Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Marlo Thomas

GET UPDATES FROM Marlo Thomas
 

A Size Zero Dress Does Not Equal Success

Posted: 10/09/2012 9:12 am

When Lady Gaga recently gained 25 pounds, the internet went crazy posting the "shocking" photos, along with derogatory comments and even speculating as to whether she may have packed on the pounds as a publicity stunt. Really? Who does that? In response to all the negative commentary, Gaga attributed the weight gain to simply eating too much pasta at her father's restaurant. But she also revealed that she has been suffering from eating disorders since she was 15.

Christina Aguilera was also in the news recently when she addressed her weight gain over the past year. She said that she had simply grown tired of constantly struggling to be super skinny in order to please record executives. She said that throughout her career, executives at her record label pressured her to remain thin and even went so far as to stage a weight intervention, but this time she told them, "I'm fat. Deal with it." She went on to say, "They need a reminder sometimes that I don't belong to them. It's my body."

Of course, eating disorders and the societal pressures to be thin are nothing new. And they are nothing to trivialize. They are painful for the girl or woman who is going through them, as well as their families. Even my good friend Katie Couric recently revealed that she, too, had suffered from bulimia in her teens and twenties as she strived for physical perfection. These revelations -- and conversations -- are a good thing. They help us know that, however down we may feel about our bodies at different times in our lives, there are many women we hold as role models who have been there, too. Lady Gaga, who is ahead of the pack in so many ways, sent a very positive message to her legions of fans -- to accept their bodies regardless of weight, scars or any other perceived "imperfections."

This positive reinforcement is much needed. Young women -- and some older ones as well -- can't help but feel insecure as they leaf through the fashion magazines' portrayal of young women with unattainable, airbrushed imagery that depicts an entirely unrealistic physical ideal. And even though we should know better by now, many of us are still comparing ourselves to that ideal.

So we thought our best response to the recent public scoldings these famous women are getting for putting on a few pounds is to remind us all that there are images of strength and success and beauty around us that are not airbrushed. And don't ask to be.

We all know that carrying too much weight can cause serious health problems. Obesity can lead to diseases that can threaten our lives. But that needn't force us to hold ourselves to one ideal. And, hey, who gets to decide what's beautiful? So let's remind ourselves and our daughters that achievement, talent and strength are beautiful in themselves. And that, by the way, physical beauty comes in a whole lot of sizes.

So in that spirit, here are ten women we love. Not a one among them is a size zero, but they all kick ass.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Adele

    In an age of manufactured pop stars, Adele is a wonderful example of true substance and talent rising to the top. The British superstar has topped the charts around the globe and the image she projects is as strong and beautiful as her vocals.

  • Christina Hendricks

    Though she may not appreciate being called "full-figured," there's no denying that the voluptuous "Mad Men" star is a complete knockout in her role as office manager Joan Harris. While some say she represents a physical ideal from another era, others may argue that she's ideal in any era.

  • Queen Latifah

    Recording artist, movie star, producer and cover girl, Queen Latifah has always presented a confident, smart and positive image to audiences. In her ten years as one of the faces representing Cover Girl cosmetics, she has shown that beauty comes in many different shapes and sizes.

  • Kate Winslet

    Though her weight fluctuations have been well-documented, Winslet has never allowed Hollywood to dictate her weight. In 2003, when she appeared on the cover of the UK edition of GQ magazine, she was digitally slimmed to such a degree that she felt compelled to make a public statement. ā€œI do not look like that, and more importantly, I don’t desire to look like that.ā€ Beautiful.

  • Jennifer Lopez

    Though Jennifer Lopez is now a global superstar, and an international sex symbol, her body type was not always considered ideal by Hollywood standards. But Lopez was smart enough to know that you work with what you have and you make the most of it. And by fully embracing her figure and celebrating it rather than trying to hide it, she helped change perceptions about what is truly an "ideal" figure.

  • Mindy Kaling

    Star-on-the-rise Mindy Kaling stepped into the spotlight on the NBC series "The Office," and is now writing and starring in her very own series, "The Mindy Project." Whether she is acting, writing or walking the red carpet, Mindy seems well-aware that it is her uniqueness in a sea of same-ness that sets her apart, and that trying to conform to the ideals of others is truly a fool's game.

  • Kelly Clarkson

    Ever since Clarkson won the first season of "American Idol" in 2002, both the media and the public have obsessed about her weight. But through it all, Clarkson has shown the same independence, resilience and confidence that is reflected in her music. By rejecting industry pressure to present herself as something other than what she is, Clarkson has become a positive role model to millions of young women.

  • Jennifer Coolidge

    Character actress Jennifer Coolidge has appeared in countless films and television shows, but she is perhaps best-known as the sexy "Stifler's mom" in the film "American Pie." Whether she's playing a bubble-headed manicurist in "Legally Blonde," a ditzy dog owner in "Best in Show," or the kooky neighbor on the hit show, "2 Broke Girls," Coolidge is consistently sexy, funny and endearing, and she has never needed to be a size zero to play the "hot blonde."

  • Melissa McCarthy

    From her hilarious turn in "Bridesmaids" to her TV series "Mike & Molly," Melissa McCarthy has become a fan favorite with her brilliant comic timing and versatility as an actress. Though she may play characters who have issues with their weight, she is never the butt of the joke. Instead, she makes us laugh with her attitude, her energy and her spot-on characterizations.

  • Candy Crowley

    As CNN's Chief Political Correspondent and host of "State of the Union," award-winning journalist Candy Crowley has earned industry-wide respect and admiration the old-fashioned way -- she worked her way up from a position as a radio newsroom assistant. On October 16, she will become the first woman to moderate a presidential debate in two decades.

 

Follow Marlo Thomas on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MarloThomas

FOLLOW MARLOTHOMAS
When Lady Gaga recently gained 25 pounds, the internet went crazy posting the "shocking" photos, along with derogatory comments and even speculating as to whether she may have packed on the pounds as ...
When Lady Gaga recently gained 25 pounds, the internet went crazy posting the "shocking" photos, along with derogatory comments and even speculating as to whether she may have packed on the pounds as ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 522
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (13 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abscs2000
12:12 PM on 11/13/2012
Uh, yes it does.
03:35 PM on 11/05/2012
You have always looked anorexic.........who do you think you're kidding.
11:28 PM on 10/14/2012
Personally skinny is a turn off for me, for two reasons...
1) The last thing I want is a woman who reminds me of me when I was twelve, rail thin and so crippled by insecurity it hurts to go outside. I've moved on and I'm not interested in moving back to jr high-ville so I can be your emotional stepping stones. Besides, unless your interested in becoming a man what worked for me won't work for you.

2) An ounce of confidence erases 50 lbs in the blink of an eye. Seriously it's all about confidence don't ever forget that.
10:52 PM on 10/14/2012
Let's be realistic here. For years, the media and the entertainment industry has set the standard for a woman's beauty. Models are thin. The woman named the sexiest woman alive is not a plus size woman. Instead of pointing out larger woman who are celebrities or successful, why not cover the successes of women in general. I am a petite small successful woman, I worked hard at both.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abscs2000
12:15 PM on 11/13/2012
Go andrea! I'm with you, F & F
09:54 PM on 10/14/2012
I have spent decades in health care, have read thousands of history and physical reports. The majority of the time doctors refer to female patients as obese, whil the guy can have a giant beer gut and no reference to weight is mentioned. It's everywhere,this double standard.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
09:48 PM on 10/14/2012
"A Size Zero Dress Does Not Equal Success"

---

OMG, that's SO true.

http://i.huffpost.com/gen/815078/thumbs/o-KIM-KARDASHIAN-SEXY-570.jpg?7
09:23 PM on 10/14/2012
No woman, no matter what she weighs should have to apologize for her weight. Men don't. I don't care if you're a size 0 or a size 22, no woman should have to make excuses for the space she takes up. Girls need to be told that they're worth more than their size, no matter what that size might be.
09:19 PM on 10/14/2012
Despite the fact that I generally agree with the sentiment of this article, I don't think it's really saying anything at this point. Bloggers post the same stuff about our society's warped beauty standards like every 45 minutes. At this point, especially with the photo montage, all you're doing is demarcating which public figures fall under those standards and which don't. Yeah, our beauty ideals are messed up and make a lot of women and men sick but this article doesn't seem to be making me feel any better about what my body looks like or any more hopeful that one day we'll embrace a more diverse concept of beauty. This is an ongoing problem and no one seems to have any better ideas about dealing with it than: 1. denounce unattainable beauty standards 2. dig up quotes of famous women saying they accept their bodies 3. photo montage of "curvy" women who, despite being "plus sized" are still better looking than most average people.
08:47 PM on 10/14/2012
The models of the '50s were curvy and gorgeous. Marilyn Monroe and Sophia Loren were NOT size 0s.

At what point did the beauty standard require that a woman look like an anorexic adolescent BOY?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abscs2000
12:17 PM on 11/13/2012
One can be naturally thin and still have a sexy body with proportionate bust, waist and hips.
08:34 PM on 10/14/2012
If success = identifying microbial organisms under a microscope then size 0 doesnt matter. If success = gaining and keeping the attention of heterosexual men then size 0 absolutely matters.

Its like parking a Lamborghini next to a Suburban... which gets the most looks....
photo
Freethinking American
Reason begets humanity for humanity
08:31 PM on 10/14/2012
In the past, the "beauty" we seek today -- emaciated shells of women, starving themselves to look like teenage boys, would be considered grotesque. Why are curvy women seen in such a bad light nowadays? When did the body of a young boy become the model for feminine beauty? Ruben had the right idea.
08:50 PM on 10/14/2012
Because in the past women were covered up from head to toe. In order to look skinny they wore unbelievable torture devices such as girdles and corsets.... Look up wasp-waist.... Thats not a modern term.
photo
Freethinking American
Reason begets humanity for humanity
05:30 AM on 10/15/2012
Those devices were intended to accentuate curves, not hide them. It's only in modern times that we have decided that our women should look like prepubescent boys; e.g., Twiggy.
photo
Pubdestroyer
Just your average comedic intellectual who is curr
08:54 PM on 10/14/2012
Ruben had the right idea before scientists discovered a direct connection between obesity and a hundred life-threatening diseases.
photo
Freethinking American
Reason begets humanity for humanity
05:34 AM on 10/15/2012
I think the pendulum has swung far too much toward the concentration-camp look. You're free to be choose women who look like boys -- different strokes.
08:30 PM on 10/14/2012
A Size Zero Dress Does Not Equal Success... Maybe not but in any industry where looks count a size 20 = No Success.
09:55 PM on 10/14/2012
Unless you're male (cee lo green, meatloaf...).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
katmeyster
We don't have a spending problem.
07:36 PM on 10/14/2012
My friend's sister was 5'10" and 115lbs and wanted to be a model. She spent a lot of her time on diuretics and speed -- yet she was constantly told she was too fat and needed to lose another 5 pounds. Is that healthy? The designers don't think their clothes look good on anyone who isn't heroin thin, and I'm so sorry that people buy into this crazy, crazy, ideal.

It's a pretty sick reflection of our society (but not new, really).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
katmeyster
We don't have a spending problem.
07:30 PM on 10/14/2012
What cracks me up is when not-so-great-looking men complain about movie stars who move from size 0 to size 4, or who show a tiny bit of cellulite, or make the offensive move of growing too old. Its as if the only purpose of a woman is to be sexy to them, or be able to bear their children. I take it back, its not funny.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptainFrogbert
05:00 PM on 10/14/2012
Weight shouldn't be the issue. Skinny does not equal healthy. Think of some of the female athletes at the Olympics, like some of the water polo players. They would be considered "plus size" but nobody, but NOBODY can play water polo and be out of shape. They are, by definition, healthy.

It's not about dress size. Or it shouldn't be. It's a shame that too often, it is.
photo
Pubdestroyer
Just your average comedic intellectual who is curr
08:55 PM on 10/14/2012
You know nothing about the connection between skinny and healthy. Fat is not where it's at when it comes to longevity.
09:40 PM on 10/20/2012
yeah but plus size also doesnt equal healthy