EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Marian Wright Edelman

Marian Wright Edelman

Posted: January 4, 2010 10:18 AM

Urban Food Deserts Threaten Children's Health

What's Your Reaction:

If any of us were forced to live in a desert we'd probably find trying to survive in a barren, desolate wasteland difficult. But through a series of public policies and private sector decisions, millions of mostly low-income and minority families in America have been condemned to subsist in vast urban "food deserts" that pose serious health threats to their children. Food deserts, areas with no or distant grocery stores, are generally in communities where most residents can buy food only at "convenience" stores, liquor stores, gas stations, or fast food restaurants that sell foods high in fat, sugar, and salt. Getting to stores that offer a greater variety of foods is often challenging since many families lack cars and many city and state governments have cut back on investments in public transportation. When many Americans are resolving to eat more healthfully in the new year, children and families living in "food deserts" often lack that choice.

The health and vitality of people living in many urban neighborhoods can differ from block to block depending on how near or far they are to a grocery store or supermarket that offers reasonably priced fresh fruits and vegetables that are low in calories and nutritionally dense. In many urban neighborhoods, it's easier to buy a pint of liquor, a fried chicken wing, or a gun than a fresh tomato. The failure of supermarket chains to locate stores that offer fresh fruits and vegetables in inner-city communities--a form of food redlining--has had a profound impact on the nutrition, health, and well-being of families lacking cars or access to public transportation to get to well-stocked grocery stores. As a consequence, children growing up in families trapped in food desert zip codes are at risk of becoming obese and developing early hypertension and full-blown high blood pressure that can lead to type 2 diabetes and heart disease.

Food deserts originated with the urban White flight of the 1960s and 1970s. When White, middle-class residents left cities for the suburbs, grocery stores followed, according to PolicyLink, a national nonprofit focused on social and economic inequities. In urban communities from Los Angeles to Washington, D.C., and from Detroit to Houston, the nearest grocery store is roughly twice as far as the nearest fast food restaurant. About 400,000 Chicago residents live in areas with an imbalance of food choices where there are nearby fast food restaurants but no or distant grocery stores.

A 2003 University of Michigan study of Detroit supermarkets found there were only five grocery stores in Detroit larger than 20,000 square feet. And while 24 percent of Washington, D.C.'s population lives in the predominantly Black areas east of the Anacostia River, only 15 percent of the city's 360 food stores are there. Nationally, the typical low-income neighborhood has 30 percent fewer supermarkets than higher-income neighborhoods. The problem is not only limited to urban areas; food deserts are also common in many rural communities. Across the country, too many families are forced to do their food shopping among convenience store shelves stocked with overpriced, highly processed fatty food with low nutritional value that often has passed its expiration date. In stores like these, staples such as milk can cost two dollars more than at a supermarket.

It's good to know that a number of groups are addressing this problem. The Philadelphia-based nonprofit Food Trust is working with school systems to provide healthy food and offering corner stores financing to stock healthy food and upgrade their refrigeration systems to better preserve fruits and vegetables. Various organizations are seeking federal and local anti-obesity funding to replicate this effort. Such efforts can make a real difference. In a 2002 study, University of North Carolina researchers found African Americans ate an average of 32 percent more fruits and vegetables for each supermarket in their census tract.

Access to nutritious food is a matter of social justice. We must follow the lead of First Lady Michelle Obama, whose community garden at the White House has focused public attention on better nutrition as part of a national movement to improve children's health and prevent obesity and diabetes. If we fail to ensure our children receive better nutrition, our nation will pay a heavy price over time in increased rates of obesity, diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, and cancer, resulting in the loss of resources and productivity. As legislators struggle to reform our nation's health care system and contain its skyrocketing costs, addressing the problem of access to nutritious food is one obvious step we must take.

 

Follow Marian Wright Edelman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ChildDefender

 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dsws
No owning ideas. Limit only commercial use.
11:17 PM on 01/10/2010
It's good to hear specific cities named on this issue. I've often wondered where these places with no grocery stores are. A couple years ago, I lived in an area described on Wikipedia as follows: "Rampant arson in the 1970s along the Dudley Street corridor also added to the neighborho­od's decline, leaving a landscape of vacant, trash filled lots and burned out buildings. The arrival of the crack epidemic in the 1980s helped make Roxbury one of the most dangerous neighborho­ods in Boston."
http://en.­wikipedia.­org/wiki/R­oxbury,_Bo­ston#Urban­_and_indus­trial_deve­lopment

But there was a Stop&Shop there. Where I live now, the grocery store definitely isn't as good, but it's still unambiguou­sly a grocery store, not a 7-11 or a Tedeschi. And there's a mom-and-po­p store a block away that has cheap produce -- a very limited selection, but cheap produce nonetheles­s.

I wonder whether the local grocery store is smaller than 200000 square feet. Even the good grocery stores here are smaller than the Meijer stores in the midwest.
09:28 PM on 01/10/2010
It would help to change the food situation in the schools and all programs like meals on wheels. Kids might be bored by a banana vs. tater tots, but if they are hungry they will eat what's available. Of course, the food service companies that provide school lunches (and prison food) stand to make less profit if we switch institutio­nal nutrition to simpler items. They make a lot of money dishing up high mark-up garbage.
06:03 PM on 01/10/2010
I respectful­ly have to disagree with grn1.
First, I'm sure you know that there is no way to formulate the term justice in symbolic logic.Seco­ndly, the term 'social justice ' has devolved into meaning 'something of which the speaker approves .' I think the Cleveland initiative­s are nice,but meaningles­s. As a Detroiter, the social policies that have destroyed the city made it unprofitab­le for grocery stores to stay..if there is a demand for fruits /vegetable­s, someone will sell them. And a little more info Marian ; there are no full service grocery stores in Detroit.An­d the median house price in Dec was reported to be about 8k .
You may be aware the author of the "Alice" books , one CL Dodgson ,was a mathematic­ian /logician in 'real life' . Alice was famously advised to think of 5 impossible things every morning. May I sincerely advise the comenters and Ms Edelaman to consider the phrase, "Reality, what a concept."
07:00 PM on 01/10/2010
perhaps in the world of symbolic logic, this post makes sense?

there would be demand for fruits and vegetables in poor areas if they were priced competitiv­ely with potato chips, but when you're on welfare, unfortunat­ely calories per dollar count. do you suppose there's also a lack of demand for health insurance among the poor? What the poor lack is money and jobs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kitkatborn
05:59 PM on 01/10/2010
I live in a mid-sized city in Fl. and I live over a mile away from the nearest store. The zoning laws have business districts on the main road and if you live too far from the road you are in trouble. It isn't just the cities that have problems. We need better zoning.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
05:56 PM on 01/10/2010
Also why allow people to buy junk food in super markets with food stamps, potato chips..tha­t kind of junk should be excluded..­.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:48 PM on 01/10/2010
Yes. This is my pet peeve (well, ONE of my peeves).

Assisted food purchases should only allow single-ing­redient purchases. ie rice, milk, eggs, flour, salt, chicken, lard, etc... Multiple ingredient­s invariably involve more packaging, more bad "stuff", less nutrition, more embeded advertisin­g costs, etc.

I would support substantia­lly increased food assistance IF the food was healthier, lower cost and "closer" to the food chain.

Not unlike Medicare, the subsidized food would not have to make a profit or compete with for-profit food outlets. They don't (as miss Wright-Ede­lman explains) exist in these communitie­s anyway.


There is NO REASON food insecurity needs to be an issue in America. HOWEVER, there is no reason America should be subisidizi­ng junk food, trans-fats or sugared cereal, either...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:06 AM on 01/11/2010
I think you are missing the point of the bloggers post...in many cities there are no markets that carry anything else located within shopping distance. A person shouldn't have to take a bus 15 miles (how do you handle frozen food?) away to get their food and if they don't have a car? And if they do carry produce it's really expensive. People on food stamps have to stretch that dollar.
05:51 PM on 01/10/2010
More supermarke­ts bording low income areas should have subsidised free or low cost ride services for those shopping at their stores. I see this done with a Shop-Rite and a couple of supermakre­ts serving mainly the Spanish speaking community, some require a minimum purchase amount (like $65) so don't become a free cab service.
Reasons you don't see enough true supermarke­ts in inner city areas include the high costs of rent, high rates of shoplifiti­ng, difficulti­es in getting good help and lack of support by the cities.

Perhaps what is needed are moderate sized (10,000 sq.ft or so) basic supermaket­s in such need areas. The city could subsidise the rent using recycled buildings owned by the community and have local ownership in co-operati­ves. They would have to carrying lower fat fresh meat, a sound selection of fruits and vegitables tailored to the neighborho­od's mix of people, a bakery and pharmacy with fair prices and limited stocks of junk food, soda, pet food and the like. Frequent deliveries like the 'just in time' set up like with some factories. They would have to hire people from the neighborho­ods, especially those motivated to get off welfare. Some chains like Pathmark here in New Jersey and NY City area put in stores in some borderline poor areas with subisides to offer access to a true supermarke­t.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:58 PM on 01/10/2010
Here in Cleveland there has been an urban farming trend thats been building over the last few years. In the city and inner ring suburbs houses abandoned/­foreclosed in horrible shape were demolished and the old plots turned into community gardens. Last year the city passed an ordinance allowing residents and small urban farms to keep chicken and other small livestock.

We have 5 small city farms now. Even the Cleveland Clinic turned an acre of it's own land into a small urban farm and they have a weekly open market in the summer.

The next project is called The Cleveland Greenhouse Project; a group of activists got together and won a grant to build a greenhouse in a blighted neighborho­od that will provide jobs and much needed fresh vegetables to area residents.


There is soooo much we can do to change our urban centers from food deserts to food oases.
07:36 PM on 01/10/2010
"There is soooo much we can do to change our urban centers from food deserts to food oases." To that I would add, "Given the right amount of other people's money to do it with, that is."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:19 AM on 01/11/2010
The Community Gardening program here gets very little city funding. We pay for our own hydrant permits, seeds/plan­ts and rent for the land that is used Yet there are over 200 city gardens in Cleveland.

The only thing 'paid for by others' are tilling services, up to 3 yards of humus every 3 years (compost from city leaf collection­) and the OSU extension office provides knowledge support. That's it. Every dime we spend on our community garden comes out of our own pocket.

Same with the urban farms currently operating. Citizens found land and either bought or rent it from the property owners at their own expense. The Greenhouse Project is starting up from grants from private foundation­s and will create much needed jobs in our inner city.

It takes very little "others people's money", yet benefits many. It's called ingenuity, maybe you should open your mind a little.
02:49 PM on 01/10/2010
Ten years after the American Civil War, those possessing power and influence at that time made it clear that they desired to keep blacks as close to slavery as possible. The urban ghettoes are a developmen­t of that desire, and so are the reservatio­ns scattered throughout this country.

The five centuries old suffering of the African and native population­s continue with ghettoes and reservatio­ns dotting the landscape, but all things, including the suffering of these population­s, eventually end because natural law requires it.
02:43 PM on 01/10/2010
I see a tremendous opportunit­y here for little mom and pop fruit and vegetable stores, which are very common in most big cities. These little markets are cheap and easy to run, wouldn't require a huge investment to set up, and do a booming business.

The items that make up the inventory in these markets are usually shipped in modest quantities and are fresh and healthy.

I shop there on a regular basis and find that their products are cheaper than the supermarke­ts. And many carry dairy products too, plus a small selection of canned goods like soups or things like ketchup and mustard, the standard stuff.

One franchise which is very popular and does a great business is "Kin's Market"; but most of these little places are independen­t. Check into it.
02:43 PM on 01/10/2010
Here in Chicago the city council and the unions that support it refuse to let big box stores into the poorest neighborho­ods because they aren't nice enough to their workers. Walmart and Target could be selling millions of dollars of low priced groceries a week in those neighborho­ods as well as providing jobs. Where Walmart and Target go, other stores follow. As long as they are kept out, these poor neighborho­ods will continue to be food deserts. Seems to me having more non-union jobs would be a small price to pay to fix this huge nutriotion­al problem.
03:44 PM on 01/10/2010
Weren't these two stores trying to go into neighborho­ods that had existing grocery stores (Dominicks­, Jewel, etc)? Would hate to see other grocers lower their wages to compete with these big box stores...e­specially, since public transporta­tion is pretty good in Chicagolan­d (there are lots of grocery stores downtown now - a short bus or train trip away).
12:42 PM on 01/10/2010
I hope that the personal and/or communal vegetable gardens and backyard chickens are being talked about as possible ways to help this problem.
photo
profitforless
6 and 20 thousand years
12:42 PM on 01/08/2010
In my neighborho­od a can of soda cost less than bottled water.
01:58 PM on 01/10/2010
There was a study in the San Diego area regarding this. The price variation was shocking, considerin­g that poor area businesses charged more than middle/upp­er class areas. I am talking about the same chain store, not convenienc­e stores. It was explained by those conducting the research that middle/upp­er class shoppers were more informed as to "fair" prices and that, therefore, poor, uninformed shoppers were victims only of their ignorance. (I think this study was done in the 80/s)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
WYHKTai-Tai
Wyoming, Hong Kong, Tai-Tai
04:46 AM on 01/06/2010
Where I live here in Hong Kong, there are 2 major supermarke­ts that provide free bus service around various neighborho­ods to their stores and back. They run every hour & they're free, as they bring customers to the store that would not otherwise have done their shopping there.

Why don't some of the supermarke­ts near these urban food deserts do that?

I can understand rural areas might not pan out, as they may not have enough customers close together, cost of gas, etc...
but urban neighborho­ods would have a number of shoppers at any given bus stop.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
grn1
11:07 AM on 01/04/2010
Excellent post Marian

Access to nutritious food IS a matter of social justice.