More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Carmichael

Michael Carmichael

Posted: January 5, 2010 01:17 PM

Avatar Pulls the Political Trigger

What's Your Reaction:

Avatar is a popular and commercial phenomenon soon to break through the most cherished barrier in Hollywood to become the top-grossing movie of all time. In doing so, Avatar's creator, James Cameron, will only be besting himself - for his earlier blockbuster, Titanic, currently occupies the sacred top box office slot.

But, this box office banter is perfectly trivial - isn't it?

The real question should surely be: Is Avatar more than a mere box office phenomenon? The simple answer is, "Yes, it is much more than a commercial phenomenon - Avatar is political dynamite."

While Hollywood regularly produces fine films with progressive themes, few of them ascend to box office nirvana. Here are a few cases in point: Milk; In the Valley of Elah; An Inconvenient Truth; Syriana, "W.", Good Night and Good Luck, Religulous and Rendition. All made their riveting political points then vanished into the yawning chasm of artistic achievement wrapped in the well-worn shroud of commercial obscurity.

While Avatar is being hailed as a breakthrough to new levels of filmic techno-sophistication - its 3D and special effects are wrapped around a scintillating story line that is driven by thermonuclear political intensity. Avatar is a hyper-political film from its gripping beginning to its illuminating end.

In a nutshell, Avatar's political message is: The American Military-Industrial Complex will utterly destroy the known universe. Avatar depicts a war in heaven - on a mythological planet named "Pandora" - where the cosmic box is opened to reveal that the evil demons set loose to destroy humanity are - us - the US of A. The evil Usses are, indeed, Us.

A brief recapitulation for anyone who has not yet seen the film: The US Military-Industrial Complex is hell-bent to colonize and mine Pandora for its rare extra-terrestrial element, Unobtainium, a mineral with anti-gravitational properties that will resolve the terminal decline of Earth and permit the colonization of more planets for the aggressive exploitation of the universe in pursuit of energy to fuel an endless cycle of extraction and consumption.

The characters of Avatar are archetypes. The protagonist is a paraplegic ex-Marine named Jake Sully who became paralyzed from the waist down like the heroic Ron Kovacs in some future US military intervention. Sully is proselytized into a high-level research program on a far-flung planet that will liberate him from his paralysis with occasional interludes as the mind of an avatar - a native of Pandora, a humanoid people, the Na'vi. On the distant planet, Jake Sully meets the lead scientist of the Avatar project, Dr. Grace Augustine, and her dual nemeses, Parker Selfridge, the corporate bureaucrat driving the mission to mine Unobtainium, and Miles Quaritch - the US military commander of the Pandora invasion.

Upon his formal implantation into his 10-foot tall blue-skinned Na'vi avatar, Jake Sully immediately falls into the vortex of the rapidly spiraling plot. Lost on Pandora and facing grave dangers, Jake meets his savior, Neytiry, the princess royal of the Omaticaya clan. Inevitably and against the will of the princess, Jake Sully is swept deeply into the Pandoran culture. This development pleases his immediate supervisor, Grace Augustine, and his ultimate commander, Miles Quaritch - but Jake's conversion to Pandoran Na'vi ultimately sets off apocalyptic repercussions that will threaten the existence of his mother planet, Earth.

The story is driven by the conflict in Jake's mind. Torn between his commitment to his human DNA and his longing for restorative surgery to regain the use of his body, Jake finds liberation as a Na'vi warrior who dives deeply into the indigenous aboriginal culture of animism and the unadulterated exaltation of Nature. The Omaticaya dwell in a veritable paradise of a planet-girdling rainforest where trees provide the skeletal infrastructure for their naturalistic civilization.

The clash of civilizations results in a Gotterdammerung of the terrestrials. Miles Quaritch is the last surviving American soldier in the decisive battle, and Neytirry slays him with two arrows shot straight into his heart.

The final sequence depicts the forlorn retreat of the remnant of the American forces including Parker Selfridge (presaging a sequel) followed by the final excavation of the mind of Jake Sully and its permanent implantation into his avatar - his Na'vi body.

After the release of Avatar, the American right suffered a massive attack of apoplexy. While many right wing critics have panned the film as flawed for its sacrilegious message as the triumph of Animists and Druids over Christian Soldiers, Alex Jones, the conspiracy theorist, declaims Avatar as a plot to install world government via the "phoney" environmental crisis. While Avatar is grist for the right-wing mill, it is honey to the ears of the progressive trend.

On New Year's Eve while vacationing with his family on Oahu, President Obama and his family were privileged with a private screening of Avatar. The paparazzi will now be placed on alert for the presence of Zoe Saldana who played Neytirry on the White House guest list.

Avatar is powerful art. The finest movies, films and cinema are transformational. They reveal something deep about ourselves. Avatar pulls the political trigger and transforms each of us - one by one - in our multitudes. Let's look forward to the sequel sometime in say - December, 2011 on the eve of the Mayan Apocalypse of 2012 - and the next presidential election. Oh yes, for its excellence, innovation and artistic originality - Avatar should sweep the Oscars, but right-wing knives are already out and operating on its anti-American godlessness.

 

Follow Michael Carmichael on Twitter: www.twitter.com/alchemistoxford

Avatar is a popular and commercial phenomenon soon to break through the most cherished barrier in Hollywood to become the top-grossing movie of all time. In doing so, Avatar's creator, James Cameron,...
Avatar is a popular and commercial phenomenon soon to break through the most cherished barrier in Hollywood to become the top-grossing movie of all time. In doing so, Avatar's creator, James Cameron,...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:10 PM on 01/07/2010
Whether he was a US military commander or private contractor, I found it unfortunate that antagonist Quarich was given a southern accent.

Come on, really?
01:23 PM on 01/07/2010
"In a nutshell, Avatar's political message is: The American Military-Industrial Complex will utterly destroy the known universe ... A brief recapitulation for anyone who has not yet seen the film: The US Military-Industrial Complex is hell-bent to colonize and mine Pandora..."
____________

Where does this come from? This is a classic example of how preconceived notions lead to unchecked assumptions. Where in the movie is it stated that the militia is from the United States? Does it say anywhere that it's a government-backed military force of any kind?

The soldiers in the movie were enlisted in a private army, hired guns for a corporation. The movie questions this notion of private companies using private armies carte blanche, challenges whether such armies should be able to take whatever they want and kill whoever they want, and demonstrates resistance by those oppressed by private militia.

It's important that we do our own thinking, and not let others--in this case, biased partisans who are reading agendas that are written in their hearts, and not in the script--start the thinking process for us.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
10:19 AM on 01/07/2010
The William Johnstone dime novel series ASHES painted the US as the enemy, too, and the author was an arch conservative. It seems that cartoonish morality is apolitical.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
QueenOfViolets
12:47 PM on 01/07/2010
Yes, I agree.

Whether it's conservative or liberal propaganda, propaganda is an insult to the audience, because it assumes that the audience is too stupid to get a message unless it's spelled out in giant letters.
.
09:27 AM on 01/07/2010
"In a nutshell, Avatar's political message is: The American Military-Industrial Complex will utterly destroy the known universe... the evil demons set loose to destroy humanity are - us - the US of A. The evil Usses are, indeed, Us."

I went to see this movie because the special effects looked awesome and the sci-fi space fantasy story looked interesting. I was disappointed by neither (although, I found the 3D more distracting than enhancing). The plot was predictable, but very well conceived and well paced. The CG was flawless and the world of Pandora was a tsunami of visual stimulation.

One way to create an intriguing fictional story line is to exaggerate an otherwise negligible element and extrapolate the consequences in the absence of natural controls and see where it takes you (e.g. the effect of C02 on the climate). Avatar does this by exaggerating corporate greed and diminishing moral checks and balances – the result is attempted genocide to obtain an extremely profitable resource.

I agree that in the fictional world of this movie, this scenario is plausible and abhorrent; but in reality, I don't accept the premise that the American Military-Industrial Complex is as evil as the corporation in this movie, nor is it headed there. Avatar is no more realistic than any of Isaac Asimov’s extrapolations.

So, while the left is getting all excited about a “liberal message movie” making a ton of money, the right isn't accepting your premise. Sorry to disappoint you.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
10:16 AM on 01/07/2010
If that's the case, honey, then why what the Iraqi Oil Ministry building the first one secured by the Coalition Of The Willing when hitting Iraq?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
QueenOfViolets
12:49 PM on 01/07/2010
That doesn't prove Avatar was a good movie.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JWB2012
10:48 AM on 01/07/2010
I don't feel that the " Military - Industrial Complex is evil simply because for me "evil" does not exist ( keep it down, I've heard it all before!). That said, the oligarchy of the M.I.C. IS what is controlling the global domination agenda with wars, religious, political and economic control. These facts exist. It's very real. If I were religious, I would absolutely, positively call the M.I.C. evil to the core. And the people who have given away their power to it have become ignorant slaves to a dysfunctional and collapsing mind - controlling agenda hell bent on our destruction. To clarify for the "morally indignant" of you, here's the "why" behind my opinion ( note: I said opinion)..."Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and right doing is a field. I will meet you there." - Rumi or, "Judge not." - The Holy Bible
09:54 PM on 01/06/2010
The anti-American theme was a clunker. What truly is artfully woven is the themes of German Teutonic Romanticism and Mysticism. The Na'vi are the pure ubermenschen of myth, to which the crippled soldier evolves into--a very German theme. The author borrows from Leni Riefenstahl, especially her film The Blue Light. Mystical and pristine mountains in the sky and forests, the blue growing rocks with mystical powers, Cameron substitutes for the outsider invaders of pillaging villagers the Americans. Blue crystals in the skin too! The scene with floating rock atop a circle of blue light is Cameron's homage to the stunning first blue moon light/blue crystal scene in The Blue Light. The blue crystals in the Na'vi faces are a BIT too much.

I can also venture to say that the "Na'vi" are influenced by the Nuba Riefenstahl studied. Her controversial book came out about the same time Cameron claims he came upon the idea, middle 1970's. To those who think my idea novel, easily found on web is an article documenting Riefenstahl's influence on earlier Cameron films.
06:21 PM on 01/06/2010
Saw the movie and could not help but cringe at the scale of the deforestation scenes. Great film on so many levels. I agree with Michael, the film does have some strong anti military-industrial-complex overtones. Overtones that will find fans in many places inside and outside the U.S. Whether the muscle is U.S. or foreign-made the outcome seems to be quite similar, the complete devastation of whatever ecosystem was there before...
11:05 PM on 01/06/2010
Well said. And agree.
03:36 PM on 01/06/2010
Well written article- Bravo Zulu
03:22 PM on 01/06/2010
I believe "Avatar" will pass the $3 billion box office mark, surpassing even "Titanic".
03:09 PM on 01/06/2010
Wow. That's a riveting commentary. Avatar is high art. I guess lame allegory, weak characters, contrived story, and poor development - along with some new technology - now constitute high art in cinema. All those lame art film directors you mentioned better get on board now or be relegated to, as you say, "the well-worn shroud of commercial obscurity". Are you listening Van Sant? Are you listening Schnabel? You'd better listento Michael Carmichael. He's really in the vanguard of the cinematic arts, so either listen to him or perish.
02:48 PM on 01/06/2010
Ok, whether you liked the movie or not- when I saw it, they made it very clear that the military presence in the film was NOT the US government, or any government. What I got out of it was that they were a private mercenary company hired by a corporation. I never got any kind of an anti-US military idea there. In fact, the only character who is 'officially' identified as an ex-Marine is the hero and he is shown to be a good soldier as well as a decent person.

Sometimes the bad guys in a movie are just bad. I felt like if they showed 'negative' military in the persona of the mercenaries, they also showed 'positive' military in the characters of Sully and the helicopter pilot.

I feel like some people have an agenda and are trying to make this film 'anti-american' to serve their own ideas. If you didn't like the movie or the message that sometimes humans are selfish and destroy other cultures violently for their own financial gain, that is one thing. But it isn't really 'un-american' to point that reality out. It is something that has happened in all human cultures for thousands of years.
photo
Feesister
You've got to give to get back
01:58 PM on 01/06/2010
I didn't think Avatar cast the US strictly as the bad guys. In the movie, the scientists worked to do the right thing by the inhabitants, while the military and corporate types wanted to destroy the Navi to get to the resources.

Ok, I get that this is all fiction, but apparently some are taking this as a swipe at the US. Maybe the truth hurts?
11:06 PM on 01/06/2010
Hello. And fist bump.
01:40 PM on 01/06/2010
The biggest flaw to Avatar is that the spokesman for the military industrial complex says that the deposit of unobtanium is the closest deposit in 200km. After going millions of miles, you would think that they could find another deposit without destoying a native tribes land. If thay had said it was the largest deposit on the planet, then that would be different. One would think that with 12 years in development, someone would have found that statemnent absurd.
02:50 PM on 01/06/2010
Well, but I think the point there is 'we know its here, we already found it, we want to get it' because its there. Not that they couldn't find more or preserve the culture, etc. but in our history as a species, that is not what usually happens in any culture or situation. So although I totally see what you mean about the absurdity, I think it is pretty realistic to assume that the corporation would just decide to get it because its there.
01:18 PM on 01/06/2010
This movie conveys much much more than left vs right and the American military industrial complex. It speaks to greed, injustice, racism, psuedo god-complex, imperialism and genocide. The United States was founded on imperialism, following the model of the Roman Empire and other conquests in world history. As we look to the near future, or what is happening now, the rain forests of South America and Southeast Asia are prime targets for the super powers of the globe and their multinational-corporate bedfellows.

People will suffer, the ecosystem will suffer. Women, children and men will lose their lives either through slaughter or lack of the natural resources essential to their existence. Any why??? Because humankind continues to lose touch with its own humanity.

While we may be making gains in in our ability to connect to one another through technology [Skype, GPS], we meanwhile are creating an unforgiving disconnect between ourselves and our environment, and between the relationship of you and me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijam
Independent
12:06 PM on 01/06/2010
{snark ahead warning} It's a stupid fairy tale for children who actually believe that things can be changed because they are idealistic and don't know any better.
12:14 PM on 01/06/2010
The bible?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oregon bird
01:43 PM on 01/06/2010
No, the bible is about maintaining status quo. Repelling all boarders. K/illing the bad guys, r/aping the beautiful girl, and being refused billing in the second installment because you wrecked your face. Or something like that. Ar, matey!

Geez. It's a movie. Some of us will see it. Quit bugging us with geek reasons to splutz all over the screen, already!
photo
MimiK
living in dramatic times
04:33 PM on 01/06/2010
Actually, it's a cautionary tale for cynics who think that being negative is a sign of intelligence.
10:51 AM on 01/06/2010
Avatar's message is the same message as Pocahontas (Capt. Smith falls in love with indigenous native and turns on his own invading army). It's the same message as Dances with Wolves, it's the same message as Ferngully.

There's nothing new in this message, what has changed is the audience's response to it. There are far too many people out there who now see a left vs. right message in absolutely everything.

One thing to note, it actually wasn't the USA who was the invading army in the movie but a private contract army paid for by Big Business.
11:36 AM on 01/06/2010
So you are thinking that the 'private contract army paid for by Big Business' isn't the same behind the military madness machine operating under the guise of USA?
11:41 AM on 01/06/2010
Blackwater did come to mind.
12:06 PM on 01/06/2010
If you've never seen "Aliens" I suggest you do so immediately. It seems to exist in the same universe where humans can be healed of any disease or paralysis and a shadowy "company" controls the cosmos and everything is a for-profit venture. And that was made in 1985!
12:11 PM on 01/06/2010
It goes further than that. One can read the Romantic novels of James Fennimore Cooper (in this country) or Jose de Alencar (in Brazil) to find very early traces of the elements of Avatar... Also strong parallels to The Mission.

Your points about audience interpretation and the technical point about the plot are also correct.

It is riddled with silly fetishization of paleolithic life as some sort of edenic ideal, corrupted by the corrosive effect of civilization... oh wait... this is just a post-judeochristian cornball...
01:49 PM on 01/06/2010
You're right, it borrows from the Book of Genesis too.