Huffpost Entertainment
The Blog

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Marshall Fine Headshot

Live from Sundance Film Festival: Day 1

Posted: Updated:

They want to rebrand - or perhaps reboot - the Sundance Film Festival this year. Which is why, when you sit in one of the theaters waiting for a film to start, you get a shimmering display that looks like LED lights, which occasionally coalesce into words to reveal the festival's message in what are meant to be Jenny Holzer-like epigrams:

"This is cinematic rebellion."

"This is the renewed rebellion."

"This is the rebirth of the battle for brave new ideas."

What are they rebelling against? Well, as Marlon Brando said in "The Wild One," "What have you got?"

Yes, Sundance has a new artistic director this year. Programmer John Cooper has succeeded Geoff Gilmore who spent decades in the job and oversaw the rise and fall of independent film from sex, lies, & videotape to Precious and (500) Days of Summer.

Cooper and his crew have been vocal about their impulse to go back to the festival's original impulse: to nurture the artist with an independent vision, to work outside the mainstream, to support filmmakers who are willing to push the envelope.

Which means that this rebellious new Sundance attitude may also signal Sundance's first video-on-demand festival - because, essentially, that's where way more of Sundance's best movies are going to wind up, instead of being snatched up for theatrical release.

Oh, sure, there will be Sundance films that find their way into theaters, but the days of the mega-bucks Sundance sale - or sales - seems distinctly in the past. Ten years ago, even five years ago, films that played at Sundance could expect to find their way into theaters within a few months or by the end of that year. And that includes even less commercial fare such as David Siegel and Scott McGehee's Suture or Rebecca Miller's Personal Velocity. There are still worthy films from Sundance 2009 - films with big stars in them like The Greatest and I Love You, Philip Morris - that are awaiting release, more than a year later.

But this year, Sundance actually has a section devoted to three films that will begin airing in video-on-demand venues the same day that they play in Park City. "Experience the Sundance Film Festival from your living room!" read one press release I received.

Once upon a time, a timely and provocative political documentary such as Michael Winterbottom's film of Naomi Klein's book, The Shock Doctrine, could count on a theatrical release in, at minimum, Manhattan. No more. Now it's part of Sundance Selects' program of films released straight to your home distribution system. It's a symptom of where the economics of independent film have gone - and perhaps the thing that will help take the taint off the tag "straight to home video."

It's hard to imagine that Cooper's other innovation - the "Next" series, films made on a shoestring by filmmakers with enthusiasm, if not necessarily story-telling skill - will result in the films actually being seen outside of Sundance. Unless, again, some video-on-demand concern pays its pittance for them.

A film like Kate Aselton's The Freebie has the potential to break out, because it's emotionally smart and features strong performances by Dax Shepard and Aselton (star of the FX comedy The League who also happens to be Mrs. Mark Duplass). On the other hand, something like Linas Phillips' virtually unwatchable Bass Ackwards barely belongs in a festival, let alone running around loose in public where a real person might buy a ticket to it. And more of these entries resemble Phillips' effort than Aselton's.

The unspoken truth at this year's festival seems to be that there is no market for the artsy and adventurous little narrative film or the hard-hitting doc (at least the ones that aren't made by Michael Moore). The alumni of last year's Sundance doc crop - The Cove, Crude and several others - did virtually no business when they reached theaters, despite critical encomiums and massive press.

And what of a little film like Howl, which opened the festival last night?

This commentary continues on my website.