USA Today and Gallup released results from a one night survey yesterday that are very encouraging for Democrats: 49% of the adults surveyed nation-wide said "it is a good thing" that "the U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill that restructures the nation's healthcare system" and only 40% say it is a "bad thing." And yes, the improvement as compared to other surveys occurs along a predictable fault line: For the first time, a poll shows Democrats slightly more positive about the legislation (79% say it's a good thing) than Republicans are negative (76% say it's a bad thing). As I've been arguing recently (ditto for Josh Tucker), there is certainly room for Democrats to grow their support for health reform .
Perhaps even more intriguing, Gallup asked respondents to choose one of four terms -- enthusiastic, pleased, disappointed or angry -- to describe their reaction. "Although much of the public debate over healthcare reform has been heated," Gallup tells us, " barely a third of rank-and-file citizens express either enthusiasm (15%) or anger (19%) about the bill's passage." Even among Republicans, only 41% are angry.
But let's all take a deep breath and not over think this. Remember that this is a one-night poll, something inherently skewed to those who happened to be at home Monday night. Those at home were more likely to be following the news on a news day dominated by a huge and unqualified win for the Democrats, a day when for the first time in a long time the process stories that dominate coverage portrayed Obama and the Democratic leadership in a positive light.
Here's a reality check: One-night polls sometimes pick up momentary reactions that quickly fade. On June 9, 2009, Criegh Deeds won a dramatic, come from behind victory in Virginia's Democratic primary for governor. The next night, Rasmussen Reports fielded a one-night survey in Virginia and found a startling result: After having trailed on all previous polls, Deeds led Republican Bob McDonnell by six points (47% to 41%), after having trailed on all previous polls. Five days later, the DailyKos/Research 2000 poll had Deeds down by a point (45% to 44%). Two weeks later, PPP had him down by six. Thirty-six more polls followed over the next four months, and McDonnell led on every one.
Chuck Todd is right: At times like this, we just need to be patient and wait. In a week or so, we should have a good sense of whether this instant reaction is real or the artifact of a one night poll.
How will Donald Trump’s first 100 days impact YOU? Subscribe, choose the community that you most identify with or want to learn more about and we’ll send you the news that matters most once a week throughout Trump’s first 100 days in office. Learn more