More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Melissa Silverstein

Melissa Silverstein

Posted: April 15, 2010 09:15 PM

The Politics of Hit Girl

What's Your Reaction:

There aren't many times when I go to a movie and I leave speechless. But that did happen to me recently when I saw the film Kick Ass. For those of you that don't know, the film is about an average to slightly nerdy comic book loving kid who decides that he can be his own type of superhero. He dresses up in a wet suit and heads out into the street to save some people. The film is based on the comic book by Mark Millar, is written by Jane Goldman and Matthew Vaughn (the pair the brought us the underappreciated Stardust) and directed by Vaughn.

Now, you ask, why did Melissa Silverstein of Women & Hollywood a) even want to see this film; and b) what about it could have made her speechless?

The answer is Hit Girl. (Alert: there will be spoilers below)

First, let's be clear. This is a movie for adults. If your kid wants to see it, say no.

Hit Girl is a character that I have never seen on screen before. She is an 11 year old girl assassin. This girl, played amazingly by Chloe Grace Moretz, is a walking destruction machine. She shoots, she stabs, she bayonets. She does things on screen that literally left my mouth agape. FYI - no studio would touch this movie. They loved it, but said you gotta take out Hit Girl. No one would finance a film with an 11-year-old girl killer. Those movies are just not made in Hollywood.

The thing about Hit Girl is not just that she is a brutal and ruthless killer. She enjoys it. Way. Too. Much.

And the language. I really thought there were language limits, but Hit Girl pushes those boundaries, and quite frankly, after this movie I don't think there are any language barriers left. They've been trampled by an 11-year-old girl. Never before have a heard the c-word (yes, that word) uttered by a girl describing men. While I was horrified at the moment, I have to admit that I smiled at the same time because she was doing something onscreen I never thought I would see. A girl kicking ass. Literally.

So I am conflicted. The thing about Hit Girl, as Jane Goldman said to me in an interview, and I agree with, is that because she is 11 the violence is not sexualized. So much of violence we see in films is perpetrated on women because they are women. Hit Girl kills because that's what her daddy (Nicolas Cage) taught her to do (let's not get into the bad parenting here.) You know you're into different territory when the first scene you see of your heroine is her father teaching her take a bullet in a vest.

The question I've been asking myself since I saw the film: does Hit Girl movie us forward or backwards? I don't really have a final answer. The pros are that she is actually the hero of the film. She saves everyone and kills all the bad guys. The last time I saw that was...well...never. The actress who plays Hit Girl, Chloe Grace Moretz, wanted to play an Angelina Jolie type action role. This is the type of part she told her agents to find according to a story in the NY Times: "You know, like an action hero, woman empowerment, awesome, take-charge leading role." It warms my heart that a young actress is interested in playing these kinds of parts; that she wants to, for lack of a better word, kick ass, is cool. Also, the fact that all these guys are destroyed by a girl never becomes an issue. There's no sexist bullshit about guys being killed by a girl. She comes and reeks havoc and all these guys want to do is survive.

The cons are the language and the fact that she uses her "girlness" to disarm people (because, really, who would think a little girl could kick your ass?)

We would never be having this whole conversation about Hit Girl if the character would have been Hit Boy. No one would care in the same if a 11-year-old boy said the c-word. I'd probably just dismiss it as another sexist movie and character and move on.

I'm still very conflicted about this. I don't know if this is progress or if this is setting up girls in a very bad way. But one thing I do know is that with all the buzz surrounding the film, I am hoping that the sequel will be called Hit Girl instead of Kick Ass 2.

Just a Sweet Young Actress? $&@%# Right!
(NY Times)

Originally published at Women & Hollywood

 

Follow Melissa Silverstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/melsil

 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:44 AM on 05/01/2010
In all truth i think the fact that everyone believes that if HG were HB there would not be a problem is totally baseless. While some of the gratuitous violence might have been written off, i believe people would still have been upset because of the character would still be 11. More over critics would have been angered even more at the usage of the C Word, saying that it was promoting sexism even though it was being used towards men
11:35 PM on 04/24/2010
hi there..there was actually a movie with similar theme called Leon the Proffessional starring a very young Natalie Portman and Jean Reno, minus the profanities from the young lady, of course. But Mellisa's article hit's the button.
06:43 AM on 04/20/2010
OK, my nephew and niece made me take them to the movie yesterday, and the experience proved 2 things: Millar is a gutless hack who won't even fight to preserve the integrity of his art; Millar composes such woefully inauthentic dialogue, the film-makers retained almost nothing of it (leading to reworking nearly all the characters and the nature of their interaction).

Peruse, if you will, this 7 page sample of KICK-ASS #5 which introduces Red Mist and note how UNLIKE the movie it is:

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=1750&disp=table

Btw, I consider the movie story a rare (slight) improvement over the original comic, with the exception of Dave's relationship with Katie -- Dump that "hero", he's less than "zero"!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
O K Ali
Wash your hands, seriously.
03:20 AM on 04/20/2010
One of the best movies I've seen in the past few years. Reminded me of the calculated brutality of Ellen Page as Hayley Stark in Hard Candy. Maybe as a male, my view is skewed, but i don't mind when female roles get their hands dirty. One of my favorite fight scenes to date is Uma Thurman in Kill Bill Vol.1. Okay, it's an 11 year old girl who wields knives and handguns who cusses like a sailor on leave, I get some people are squeamish when it comes to females leaving their sugar and spice behind when they venture out in the world. Before people start a tsk fest, they shoulld at least stop and maybe ask why she is doing it.. There is actually a reason to her "madness".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Catherine in Tulsa
I am woman, hear me vote: Obama 2012
01:21 PM on 04/20/2010
You will make an awesome boyfriend/husband!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Childers
12:13 AM on 04/20/2010
Most of the reviews portray the character as speaking in a whirlwind of profanity. Not so much. As a matter of fact, most of the "naughty words" were germane. It's actually a testament to the filmmakers audacity of storytelling that they kept the language restrained and realistic. I think "Laser guided f-bomb" is the trope that we are looking for.
One thing does leave me rather curious thou. Chloe Moretz's parents allowed her to see the finished film Mostly it was because she was in it; makes sense. But also because they are assured that she will not act out like the character she portrayed. This being the possible case, is it possible that other parents could see this film with older kids. I wouldn't take a much younger child to see it, but my own daughter is the character in questions age; and she is a smart, wise young lady.
12:11 PM on 04/19/2010
My 21 year old daughter was home from college for the weekend. We saw Kick Ass together (Mom, too!) and enjoyed it very much. One of my metrics for a good movie is whether it inspires post-viewing conversation. Kick Ass wins big on this metric.

As my daughter was leaving yesterday to return to school, she joked that she was disappointed that I had never taught her to beat up and kill bad guys. I replied that her Grampa has lots of guns, and we have the whole summer ahead of us.

I predict a run on purple wigs and plaid skirts.
03:18 AM on 04/19/2010
I agree with WRPrintz. I see a lot of movies, and this is the best one I've seen this year. Maybe it's the best one I've seen in a very long time

The story and dialogue are pitch-perfect. The camera work and cinematography are flawless. The action sequences are breathtaking and inventive. Finally, there's an over-arching intelligence and compassion that infuses the project that makes you feel that you've seen something unique and powerful.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
WRPrintz
Your Micro-bio is empty.
11:45 PM on 04/17/2010
This is actually the best movie I have seen this year.
02:28 PM on 04/17/2010
Ugh, I'm so sick of people trying to dissect and strip apart art... any art... whether it's paintings, poetry, novels, or movies. I saw Kick-Ass yesterday. I left work early, went to the theater and let my mind relax for two hours and thoroughly enjoyed this movie. It's entertainment. If you've seen any of the director's interviews or panel discussions, you would know that Matthew Vaughn was not trying to raise social awareness of anything. Oh, and he doesn't give a crap what you or anyone else thinks. That point is proven in that when Hollywood refused to finance the film, he told them to screw-off and raised the money himself.

He took a very successful comic and made a movie out of it. It's an adult movie with an "R" rating. It's not meant for kids. As an adult, if you're not capable of watching this film for the purpose the director intended, which is for pure entertainment, then head to a proctologist and get the stick removed. IT'S. A. MOVIE. Get over yourself. Roger Ebert said he, "didn't see the point to this film". Why does there have to be a point???????? Can't it just be a story with sounds and moving pictures? Does it really have to satisfy something deeper than that?

By the way, I agree with all who've said Chloe Moretz stole the film. Big things on the horizon for that actress.
10:52 AM on 04/17/2010
I was totally discombobulated with Hit Girl
what I'll gonna say to my daughter when she said
something like :" I wanna be like her "

I'm just kidding I don't give a damn,
What they gonna do next?

Chiuauas playing
coyotes with heavy guns?

is just another way to make more action movies
now exploiting sweet little girls with heavy guns

I like Nicolas Cage rage
he's perfect as Big Daddy.
03:46 AM on 04/17/2010
The title of the movie is Kick Ass. If we're going to complain female heroines actually kick ass for once, what's with the complaints when they're relegated to being dainty damsels in distress who's only purpose is to serve as some trophy of war between good GUY and bad GUY.

I mean Maggie Gillenhall's character got blown to bits playing that part in Batman and nobody even remembers she was in the movie. Yet, Heath Ledger and Bale are the ones who get the accolades because nobody puts their performance in a box because of their gender. Heath Ledger can "magically" make a pen disappear into a man's face and we gave the man an Academy Award because it spoke to the character he played and played well.

People are going to remember this little girl instilling so much fear in 5 grown men with machine guns they were cowering behind a corner even when they knew she was out of ammo. They even resorted to using a bazooka on this kid. There's no way any of that fear would have worked if the audience didn't see just how extreme a caricature of vigilante violence this 11 year old girl represented in the bad GUYS minds.

The film-makers deserve to be applauded and I hope this opens the door for female caped crusaders that actually play the part not just slightly more muscular lois lane types...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IMEHO
11:58 AM on 04/17/2010
Um Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Jessica Alba in Dark Angel, Halle Berry in X-men lets not pretend women don't play action heroines.

Sabrina the teenage witch.
photo
kapalabhati
Lokah Samasta Sukhino Bhavantu
01:00 PM on 04/17/2010
But Alba and Berry, though kicking ass and taking names, were played as sex symbols. I agree about Buffy.
01:57 AM on 04/17/2010
Oh, it also bears mentioning that the movie itself was amazing. I'm going to come right out and say it: Kick-Ass is tied with The Dark Knight for best superhero movie of all time.
01:56 AM on 04/17/2010
I don't know that the characters Hit Girl and Big Daddy serve much more purpose than being a unique, more sinister take on the Batman/Robin archetype. Essentially the former are simply ultra violent versions of the latter. If there is a point to made here, it is perhaps that in the real world it would impossible for a masked vigilante to effectively fight crime without crossing the line that superheroes traditionally won't cross, that line being murder. Kick Ass attempts to follow the traditional superhero model: protect the innocent without killing the guilty. As a result he almost loses his own life several times. Big Daddy and Hit Girl on the other hand employ a kill or be killed method, and in doing so blur the line between hero and villain. It seems we are meant to ask, are these two really good guys fighting crime or simply revenge driven murderers? Looking for much more social commentary than this, though, may be a stretch.
04:24 PM on 04/17/2010
exactly
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:25 PM on 04/16/2010
Could we maybe, I don't know, have a movie that empowers girls without turning them into weapons?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Catherine in Tulsa
I am woman, hear me vote: Obama 2012
04:06 PM on 04/19/2010
why? is it too much to think that women might want revenge as much as a man? women aren't capable of feelings beyond love and maternal instincts?

it's 2010.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jcwtts1
Elections have consequences
03:23 PM on 04/16/2010
Here is the trace, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Lara Croft (video game), Martial Arts Video Games, Alias, Kill Bill Vol 1, the explosion of women kicking a in games and movies.

I'd love some help with the trace I feel like I am leaving somethings out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
urnumbersix
"I am not a Number. I am a Free Man!"
12:03 PM on 04/17/2010
Jessica Alba's "Dark Angel."
Carrie Ann Moss in "Matrix" trilogy.
Jolie as "Lara Croft" series.
Jolie in "Wanted."
Jolie in "Mr. and Mrs. Smith."

(Yeah, Jolie has made her "Big Bucks" on kicking a$$. BWAH!)