Juveniles Don't Belong in Adult Prisons

Jails and prisons are dangerous places for anybody, but especially for children and teens. Many of these institutions house vicious predators who have been locked up for brutal violent crimes. Yet on any given day, approximately 9,500 juveniles under the age of 18 are locked up in adult penal institutions. Children as young as 15 can be prosecuted as adults in many states without review by a judge or a court hearing.

The Campaign for Youth Justice report, "Jailing Juveniles: The Dangers of Incarcerating Youth in Adult Jails in America," released in November 2007, outlines the challenges to keeping children safe in adult jails. It catalogs the numerous jurisdictions throughout the United States where teens are placed in great danger because of the variety of flawed policies and laws governing juvenile incarceration. In 44 states and the District of Columbia, juveniles as young as 14 can be tried in the adult criminal system. Forty states either permit or mandate the jailing of young people in adult facilities before trial.

The report argues that children and teens should not be held to the same standard of accountability for their actions as grown-ups, citing research that shows the developmental differences between adolescents and adults. These findings indicate that the prefrontal cortex, which governs the "executive functions" of reasoning, advanced thinking and impulse control, is one of the last areas of the brain to mature.

In numerous cases, there is no public safety justification for locking up these young people in adult prisons. Juveniles may be held in adult jails for months or even years, although most of them are not charged with a violent crime, and many will not be convicted of any crime. Nevertheless, they languish behind bars with dangerous criminals and are at great risk of being raped and beaten. Many are pushed to attempt suicide.

As in the administration of many laws in this country, Black and Latino children and teens end up in adult facilities in numbers disproportionately higher than their representation in the general population. Nationally, according to the Campaign for Youth Justice report, three out of four young people admitted to adult prison in 2002 were either Black or Latino.

At issue is the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act of 1974 (JJDPA). When originally enacted, it was designed to prevent young people from going to adult jails and prisons and to separate young people from adults while incarcerated. These protections were called "Sight and Sound Separation"--a young person would be beyond the sight and sound of the adult inmates. Over time, however, these provisions have been eroded and do not apply to young people being tried in the adult criminal system.

Now judges in juvenile courts are often excluded from the decision to prosecute children and teens as adults. In many states, these decisions are made at the discretion of prosecutors, no matter how minor the infraction might be. The JJDPA does not provide a level playing field for Black and Latino youths who are more likely than White youths to end up in adult prisons and jails.

We have an opportunity and responsibility to do better in our country. Placing juveniles in adult jails and prisons is an appalling injustice -- and it doesn't work to reduce crime. With the JJDPA set to be reauthorized this year, Congress must amend the Act to ban the placement of children or teens in adult jails or prisons no matter what court hears their case. This is the right and sensible thing to do.

For more information about the Children's Defense Fund, go to www.childrensdefense.org.

Marian Wright Edelman is President of the Children's Defense Fund and its Action Council whose Leave No Child Behind® mission is to ensure every child a Healthy Start, a Head Start, a Fair Start, a Safe Start and a Moral Start in life and successful passage to adulthood with the help of caring families and communities.

Mrs. Edelman will release her new book, The Sea Is So Wide and My Boat Is So Small: Charting a Course for the Next Generation, in September 2008. The book will be a look at what's been done and what still needs to be done to make our world safe and fair for all children.

Sign up to receive an email notification when the book is available for purchase.

Follow Marian Wright Edelman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ChildDefender

Comments

[nightbloom]

Just to correct my earlier comment, a second read through the article revealed to my bleary eyes that the author did in fact mention sexual assault as a concern, however briefly. My bad. Nevertheless, it's a point worth emphasizing.

[RN4MERCY]

Our "if you're not wealthy, you're not welcome" society has already failed these youth; it doesn't make any moral or ethical sense to put young offenders in an adult prison population where they will most certainly be victimized and exploited physically and emotionally.
Under such circumstances, even the most sincere and progressive attempts at counselling and rehabilitation will be doomed to failure. How can at risk youth ever grow up to be the educated, compassionate adults God intended for them to be, if the only role models they have use them and live by the code, "do unto others, before they do unto you?"
Their offenses are generally symptoms of a national disease: turning a blind eye to the socio-economic disparities that enable our "cradle to grave" prison system to exist.
Thank you, Marian, for your advocacy!

[nightbloom]

One additional argument in favour of separating incarcerated youth, which isn't addressed in this commentary (but which the author is no doubt aware of) is the high incidence of sexual assault within the male prison system. The statistics demonstrate that becoming a victim of male-on-male rape is an unacknowledged rite of passage for young men entering the prison system (along with all the other risks which that implies, namely HIV). In fact, if you run the numbers on sexual assault within the male prison system, you get a rate of male victimization that dwarfs the female rate in the general (non-incarcerated) public. I've always found it astonishing that feminists - normally so preoccupied with rape - fall silent on this undeniable reality.

[charon]

If a 16 year old does an adult crime, such as assault with great bodily harm or armed robbery, then I see nothing wrong with him or her being sentenced to adult prison. I do think, however, that the criminal code, sentencing guidelines, and adult prison system all need to be entirely redesigned. I'll save my ideas for that for another blog.