The Republican Party's Spokesperson Should Be...
It is really remarkable to watch the Republican Party implode. This was the Party that had it all. The Presidency, Congress.
Today, their leading spokespeople are Bobby Jindall and Michael Steele. They watch President Obama's oratory and popularity, and they have tried to emulate him - with people of color, youth. This is like watching the NFL teams try to emulate the Super Bowl winner - they won the championship with the 3-4 defense, so we'll play the 3-4! We'll hire the assistant from the championship team! Usually, by the time you emulate the winner, the league is on to some new trend. Or, you have actually missed what made that team win. And in the case of the Republican Party, they're missing out on an important point about Obama's popularity.
Aside from the fact that he's "new" and talks about "hope" and "change," President Obama's popularity is soaring because he is perceived as sober, responsible, and concerned about the vast majority of Americans. We just had a disastrous, divisive president who often seemed overwhelmed by the job. He was incredibly irresponsible. He probably never wanted to be president in the first place.
This president is a response to that president. Forget the fact that he's African-American, or relatively young. He is pro-active - and that is the most important characteristic about him that Republicans can emulate.
Let me give a comparison for the Republicans reading this (and if there are, what are you doing on the Huffington Post?): in 1993, David Dinkins was finishing a disastrous first term as Mayor of New York City. Crime was on the rise, Dinkins seemed out of touch, and often idle, as the City appeared headed toward dark days. Along came Rudy Giuliani. Rudy was, essentially, a war-time Mayor. He came into office and he acted - there was no question as to who was in charge. You may not have liked everything he did, but you could never say that he was not trying. Just the fact that he was so on top of things - showing up at every crime scene, finding new ways to fight crime - helped the city's confidence. The city, which had seemingly intractable problems and many felt was in a state of permanent decay, was instead on the move again.
Obama is Rudy Giuliani (the Rudy of his first-term, not the Rudy of his second-term, who still thought he was a war-time mayor even though the city was at peace). The country seems to have intractable problems. But we have a pro-active President, one who shows up everywhere, is on TV nearly every day, and with the sheer force of his personality, he makes a difference. All of his ideas will not work - but he's going to try. Some say America is in decline - President Obama says we will be on the move again.
Now, here's where today's Republicans come in: the point isn't that their new spokespeople are charismatic like Obama; young like Obama; of color like Obama. The point should be that they are sober leaders who can speak with authority on the situation that we are in today, and speak with authority on the changes that should be made so we can get out of this mess. That's what the American people want right now.
Michael Steele is not an authority on the issues facing the country, and he has proven to be a disaster on TV. Bobby Jindall had a shot, but his ideas were the same old same old, and he was awful on TV, so he's out, too. Who's left?
Rudy Giuliani flew off the deep end years ago, and now he's a punch-line. He's out. Obviously, the moderates don't take Sarah Palin seriously. Out. I know Rush Limbaugh is intimidating to the Republicans in Congress, but seriously, folks. He's out. Eric Cantor, the Congressman, may be a power on the Hill, but he's putting the Republicans in a deep hole. Paul Ryan is a young Congressman with credibility - maybe he can be the person Republicans need, but he may be too new to be an authority.
There are two that I can think of for the Republicans right now: Mitt Romney and Newt Gingrich. The rise of Newt has been well chronicled lately. Newt has more ideas in his head than any other leader out there. But Newt still remains a divisive figure.
And Mitt - well, here's the thing. Mitt ran a horrible campaign for president. He ran against his own previously stated positions. He ran a campaign that was appropriate for 1988, not 2008. He missed the yacht on what the country was looking for, and he was passed in the race by John McCain.
But Mitt can speak with authority on the economic crisis facing the country. Now, as a Democrat, I don't agree with much of what Mitt would say. But if I'm a Republican, or one who recently left the Party, I may listen to Mitt, given his previous positions of power in the business world. Certainly, he speaks with more authority than the radical righties on Capitol Hill, who speak of nothing but tax cuts.
If Mitt is willing to reject Republican Party orthodoxy, and I don't believe Mitt is as "conservative" as he pretended to be in 2008, he may have some ideas that voters would find palatable. This is his opportunity, to be Mitt, the guy who brought health care to Massachussets, the guy who turned around the Olympics, the guy whose father led Michigan and who knows the auto industry.
And so, Republicans, do not look for Obama-lite as your spokesperson. Look to Mitt Romney. He could not answer the call in 2008, but maybe he can do so now. He is your best bet.
Loading comments…
Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to
Matt, you say "if you are (Republican), what are you doing on the Huffington Post"...it
But as affable as Mitt Romney is, he's still wack on the issues. Big time. He "looks the part", but that's about it.
Watch out for Govenor Huckabee. As Bill Clinton foresaw early in the 2008 primary, Huckabee is a very effective campaigner (whether you care for Huckabee & Clinton or not, you have to wonder what was in that Hope AK water), And Huckabee's position on immigration and other domestic issues was self-defeating because he said what the Repugs needed to hear but refuse to accept. And he's laying low now, when Repug front-runner status is a clear lose/lose spot. His weakness will be money discoveries; remember the gubernatorial gift registry and the untimely Carribean speaking tour; more will follow.
I'd put my money on Huck too.
Huck comes across as a real person.
Mitt comes across as PLASTICMAN!!!!!!!!!
The GOP is a treasonous organization that supported the Bush Administrations attempts to undermine the US Constitution and a defacto repeal of whole sections of the founding documents.
The GOP have spokespeop
Irrelevant.
No matter what, the Republians are in the toilet and it's getting worse by the day. I'm thrilled.
Me too! It's like watching a slow-motion train wreck, but much more enjoyable.
This is how the new GOP works: find a sellable, gimmicky 'empty vessel' that has high electablility, then once the person is elected, have them stand back and let the neocons run things. Palin was a gimmick; Jindal is a gimmick. (I would even suggest that the empty vessel we know as Reagan was a gimmick.) Steele, unfortunately, is yet another gimmick.
Good Point! The GOP is about gimmicks and manipulation and lies.... and unaccountability. Look how quickly the Dems threw out Blagovich.
Umm..... SHHHHHHHH! They're supposed to make a pick like Palin or Limbaugh so they'll have no chance!
Stop giving republicans advice. Let them self destruct. They would not do the same for democrats.
You're assuming they would be smart enough to take advice from a democrat. LOL Not likely to happen.
Get real! Do you really think any Republican is going to take advice from a Democrat? That's as insane as Obama's economic policy. Why don't you recommend that your messiah go ask Rush Limbaugh what he thinks he should do about the economy? That's about as likely to happen.
That's right, you guys are too smart for that....
Well Matt, here's the thing. You had me cheering over your well written article...
"The point should be that they are sober leaders who can speak with authority on the situation that we are in today, and speak with authority on the changes that should be made so we can get out of this mess"
Come one now Matt, the GOOPers/RN
Everytime I see one of that gutless bunch stand in front of a microphone to BS on something happening on the Hill, it looks like they are about to cry and run out of the room. NOT ONE among that bunch of gutless wonders have the ba*ls to tell Rush Limbaugh to stick to what he is paid to do (shock folks and tell a lot of REALLY BIG lies) and let the politicians handle the politics.
Don't give the republicans any ideas....l
The big self-destruction that I see going on around here is what your administration is doing to the economy. The stock market has lost over half its value. There's a two trillion dollar deficit for just this year with hundreds of billions of dollars more being added to it every couple of days. Unemployment is already over 8% and even the most optimistic estimates say it won't stop until it hits double digits. Hundreds of thousands of jobs are being lost every week. And where's your messiah in the middle of all this? Why he just "saved" 25 jobs in Ohio. He just reversed stem cell research. He declared war on Rush Limbaugh. Does this guy have ANY idea what his job is supposed to be? Where's his promise to stand firm against earmarks and pork coming from Congress? Where's his promise to reduce the deficit? Where's this change we're supposed to see? The only change we're going to have will be what's left in our pockets when he gets done picking them.
on 03/07/2009 OldManJack2 said:
blah blah blah economy blah blah blah blah stock market blah blah blah deficit blah blah blah unemployment blah blah blah messiah! blah blah blah stem cell blah blah blah earmarks blah blah blah stupid joke.
Bad News, Jack: Obama's the president, 57+ in the senate, 254+ in the house... good luck with that whole hysteria thing
OldmanJack you are sounding like chicken little. Trust me, the sky will not fall. Obama is doing everything he promised his supporters he would do. The things that he has proposed may work, they may not, but if they don't in 8 years I'm pretty sure the political pedulum will be swinging the other way.
LOL! Another middle-class sap the republicans have convinced is in the top 5%. If you think the GOP has your best interest at heart, you've got another thing coming, but feel free to follow them right off the cliff. Oh, and let's give credit where credit is due; President Obama has been on the job for about 6 weeks, so you don't get to blame him for the country being in the ditch. That blame belongs squarely on Bush and his supporters, you included.
Mitt has dollars; Gingrich has ideas; Jindal has Jesus; Palin has looks; Huckabee has the South; Limbaugh has listeners.
If the GOP were to coalese, they would provide a united front against Dem and progressives. The antidote is two-fold: co-op good ideas from the right, yes, they have some good ideas; and keep the base divided. This should tie them down for an election cycle.
woot MITT!!! the guy that shipped thousands of jobs over sees!!!!!!!!!!
woot Newt!!! his sister alone would bring him down!!!!
The thing about Obama, indeed his wife along with him, is that they actually care for people. I mean seriously, it is such a novel concept to Washington which is why they and the media can't understand why people like him so much. Like you said, people know Obama is working hard for them, and actually cares for them, even if they don't like every policy he puts out there. People appreciate he is trying to bail out Main Street regular folks instead of the fat cats. People can sense genuine care. It is why all regular folks around the world were cheering for him when he won.
In my view, genuine empathy and care for the least of these is the foundation for all of his policies (i.e. healthcare, education, jobs). Mitt Romney may fake it for a while, but in the end people will see that he doesn't care about them and they will never feel that vibe from him as they do Obama.
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or connect with
