iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mallika Dutt

GET UPDATES FROM Mallika Dutt
 

President Obama, Immigrant Families Need More Than Deferrals

Posted: 08/23/2012 1:04 pm

Right now, tens of thousands of teenagers and 20-somethings are standing in lines that circle full city blocks and fill rooms the size of airplane hangars. What are they waiting for? Not concert tickets or the latest iPhone. They are waiting hours -- even days -- for a fair shot at a bright future.

President Obama's recently unveiled deferred action program has given more than a million young Americans the chance to live, study, work and thrive without fear of deportation in the country that is their home. Deferred action is a laudably decisive move after ten years of Congressional gridlock on the DREAM Act -- and is an important step toward a common-sense immigration process. But it is only a first step, and a small one at that. Because many of the young people lining up to apply for these reprieves are doing so with a mix of relief and fear. They know that while they act to pursue their own dreams and freedoms, their parents -- who brought them here to do just that -- remain at risk.

Further, the new plan doesn't offer young immigrants green cards or create a road map to citizenship. And its eligibility criteria excludes all but a narrow cross section of new immigrants. It is also temporary -- lasting only two years and subject to the changing winds of politics and elections. It offers some hope and humanity to many young individuals, but it holds no promise of keeping their families together. It does not restore the protections for immigrant women recently stripped from the new House version of the Violence Against Women Act. It is only a tiny dam against a continuing flood of anti-immigrant legislation and sentiment.

2012-08-20-PhotoFrancineOrrMCT.jpg


As President Obama himself has said of our treatment of immigrants, "We can do better." So let us. Obama must extend a hand to all immigrants living in the United States. The moms and dads, cousins, aunts, uncles, friends and community members who have deep roots here, who came here to build something better for themselves, their families -- and for this country. These aspiring citizens strengthen our economy, enrich our culture, and share our values. And yet deportations remain at an all-time high, leaving the mothers of some of our best and brightest unsure if they'll even be back to pick them up at school at the end of the day.

So as the 2012 elections approach, we must keep pushing to put a road map to citizenship on our national agenda. Not only for the DREAMers, but also for their parents, their friends and families, and all the people who have built their lives here, and who have built us up in the process. The President has begun to show strong leadership by sketching a lifeline for a generation of new Americans. Now he, or his successor, must move decisively to end the policies that inject fear into our communities, tear our neighbors' families apart -- and diminish our national soul. We need a sensible, sturdy system that supports the human rights of all immigrants to the United States, and we need one now. No more deferring. It's time to act.

 

Follow Mallika Dutt on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mallikadutt

FOLLOW POLITICS
Right now, tens of thousands of teenagers and 20-somethings are standing in lines that circle full city blocks and fill rooms the size of airplane hangars. What are they waiting for? Not concert ticke...
Right now, tens of thousands of teenagers and 20-somethings are standing in lines that circle full city blocks and fill rooms the size of airplane hangars. What are they waiting for? Not concert ticke...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:05 PM on 08/29/2012
I know something just as ignorant and deadly!
11:49 AM on 08/28/2012
In this column there doesn't seem to be an understanding or perhaps a more polite word would be, appreciation, of the fact that the United States doesn't have any responsibility to those who broke the law other than a quick and safe trip back home.

The President is stretching and in my opinion breaking the law to avoid deporting those who entered illegally. But that is still not enough. Evidently it will never be enough until everyone who wants to enter and stay in the US can do so and the US starts to look like and have the same income distribution and infrastructure problems of the countries the illegal immigrants departed.

That's not good for anyone. It's not about hate but an illegal immigrant should be immediately deported. Turning a blind eye just leads to more demands, more illegal immigrants and more costs until the system breaks.

http://www.theurbanpolitico.com/2012/08/yeah-about-that-dream-act.html
11:51 PM on 08/26/2012
Give these poeple an inch and they want a mile. They got deferrment. Now they demand amnesty for their parents. When will the insanity end.
07:07 PM on 08/26/2012
If your values are 1) driving without a drivers license and driving without tax and insurance 2) mooching off our welfare system 3) failing to register with the selective services 4) stealing jobs 5) stealing college places 6) treating our emergency rooms as your own private clinic and 7) contempt for our laws then yes Illegals do share our values.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hlasv3
Liberty requires eternal vigilence
10:18 PM on 08/25/2012
They're not going to be happy until all of them are here, they've been given everything, and there's nothing left for anyone. Then what should we do? Invade poor Canada?
08:16 PM on 08/24/2012
I'm sure everyone on this blog has read/heard about US median income declining and the number of people at the bottom increasing? Doesn't anybody understand that much of this is probably being caused by the fact that the fastest growing large demographic group in the US -- namely Hispanics -- is generally poorly educated and doesn't earn much? The more poorly educated people we import, the more kids they have that don't get good educations, the more low earners we will have. The math is very simple.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
08:07 PM on 08/24/2012
This is all going to lead to another general amnesty if BO gets another 4 years to tinker with America's laws. I hope to God this does not happen.
photo
Snake1994
Snakebite!
05:16 PM on 08/24/2012
I just can't believe what this women is asking for here, It leaves me speechless! She's calling for a lawless nation.
photo
Hoodooman
Non-Aggression Principle
04:41 PM on 08/24/2012
Immigrant families? I don't remember my parents (who came here legally) going through anything described in this article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BeasTT
04:16 PM on 08/27/2012
Neither do I remember such stories as the one in this article.

My family came legally as well, and it was rather pleasant.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hlasv3
Liberty requires eternal vigilence
01:59 AM on 08/24/2012
No. They don't need any more. They get too much already. I live in a Senior building with seniors (American citizen's) who are getting their Social Security cut back, their Medicare benfits cut back, their food stamps cut back. Why? Because illegal's are coming here and demanding what they have not earned and have no right to. These people have worked their whole lives and what little they are getting is getting smaller because illegals are getting ever more welfare, food stamps, free medical. Go back to YOUR government and DEMAND from them. Stop taking what is not YOURS!
09:31 AM on 08/24/2012
You are grossly misinformed: if one does not have a social security number (which illegals do not have) one is ineligible for welfare and food stamps. Moreover, you are assuming that all illegal immigrants do not pay taxes. Here's a little fact for you: if one does not have a social security number, one can request a tax payer ID from the government with the exact same number of digits (9), which allows one to properly fill out a tax form. I say this from experience as I was illegal and paid taxes for many years (as well as my family) before leaving on my own accord. It's quite simplistic to blame the cut back of your benefits on illegal immigrants, while knowing full well that many factors are involved. Stop spewing out the rhetoric without having all the facts. Some of us who were there illegally entered when we were children and grew up loving the US and contributing to the society.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hlasv3
Liberty requires eternal vigilence
10:10 AM on 08/24/2012
I believe you are an exception to the rule.  I worked in Medical Records for years and every Latino child born was paid for by The State of California.  Hospitals have closed because they can't afford to treat illegals for free.  I've said this over and over.  Go to the welfare office, or to the Social Security office and see who's in there.  Especially welfare.  Those who have contributed deserve.  Those who have not, don't.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
11:17 AM on 08/24/2012
"Individual Tax Identification Numbers

Some W-2s received by SSA have an Individual Tax Identification Number (ITIN) in the SSN field on the form, instead of a valid SSN. An ITIN is a 9-digit number issued by IRS to non-citizens who need tax identification numbers for tax purposes and who otherwise do not meet the requirements for being assigned an SSN. When employers show an ITIN on the W-2, this results in the W-2 being posted to the suspense file because an ITIN is not a valid SSN"

http://www.ssa.gov/legislation/testimony_031004.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hlasv3
Liberty requires eternal vigilence
06:01 PM on 08/28/2012
Ha Ha!  You seem to have gone through Latino Voices and read most of my rants.  I get lots of 'hate' back and what I say won't make much difference, but, I know my points are valid.  I'm not completely negative however.  I'm hoping somehow it all turns out O.K. anyway. 
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nasknit
Freedom isn't free.
01:56 AM on 08/24/2012
"....continuing flood of anti-immigrant legislation and sentiment." What part of ILLEGAL does the author NOT understand? There is a WORLD of difference between legal immigrants and illegal aliens.
THERE is NO statute of limitations on being in this country illegally.
11:46 PM on 08/23/2012
Illegal aliens are not immigrants of any type, they are foreign intruders. What they need, and the law requires, is deportation. Mallika, why don't you instead advocate for real immigrants, the ones who obey US law, and require a relief from the very long waiting times, stretching into decades? Maybe they are not anti-American enough for you, that's why you don't advocate for them?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nasknit
Freedom isn't free.
01:59 AM on 08/24/2012
F&F.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BeasTT
10:21 PM on 08/24/2012
Amen brother, I waited years to come legally. I didn't cry and scream racism.
08:30 PM on 08/23/2012
"step toward a common-sense immigration process"

common sense = no limit & no enforcement, right?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
01:17 AM on 08/24/2012
What common sense is there? Insourcing 1.7 million illegals. costing $585 millon illegals into the U.S. Workforce, aready having 12.8 million U.S. Citizens out of work?

Even for political votes ~ this is just ASININE
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
spytheweb
Black Democrat
10:47 PM on 08/24/2012
23 million Americans out of work.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nasknit
Freedom isn't free.
01:57 AM on 08/24/2012
Don't forget, OPEN Borders!
photo
voyager48
Illegitimi Non Carborundum
04:07 PM on 08/23/2012
And so creeping amnesty drive begins!
09:22 PM on 08/23/2012
Did you expect anything else?
photo
Snake1994
Snakebite!
12:08 AM on 08/24/2012
That's what it's all about!
photo
iuriggs6
Sure thing. Shoot, Timmy.
03:19 PM on 08/23/2012
Sorry lady but people that ignore our laws, want our laws changed to suit their needs and scream racism when our laws are enforced don't share the same values I have.
James Greybush
The rules should be the same for everyone
05:51 PM on 08/23/2012
well, that did it.

F&F !
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nasknit
Freedom isn't free.
01:57 AM on 08/24/2012
Wish I could fan you again!