I had caught him lying to me. But, wait for it... I was in love.

I think some women find getting married so compelling they do not accurately assess the consequences of being that way. Could that be, in part, why we find so many women jumping ship these days?

Society has, of course, laid the groundwork for the desire. That was, after all, what women were supposed to do back in the '50s and '60s. The workplace was unfriendly territory, and the expectation of all women was to become wives and mothers.

I also think there is some biology involved. The primitive parts of our brain -- you know, the ones that dictate how we feel, urge us to act, then require the higher functioning portions of our brain to make excuses for it later -- favored women who hooked up with a male. It increased our chances of survival. I think we don't pay enough attention to that long-engrained evolutionary proclivity. But it's there.

Personally, I have always found big weddings and all of their accoutrements ridiculous -- a belief which has led to more than a few people to contend that I am a quart low on estrogen. Be that as it may, I had a deep, abiding, raw desire to get married. It felt more like a need than a want -- unexplored and unexplained, but completely undeniable.

As an attorney, I did not need someone to support me financially. I never intended to be a housewife or do the things that housewives do. I was never particularly the nurturing kind. I was, in fact, quite the loner -- so much so that two weeks into our marriage I went back to the apartment I had yet to give up because the constant "there he is" of it all actually gave me the willies.

Let me go on the record as saying I am a fan of marriage. I think a good man is a great thing, and I like the one I have. All I am saying is that women need to be aware of both tradition and biology -- two very compelling things.

I also think that we can learn a lesson from Liz that might not be readily apparent in the light of her relentless pursuit of marriage. Like Liz, we are what we do, whether or not we get married or manage to stay that way. Though that sounds like something women shouldn't need to hear in this day and age, I still think we struggle with it. It's just something we ladies need to keep in mind the next time we settle in to watch the next episode of the hit series, "Say Yes to the Dress."

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Konnie
PO'd PROGRESSIVE
07:37 PM on 03/29/2011
elizabeth was a product of her time. human beings of a certain age...........

i believe in karma - fate - believe that you are supposed to find that person at that moment. if you have children you were vessels for that egg and sperm.............if you happen to like each other for some reason or another and stay together - well isn't that special. believing in this way is freeing. i should have
left 15 minutes after i conceived my 2nd daugher...........lesson learned.

it's just my opinon but i think parents in my generation did a terrible job of raising their sons. mothers
didn't insist they grow the ____up, crawl out of the basement, take that ____ game and break it. and
fathers - you let the kid disrespect his mother. you didn't teach him how to be a grownup. oddly, they
seem to have done more for their daughters. but i must add, more as the poster child of what not to do.
01:46 PM on 03/27/2011
i get into a cold sweat at the THOUGHT of marriage. its bin difficult, defying the stereotype and the social pressure. but truly. marriage terrifies me. if this makes me a freak... so be it. Im 39. I've had 2 marriage proposals in 2011 already. In 2010 I had 4. And Im not a serial dater. Men just want to marry me. Maybe they ask bcos they know I'll say no? These are all men I've dated to various degrees of seriousness over a period of several years.
I just CANNOT commit... i've had a recurring nightmare since the age of 9 about getting married and its the only nightmare I've ever had.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nicole Dixson
05:15 PM on 03/26/2011
Dude, did you see all those jewels? I think it served Elizabeth well. Having not known her, I doubt she regretted any of her marriages. She seemed to be a woman who liked to love and be loved.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:38 PM on 03/25/2011
True, we engage in a lot of traditions solely for the sake of tradition, like Halloween and marriage. Entangling legal implications with emotion when there's little need for it, other than health insurance and the bizarre self-appointed hospital authority on who can visit a critical patient. I'm sure a huge amount of the population have people who are more important to them than each immediate family member.

Women can now bring home the bacon and men are capable of cooking it so, as the practical aspect of legal unity being a necessity fades away, it's hardly essential for survival any more. But the relic of marriage lives on in the expectations of the elder and the dreams of the youth.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janalyce
01:24 PM on 03/25/2011
You've got the right facts, but you're drawing the wrong conclusions.

Marriage, throughout most of human history, has been a matter of economics and property rights more than anything else. In many societies, its even been the norm that the bride and groom hardly know each other before the wedding.

The promotion of marriage as a romantic culmination is fairly recent. As for that "fairy tale" wedding, that's also something that's not historically accurate. For most people, a wedding was a matter of exchanging solemn, binding vows and creating a legal contract, not a "cast of thousands" extravaganza with the bride as "star."

Weddings now are big business. Go buy a copy of Bride Magazine, if you can lug it home without having a hernia. Couples now focus, not on the contract or the vows, but on the hype, the performance, the tens of thousands of dollars many pay for this "once in a lifetime moment." Brides are hit with so much advertising that tells them this is their one chance to be "a star."

Weddings, despite the hype, aren't the culmination of fairy tales. They are the beginning of the partnership called marriage...and over-glamorizing them and marriage serves no one.
11:21 AM on 03/25/2011
People want to get married because it is a notch in their timeline that they feel that they need to get to. It is universally expected to grow up, get married, and have kids. If that notch is not reached there is constant dissonance and a growing need to get there. Men vs. women? Women are more mature and probably reach the conclusion that they should get to that notch quicker than men do. Not sure why I used the word 'notch' in this, though...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:21 PM on 03/25/2011
Lust and because we hit the "notch" before we've had time to think, does this even make any sense? and there's immense social pressure to do it, by default. It comes packaged in the incredible advertising "...and they lived happily ever after!" Boom! Crash! as the unrealistic expectations slam down on the ground. I can't believe he did THAT! I can't believe she needs this much STUFF! And then there's the religious spin, you can't sex outside of the eternal commitment of marriage without facing eternal damnation. And, we assume it's universal. Our legacy of John Wayne and Doris Day is fading though.

From sociology class, years ago: one culture insists everyone under 21 be gay, for birth control reasons, in another culture no man would marry a woman who has not yet bore a child, they may be sterile and what a disaster that'd be, in another culture the men all line up in their makeup and the women walk down the line to pick out anyone of interest, another culture has the woman's brother responsible for the rearing of her children, etc.
10:12 AM on 03/28/2011
That's my point- the social pressure has a lot to do with peoples' desire to get married.
08:52 PM on 03/24/2011
Oh, your statement about how 'there he is' all the time gave you the willies -- I was just thinking about that earlier this week. How in the world would I be able to deal with being married, anyway? Have someone around me 24-7? I'm horribly conflicted, because I want to be married so badly and yet have been alone my whole life (except for a few kinda-serious flings). Even with the longer relationships, I never lived with the guy. I'll need to have separate bathrooms, ample living space, and a separate 'snore room' for those nights when I can't stand the noise no mo!
Finally,as for Elizabeth, I also was baffled by her weddings in later life. Honestly, none of the last few even seemed to make her happy, so why did she keep doing it?
07:40 PM on 03/24/2011
Great article. I myself ave been avioding mariage. I just don't think it's necessary even though I'm perfectly happy with my man. Having listened to sage advise from the older and wiser, I'd have to say that the biggest mistake women make when getting married is that they assume that things will get better or that the relationship will change after marriage. That he would somehow become more committed ie drink less, flirt less help around the house more. The most successful marriages I've seen is when there wasn't that expectation and the relathionship was as good as it gets before approaching the altar.
06:57 PM on 03/24/2011
Having been married and divorced a couple of times, I can say I exercised extremely bad judgement in marrying, and escaped my mistakes by divorcing. Even though it cost me considerable money, and a few tears, I am much happier single. In the old days, women just stayed with their husbands, no matter what; now we can afford to get a divorce and no one blinks an eye. The divorce rate is about 55% so figue the odds. So if you feel the need to strut down the isle...get a prenup, keep your own credit and bank account, and call the show "Cheaters" if you even suspect he is up to something.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bluelynx
04:47 PM on 03/24/2011
I had a boy friend once, and I'm so glad I did not marry him! Oh, I could imagine us having a happy enough life together, to the point of ignoring bright red flags. I have a sterling credit record. He kept getting cards in the mail saying "Please contact us, you have won a dream vacation!" (This is always a trap from a bill collector.)
He lamented that all of his exes were so vindictive. I never thought to find out why.
There were calls coming in...female voices, quick hang-ups.
Then came the misdirected letter, to "Hot Sexy Lover".
I wised up, and fast!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
catcrazee
Rescue...save their life and yours
03:58 PM on 03/24/2011
Well, I am certainly glad there is another woman who has "always found big weddings and all of their accoutrements ridiculous". I felt so alone. hahaha
02:13 PM on 03/24/2011
I think that Liz may have been a romantic optimist who really valued love in her life and was someone who liked to leave her life open for the possibilities that love would find its way back in.
I think the world needs a few more optimists these days.
photo
PatA
Pink is a 4 letter word
03:03 PM on 03/24/2011
I think you are right, IrishgirlsUSA. I've been single for 20 years and my optimism is waning but I would still like to have a partner. I am very lonely.
photo
french queen13
my beloved is mine and I am his
11:32 PM on 03/24/2011
She said herself that she was taught that when you fall in love and want to have an affair, you get married. Kind of a complicated way to go about it!
photo
Scholastica8
PEOPLE MATTER!
01:05 PM on 03/24/2011
I don't know whether it is something biological or psychological, emotional or brainwashing, but in my experience, from puberty on, girls & the women they become have men, children, & marriage on the brain. I write as an outsider. As a girl of 7, before I actually understood how babies were made, I determined that I would never marry & never have children. I am not gay. I am just missing that compulsion from my emotional or biological makeup. I do not want the emotional baggage that sexually charged relationships bring. As an outsider, I've noted that the vast majority have more downside than upside, although those involved never see that until after it's over & then they often cannot admit the error. They dig to find something to make the experience worthwhile.

In high school, I had few friends, because for girls 95% of high school was about boys. Instead, I became an observer of "the dance." Did the boys notice?.... I'd have to say NO. What the boys noticed were the girls' assets... not the girls' emotions. Instead, judging from my observations, the girls & the women they become often attribute their own emotional desire for emotional love, home, & family to whatever man they desire at that moment. They are often willing to completely recreate themselves to conform to the man's desires. I have never understood this.

It has to be more nature than nurture. The female groups center around "boy talk" so much... then, that society
photo
french queen13
my beloved is mine and I am his
11:37 PM on 03/24/2011
You sound like my long-lost twin (second one today!), Scholastica8. Our school experiences seem almost identical on that front. I'd go so far as to say the boys at my school (or rather, my year level) actively despised any girls who weren't interested in them. I too have never wanted children, not ever. Can't stand the thought, actually. I do have the relationship, but I've only ever been involved with one man; he is, in the sexual or romantic sense, the only living man in this world or any other, as far as I'm concerned.