More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Leach

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Leach
 

The Average Catholic Is Not Who You Think She Is

Posted: 04/12/11 08:03 PM ET

Forget the TV babble. Never mind what you read in the papers. Here's the real skinny:
The average Catholic is young, old, middle-aged and every color of the human rainbow. She prays the rosary or chants a mantra or doesn't use words at all. He reads the diocesan newspaper or a religious magazine or, most likely, nothing "Catholic" at all. She goes to a Bible study group at the parish or to a yoga class at the civic center or watches CNN and considers from her sofa what life is all about. He reflects on the teachings of Jesus or meditates on a spiritual book or simply remembers the chosen part of things learned long ago. She is interested in what she is here for and what it all means and what to snack on when American Idol comes on. The average Catholic does not fit easily into a square or a circle but belongs to a big triangle that holds all shapes and sizes.

The average Catholic is outraged at the crimes of many in the hierarchy but refuses to throw the baby out with the bathwater. She knows the baby is precious, real, never grows old, can still give her joy, peace and assurance, and it's not dependent on people.

Napoleon once told a Cardinal that he could destroy the Catholic Church with his fists, in an instant, if he wanted to. The Cardinal laughed and said, "We bishops have been trying to destroy the church for 1,800 years with our sins and stupidity but haven't come close. What makes you think you can do better?"

The average Catholic could not care less about the issue of papal infallibility but is grateful that her church is a moral standard bearer. He is proud of the Pope's affirmation of life wherever he goes. She wishes more leaders, in the church and in the world, would witness to the truth that all of life is sacred: from womb to tomb; in the unborn and the dying; the murderer on death row and the mother in a coma; the soldier in Afghanistan and the homeless family in Iraq; the child abused by a pedophile and the pensioner who can't afford a doctor; in the oil-poisoned Gulf and the coal mines of Pennsylvania; in the Arab and in the Israeli. The average Catholic has a high moral standard but is reluctant to chastise anyone, other than himself, who doesn't live up to it.

The average Catholic knows from experience that birth control is a blessing and that abortion is a tragedy. She values the virtues of fidelity and chastity but would never call sex outside of marriage or divorce and remarriage sins. To him that would mean calling a person he doesn't even know a sinner. The average Catholic is deathly afraid of throwing stones. The only sinner she's greatly familiar with is herself. When told that "God hates the sin but loves the sinner," the average Catholic voices confusion. How can anyone separate the two? And if God is Love, how can God hate? The average Catholic prefers to cultivate an attitude of unconditional love and forgiveness -- until somebody steps on his toes. Then it gets personal. And all good ideas go out the window. The average Catholic is imperfect and knows it. When she prays the Our Father and says, "Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us," she has to go fast or she'll tremble in her boots. Sometimes he wonders if he'll ever get it right.

The average Catholic is rarely interested in anyone's sexual orientation. He finds public or private talk about the sexual activities of homosexuals or heterosexuals tasteless and can't understand why anyone would want to flog or flaunt, persecute or parade sexuality of any kind. In her rare moments when she is in the vicinity of "being close to God," the average Catholic knows that sex is at best a glorious distraction and at worst nothing but trouble. He can't stop the world from emphasizing it, but he thinks it wouldn't hurt for the church to declare a moratorium on speaking about sex for the next several years. The worst result: a better sense of balance.

The average Catholic likes priests and nuns, and is not alarmed by talk of new forms of priesthood. She has lived long enough to know that things change. He knows that appearances always change but the chosen part of priesthood -- the spiritual part, service to others for the sake of the kingdom -- will never change. Nor Jesus' promise: "I will be with you always, even to the end of the world."

The next time you look at the statistics, please remember: the average Catholic is very much like you.

 
 
 
Forget the TV babble. Never mind what you read in the papers. Here's the real skinny: The average Catholic is young, old, middle-aged and every color of the human rainbow. She prays the rosary or cha...
Forget the TV babble. Never mind what you read in the papers. Here's the real skinny: The average Catholic is young, old, middle-aged and every color of the human rainbow. She prays the rosary or cha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 334
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
BlueCashew
If I were a cat, what life would I be on?
02:36 PM on 04/26/2011
Nice job on this article.
11:38 AM on 04/26/2011
This is not a bad description of the moderate Catholic I believe. I certainly fits with my own experiences of your average Catholic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
04:07 PM on 04/19/2011
The Prince of Darkness has taken possession of Benny 16 and his court of dunces in violet and scarlet. Catholics need to pressure him to step down, or force him into exile through pressure applied to Premier Berlusconi and the Italian Government. Then elect an anti-pope to replace him.

The old Bavarian Sausager Maker in his jeweled pointey hat should be given comfortable quarters, his books, his piano, and be permitted to be joined by brother George. Sardinia, Devil's Island, Mauritius, and Elba or St. Helena, all of them should be rather nice this time of year.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
03:56 PM on 04/19/2011
This piece is pure nonsense. The average Catholic is clueless about his/her own Church. Wrapped up in their own piety and peasant superstition. All while this pope has presided over the greatest scandal since the Protestant Reformation and has done nothing to get rid of the perpetrators of these sexual abuse crimes.

Rome has become the abode of the Prince of Darkness with a pope and hierarchy themselves possessed of demons.
11:37 AM on 04/26/2011
Peter Mandelson?
12:02 PM on 04/18/2011
Catholic means universal. I have read many of the posts here, and they started out praising the article and went down hill rapidly. I am a political liberal, I am pro-choice, I am pro gay marriage, I am anti- gun, anti-death penalty, I do not believe in extraordinary measures to keep some one in a vegetative state alive, I am against war, all wars. I beleive we are obligated to take care of the earth for which we are stewards. I believe in the constitution. my ancestors came here for freedom of religion. I am an AMERICAN and I live a very conservative life, that is why my politics are liberal, so no one EVER takes that right away from me. I am Catholic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheWM
aka The Wrong Monkey
12:01 PM on 04/18/2011
"The average Catholic is rarely interested in anyone's sexual orientation."

That may be. Still, even if it's only one in ten who is inclined to cause big problems for other human beings for daring to be who they are, that's still over 100,000,000 bigots and it still includes the Pope. It's still a huge problem even if the average Catholic isn't a part of the problem. Even if people like Michael Leach are sometimes inclined to shut their eyes to the problem, as he seem to have been inclined while writing this piece.
11:41 AM on 04/26/2011
The 'grassroots' Catholics of my age, who usually attend mass, and went through Catholic school - as did I - have a very liberal attitude towards sexuality, and have no problems with difference of orientation.

I would expect more problems to arise the older the generation of Catholic you asked.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheWM
aka The Wrong Monkey
11:56 AM on 04/18/2011
Michael Leach, and some of the more enthusiastic readers leaving comments, correctly point out that there is a lot of diversity among Catholics.

I don't think that should surprise anyone, as their are over a billion Catholics, and there are going to be all sorts of different viewpoints and lifestyles and ideologies in any group that big. The group of Baptists is one-tenth as large, or smaller, depending on whom you include, but it's big enough to include John Birch, Jerry Falwell and Martin Luther King, Bill Clinton, Jimmy Carter, Al Gore, Mike Huckabee and John McCain, Aretha Franklin and Chuck Norris. Big groups are diverse. This is not news.

Without wanting to deny that, and without the slightest desire on my part to paint all Catholics with one brush, feel-good puff pieces like this completely fail to address the many legitimate reasons for opposition to Catholic doctrine and teachings expressed by more serious people, including, ironically, a lot of Catholics.
11:46 AM on 04/26/2011
Yes, but it is refreshing to see an honest portrait of what I see most Catholics I have talked to are like. Just because the Church is painted as antiquated and far too conservative in its views and actions - does not mean it represents the average parish community.

Both non-Catholics, and Catholics like myself, have a obligation to speak out against what we feel to be wrong. It is nice, for once in part of the liberal-media (I mean this in a good sense), to be given a fair-shake, and to 'humanized' once again - rather than being perceived all as bigots.
06:51 PM on 04/17/2011
And the average Catholic is politically conservative (Scalia), politically liberal (Pelosi), Pro-Life, Pro-Choice, believes basic health care is a human right, believes basic health care is a privilege for those who can afford it, invites their gay child's partner to Thanksgiving dinner, tells their gay child they have been disowned, laughs loudly at Monty Python movies, wants the National Endowment for the Arts dufunded because a painting offended them, chose vegetarianism for health and animal-rights reasons, teaches their children to shoot animals for sport, thinks man-made Global Warming is a danger to the planet, thinks man-made Global Warming is a myth.
In other words, I'm a Catholic and my siblings are Catholic. We liberal Catholic siblings call our conservative Catholic siblings "Catholic, too". Our conservative Catholic siblings call us liberal Catholic siblings "heretics who are Catholic and Christian in name only". Is this anyone else's experience?
08:18 AM on 04/18/2011
I'm politically liberal, but somewhat liturgically conservative, so add that to the mix too!
11:49 AM on 04/18/2011
No. Only on T.V.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
02:53 PM on 04/17/2011
One of the other HP articles says that 98% of Catholic women have used contraception. That and this article should serve as evidence of how diverse we are as humans.
photo
farmilyman
everything is illusion
12:27 AM on 04/17/2011
The average catholic is catholic only because their parents want them to be.
03:12 PM on 04/16/2011
Where are the data/statistics to back up all these claims of "average"? I'm a Catholic (and sociologist) and generally resonate intuitively with the main points of the article, but it's meaningless without a statistical/research basis for the assertions.
01:34 AM on 04/20/2011
Now, now, this is a "feel good" piece. Don't go asking for evidence.
07:11 AM on 04/16/2011
Thank you, thank you, thank you for this wonderful profession of faith in the Catholic tradition. It is so true, we average Catholics cringe as the hierarchy clings to life support and American bishops cave to Rome as they send most of the money that funds the Vatican.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
04:01 PM on 04/19/2011
Yes and most Catholic people in the pews permit their decadent bishops to abuse their minds, misappropriate their donations, and then cover their purple tushes so the DA and the Obama Justice Department won't sent them to prison for protecting child buggerers.
03:33 AM on 04/16/2011
This is quite possibly the best piece I've ever read on HuffPo. God bless all of you, whether you love or hate Catholics.

This blogger has earned a new fan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrsL
marriage & motherhood with mirth and grace
05:52 PM on 04/15/2011
I was with you for the first three paragraphs. Kinda shaky on paragraph 4 because actually papal infalibility is one of the hallmarks of Catholicism. Disagreed with a lot of the rest of it

I guess "average" depends on where you are and who you know!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
04:17 PM on 04/19/2011
Today Catholicism has become a collection of free thinkers. Catholics can be identified more easily by the Church doctrines they have wholeheartedly REJECTED, than by those teachings they accept. The only difference they have with Unitarians, is Unitarians generally have more money and are more formally educated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrsL
marriage & motherhood with mirth and grace
10:59 PM on 04/19/2011
I would disagree with that. There are the devout Catholics who are following the church Christ founded, and the others. That's basically it.
photo
Jradxit
Faithless morality over baseless faith
09:21 AM on 04/15/2011
There's only bathwater folks. The baby is a myth.