Huffpost TV
The Blog

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Maureen Ryan Headshot

'Sleepy Hollow' Finale Review: They're In A Hell Of A Mess Now

Posted: Updated:

sleepy hollow

Do not read on unless you've seen "The Indispensable Man" and "Bad Blood," the episodes that made up the Season 1 finale of "Sleepy Hollow."

To quote Ichabod Crane: "Dude."

That finale was even more bonkersawesome than I dared hope. I did take notes on those two episodes and I'll share those thoughts below (and in this Talking TV podcast), but it's always a good sign when I stop taking notes while I'm watching a show. I was so engrossed in the last couple of acts of "Bad Blood" that I just sat there, marveling at what a wild ride it was.

There was a lot to savor: A terrifyingly tense family reunion! Abbie recovered her memories! Henry Parish was revealed as Jeremy Crane! Henry/Jeremy gave Katrina to the Headless Horseman and buried his dear old dad! And somewhere in the midst of all that, Ichabod got new pants! Not the dreaded skinny jeans, thank the Lord.

That ending packed quite a wallop, and I'm sure the show's producers are going to be pelted with questions until the show returns next season. Among the more burning questions I have are the ones below (and please feel free to leave your questions in the comment area):

1. Is Jenny dead? I highly doubt that, given what an integral part of the ensemble the character and the actress playing her, Lyndie Greenwood, have become. The scene between Jenny and Abbie in the gang's hideout was one of my favorite moments of the season; the actresses share a great vibe and the writers have done an especially good job of writing for them in the closing hours of Season 1. Last week's episode, "The Vessel," did a fine job of deepening the sister's relationship (we know now that Jenny stayed away from her sister in order to protect her), and the season as a whole has given us a lot of insight into their formidable defenses and their unbreakable bond. As was so often the case in the "Sleepy Hollow" finale, their relationship was given time to breathe, and that conversation between the sisters made their individual fates that much more surprising and effective.

2. What will the Horseman do with Katrina? As I've written before, I have nothing against the actress Katia Winter, who plays Ichabod's wife, but Katrina being stuck in Purgatory limited the utility and impact of the character, and her otherworldly state made that relationship seem less important. As Ryan McGee and I discussed on the podcast, putting Katrina in the real world with her husband puts a lot of great potential developments on the table, so I'm glad that she's among the living once again (perhaps she'll have a less thorny relationship with modern fashion and technology?). But we've no idea what the Horseman plans for her -- presumably it's not anything good. Let's, er, face it: If he plans on rekindling their relationship, making out appears to be out of the question.

3. Who will rescue Ichabod and Abbie if Jenny and Katrina are out of commission and Frank Irving is in jail? Oh my, the writers have given themselves a lot of problems to solve when Season 2 begins, but I relish the idea of them untangling those knots even as they create even more knotty dilemmas for the anti-Apocalypse crew.

It's those moral and personal dilemmas that have elevated "Sleepy Hollow" from the ranks of "satisfying" to "excellent" and "frequently awesome" for me. There were wobbles here and there as the world and the characters were developed over the last few months, but for the most part, Season 1 recalled solid, exciting and emotionally satisfying seasons of "Angel," "Buffy," "Supernatural" or "Farscape," among other examples I could cite. The best genre shows use the elasticity of their rules regarding life, death, time and punishment to explore why people are willing to make certain sacrifices, and to create compelling character portraits. As is the case with the best supernaturally-tinged dramas, this show is chock-full of people with believable faults and credible wishes to help themselves and others -- and who regularly have to choose among terrible options.

"Sleepy Hollow" really nailed those foundational ideas about loyalty and sacrifice in its first season, and it was blessed with a cast that could run with anything that was thrown at them -- and then some. That allowed it to exceed my hopes for what it could accomplish and to unify what could have been a jarring mixtures of tones, aesthetics and moods. Everything from the light comedy of Ichabod at the historical re-enactment to the freakiness of Moloch summoning his minions to the bittersweet yearning of the fake Purgatory scenes worked like gangbusters. This world has a lot of flavors but they don't clash, they harmonize.

I'll put that another way: When a show's got Zombie George Washington roaming around and that seems completely credible and normal (not to mention awesome), well, that show is doing something very right.

There were so many things to savor, from the lines that will be fueling the Sleepyheads for months ("Admit it, you admire me a little bit." "Microscopically.") to the slower, quieter conversations to the whooshing sense of momentum that the finale built as it cruised to its climax. Here are just a few of my favorite moments (and again, share yours in comments):

  • How fabulous was Ichabod wanting a phone upgrade? I love that Ichabod's relationship with the 21st century is not staying static and the writers aren't just repeatedly going to the well of "He doesn't like Modern Things!" Over time, that would be less and less funny, but the show's not making that mistake. An Ichabod who covets a better cellphone and is figuring out texting -- sort of -- is a fun place to go, and I look forward to him mastering Facetime and Candy Crush.
  • "Respectfully, Leftentant Mills."
  • "Yolanda was a much better listener!" You said it, Ichabod. If Yolanda doesn't return in Season 2, why are any of us alive?
  • Ichabod's decision to draw the map from memory was a great moment for Tom Mison, and his performance in the scene with his dad was equally excellent. I choose to believe that Ichabod was telling Abbie the truth when he burned the map; he really did make a sacrifice in that moment and he truly didn't want to betray her, but his love for his wife remains strong and that pull was hard to resist. But circumstances changed and the need to get Katrina out became more pressing. That said, the episodes did a good job of reminding us that both Ichabod and Abbie have divided loyalties: They both have loved ones in danger, and they both might need to sacrifice people they love in order to save the world. It's not the first time that dilemma will test their relationship, nor will it be the last.
  • I loved Abbie saying "I want to face [Moloch] for me." The finale did a fine job of outlining the emotional stakes for each character, especially Abbie. The fact that Abbie chose to go into Purgatory and that she chose to confront her fears and regain her memories helped the second hour work especially well. I watch a lot of TV -- too much -- in which female characters exist to complete mundane tasks or to shed light on the journeys of the male characters. "Sleepy Hollow," to its credit, resists all kinds of cliches, especially where female characters are concerned. Abbie has her own path and she and Ichabod truly have a partnership -- they're equals as characters and as Witnesses. She can be vulnerable and afraid and human, but Abbie's never a victim, and I'm half-convinced she's going to save herself from Purgatory.

Some questions or quibbles that I had (and they're minor):

  • The Frank Irving scenes in last week's episode and in the finale were fine and all, but they felt disconnected from everything that Abbie and Ichabod were going through. Ideally Irving and his family will be more organically incorporated into next season's events.
  • I generally like the score but at times it's too insistent and intrusive. It's a common issue on network dramas, but there are times "Sleepy Hollow" doesn't need the juicing up -- it's plenty exciting/scary/resonant on its own.
  • It kind of makes me laugh (and not in a bad way) that everything to do with the seal Henry/Jeremy broke confuses me. I don't know where the seal the Horseman gave to Henry was the whole time. Henry/Jeremy was raised years ago and just now obtained the seal, thanks to a deal between him and the Horseman? What took so long? Why didn't that happen earlier? Don't they sort of work for Moloch and why didn't he expedite that? I expect Henry had to bring about certain events in order to obtain the seal, and I know there was some dialogue to that effect, but that part of the story seems murky to me. That said, I enjoyed the finale a great deal, and not knowing the deal with the seal -- a MacGuffin if there ever was one -- was a real stumbling block for me. The emotional confrontation between Henry/Jeremy and his parents was one of the main attractions of the last part of the finale, and the actors nailed that part completely.
  • Did anyone else wonder about how the father of our country built that gigantic underground chamber on an island without it being flooded? Perhaps it was just homeowners whose basements have flooded who questioned that particular development.

Given that this is a show about time travel, more or less, let's travel back to September. When "Sleepy Hollow" debuted, I wrote about how much I enjoyed this show but I was honest about the fact that I thought there was a good chance it would fall apart within a few weeks. "Sleepy Hollow" not only didn't fall apart, it built on its many strengths as the season developed and turned into a full-fledged addiction. And that finale was legitimately badass.

I will miss you, you bonkersawesome, exciting, funny, sweet, emotionally intelligent and wonderfully satisfying show. Come back soon.

Ryan McGee and I talk about the "Sleepy Hollow" finale in this week's Talking TV IchaPod, which is here, on iTunes and below.