iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.

GET UPDATES FROM Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.

Historically Black Colleges and Universities Are Worth Saving

Posted: 09/22/11 03:40 PM ET

If you haven't been paying much attention to the debate concerning the relevance and effectiveness of historically black colleges and universities (HBCUs), now is the time to sit up and take notice. If you don't, there is a chance it could soon be too late. Over the last two decades, we have seen the number of HBCUs in the United States sharply decline and this greatly concerns me. Those who believe in the benefits of HBCUs need to stand up and let their voices be heard, before these important institutions are gone forever.

HBCUs are coming under fire for everything from not improving their failing infrastructures to producing lower graduation rates, and more. But we need to take a moment to look at why people should pull together, rally around them, and help them make it through turbulent economic times. HBCUs have helped to educate some of the most prominent African-American figures in this country's history, including Jesse Jackson, Samuel L. Jackson, Martin Luther King Jr., Spike Lee, and Thurgood Marshall, among many others.

HBCUs provide cultural benefits, as well as providing an affordable education. This cultural foundation has been important to the African American community for over a century. Our HBCUs were there, supporting the community and educating our people, long before other colleges would even let them through the door. So are we saying that, just because mainstream American colleges will now let black students in, we should abandon the institutions that supported us and helped us get to where we are today?

HBCUs are a part of African-American tradition, going back generations. They were not only there during the struggle; they helped our people get through it! We owe them our support and respect. They were there for us, and it is time, right now, for us to be there for them.

The biggest reason that HBCUs are fading is because they are often lack sufficient funding, which makes it difficult for them to survive. Without adequate funding, they will end up deteriorating and are apt to become a thing of the past. The low completion rate at HBCUs has also been a contributing factor to their demise. But I believe that it is the other way around: the lack of funding has contributed to the lower graduation rates. HBCUs have to deal with the fact that many of their academically eligible students drop out of college each year because their financial needs cannot be met with Pell Grants and other aid. A large portion of HBCUs have small endowments, so there isn't a huge rainy day fund to tap into when financial challenges arise.

I received my Masters and Doctoral level training from Jackson State University. Recently, Washington Monthly magazine ranked Jackson State University number 9 among 258 colleges and universities across the country in terms of social mobility, research and service ratings. This attests to the fact that many of our HBCUs are achieving astounding results, against all odds. In my home state of Mississippi, I grew up attending athletic and cultural functions at Tougaloo College, Alcorn State University, Mississippi Valley State University and of course, the aforementioned Jackson State University. These universities are sources of great pride and a part of the African-American intellectual tradition.

Now is the time when people who support HBUCs, including advocates, organizations, faculty, students and alumni, need to rally together to help save this historical piece of African-American history. If these groups come together and make their voices heard, we will be able to save these institutions. But make no mistake, if there is no rally, if there is no coming together to let the powers-that-be know that we want them saved, then I predict that they will be gone in 50 or so years. And they will not return. Nobody is going to turn back the hands of time and open another historically black college or university, because it wouldn't be historic. Right now, they are historic, and they need our support and rescue!

Many people are currently asking whether HBCUs are worth saving in the first place. I ask, how can these historical institutions, which represent African-American culture, tradition and struggle for educational equality, not be considered worth saving? If they are not worth saving, then it makes it very difficult to find any other piece of African-American heritage that is worth saving. These educational institutions are symbols of our people that must not be ignored.

I urge those who care about these institutions to speak out, show your support, and demand that adequate funding be provided to them, so that they can make it through these turbulent economic times. It's not just about saving a college or university. This is a metaphor for saving ourselves! With proper funding, these schools will thrive, carrying on our culture and traditions as they were meant to do.

In the words of the great Eldridge Cleaver, "You're either part of the solution or part of the problem." Which will you be?

 
 
 

Follow Matthew Lynch, Ed.D. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/lynch39083@aol.

If you haven't been paying much attention to the debate concerning the relevance and effectiveness of historically black colleges and universities (HBCUs), now is the time to sit up and take notice. I...
If you haven't been paying much attention to the debate concerning the relevance and effectiveness of historically black colleges and universities (HBCUs), now is the time to sit up and take notice. I...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:59 PM on 10/14/2011
As a Prairie View A&M graduate who has also taught at HBCUs, I will agree with a lot that is in the column. However, I would not say that HBCUs are fading. I would say that they are under siege. Funding is to me the biggest issue. In a bad economy, HBCUs especially are targets for budget cuts. We, whether one went to an HBCU are not, need to target these politicians who are going after them. An example may be the governor of Louisiana. In addition to us (of course) better supporting our schools financially, we need to look at these politicians who do not adequately fund the schools.

Also, we need to quit always being on the defensive and put others who attack the schools on the defensive. While academics are not a problem at these schools, public relations are a problem. In general HBCUs, namely the administrators, do not do a good job of promoting and defending the institutions in my opinion. HBCU need to and can do a better job in this area.
12:58 AM on 09/27/2011
There were so many people that I felt genuinely didn't need to be in college yet and clearly didn't want to be in school. I had never seen so many people fall through the cracks. The other problem I noticed was the outright rudeness of many of the staff and the bad attitudes of many students. Now I also encountered some of the nicest people, staff and friends included, but the sheer number of rude people was just unacceptable to me. I felt judged more so than even in high school. I the few liberal arts courses I took were nowhere near as rigorous as they are at unc. The sciences classes were much much better at the HBCU than the liberal arts courses there, it wasnt even funny. I think we have to ask ourselves if we can afford to fix the problems within HBCUs because they just can't compete academically or aesthetically right now. If they continue to have subpar standards they only do a disservice to the community they seek to help. Now again I was a bad student but you have to have a cutoff at some point. HBCUs will have to become much more competitive. But can they afford it? I really don't think an HBCU can stay relevant in a 21st century world if they don't offer more courses, have better facilities staff, and get stronger students. I don't think I could ever go back to an HBCU again, save for the law school
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
08:14 AM on 09/27/2011
Yes, there are some pros and cons to attending HBCUs, but that can be said for PWI's also.
12:56 AM on 09/27/2011
I have so many different and conflicting ideas on the subject having attended an HBCU and then transferring out to a "PWI." The thing was I was very lazy in high school, although I did take all honors or ap classes. I just did enough to get by and graduate. Needless to say I wasn't going to be going to harvard or even a top state school. So I applied to a few schools and got in to a few of them including an HBCU. I ended up going to the HBCU mainly because it was in Durham which is close to chapel hill, and Raleigh. I was a bio major so I was in mostly science classes. The science classes were relatively challenging and I had to study to do well. Now, I was a bad student in high school, but I don't think I had ever been around so many bad students. Not to say there weren't great students, there were, so I am not talking about those people. But just the outright negative vibe I felt many people exuded in regards to education was staggering to me. I think the one big problem with HBCUs is the less than rigorous admittance standards. I wonder if the lower standards are in response to certain government mandates which want to push people into colleges- because the more money you loan to people the more money the govt takes in. There were so many people that I felt genuinely didn't
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
08:13 AM on 09/27/2011
As always, you make some interesting points.
11:39 PM on 09/25/2011
7 comments...might be a testament to how much HBCU's matter in the grand scheme...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ohin Gaston
12:28 PM on 09/26/2011
Exactly!!!? Want to know the Stories on Blackvoices Ahead of this...Mike Jacksons Doc, DC Comics(even though I'm a nerd), Oh yeah and Basketball wives. I'm not sure how they put the editorials in order, but you have to scroll way down to see this story.

Proud product of Morehouse.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
08:12 AM on 09/27/2011
Thanks for the info Ohin.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
10:27 PM on 09/26/2011
Maybe so. The funny thing is that I have gotten over 7 emails from people personally thanking me for writing the article. First time that's happened.
06:50 PM on 09/23/2011
Interesting piece. I understand the social preservations that should be made regarding historically black colleges and universities in America. However, I believe that by keeping HBCUs, it causes America to still be negligent of desegregation. I feel that HBCUs do not prepare its students adequately enough for the real world because of its lack of assimilation with other races. I am biracial (half african american and half causcasian), and I just do not like the idea of an all black school. I just feel that we need to integrate the students in these schools into white culture. The same argument however can be made for women's colleges for example. Those institutions have gotten their start from the beginning from women being shut out of many institutes of post-secondary education. And yet, for the same reason as HBCUs, they are still around for being a safe community for the minority group, and as an historical preservation. By no means am attempting to belittle HBCUs, I am just merely saying that I feel they are not progressive enough, and I think that students of these institutions are missing the preparation for the real world that comes with integration.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
11:32 PM on 09/23/2011
We are all entitled to our own opinions and even though we disagree on some points, you still make an impressive argument. Thanks for posting and I hope that you will continue to support my work.
02:02 PM on 09/23/2011
Just like Dr. Lynch I grew up attending HBCU events and I listened to my parents and grand parents talk about how the "yard" was back in the day. I loved how no matter how big or small the campus was they were all family and supported eachother and the school. So let us flock together and help save our HBCUs because the memories and traditions are priceless.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
05:28 PM on 09/23/2011
Sheene, thanks for your comments. I agree with your assertion that HBCU alumni and supporters need to mobilize and rally for our schools.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jalexvip
12:49 PM on 09/23/2011
Let's assume for a moment that these Universities are worth saving. Where is the money to save them going to come from? Let's be clear; they have graduated a major portion of our most powerful black people and they were there when Blacks couldn't go anywhere else. It is only natural that we feel a responsibility and a debt of gratitude but I think the time has come to rethink HBCU's. Not because they no longer serve a very useful purpose; far from it, but because it is going to be virtually impossible to keep them open in a declining economy with no means of support. The brightest students are going elsewhere, the best athletes are going elsewhere and so are the best teachers.
The President's job bill calls for money to be spent to train and retrain Americans and returning veterans for Green Jobs of the future, what better place for this to take place than the HBCU's. I propose closing the weakest schools and restructuring the rest to accommodate a progressive curriculum that primarily focuses on teaching students to own and operate businesses and preparing them for career fields of the future. HBCU's are going to eventually die anyway, and there's nothing we can do about that so why not seize this opportunity to keep them alive by helping some of them with this new agenda.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
05:26 PM on 09/23/2011
The disheartening reality is that America has billions of dollars to fight a two-front war, but cannot or will not properly educate its children. If a hostile country attacked the U. S., it would take less than 24 hours for American troops to be mobilized into battle. However, we seem unable to mobilize a sea of educated teachers and administrators to wage war against academic mediocrity, which is a bigger threat to our national security than Iran or North Korea.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Lynch, Ed.D.
Professor, Author & Activist
11:25 PM on 09/22/2011
I would appreciate and I welcome all comments. I wrote it as a means of stimulating debate on the subject.