More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Joseph

Mark Joseph

Posted: July 1, 2010 02:34 AM

Election 2010 and the End of Cristianity

What's Your Reaction:

There's an old saying that has guided American politics for a very long time, that "where you stand depends on where you sit," and there is perhaps no better example of it than the recent saga of party-switchers Charlie Crist and Arlen Specter, the Governor of Florida and the lame-duck Senator from Pennsylvania, respectively.

Crist and Specter were both Republicans who decided to leave the GOP when it became clear that it was the only way they were going to stave off more conservative opponents in Republican primaries. Nothing wrong with that of course, as there is a longstanding tradition of party-switching and going independent in our country.

But the real problem in the case of both Crist and Specter was that their stands on issues began to change immediately upon their switching parties, revealing them both to be shallow, opportunistic political creatures who seemed to have no inner core beliefs, but were instead willing to vote in whatever manner best fit their circumstances at the moment.

In the case of Specter an amazing thing happened shortly after he switched from the GOP to the Democrats: suddenly and without warning he began to vote like a Democrat. The sudden switch caused one right-wing group which had given Specter a 42 rating in 2008 and a lifetime rating of 43 to give him a rating of 20 after his switch and voila: a moderate Republican was suddenly transformed into a center-left Democrat.

Crist's transformation was even more sudden and dramatic: A longtime anti-abortion Governor when he was a Republican, within days of leaving the GOP to become an Independent Crist reversed his position on the issue, deciding to veto a bill which required women to have an ultrasound before receiving an abortion.

The voters of Pennsylvania tossed Specter out, choosing instead a race between a strong progressive named Joe Sestak and a strong conservative named Pat Toomey; Crist may be the next casualty. Instead, Tea Partiers and boldly progressive candidates may do well this year as the American people in 2010 seem to crave authenticity from their political leaders, be it center, left or right. They want bold colors, not pale pastels, to quote an authentic politician from another era, and what they don't want is Cristianity, a cynical brand of politics that is practiced by those who have no internal philosophical compass but are instead merely guided by the company they keep.

Whether 2010 is a year that tosses out politicians merely for being incumbents or is specifically targeted at those who support President Obama I can't say for sure, but what is appearing to be increasingly clear to me is that it will be the year in which voters reject Cristianity and insist on candidates whose positions are so rooted in who they are that, though they may change uniforms from one party to another or wear no party uniforms at all, their overall guiding political philosophy would remain unchanged and that where they stand would not be affected by where they happen to sit.

 
 
 

Follow Mark Joseph on Twitter: www.twitter.com/markmjm

 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:33 PM on 07/02/2010
I READ YOUR REVIEW OF GENERATION ZERO Bossie a Rightwing filmmaker(Bossie is as Right as David Kamp the Vanity Fair editor and a fellow anti-American lifestyle person is Left they are in both parties) claims that parents in the 1950's after enduring the Great Depression and World WarII were overly lenient with their children yes the 1950’s parents who beat kids and made them feel trapped were to nice to their kids. According to Bossie,because of the free culture of the 1950’s,the baby boomers by 1969 were dancing in the rain in Woodstock.From there by taking aim at “Ozzie and Harriet”,Bossie is claiming that the sitcoms of the 1950’s lead to a loose culture, which lead to the kids when they got older engaging in the controversial political activity of the 1960’s.Which led to the sitcoms, shopping malls, and massive deficits of the 1980’s.

Has Bossie noticed that right now in movie theaters you have one movie, “Get him to the Greek”, which mocks and makes fun of Rock stars. The second movie is a remake of the “A Team” they couldn’t do a “Karate Kid” remake without changing the villain from a stuck up fellow High school student to a Chinese national. You then have these animated films where the world’s biggest movie stars are the voices of Claymation characters.But Bossie still talks about the culture as if it's wild
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
09:19 AM on 07/01/2010
This implies that it's OK to be wrong, just so long as you really really believe it.
09:15 AM on 07/01/2010
My other point. What end of what Christianity? Christianity, assuming that you mean by this, modeling one's life on the example of Jesus Christ, has never really had more than a toe-hold in the United States. That's not about to change. That percentage of true Christian people are intact.

All those people who proclaim it and bandy about the name of Jesus are as Christian as I'm a devout Shintoist. Mark Twain nailed that hyppocrisy 100 years ago when he penned "Letters From the Earth." It still stands today. More so, in fact.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Cortez
If I had all the answers I wouldnt be writing here
01:49 AM on 07/02/2010
It's Cristianity as in Governor Charlie Crist not Christianity as in Jesus Christ.
09:08 AM on 07/01/2010
Could be the other way around, Mark. What if they voted with the party back then and today, having switched, teams they now vote with their core beliefs? Huh? Say what?

Before you repel me with various details. just remember, a politician is a politician first and then a human being. Oh wait, that could very well mean that in neither phase did they vote based on a core belief about anything. Ah, that's better. They were never human beings. Ta-da!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
collinda
1ProudVet
07:55 AM on 07/01/2010
This guy isn't even paying attention. Key difference between Spector and Crist: One's a governor. Governors are expected to rise above politics and get things done. Think of it in terms of a red state like LA before and after the oil spill. Two totally different mindsets. When Republican are in office, deficits (and the Constitution) don't matter. "Tea Bagger" Rubios' small government message will not work with an oil spill baring down on Florida. They got millions of fed dollars to lobbying for and years of clean up ahead to save their #1 industry: Tourism
RabidRightRebel
A moderate voice who rejects the rabid right
07:47 AM on 07/01/2010
I do not know what you are talking about: As far as I can see the Republicans have been overrun by rabid right religious fanatics who think praying will solve the oil spill and the economic crisis.

Naturally this has led to a certain degree of contempt for the evangelical fanatics but it does not mean the end of Christianity any more than the Spanish inquisition was the end of Christianity.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
The End is near
06:24 AM on 07/01/2010
That clever headline will probably draws lots of clicks.

"Nothing wrong with that of course, as there is a longstanding tradition of party-switching and going independent in our country."

That longstanding tradition of party-switching is a longstanding tradition of wrongness.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matt Osborne
03:10 AM on 07/01/2010
If Crist were a stock, I'd buy him. As for Specter: wasn't his opponent coming from the left?

If teabagging was a stock, I'd short it. The "movement" has made lots of noise, but it's proving electorally impotent and its candidates who do win become gifts that refuse to stop giving.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
The End is near
06:26 AM on 07/01/2010
Specter's polling indicated that he could not win the Republican primary, so he changed parties believing that he would fare better in the Dem primary and he didn't.