American Idol -- Top 9: Kris Allen Shines

05/02/2009 05:12 am ET | Updated May 25, 2011

In a blessedly brief Idol (anything less than two hours feels like a speeded-up pleasure), the Top 9 Idol contestants sang any song that was available for purchase on iTunes, surely the weakest theme ever. And as Kara Dio Guardi sparred with the audience, delivered some bizarre lines (Studio 57?) and seemed to reach out to the other judges without success, it's gonna be the audition rounds for season 9 before we'll know whether she's coming back or not.

According to Marc Berman of Mediaweek, the show scored a 13.3 overnight rating, followed by the dead-on-arrival Osbournes variety show, which lost 63% of its Idol lead-in.

The show began with the contestants walking out to center stage with Adam Lambert discretely guiding Scott MacIntyre. Ryan Seacrest mentioned that Idol finalists have scored 29 Top 40 hits. It wasn't clear to me whether he meant Top 40 on the Billboard charts or Top 40 on iTunes, but surely the total was low: if you include R&B and country and other charts, I'd say Idol finalists have scored significantly more hit singles.

ANOOP DESAI -- Sang Usher's "Caught Up," the final Top 10 hit from the massive, 9 million selling album Confessions. (His most recent album, Here I Stand, was such a flop that Usher is reportedly releasing another album sometime this year.) Anoop was wearing a ridiculous jacket with a chain on it a la Michael Jackson and strode the stage with a suburban swagger. I knew it was a mistake last week when Randy Jackson urged him to get funky again and indeed Anoop fell flat. Though not because of his vocals, which were servicable, especially if you listened to them without watching him. But he just looked like a goof. Kara said rightly that he looked as if some frat guys had just dared him to sing Usher and Simon called it posturing. For a guy who got into the Top 13 because of his likability, the more we see of Anoop the less we like. He seemed defiant during the critique, which never helps. But perhaps some of his annoyance came from the fact that every judge began by saying his vocals were pretty good but still trashed him. That plus going first means he is in serious trouble.

MEGAN JOY -- Sang Bob Marley's "Turn Your Lights Down Low" from Exodus but somehow thought the song belonged as much to Lauryn Hill, who covered the tune on a compilation album and had a Top 15 hit in the UK with it. Megan Joy needs to have Christopher Cross produce her debut album because she is the very definition of a studio voice -- someone who has a very limited vocal ability but quirky and intriguing enough that in the studio she might be able to piece together some good work. Certainly she'll never really cut it live. But whereas Anoop sang ok but seemed annoying, Megan Joy sang poorly but still came across as fun and goofy, including that odd moment of pointing towards the sky (or the band). Her vocals were flat and low and shaky throughout but I strongly disagree with the judges who said it was a terrible song choice. Seems well within her range to me; she just isn't that good a singer.

DANNY GOKEY -- Sang the Rascal Flatts tune "What Hurts The Most," their biggest pop hit to date. Gokey had a bum last note and oversang in the "big" moments just a tad, but it was a strong performance and a marked improvement over last week. The judges -- relieved to have the guy they've been touting back on form -- praised him to high heaven, with Randy again offering terrible advice that Danny should move more on stage. Uh, no he shouldn't.

ALLISON IRAHETA -- Sang No Doubt's massive hit single "Don't Speak" (#1 for 16 weeks!), which counts as a golden oldie for the 16 year old since she was about four when it came out. Yes, her outfit was more appropriate for a Cyndi Lauper cover, but the judges again ignored what a fine vocalist Allison is. Her version had some nice touches but was a tad too close to the original for my taste. Still, she sounded strong again. The judges all spent more time trashing her dress with the result that Allison again seems overlooked in the talent department. Is she under the radar a la Kelly Clarkson or simply being fatally ignored?

SCOTT MACINTYRE -- Sang Billy Joel's "Just The Way You Are," the first breakthrough hit of Joel's career. (It hit #3 and stayed there for two weeks and ultimately went gold. Previously, "Piano Man" had only hit #25. Joel went on to have 33 Top 40 hits.) Scott just sat at the piano and played the song, which is about as good a showcase for him as you can ask for. But it also highlights his many weaknesses. He was flat and off key and every time he tried for a vocal run or big note it was a disaster. Vocally, he's just as bad as Megan Joy but without the quirks to keep it vaguely interesting. The entire performance was at a funereal pace, which Paula referred to as "legato." All the judges praised him to high heaven so I have to assume he'll be safe for another week, though frankly he belongs in the bottom two.

MATT GIRAUD -- Sang the current hit song from The Fray, "You Found Me." He sang the tune at his keyboard surrounded by the anonymous pretty girls who flood the front of the stage, a number of whom seemed more focused on the camera than his performance. It was kind of a mess and reminded me of a bar band covering a Top 40 hit -- serviceable and similar to the original, but soulless. The judges hated it. That combined with Matt looking unconfident and unhappy made for a very bad night.

LIL ROUNDS -- Sang Celine Dion's "I Surrender" from A New Day Has Come, which was never a single but has been performed on Idol multiple times. Rounds had a terrible look -- too much makeup and lip gloss that made her seem ready for the prom but not primetime. And her vocals were strained and flat on the big notes. Paula Abdul nailed it by saying she didn't want Lil to be adult contemporary but r&b and fun. Still, the first three judges were overly friendly when Lil could have come in for some serious critiques. Only Simon came down hard, calling it a wedding performance. I would have predicted the bottom three until Ryan joked with Lil's kids and one of them ended up hugging Randy while tears streamed down Lil's face. She'll be safe.

ADAM LAMBERT -- Sang Wild Cherry's #1 smash "Play That Funky Music," as good an example of a one-hit wonder as there is. Lambert insisted he would TRY to make it sound contemporary, but I wondered where the problem was. Last week was the first time I truly enjoyed Lambert's performance and that good will carried over to this week. I still don't like the vocal histrionics (every time he does a high-pitched vocal riff I think of KISS). But he stayed on melody for most of the tune and delivered the song flawlessly. The guy definitely can sing, even if I still think his sensibility is more for faux rock of the Rent kind than actual pop music. I never liked his original hair style but it seemed like his real look. The Elvis look of the past two weeks seems more like a wig, like part of a costume, than the spiky look. And proving he's smart, Adam gave a shout out to the much-maligned house band. It's always a good idea to keep the behind the scenes folk on your side. And again, he delivered the song very well. That's two weeks in a row where I can applaud Adam. Kara's comment about it being like Studio 57 was truly jaw-dropping.

KRIS ALLEN -- Sang the Bill Withers gem "Ain't No Sunshine," his first big hit. If you don't own Just As I Am, do yourself a favor and buy it immediately. (Paired with his second album, Still Bill, it's a must have.) I've been a fan of Kris for purely superficial reasons from the get-go. But he keeps getting better and better every week. Tonight's performance was truly sensational. The tune has a tricky bridge with a string of "I know" repeated over and over. Withers makes it seem effortless and gripping but many other artists sort of just stumble through that moment. Kris broke it down very nicely and cleverly in a way that didn't mimic Withers but didn't abuse the melody either. He was soulful and intense and just generally great. All the judges rightly praised him but not enough in my book. With Lil stumbling and Danny just repeating himself, Kris looks like the one with the mojo to me.

Who belongs in the bottom three? Allison was treated so dismissively that I worry it'll be her. Matt Giraud was treated so roughly and seems so unhappy, it could easily be him. Lil Rounds would also be a contender if it weren't for her cute kids. Scott MacIntyre belongs there but the judges are propping him up right now. But being bad and going early is a deadly combination, so I think Anoop and Megan Joy are definitely in the bottom three. They'll be joined by...Matt Giraud. The bottom two is Anoop and Megan Joy and because there are so few women left, I think Anoop is going home.

Go here to read Enetertainment Weekly's Michael Slezak rundown of the show, with another EW journalist reporting on the show from the studio audience.

Vote For The Worst (which tries to rally people to support their pick for the weakest singer) continues to bang the drum for Megan Joy.

Dial Idol -- which predicts who is going home based on the amount of busy signals their automated dialing system picks up -- says Anoop is in danger.

And the Associated Press recaps the show, but can't even be bothered to mention Matt Giraud. Ouch.