iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Marty Kaplan

Marty Kaplan

Posted: March 16, 2008 01:39 PM

My Goat Ate the Economy


If George W. Bush had read The Pet Goat to his Economic Club of New York audience on Friday, his speech would have been no less infantile. If the first 9/11 was caused by a massive failure of intelligence about terrorism, the second 9/11 -- the slow-motion collapse of the American, and maybe the global, economy -- has been caused by a catastrophic failure of intelligence about Wall Street rapacity. If the now five-year-old Iraq war was the inevitable, tragic consequence of the neoconservatives' Project for the New American Century, then the subprime mortgage quagmire, the Bear Stearns bailout, and the foreclosure fiasco are the foreordained outcome of the Republican ideology which holds that regulation of corporate financial behavior is the domestic equivalent of Islamofascism.

The economic meltdown is the new 9/11, and it's George W. Bush's fault -- his, and the fundamentalist free-marketeers who have been living high on the hog, feeding at the public trough, intimidating Democrats, and getting away with capitalist murder ever since Ronald Reagan made "government" a dirty word.

"An interesting time," Bush called it at the Economic Club. That's the financial version of Rumsfeld's "stuff happens" analysis when rioting and looting engulfed Baghdad. (Will the media celebrate that five-year anniversary, too?) Every cocky corporate titan who has been caught in flagrante delicto has been written off by Republicans as an isolated exception. Every ingenious, computer-assisted Ponzi scheme has turned out, Milton Freedman be praised, to be legal. Ken Lay and Jeffrey Skilling? A couple of bad apples. Pump and dump? In the eye of the beholder. Slice-and-dice derivatives? As patriotic as a flag lapel pin.

"Moral hazard" is a term given currency by today's subprime mortgage crisis. It means that people will take a stupid risk if they believe they won't have to pay a price if things go sour. Years ago, during the savings and loan crisis, the principle of moral hazard was front and center; gamblers like Neil Bush, of Silverado Savings and Loan, flourished because buccaneers of his ilk were protected from the downside of their speculation by no-fault taxpayer-funded insurance. (No doubt that's what his brother the President meant in his first inaugural about ushering in an era of personal responsibility.) Today, the Fed's rescue of Bear Sterns -- the poster child of Wall Street greed and recklessness -- has brought "moral hazard" back to the fore. Bear Stearns says these guiding principles are the blueprint for how it does business: "respect, integrity, meritocracy, innovation and a commitment to philanthropy." In the wake of the bailout, maybe they should switch their motto to Alfred E. Newman's: "What, Me Worry?"

"Moral hazard" is how we got into Iraq. Colin Powell's Pottery Barn rule -- "you break it, you own it" -- is wrong. Bush broke Iraq, but we own it. Just as we, the taxpayers, are being forced to pay for the crockery broken by the Bush Party on Wall Street, we -- the taxpayers, the soldiers, their families, and America's reputation in the world -- are being forced to pay the price for the hubris of the neocon "freedom agenda." Is it too farfetched to compare Bush's pardon of Scooter Libby with Ben Bernanke's pardon of Bear Stearns? If you want to see why the insane risks of invading Iraq seemed so tolerable to the White House, look no farther than the unitary executive, the signing statements, and an opposition that would take impeachment off the table.

Toxic dumps are required to have warning signs on them. It would be fitting if schoolchildren saw a mandatory DANGER: MORAL HAZARD notice when, on a day that can't come too soon, they enter the George W. Bush Presidential Library.

Follow Marty Kaplan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/martykaplan

 
 
  • Comments
  • 400
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
hypnotoad72
Real democracy = living wages.
07:13 PM on 03/23/2008
Hmmm: Gas prices, lack of wages, the war, offshoring... plenty of reasons why things are in disarray. Whether or not which factor of them all is the primary cause of our economy teetering is up for debate.

Still, what needs to be done to raise the value of the Dollar and put things back to rights?
06:09 PM on 03/21/2008
Shock Doctrine,

Robber Barons,

Conservative=corporatist=fascist=GOP=BushCo=McCain=Bankruptcy.

Bankrupt morally, intellectually, politically.

Bankrupt financially unless you are one of the few chosen cronies.

The Permanent republican fascist majority is still moving forward toward a Hoover depression, so they can further dominate the peasants and avoid prosecution.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rmabelis
10:57 AM on 03/18/2008
Our economic problems are not caused by a lack of intelligence concerning the rapacity of Wall Street. Promoting that rapacity is the purpose of Republican Ideology. Greed is, according to Republican ideology, good. Indeed greed is the greatest of all possible goods. How else do we provide incentives to producers to produce more of the things we want and need? You can't have capitalism without greed. The entire goal of Republican low tax on the rich economics is the promotion of greed.

We have created a culture of greed. The rapacity of Wall Street is nothing more than a result of the promotion of greed. You get what the system you put in place is designed to produce. The prevailing ideology of the post Reagan Revolution political system aims at the creation of an economy based on greed. And because greed is now at the heart of our economic thinking the solution to our economic problems may have to be far more radical than most Americans are willing to accept. At least until greed has done its destructive work.
04:25 PM on 03/18/2008
"At least until greed has done its destructive work."

Mission accomplished!
09:09 AM on 03/18/2008
Excellent post. The current economic 'slowdown,' or whatever you want to call it, is still in its early stages; things will get worse before they get better. There is a tidal wave of instability that is wreaking havoc on the economy, producing more bad news with almost every new day. If anything, this administration's policies, particularly borrowing money from foreign countries to pursue its foreign policy misadventures and encouraging corrupt plutocrats to run amok, have exacerbated the serious structural weaknesses within the American economy that have been building up for decades.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
provoice
12:24 AM on 03/18/2008
The sad part of money is that if you have enough of it, you will always be able to make MORE... regardless of what happens to the economy.

As a result, the affluent look at a downturn in the economy as a chance to do something different to make money... buy gold, sell short, become slum landlords... whatever it takes.

Meanwhile, the poor sucker on the bottom of the heap becomes the recipient of the "trickle down"... which is basically what happens to cow crap if you happen to be under the leaky barn floor.

Taking back our country is beginning to look like it is going to take a lot more than just voting the scoundrels out... we may have to start a whole new underground economy that shuts out the big guys!
11:48 PM on 03/17/2008
The three worst things that will destroy our economy and make you lose your job are:

1. High tax rates on Americans
2. Less free trade (i.e. more tariffs and restrictions)
3. More business regulation and government interference

Obama and Hillary want to do all three.
01:47 AM on 03/18/2008
BTN: Spoken like a true Republican. How come the economy almost always does better under Dems?
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
RButler
I've always wanted to have everything I wanted
10:42 PM on 03/23/2008
They can lower taxes all they want. The oil companies and other corporations will just capture that excess money for their profits and their CEO's salaries. That $600 check Bush is cutting you. Heck. The oil companies already have a claim on it as gasoline prices rise to $4/gal and over. I know. I know. You thought you were going to put it towards a plasma TV or pay down your credit cards. That $600 is going to go to increased food and other prices, too.

Where do you think that rebate check you got a couple of years went? If the government cuts your taxes then your boss can justifiably not give you a raise or benefits. Hey, you got a tax cut. Meanwhile, the services that you expected from the government will also be cut eventually. It's a race to the bottom. I wonder if there will be another company starting up for those people who can no longer afford to shop at Wal-Mart.
11:04 PM on 03/17/2008
"...the Republican ideology which holds that regulation of corporate financial behavior..."
Republicans believe in small government. Meaning a government exclusively for the 1% richest. (Known in political science as 'feudalism.') I don't know why people keep being surprised - they actually come out and say it.

Can't agree more. Said it a few times myself. What they want and why they are so mad, is a return to the good old days. 1200 AD is about right. When the men who were BORN to rule, ruled with no questions asked, by divine right. The darn middle class rose up and ruined it and now they are taking it back. Welcome to the Dark Ages.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TXfemmom
Grandma with eye on the future
12:38 AM on 03/18/2008
Capitalism only works when there are rules applied to it, strenuously, or otherwise, greed consumes many involved in it and we see things like the Savings & Loan of the Reagan decade, the Enron collapse which occurred because the Republican-controlled Congress led by DeLay, Ginrich, and Phil Gramm opened up the gates and dropped all curbs on organizations such as Enron, and now, we have the subprime thing because regulations and standards were not applied by the Republican-controlled Congress and Bush.

This proves that our form of economy only works when there are rules to prevent this type of immoral and down right thievery. These guys are worse than the people who go in and rob a bank, and they get $10,000. The FBI goes nuts over that, when these guys did it in $2,000 suits, got paid BILLIONS, and flew around on private jets. They cost the nation its' economic stability, and may well have finished off, with Bush's assistance, what was once a world power. We have become a third world country with a huge military, and nothing else.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
RButler
I've always wanted to have everything I wanted
10:49 PM on 03/23/2008
S & Ls, Enron, sub-prime fiasco? What's the next big scam going to be? You know there's going to be a next one. Any guesses? Health care? Oh, wait. We already have that with HMOs. I heard that the CEO of my HMO got a billion dollars. He must have some bedside manner.

It's hard for me to even imagine what would be a great way to screw people and make a lot of money. But, I'm sure there are people out there right now working on it. Where do you go to learn that stuff or are you born with it? (Bush/Cheney families)
07:53 PM on 03/17/2008
Ahhh...where to begin. The Clintons are part and parcel of the disaster that has been waiting to happen to us since Reagan took office. Jimmy Carter was the last president with any integrity--and even he indicated that there was only so much any president could do. The neo-cons and their stooges in both parties destroyed Carter's presidency and if Obama ever got to the presidency (which is doubtful) they would destroy his brand of populism too, one way or another. The elites controlling what we eat, hear, see, and live, are most apprehensive of populism--the people taking back what was once theirs. Those controlling the Matrix that is sucking the lifeblood out of our economy (and us since we will be on the hook for paying for their greed) do not want us to know the sordid truth concerning how they stay in power and their utter ruthlessness in pursuing their goals. They are fanatical in their pursuit of total control through controlling the military/industrial/financial/religious Matrix. No tin-foil hats required--the information is out there for those who would seek it--the U.S. government has not been a benign force for some time. That is what Jeremiah Wright was referring to. Ever hear of a journalist by the name of Gary Webb? Most African-Americans who know anything know who he was.
07:25 PM on 03/17/2008
"The economic meltdown is the new 9/11, and it's George W. Bush's fault"

Long before Bush took office this country's credit card debt was becoming massive, people were living outside their means and housing prices were inflated. The bubble was going to pop no matter who was there. Bush's fault lies with allowing government spending to become out of control. Beyond that people have no one to blame but themselves.
04:35 PM on 03/18/2008
Incorrect. People began living beyond their means, on credit, when inflation overtook wage increases in the 1980s. The average American now makes about half of what was normal wage in 1967 when adjusted for inflation. And inflation has been systematically under reported since Reagan, who instituted a number of insidious "adjustments" to the calculation of the CPI.

Personal responsibility is important, but on the backdrop of disinformation flowing from the government on the state and direction of the economy for thirty years, miscalculation of one's prospects is quite understandable.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
RButler
I've always wanted to have everything I wanted
10:57 PM on 03/23/2008
I've always been amazed at how easily interest on credit cards and other loans was disallowed as a deduction back in the '80s over a 3 year period if I remember. Now, you would have thought that that would have discouraged excessive borrowing by the public overall but it seems like it didn't.

When republicans say 'cut taxes and let people manage their own money' I'm pretty skeptical about the wisdom of the America public. The public that has no savings, is maxed out on credit cards and home equity loans to buy plasma TVs and SUVs or whatever. The greed of the guys on Wall Street is perfectly matched by the stupidity of the public. A marriage made in debtor's prison.
07:10 PM on 03/17/2008
.
The COMPLETE LACK of definitive regulation allowed the sub prime mortgage mess. This is a function of the bush MOB.
Endorse the lenders and the HELL with the home buyers.
If it is TOO good to be true, it will fail in the long term.
The profits are gone and so are the home buyers from their homes.
THANKX BUSH
..l
07:59 PM on 03/17/2008
Well let's see here, banks were also forced to lend to a number of first time minorities because the government said so, about 75% of loans are going bad now.

People took stupid loans and signed their name to them, can't fault the government for that. People should read what they are signing prior to signing it.
10:27 PM on 03/17/2008
That sounds like Neil Shpeal. I have two words for you. Reaganomics and deregulation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:23 PM on 03/17/2008
Absolutely right on. Poorly regulated, laissez-faire, overly-consolidated financial markets are responsible for this. We must not let this lesson get lost in the gibberish. We missed the Enron lesson. Bad apples did not sink Enron. A fundamentally flawed economic philosophy was at the heart of Enron's demise and this same philosophy is taking the entire economy and a good chunk of the world's economy with it.
It's important to remember that 'what you can get away with' determines the behavior of every player in a market. If Lehman Brothers is propping up their numbers with absurdly risky loans, then we must too or our numbers will be lower and it will look like Lehman is outperforming us.
It is entirely appropriate and necessary to set the limits on acceptable behavior for entire markets. Every player complains about regulations strangling their competitive behavior; but they all breathe a secret sigh of relief when prudent regulation keeps them from engaging in the type of behavior that could destroy their entire business. For too long, we have been force-fed this unregulated, free-market propaganda; that when acted upon, leads to Bear Stearns, etc.
05:30 PM on 03/17/2008
If we the public bail these financial predators out we could and should "Tax Them Back" The obscene salaries paid the CEO 's waltz them into financial disaster should be cut-like Bear Sterns value was cut-90% over the weekend.When they are "saved" and functioning we the public should through the Federal government require them to pay back that which saved them Tax them back.Stop allowing a Jamie Dimaond to appear to be a white knight when in fact he is a cut throat. Stop allowing Alan Schwarz to appear to be an archetect for avoiding disaster when he took a two month ride to a undeserved big payday. TAX THEM BACK.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Tulka2
Solidarity. Courage. Humor.
05:02 PM on 03/17/2008
It is simple. Bear Sterns has been "saved" with taxpayer money. We paid. The CEO will go to bed happy. The rich invested in Wall Street will go to bed happy. I have heard Wall Street say over and over, "If the banks and/or Wall Street fail, everyone in America will feel it". What, i ask, is the difference? We, the American taxpayers, are deep in debt, no matter if bankers and stockbrokers are saved or not. This only means the rich are bailed out. How about people with their homes in forclosure?
08:00 PM on 03/17/2008
In case you didn't get the memo, Bear Sterns is gone. Their employees aren't going to bed happy, more than 1/3 of their stock was held by employees and dropped from $130 a share to $2 a share in one week.
08:50 AM on 03/18/2008
Actually, yhe value of a share of Bear Sterns (BSC) dropped from $130 per share to $2 per share in a year, not a week. It was $30 at market close last Friday. And, the Fed Gov didn't lend any money to bail out the buyer of BSC. It was a loan guarantee. BTW, the BSC portfolio of equities is certainly worth a great deal more than $2 per share. As usual, Wall Street has overreacted.
04:32 PM on 03/17/2008
I forgot to say THANK YOU for bringing up Neil Bush, of Silverado Savings and Loan scandal. The Bush Crime Family has been robbing taxpayers blind for generations! The S&L robbery is just another historical fact that has been forgotten or never mentioned on the US airwaves or in print!
04:18 PM on 03/17/2008
Thank you for spelling out the truth Marty!! It's obvious you read history -too bad the majority of the people in America don't -we may not be in this mess if we were an informed public.

I know that the corporations who own all our media outlets (loyal Bushies and other GOPers) are doing their best to keep America stupid but there are these things called libraries, and they have books and other informative resources so people can learn the truth about what's going on. Or go online and search for the truth -it's out there!
08:53 AM on 03/18/2008
KR3rdC
Your comment reminded me of the late great Bill Hicks.

I so wish he were still alive. He would be having the rant of all rants right about now. He'd be superfly TNT.