iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Magda Abu-Fadil

Magda Abu-Fadil

Posted: October 14, 2010 12:21 PM

"The 'free speech' spring in Egypt is nearing its end" was the headline of a report in Lebanese daily An-Nahar describing the sacking of noted controversial media figures critical of the regime ahead of legislative elections in November.

"The regressive move began last month with news of halting the Saudi-owned Orbit satellite TV's program broadcasts from Cairo to bar talk show host Amr Adib from his nightly appearance when he outdid himself and dared to air biting criticism of heavy media coverage of Gamal Mubarak as the heir apparent to his father President Hosni Mubarak," the report said.

2010-10-14-AmrAdibranklesEgyptianauthoritiesAbuFadil.jpg

Amr Adib rankles Egyptian authorities (Abu-Fadil)

Adib's television show had a large following in the Arab world.

Days later fiercely provocative anti-regime journalist Ibrahim Eissa's daily segment on On TV was unplugged to be followed by his firing this month as editor in chief of Al Doustour newspaper by its new owners.

The news came as a lightning bolt to dissidents and free speech advocates whose "Kefaya" (enough) and other movements had gained momentum in a bid to end President Mubarak's 29-year rule.

2010-10-14-IbrahimIssasackedforantiregimestanceAbuFadil.jpg

Ibrahim Eissa sacked for anti-regime stance (Abu-Fadil)

It also rattled liberal media circles that have been increasingly complaining of a tightening noose around anyone critical of the Mubarak regime.

"The Committee to Protect Journalists is alarmed by the deterioration of press freedoms in Egypt ahead of November's parliamentary elections and next year's presidential vote," said a statement by the New York-based organization, adding that it was particularly concerned over the firing of Ibrahim Eissa.

Eissa had regularly published news of the banned Muslim Brotherhood and recently printed an article by former International Atomic Energy Agency head Mohammad El Baradei - a possible presidential contender in 2011 and a Mubarak critic.

But Islamist websites have also blasted Eissa for reportedly defending Egypt's Coptic Christians and besmirching Muslim religious figures and writings.

Eissa told Al Jazeera TV he'd been warned by the paper's new two-month-old administration before being fired not to cross certain political red lines by attacking the government.

He said Al Doustour never claimed to be an opposition paper and never participated in any play-acting with the current regime, in a swipe at toadying by so-called opposition parties.

Eissa, recipient of the Gebran Tueni Award for press freedom (named after the assassinated An-Nahar publisher), also told Agence France-Presse that Al Doustour's new owners, key figures in the opposition Wafd Party, asked him not to publish El Baradei's article about the October 6, 1973 war with Israel.

Al Doustour, considered the widest circulation opposition paper in Egypt, had become a thorn in the government's side.

Its ousted editor was sentenced to two months in prison in September 2008 for writing that President Mubarak was in poor health and that his son Gamal was not fit to succeed him.

What surprised Egyptians was that El Sayyed El Badawi Shehata, who heads the Wafd party, bought major shares in Al Doustour; briefly headed the paper's board of directors; resigned as chairman; sold his shares to co-board member and shareholder Rida Edward; and dismissed Eissa on charges of short-changing staffers of their salaries and benefits while raising his own and that of cronies.

But Al Doustour journalists opposed to the firing disputed the claims, saying they'd taken over the paper's website and that Eissa continued to edit the site's content.

The reporters staged a sit-in at the paper demanding Eissa's reinstatement and said the new owners had sent men to remove all the computers, according to the pan-Arab daily Asharq Al-Awsat.

Lebanon's daily Al Akhbar reported the staffers had also posted news of what happened at the paper on their Facebook walls and uploaded a video clip on Al Doustour's website demonstrating the dismantling of the computers.

"I can't imagine Al Doustour without Ibrahim Eissa," opined Mansour Hassan, a former Egyptian information minister, expressing his solidarity with the sacked editor.

He told Al Youm Al Sabeh newspaper that Al Doustour was a very effective opposition publication and expressed his dismay at its disbanding by key opposition figures.

Mansour warned that Egyptian freedom of opinion and of the press would suffer greatly with Al Doustour's demise and urged various national forces to side with the paper.

2010-10-14-EgyptianshavefewerchoiceswithclampdownonmediaAbuFadil.jpg

Egyptians have fewer choices with clampdown on media (Abu-Fadil)

"Don't be misled by the Wafd being an opposition party," an editor of a state-run daily's website told this writer on condition of anonymity. "They're in collusion with the government and just want a piece of the pie like everyone else."

Egyptian media analyst Yasser Abdel Aziz told the German Deutsche Welle radio the confluence of big business and government interests prompted the Wafd leader to secure his position in the country by de-fanging Al Doustour.

In another move, Egyptian authorities recently restricted the use of instant messaging and news alerts on mobile phones without prior government approval for fear opponents and journalists would use that platform to disseminate unfavorable reports.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:08 PM on 10/15/2010
Considering the only thing keeping the Mubaraks in power at this point are foreign powers someone should remind them that the Shah got overthrown too. A bare minimum of making yourself liked by the population you dictate to against their collective will might be a good start.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
08:30 AM on 10/15/2010
Why is this surprising, is there free press in the Arab/Muslim world?

I laugh when people quote Al Jazeera in particular.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlietuna11
12:04 PM on 10/15/2010
as they used to say, fox news shows our military firing off missiles, Al Jazeera shows them landing. whether you like them or not , they will present more facts than all other arab papers combined . that there more balanced and truthful that fox news surprises no one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
01:05 PM on 10/15/2010
Who cares about Fox news?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sherifdxb
08:23 AM on 10/15/2010
There has always been red lines in Egypt and in the rest of the Arab World. Even Al Jazeerah can't criticize its bankrollers, the Qatari royal family and anyone it doesn't wish to anger! The problem is that when a president stays in power for far too long and gets too old, he gets increasingly irritated at any criticism. I doubt any Arab satellite TV network would want to become a platform for attacking Mubarak and his heir-apparent and Egyptian (true) opposition figures will have to resort to the internet where a wide network of young people are very active. The irony is that the internet is not available to a large portion of the population. This is the real sad story!
01:31 AM on 10/15/2010
If this was about Israel, there would be 6 HUNDRED posts demonizing Israel!
11:38 PM on 10/14/2010
Another fabulous and democratic move by the government keep in power through American largess.

What a wonderful democracy the US exports world wide.

(Please note the sarcasm in the preceding lines.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nym22
01:47 AM on 10/15/2010
A new Egypt in 2011, perhaps?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
09:18 AM on 10/15/2010
Arabs are never responsible for their own actions. if they do something wrong, it's America or Israel's fault.
09:03 PM on 10/14/2010
Let's be honest, there is little or no press freedom throughout the Arab world. The press is a tool of the state power structure throughout the Mid East.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JibberJabberwocky
02:47 PM on 10/14/2010
This is a dismaying story. Not really unexpected, especially inthe face of the other 'crackdowns' over the summer, but hope spring eternal, and hope dashed can continue to cause dismay.

I hope the Fourth Estate will continue to fight for freedom of information. Not just in Egypt, but anywhere that dissent is suppressed with a gag, rather than overruled with a fair ballot.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlietuna11
02:14 PM on 10/14/2010
magda, this story can't possibly be true, .americas two greatest recipients of foreign aid are israel and egypt. israel as you know receives the largest amount by far because they have been so fair minded and humane toward the palastinians. stealing there land and colonizing that region are just rumors that are spread by anti semites. its also impossible to believe that Egypt would supress or clamp down on the press. they have a long history of fair presidential selection and elections. rumours of Mubaraks son becoming the next president are vicious lies by his known enemies. as an american, i know my govt. has performed an exaustive study to make certain that our support for these two nations will be ongoing and justified. we all know the great benefit we receive from Israel and Egypt far exceed our greatest dreams. keep up your posts, your one of my favourites..
09:05 PM on 10/14/2010
There are so many threads where you can heap gratuitous criticism on Israel, this thread is about the dysfunctional press throughout the Arab world.
11:39 PM on 10/14/2010
No, this article is about the dysfunctional "democracy" supported by America to prop up Israel.