NYR More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Juddery

Mark Juddery

Posted: August 2, 2010 07:50 AM

Two weeks ago, I presented a taste of my book, Overrated: The 50 Most Overhyped Things in History. As expected, it garnered a few (hundred) angry comments. According to these (mostly anonymous) critics, baseball is on the list because, um, I'm insanely jealous of Americans (sorry, but even though I like many of them... I don't want to be one). Meanwhile, I included Woodstock because I have "boomer envy" (an ailment invented by boomers, specifically those who haven't done anything interesting since 1982), and added Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club because I'm a Beatles "hater". Interesting... but as people who actually know me are aware, I adore the Beatles: "Abbey Road," "Revolver," "Rubber Soul"... even two or three songs on "Sgt Pepper." That doesn't stop Pepper from being highly overrated.

OK, maybe people will calm down if I mention a few things that deserve a greater reputation, but have been overshadowed by the hype that has gone to baseball, "Sgt Pepper" and other overrated things. Here, to balance that last slideshow, are eight underrated things. (Not the most underrated things, because if anything's vastly underrated, I probably haven't heard of it.) No doubt, when you read this list, you'll only have nice things to say. Or maybe not.

If you want to see (and comment) more, check out 50-most-overrated.blogspot.com/. Or just buy the damn book.

The Bangladesh Cyclone
1 of 9
Even though nearly 350 years have passed since the Great Fire of London, one remarkably sensitive person said that I shouldn’t have trivialized the victims. I didn’t. Quite simply, there were only six of them (or eight, according to other sources). I didn’t make that up! Sure, it would have been better if there had been none, but six (or eight) is still a pretty mild death toll for something considered one of history’s great disasters. Even if you include the people who possibly died indirectly (through smoke inhalation, or homelessness), it is still dwarfed by countless other disasters. Take the Bangladesh Cyclone, which struck the Ganges Delta far more recently than 1666. November 13, 1970, to be exact. Estimated number of deaths? One million. That’s one million. Have you heard of it? While we still wax lyrical about the terror of the Great Fire of London, three centuries ago, we don’t often spare a thought for the disaster that added the most to Bangladesh’s woes, a mere four decades ago. Now that’s trivializing! Could it be that we still don’t regard third-world lives as greatly as western lives? No, that can’t be right...
Total comments: 132 | Post a Comment
1 of 9
This Underrated Thing
Unimpressive
Seriously Underrated!

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

  • 5

  • 6

  • 7

  • 8

  • 9

  • 10
Top 5 Underrated Things
Users who voted on this slide
loading...

 
 
 
Two weeks ago, I presented a taste of my book, Overrated: The 50 Most Overhyped Things in History. As expected, it garnered a few (hundred) angry comments. According to these (mostly anonymous) critic...
Two weeks ago, I presented a taste of my book, Overrated: The 50 Most Overhyped Things in History. As expected, it garnered a few (hundred) angry comments. According to these (mostly anonymous) critic...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 132
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
08:02 PM on 08/07/2010
Thank you for your opinions on broccoli. Among vegetables, its the best substitute for meat -- in fact it's meats equal, that flavor and texture of steamed broccoli. That it is also healthy, well, it's almost too good to be true.
08:14 PM on 08/03/2010
Velvet Underground?

That is the most overrated "cult" band EVER! Sure, they had some influence in the art world and music scene, but their songs were mediocre, and that's a compliment. Name one great song they wrote. There are a couple of decent tracks and one album worth a listen and that's it. There is a reason they aren't rated highly. Yes, "Heroine", great, "Waiting", okay, Femme Fetale...that's it.

Now, Iggy Pop, the Grandfather of Punk...replace VU with him and you will be "Fixing a Hole" in your list.

And "The Prisoner". Spot on pick there, but I think it's no longer underrated.

Peace,
Tex Shelters
07:00 PM on 08/03/2010
This guy thinks that The Velvet Underground and Nico is underrated???

Probably one of the most famous rock albums out there.. one that helped spark a garage rock movement. It's highly rated and very well known.
02:13 PM on 08/03/2010
I bought this album back in the late 60's when it came out. For some reason it has always been considered a "cult classic" (even shortly after it came out - which seems very weird to me). I've never understood why it didn't sell far more copies (it wasn't easy to find actually). Could it have something to do with being considered "cool" only if the number of people who really appreciate you is small?
02:06 PM on 08/03/2010
I don't know what children you know but my almost 7 year old grandson has been a huge fan of dinosaurs since he could express his preference in reading material at about age 18 months (he was an early & excellent speaker). He is very familiar with Apatosaurus & never heard of Brontosaurus until I asked him about it & he responded with a puzzled look. Brontosaurus - no mention in any of the dozens of dinosaur books he has.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skatscan
05:03 PM on 08/03/2010
It's been the standard for about 20 years now. Apatosaurus is what all museums refer to now.
02:00 PM on 08/03/2010
Many years ago (when my girls who are in their mid-30's now were about 4 & 7), a searcher decided to do an informal investigation of children's attitudes toward vegetables. So teams of researchers headed off to preschools & daycare centers. They were absolutely astonished that, given the choice, little kids prefer broccoli over all other veggies. Besides loving the sweet mild taste of fresh broccoli, they loved that it came in the form of "little trees" that were so easy for them to handle & eat.
08:37 AM on 08/03/2010
Who's more overrated? Bruce Springsteen, or Frank Zappa?
08:25 AM on 08/03/2010
"The Prisoner", I'm afraid, has to go in the overrated pile. It comes from a dark day in Britain's history. The people who gave us Shakespeare and Milton spent about a decade seemingly unable to tell a coherent story. It has nothing to do with "The Prisoner" being deep or inpenetrable, it's quite simply a victim of an extreme case of Form Over Substance, along with "The Avengers" "Doctor Who" and anything produced by Gerry and Sylvia Anderson not involving marionettes. I enjoy all of these, by the way, but more often than not they don't make a lick of sense.
03:04 AM on 08/03/2010
The fact that this is the main item on the Huffpost books homepage means I can avoid the Huffpost books homepage for a few months and not miss anything I would be interested in.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
c-tom
Badges we don't need no stinking badges
02:23 AM on 08/03/2010
Ultimate(1968), Velvet Underground (1965-73) and The Prisoner (1967-68) are all under-rated examples of the over-rated baby boomers.

The real under-rated award should go to Lester Dent who wrote 159 Doc Savage novels.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shaddup
02:07 PM on 08/03/2010
I love Doc, and still celebrate Dent's birthday, then again, I'm a pulp writer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Radarman
09:37 AM on 08/13/2010
How many characters and buddy teams were based on Ham and Monk? Is John Steed Ham's long lost son?
12:09 AM on 08/03/2010
How come it asks a question and then gives the answer? How about asking us to think? Broccoli?
Not a chance. Beets.
08:26 AM on 08/03/2010
Can beets actually be underrated?
photo
mlaiuppa
Pres. Sarcasm Society. Like we need your approval.
11:25 PM on 08/02/2010
Ultimate disc? Try adding a dog and then you might have something. You want a sport of skill, cunning and tactics that doesn't favor men or women? Try....croquette.

Brontosaurus is 4 syllables. Apatosaurus is 5. Brontosaurus just trips off the tongue easier. Beginning with a consonant doesn't hurt either. I personally think that if they can demote Pluto from being a planet to being a big rock, they can decide to replace the term Apatosaurus with Brontosaurus and make everyone happy. Especially six year olds.

As for under-rated TV. I agree with The Prisoner. But would like to add the TV version of The Highlander. It was basically a Talmudic discussion with swords and @$$-kicking. It was the TV show that kept the franchise alive so long. Fans still discuss the moral and ethical points of different episodes.
08:39 AM on 08/03/2010
Hold on there, skippy. Croquette? Not unless it's preceeded by the word "chicken". That's about as much of a sport as darts, billiards, or bocce.
Ultimate, which actually involves athleticism, is one of very few team sports where men and women play together. The Mixed Division is one of the most competitive in the sport - each team fields 7 players, 4 men and 3 women. Works out very well. And dogs? I have yet to see a dog throw a frisbee.
photo
mlaiuppa
Pres. Sarcasm Society. Like we need your approval.
12:23 AM on 08/05/2010
Did I sell it wrong? Ah, yes. Croquet. I am totally bad at French.

I wouldn't sell any of those games short, although I thing croquet deals a lot more with tactics than the others. Dart, billiards, bocce, horseshoes, bowling and yes, frisbee deal with skill. Croquet has a component that requires tactical decision making more like chess. And there is Ultimate chess. Fast chess, also known as blitz chess, lightning chess, sudden death, speed chess, bullet chess and rapid chess. But you don't sweat when you play and it's not much of a spectator sport either.

Is Ultimate about frantic, sweating and smelly? Or is it about cunning, skill, tactics? Since when does athleticism require frantically running after a ball or disc?

I don't think people play enough croquet to really appreciate the game. Tournaments will never be televised, unlike that most thrilling Ultimate game....golf. Or bowling.

My brother-in-law used to play guerilla croquet during lunch. he'd keep a set in the car and on his lunch hour he and his buddies would head off to the nearest park. But they'd expand the regulation field to the entire park and use the obstacles presented as part of the game. Croquet meets miniature golf on steroids.

Do I go for the wicket or whack your ball into eternity? Decisions decisions.
09:19 PM on 08/02/2010
I still prefer Brontosaurus to Apatosaurus. While Apatosaurus was published first, that was because O.C. Marsh was in a publication race with E.D. Cope. He found (well, was sent) a small deposit of bones, couldn't figure out much about them, so published his scant findings and called it Apatosaur or 'deceptive lizard'. Some time later he got a much larger collection of bones (which, as you say, included the bones of at least two species; it also included the bones of more than one Brontosaur/Apatosaur). He put it all together into a much too large specimen and called it 'thunder lizard', and never noticed that it was (well, parts of it were!) the same as his Apatosaur. So both collections were badly handled and poorly studied; but I prefer Thunder Lizard to Deceptive Lizard. Even the slimmed-down version of Bronto that later, more thorough studies came up with is one hecka big beast!
photo
JDM73
male, 38, writer/draughtsman/ex-musician
07:50 PM on 08/02/2010
The mighty Velvet Underground...true experimentation within a rock framework, both musically and lyrically. Lou Reed, John Cale and Sterling Morrison composed first-rate songs that don't sound remotely dated, even today--and which paved the way for punk in the '70s ('I'm Waiting For The Man', 'Run Run Run'), goth in the '80s ('All Tomorrow's Parties') and "alternative" in the '90s ('Sunday Morning', 'I'll Be Your Mirror').
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mojo filter
07:45 PM on 08/02/2010
"Wagner's music is better then it sounds."

That quote sums up the Velvet Ungerground to me. I'll take Sgt. Pepper any day.