It's Been a Bad Week to be an Immigrant Child in the U.S.A.

Posted October 5, 2007 | 08:23 PM (EST)



stumbleupon :It's Been a Bad Week to be an Immigrant Child in the U.S.A.   digg: It's Been a Bad Week to be an Immigrant Child in the U.S.A.   reddit: It's Been a Bad Week to be an Immigrant Child in the U.S.A.   del.icio.us: It's Been a Bad Week to be an Immigrant Child in the U.S.A.

Children are sacred.

Industrialized countries understand that universal edict and defend children -- no matter their circumstances.

The countries that enslave children and prostitute, exploit and press them into soldier-duty are routinely considered less than civilized and unfit to join the power ranks of the developed world.

So, it's rather ironic that the leadership in this country can still hold their heads up high while they blatantly follow the paths of those countries we purposely shun for not being smart enough to safeguard their most precious asset -- the children.

2007-10-06-marilynkids7.jpg
(Source: University of Michigan)

It doesn't matter that the children are undocumented or immigrants. They are children with potential to grow into accomplished adults, able to achieve great things.

But the actions of the federal government and local leaders, who are on a path to cleanse cities of undocumented immigrants, are also in the process of washing away a reservoir of great potential for future leaders, scientists, writers, entertainers, etc. -- but most of all, contributing citizens. All over the nation, immigrant children, of all ages, have felt the ramifications of what it means to not be born in this country.

Undocumented college-age students spent as much time watching C-Span as MTV over the last two weeks as they waited for the Senate to vote on the Dream Act amendment that was to be added to the Defense Reauthorization Bill now under debate in the Senate.

Yet, like with the Immigration reform bill, the Senate couldn't come to an agreement. So the Dream Act amendment has been put on hold.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid promised to bring the measure back for a vote by mid-November. In the meantime, students who were ready to go to school are having to put their lives on hold -- yet again. No one can blame them if they're frustrated and feel like life is passing them by as they watch their friends whom they went to high school with enjoy their college years.

In Irving, Texas, school officials are reporting that, so far this week, about 90 immigrant chlidren have been pulled from the public schools by their parents.

Police have stepped up their efforts to deport undocumented immigrants so much that parents are worried that their children will be targeted in the schools.

In the neighboring suburb of Farmers Branch, city attorneys, on behalf of the City Council, have asked the local school district to supply them with the name and address of every child living in the city and enrolled in the public schools.

From a city council that earlier this year passed punitive measures meant to drive out undocumented immigrants from their suburb (like not allowing undocumented immigrants to rent apartments), no one trusts the motives for such an unusual request, and the City Council isn't explaining why they want it either.

Yet, the biggest blow this week came in the form of the Democrat's handling of the State Children's Health Insurance Program or SCHIP. Though Bush vetoed it and congressional Democrats blasted the President for depriving thousands of low-income Latino children of needed health coverage, the Democrats had earlier disappointed legal immigrant children by dropping the Immigrant Children's Health Improvement Act or ICHIA.

It didn't matter to the Democrats that Republicans were supporting this one measure that dealt fairly with immigrant children; they dropped it without explaining why.

Some have speculated it's because the term "immigrant" was in the name of the provision, and the term has such a negative connotation these days that politicians want to distance themselves as far from it as possible.

Maybe so, but distancing ourselves away from something or someone is also a way to abandon that issue or person.

As a country, we can't afford to abandon any child.

Why?

Because there's potential in their destiny, and that's worth caring about every time.

Comments for this post are now closed

 
 

Comments
24
Pending Comments
0

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)
- CLR See Profile I'm a Fan of CLR

Actually it does matter if these children are ILLEGAL or not. We spend BILLIONS in California for the education and health care of ILLEGALS. That is an unfair burden to have to endure. We need to deport all ILLEGALS, heavily fine those who hire ILLEGALS, and return to the original intent of the 14th amendment and do away with anchor babies. We should not have to support ILLEGALS at the expense of our own citizens.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:41 AM on 10/08/2007
- feelfree See Profile I'm a Fan of feelfree

The Dream Act would have just been another opportunity to screw over the middle class parents in this country who send their children to college AND international students who enter the country legally who pay additional fees in addition to higher tuition to attend American universities.

If a college-aged American citizen wants to attend college out of state the tuition doubles.

The Dream Act would have given an illegal a tuition break and he/she would pay in-state tuition regardless of the state they chose to attend college. This is simply unfair.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:25 PM on 10/06/2007
- CarmanK See Profile I'm a Fan of CarmanK

The greatest travesty against children of foreign national here illegally, is that the USA stands by and tolerates the Mexican government inhumane treatment of its citizens. The Mexican elites rob the people of their God given natural resources and horde the wealth of the country. Drug Cartels spread their poison and misery. I am not responsible for the starvation and poverty that sickens the Mexican economy. The greatest violator of Mexican family unity is the Mexican society.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:37 PM on 10/06/2007
- Independent_voter See Profile I'm a Fan of Independent_voter

It DOES MATTER whether the children are invited immigrants or illegal aliens!!! And if the illegal alien lobby doesn't like it, they can f*ck off.

I'm tired of my tax dollars being spent on free medical care, free education, free food, free housing and on and on for people who are here illegally.

There are US citizens that don't have food, that don't have medical care and that don't have a place to live. There are over 25,000 people in the Missouri Ozark area that go to bed hungry at night and there are American childred in this region that have to live in tents in the woods. After all of the citizens and invited immigrants are properly cared for, then if there is money left we can extend a helping hand to others. But we must take care of our own people first.

Mexico has become extremely good at dumping poor, ignorant people in the US so that Mexico doesn't have to feed and clothe them. Enough already.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:47 PM on 10/06/2007
- johnnyjust See Profile I'm a Fan of johnnyjust

Let's change the law to say that when an illegal immigrant drops an anchor baby, said child is not automatically a U.S. citizen until the parent(s) earn their own citizenship through proper legal procedure.

Seems fair.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:46 PM on 10/06/2007
- CLR See Profile I'm a Fan of CLR

I agree!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:42 AM on 10/08/2007
- rlehman See Profile I'm a Fan of rlehman

Who are you people? What happened to the generosity and compassion of the America I believed in as a child? The one that took the words on the Statue of Liberty seriously? We have the means and the resources. We simply squander them on less than meaningless or downright immoral priorities.

Seems to me if we concentrated our effort on our infrastructure there would be more than enough employment and revenue for everyone. But, apparently I'm missing something because all I hear is how expensive everything is and how we can't afford it. Rebuilding our infrastructure takes labor, paid labor equals taxes, taxes equals revenue, revenue equals the money necessary to provide for not only our citizens but for those who are here desperately trying to make a better life for themselves and their children.

If you had been born in the morass that is Mexico I certainly hope you would do everything you could, including crossing the border illegally, so that your children would have half a chance at a decent life.

Changing policy so that our country is a help rather than a hindrance to the people of Mexico and rebuilding our nation so that all who live here reap the rewards makes sense. But, of course making sense is the sure way to ruin for our nation. Or so my 'leaders' tell me.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:54 AM on 10/06/2007
- ms.understood See Profile I'm a Fan of ms.understood

"Who are we people?" We are people who are tired of footing the bill for people who aren't supposed to be here in the first place. I don't believe it would matter much if they were here illegally, but paying their own way, but since they are not, it's time for them to go home. You are absolutely right in saying that if I were born somewhere and had a chance to come here illegally, that I would risk it. What people fail to realize is that just like anything else that is illegal, if you do it, you accept the risk and whatever consequences that come. I also agree with the previous writer, we must take care of our own citizens first, and allow those who are here illegally to fight for their own rights in THEIR countries just like the African-Americans, Native Indians, Asians have done and to some degree, are still doing here in this country! It wouldn't bother me so much that they are here if they didn't demand things from taxpayers that they don't have the guts to demand in their own native land.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:51 PM on 10/06/2007
- rlehman See Profile I'm a Fan of rlehman

My daughter's partner had the guts to demand her rights as a human being in Mexico. Guess what? First her sister was beaten as a 'message' and told she would be next. Luckily she was able to get a visa and a green card and lives safely in the US.

I can't imagine being tired of footing the bill for any child. I also wonder if you are aware of the lack of workers in Washington state for the apple harvest. Are you aware of the 'ghost' social security taxes and income taxes paid by illegal immigrants?

The result of all those illegals going back to their home countries would be devastating to our local economy. America is paying the price for bigoted and culturally xenophobic immigration, foreign and economic policies. You reap what you sow. And babies are paying the price.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:54 AM on 10/08/2007
- michellemcleary See Profile I'm a Fan of michellemcleary

I can't image our family can move to France, put our kids in the government funded college, and ask for government financial aid, then expect a path to citizenship, (or Canada, or Spain, or China, or Mexico.)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:48 AM on 10/06/2007
- michellemcleary See Profile I'm a Fan of michellemcleary

I don't know where this notion that all American kids are so privledged. There are millions who would like a chance at college, can we do more to help encourage them, help them financially so they don't rack up $70,000 in college loan debt. Also can we please try to hire AMERICAN technical students from community colleges before hiring H1B Visa employees from overseas! CAN OUR CONGRESSMEMBERS PLEASE STEP OUT OF THE LIMO AND TAKE A LOOK AT REALITY HERE IN THE U.S. There are millions OF AMERICANS who would like the opportunity to get a good job! HOW ABOUT OFFERING US A COLLEGE EDUCATION AND A GOOD JOB!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:57 AM on 10/06/2007
- michellemcleary See Profile I'm a Fan of michellemcleary

There are millions of young people in this country who are citizens, who are poor, who struggle to get to a college education, what about them. There are hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants now taking seats in the state colleges while most students who apply every year are turned away. These colleges were built by taxpayer money, and are mostly funded by taxpayer money, let's serve poor AMERICANS first. What about their Dream? What do we have to offer up our state funded colleges to the world's immigrants at the expense of American kids?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:42 AM on 10/06/2007
- realitytrumpsbull See Profile I'm a Fan of realitytrumpsbull

Yeah yeah yeah yeah....how long did you folks
think the 'lets sneak 10 million people under
the wire, and see if anyone really notices' gambit was going to last for, anyway? There's
an agenda here, I call it the 'what-cha gonna DO about it' immigration plan,the REASON
for having some kind of immigration system is
to at least vainly TRY to prevent the United States from going the way of several countries
that've gone ahead and exhausted their resources such as fresh drinking water etc.
That dollar's paper-thin, and sinking fast against the Euro...there's 6.6 billion people
in the world, and, guess what, they can't all
move to the United States. Well, they could
try, but the Con Me would fold up like a cheap
kite about the time the first billion got here...it might do that anyway...THEN what are
they going to do?

Admit it, you've got stock in an HMO that stands to profit by your giveaway tax plan...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:51 AM on 10/06/2007
- LarryBlasko See Profile I'm a Fan of LarryBlasko

Folks, it's not a zero-sum game. Helping kids without regard to their documentation doesn't mean we'll stop helping other kids who were born here. And as these kids grow up, the U.S. -- not Mexico -- will reap the majority benefit from their education.

We need the labor, they need the jobs, and if we could just pry our politicians away from their mirrors, there are several possible ideas. I suggested one in "Opening the Borders," (Level 4 Press, 2007) and there are at least ten others.

We also need to stomp on the mindless hate of folks who are different, whether of color, language or land of birth. But they speak Spanish! Yeah, and in parts of New York, they speak Russian, or Ukranian, or Serbian, or Arabic, or -- fill in the blank -- and so what? What's important is not how they talk, but how they contribute and how we make certain that their children, have the opportunity to contribute still more.

Larry Blasko

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:58 AM on 10/06/2007
- CarmanK See Profile I'm a Fan of CarmanK

That's such crap. The multinational corporations spend billions of dollars poisoning the minds of American people with that self-serving propaganda . We have many unemployed who if trained properly and paid a living wage could and would work. "Necessity is the mother of invention" and if the US government enforced the law, multinationals would find a way to develop a work force. Mexican nationals working in America illegally are exploited and impoverished by multinational corporations that want "AMNESTY" for their illegal acts. They don't give a hoot about damaged lives. They also don't want to pay the freight for their workforce, they want to dump that costs onto to the American taxpayer.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:17 PM on 10/06/2007
- Ben Dixon See Profile I'm a Fan of Ben Dixon

A nation only has finite resources, there for I would hope that my government would spend those resources on American children before they do on illegal immigrant children.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:55 AM on 10/06/2007
- TuffPosh See Profile I'm a Fan of TuffPosh

Certainly, those kids can be great citizens, just in their home country. In fact, they could help Mexico become a better country rather than forcing their unwanted population to emigrate in exchange for the billions they send home, something that's aided and abetted by "liberals" as well as corrupt businesses.

As for the DREAM Act, it would let foreign citizens take college discounts from U.S. citizens.

In other words, if it passed some U.S. citizens would not be able to go to college because their discount was given to a foreign citizen who's here illegally.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:36 PM on 10/05/2007
- Tyle See Profile I'm a Fan of Tyle

"As a country, we can't afford to abandon any child."

As a country, deeply in debt and deeply taxed, we cannot afford to accept more responsibility. Mexico's rich and powerful are too greedy to share their wealth with own their people. Mexico has abandoned its people and now we are supposed to pay for their children's education?

We have to take care of our own before we can help anyone else. The children in Appalachia deserve our attention first.

The destiny of Mexicans is in Mexico. Help them get back to Mexico and help them get educational assistance from the Mexican government to one of the many universities and colleges in Mexico.

The National Autonomous University of Mexico is a large public university in Mexico and ranked one of the best. Help these people get back to their country .. help these people save their country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:29 PM on 10/05/2007
- skyblue See Profile I'm a Fan of skyblue

Great post.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:16 PM on 10/05/2007
- johnnyjust See Profile I'm a Fan of johnnyjust

Thank you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:12 PM on 10/06/2007
- Quaoar See Profile I'm a Fan of Quaoar

"But the actions of the federal government and local leaders, who are on a path to cleanse cities of undocumented immigrants, are also in the process of washing away a reservoir of great potential for future leaders, scientists, writers, entertainers, etc."

violent criminals, welfare recipients, prostitutes, drug dealers, depressors of prevailing local wage rates, contributors to global warming and general environmental degradation, telemarketers, etc.

I'm not against LEGAL immigration, but you have to present both sides of the issue. Not all illegal immigrants or children of illegal immigrants are paragons of virtue who will improve our country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:12 PM on 10/05/2007
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in


Bloggers Index›
Read All Posts by
Marisa Treviño›
 

 Site  Web ask.com