Joe Wilson's Outrageous Display of Incivility

When I heard the yell “You Lie!” during President Barack Obama’s address to a joint session of Congress the other night, I thought it might have been some rabid outsider who was let into the chamber by mistake.

I was wrong. It was an insider. Joe Wilson is a Republican member of Congress from South Carolina.

Those right wing conservatives who feared that their children would be adversely affected by listening to the President’s speech on education should have other concerns—they should prevent them from watching the Congress in action.

What does a child learn about respect for democracy, for the President of the United States, and plain good manners when she or he witnesses such an outrageous display of incivility as good old Joe displayed Wednesday night?

Like Michelle, who shook her head in disbelief, I was shaking mine.

Yes, I expect a certain level of rowdiness in the Congressional halls. They had a right to stand up or sit down, to applaud or not applaud, as most of them did during various parts of the speech.

But Joe was clearly out of control. Unlike school children and mature adults, he has not learned beans about anger management. The word respect is missing from his vocabulary.

He did belatedly apologize, and the President, to his credit, accepted it. I’m not sure I could have been that gracious.

What he should do is a stint of community service in a public school, teaching children to work hard, stay in school, and be polite to those who they disagree with.

 
Madeleine M. Kunin is the former Governor of Vermont and was the state's first woman governor. She served as Ambassador to Switzerland for President Clinton, and was on the three-person panel that chose Al Gore to be Clinton's VP. She is the author of Pearls, Politics, and Power: How Women Can Win and Lead from Chelsea Green Publishing.

Cross-posted on ChelseaGreen.com.

Comments

[seawolf77]

When I said that Obama should have used the seargant of arms and had the man removed from his chambers I meant it. What all of you fail to see so I will point it out in as clear as terms as possible : What would Joe Wilson's mother think of his actions. HIGH FIVE. That is South Carolina.

[cydRN]

Well said, Sir.

Millions of Americans believe that discourse should be on par with the Springer Show. They believe, and teach their children to believe, that anyone we disagree with is to be feared and vilified. That this is shamefully un-American is lost on them.

[Sharon Wren]

Sorry Gov. Kunin, but I wouldn't let Wilson teach my kids anything. Community service is a nice idea, but having Wilson teaching kids about manners...well, you may as well let Kanye West teach too.

[JBVT]

Governor,

You always make us Vermonters proud.

Thanks again,

JBVT