iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Deibert

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Deibert
 

The Problem With Invisible Children's "Kony 2012"

Posted: 03/ 7/2012 5:55 pm

Recently, a new video produced by the American NGO Invisible Children focusing on Joseph Kony and the Lord's Resistance Army (LRA) has been making the rounds. Having just returned from the Acholi region of Northern Uganda myself, where the LRA was born, I thought I might share some of my thoughts on the subject, for what it's worth.

I think it is easy for Invisible Children and other self-aggrandizing foreigners to make the entire story of the last 30 years of Northern Uganda about Joseph Kony, but there is a history of the relationship between the Acholi people from whom the LRA emerged and the central government in Kampala that is a little more complicated than that.

Kony is a grotesque war criminal, to be sure, but the Ugandan government currently in power also came to power through the use of kadogo (child soldiers) and fought alongside militias employing child soldiers in the Democratic Republic of Congo, something that Invisible Children seem wilfully ignorant of.

The conflict in Acholi -- the ancestral homeland of the ethnic group who stretch across northern Uganda and southern Sudan -- has its roots in Uganda's history of dictatorship and political turmoil. A large number of soldiers serving in the government of dictator Milton Obote (who ruled Uganda from 1966 to 1971 and then again from 1980 to 1985) came from across northern Uganda, with the Acholis being particularly well represented, even though Obote himself hailed from the Lango ethnic group. When Obote was overthrown by his own military commanders, an ethnic Acholi, General Tito Okello, became president for six chaotic months until Yoweri Museveni's National Resistance Army took over. Museveni became president, and has since remained so, via elections -- some legitimate, some deeply flawed.

Upon taking power, the Museveni government launched a brutal search and destroy mission against former government soldiers throughout the north, which swept up many ordinary Acholi in its wake. Some Acholi began mobilizing to defend themselves, first under the banner of the Uganda People's Democratic Army (largely made up of former soldiers) and then the Holy Spirit Movement.

This movement, directed by Alice Auma, an Acholi who claimed to be acting on guidance from the spirit Lakwena, brought a mystical belief in their own invincibility that the soldiers of the Kampala-based government at first found terrifying: Holy Spirit Movement devotees walked headlong into blazing gunfire singing songs and holding stones they believed would turn into grenades. The movement succeeded in reaching Jinja, just 80 km from the capital Kampala, before being decimated by Museveni's forces.

Out of this slaughter was born the Lord's Resistance Army (LRA), led by Joseph Kony, a distant relative of Alice Auma. Kony added an additional element of targeting civilian Acholi to his schismatic blend of Christianity, frequently kidnapping children and adolescents to serve in his rebel movement. The Museveni government responded by viewing all Acholi as potential collaborators, rounding them up into camps euphemistically called "protected villages", where they were vulnerable to disease and social ills, and had few ways to carry on their traditional farming.

The LRA's policy of targeting civilians (though not the Museveni government's draconian measures) eventually drew international condemnation and in 2005 the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants against Joseph Kony and several other seniors LRA commanders for crimes against humanity and war crimes. Ironically, one of those commanders, Dominic Ongwen, was himself kidnapped by the LRA while still a small boy.

After peace talks between the LRA and the Ugandan government collapsed in 2007, the group decamped from its bases in southern Sudan to the Democratic Republic of Congo and the Central African Republic.

Following the end of negotiations, the Museveni government launched its Peace Recovery and Development Plan (PRDP), an effort to stabilize northern Uganda after years of war. Since then, according to the United Nations, 98 percent of internally displaced persons have moved on from the camps that once sheltered hundreds of thousands of frightened people.

Despite criticisms from the Acholi that the government's program has been insufficient, local initiatives and the work of some foreign organizations have helped restore a sense of normality and gradual progress to the region, with people returned to their homes and travel between once off-limits parts of the region now facilitated with relative ease.

Now a thousand miles from the cradle of their insurgency, the LRA would appear to have little hope of returning to Uganda, though their potential to wreak havoc on civilians remains little diminished. In Congo's Haut-Uele province, between December 2009 and January 2010, the LRA massacred 620 civilians and abducted more than 120 children.

In October 2011, U.S. President Barack Obama announced that he was sending 100 Special Forces soldiers to help the Ugandans hunt down Kony. By the end of the year, the Ugandan army confirmed that the troops had moved along with the Ugandan army to Obo in the Central African Republic and Nzara in South Sudan.

The problem with Invisible Children's whitewashing of the role of the government of Uganda's president Yoweri Museveni in the violence of Central Africa is that it gives Museveni and company a free pass, and added ammunition with which to bludgeon virtually any domestic opposition, such as Kizza Besigye and the Forum for Democratic Change.

By blindly supporting Uganda's current government and its military adventures beyond its borders, as Invisible Children suggests that people do, Invisible Children is in fact guaranteeing that there will be more violence, not less, in Central Africa.

I have seen the well-meaning foreigners do plenty of damage before, so that is why people understanding the context and the history of the region is important before they blunder blindly forward to "help" a people they don't understand.

U.S. President Bill Clinton professed that he was "helping" in the Democratic Republic of Congo in the 1990s and his help ended up with over 6 million people losing their lives.

The same mistake should not be repeated today.

 
 
 

Follow Michael Deibert on Twitter: www.twitter.com/michaelcdeibert

 
 
  • Comments
  • 285
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
04:58 PM on 04/30/2012
Cuando primero escuchaba de Kony 2012 yo pensé que es una idea buena. Pero cuando vi la película no piensa que sea una idea buena, porque no ayuda a la gente que esto se supone que ayude. No pienso que una persona pueda pulsar un botón y haga una diferencia en un país en el otro lado del mundo. Yo pienso en tiempos modernos la gente se desencanta con la red. Ellos piensan que ayudan cambiar el mundo cuando en realidad no lograrán nada. En Estados Unidos tenemos un problema con la gente, especialmente las liberales. Por ejemplo Three Cups of Tea autor Greg Mortenson era responsable de una organización de caridad como KONY 2012. Lo fue descubierto que el dinero que la gente le dio fue gastado. También el fundador de KONY 2012 fue detenido por exhibicionismo en San Diego. En conclusión ver una película no es igual que ayudar a las personas
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
08:14 AM on 04/21/2012
I also highly recommend that those interested in the debate read this collection of articles, many from Ugandans themselves:

Some important articles on Invisible Children and Kony 2012

http://tinyurl.com/7dowh7e
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
04:07 PM on 04/20/2012
Talitha, I think it would be news to the people of eastern DRC that the US did not intervene in Central Africa after the Rwandan genocide. Just ask the people (the few of them that are left) who witnessed the massacres of the US-supported AFDL/RPA in Mbandaka, Ting-Tingi, Kasese and so many other places.

Or ask the Ugandans, a vast majority of whom it would appear agree with the sentiments voiced in this article that Invisible Children "exploited our suffering to make money":

http://www.acholitimes.com/index.php/8-acholi-news/154-kony-2012-screening-in-gulu-leaves-one-dead-and-many-injured

The badly thought-out and fraught course advocated by Invisible Children and the serious questions raised by others about the group's true objectives and financing make this and endeavour that I do not believe is worthy of support.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
10:04 AM on 04/20/2012
Sorry, Talitha, but I don't think simply saying "it's complicated" addresses the very questionable path advocated by Invisible Children nor the other serious concerns others have brought up about the organization and its agenda. Not at all.

Nor do the Acholi people apparently appreciate an effort in which, to quote one Gulu resident who spoke before a screening of Kony 2012 there left one dead and many injured: "We expected to see Acholi in the video...(Invisible Children) exploited our suffering to make money."

http://www.acholitimes.com/index.php/8-acholi-news/154-kony-2012-screening-in-gulu-leaves-one-dead-and-many-injured
10:38 AM on 04/18/2012
So, the US should stay out of it? Do you think that it was best that the US did not intervene in Rwanda because the issues there were "complicated"?

Regardless of the complexity (which Kony 2012 Part II addresses beautifully), LRA violence is wrong nd the GLOBAL community can rally to stop it. Www.kony2012.com has great advocacy action steps for citizens of any country to use. Check them out!
photo
Wairimu
anti-extremist (of all stripes)
03:34 PM on 04/20/2012
Rwanda was in no way complicated. There were massacres going on - innocent civilians being killed en masse. Nothing complicated about stopping or trying to stop that from happening. But, there was nothing to gain so their lives were not important...
12:28 PM on 04/03/2012
as long as Kony is alive there is a chance he will strike again. whether Museveni will take the credit or not doesn't matter, what matters is that Joseph Kony need to be stopped and the children be rescued. Many people criticize Russel's work and the work of invisible children, but they have not done one single thing to help Northern Uganda. they do not have a better plan to suggest otherwise that can replace the effort invisible children put forward. being born and raised in that Region worst of all being a victim myself i say if you don't have a better plan to suggest please keep quiet and let those with better idea work on capturing Kony. Order yourself the book "The Massacres of Uganda" on Amazon or Barnes and Nobles. or go to www.themassacresofuganda.com for details on the war.
12:30 AM on 03/19/2012
"U.S. President Bill Clinton professed that he was "helping" in the Democratic Republic of Congo in the 1990s and his help ended up with over 6 million people losing their lives." - HARDLY!! Clinton did so very little in the Congo and surrounding countries, that in a few cases (Rwanda, for one), he actually visited (after the violence had ended, of course), and apologized. REGARDLESS - any publicity brought to the plight of victims of violence is a good thing, so if you don't like the KONY2012 movie - move along to a cause you do care about. At least, you know who Kony is now:)
photo
Wairimu
anti-extremist (of all stripes)
03:36 PM on 04/20/2012
Congo was after, and as a result of, the failures in Rwanda.
05:25 AM on 03/18/2012
I understand the outcry for Uganda, but what about the "Invisible Children" in America who were plucked from their homes (in other countries), after seeing their mothers/brothers/fathers murdered and brought to be sex slaves and forced labor. According to the Tolerance, Equality and Awareness movement website, 50,000 women and children are trafficked into the United States from no less than 49 countries every year. Who is going to be their voices?

Why do we (have we) not cry(ied) out in rage, about the children in Iraq and Afghanistan who are being used as soldiers for the Taliban, and other terrorist organizations. Is it because they are not worthy of our rage? Is is because they are not Christian? I sure hope not! Tell me, who is going to be their voices?

What about the children who are victims of child abuse? Those whom the system that was supposed to protect them, has failed them? Statistics from Childhelp.org say that five children die every day due to child abuse/neglect from someone they are supposed to trust. Are they not too worth our rage? Again I ask, who is going to be their voice?

We can't help other countries until we help ourselves. Our country needs to fix some of it's problems within before it goes around helping other countries and being the "big bad hero" everyone thinks we (as Americans) are.
09:39 PM on 03/17/2012
Who cares about the politics? Who cares about the politicians? Who cares if it's an over simplification? Who cares about critics? Not I. I care about the children. There should not be child soldiers, children should not be kidnapped, raped, mutiliated. I think most of us can agree on that. If the international criminal court made Kony most wanted number 1, then that's a great place to start. I'm not naive enough to think this will solve the overall problems or naive enough to think we will ever solve our problems. But we can move to make certain atrocities totally unacceptable as they arise. I don't care who starts the movement, I don't care how they do it, I don't care if a bunch of spoiled American and European children help to end the war in Vietnam, apartheid or child soldiers. I just care that people pay attention and people stop it. It IS as simple as that.
09:52 PM on 03/14/2012
I don't think it's fair to describe KONY 1012 as raising awareness when it neglects to provide a thorough explanation of the context of the Ugandan circumstances. Information without context can be worse than no information at all, and when information is sensationalized, and presented as rhetoric in which style prevails over substance, there is a tendency for people to respond to the issues in a myopic manner. For example, you have people throwing money at the problem, without a thought to the consequences of concentrating wealth in an impoverished area. Situations, such such as that involving the LRA, need to be dealt with in a conscious and delicate manner, and raising awareness that lacks any depth, whether it be on a small scale or across the country, will do nothing to benefit the profoundly complex social issues of Uganda, and Africa in general.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
12:05 PM on 03/14/2012
I think it would instructive for people to see the outrage that the #Kony2012 campaign has generated in Northern Uganda among the very people it purports to speak in the name of: http://tinyurl.com/8483qej
10:43 PM on 03/14/2012
I found your article very thought provoking insofar as it does a great job of pointing out the complexity of the problems within the DRC and problem with Invisible Children and the Kony 2012 video. However, like most of the criticism I have read you fail to advocate any kind of alternative. What exactly should people do beyond raising awareness about the horrible things happening within the DRC? Beyond our the effort to better educate people about these complexities what can be done in terms of advocacy?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
08:21 AM on 03/15/2012
Matthew, In terms of advocacy and organizations worthy of support, please read my follow-up: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-deibert/how-invisible-childrens-k_b_1334410.html?ref=impact. All best, MD
01:18 PM on 03/12/2012
If you saw KONY 2012 and want to help Uganda, then play this iPhone game “Raise the Village.” I’m on the development team and we give money directly to a village in Uganda that was ransacked by the LRA. Basically, you build a virtual village and simultaneously help a real one. http://bit.ly/sNHI72
10:50 AM on 03/12/2012
Kony 2012 is just trying to raise awareness to the problem. If you have a better way of getting the attention of tens of millions of people you should try contacting Invisible Children and give them your suggestions. Don't make something negative that is a positive if only the publicity of it. I doubt Kony 2012 is going to make anything worse for those in that region. It is time for people to come together to find solutions not slam others ideas to raise awareness.
02:29 PM on 03/12/2012
It seems to me that ultimately this is about Africom. Kony is undoubtedly a monster, and plenty of well meaning folks are trying to do the right thing--but what will come of this will be a western military presence that will continue what's gone on on that continent for centuries--the rape and plunder the African continent by the west. The story is that China is way ahead of the west in gaining access to natural resources in Africa--most notably rare earth minerals, used in (cell phones and computers and) advanced weapons systems. Africom is about kicking China out of Africa--just as Libya was about evicting China from its oil interests (and establishing a hedge against African unity). The pretext may be human rights but foreign policy and statesmanship (and Africom) has nothing to do with morals or ethics; to think otherwise is naive.
04:14 AM on 03/12/2012
This issue is that the video is false and doesn't accurately depict Uganda. It has inaccurate information.

Its that simple. People from Uganda are posting videos about it, you should hear what they have to say. Thats the first thing i heard. Then i heard the the president general Musinev is a US backed dictator for life who likes american guns go figure...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Deibert
05:44 PM on 03/13/2012
I agree, Charles. I think the Ugandans themselves have spoken very eloquently on the matter. I particularly liked this line from a Ugandan human rights activist: ""Kony is bad news but so is Museveni." http://www.acholitimes.com/index.php/perspectives/opinion/16-kony2012-should-have-advocated-for-dialogue-and-not-military-option
11:59 PM on 03/11/2012
I was trying to process why I was seeing so much support and criticism at the same time and why many of us felt uneasy about re-posting. I wrote some thoughts about consumerism and commodification, I think it helps us navigate through the catch 22 of modern activism: http://pumthuggee.com/2012/03/radicalism-is-the-new-caffeine-kony-2012/