iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Shank

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Shank
 

Bringing Florida to Justice, Not Just George Zimmerman

Posted: 03/25/2012 6:45 pm

To ask "Who is George Zimmerman?" -- as many are now asking -- is perhaps the wrong question. Undoubtedly, Zimmerman needs to be brought to justice in the tragic and unjust killing of Trayvon Martin.

The killing of Trayvon Martin demonstrates how insidiously pervasive racism remains in this country and reminds us how truly far we are from achieving racial justice.

A bigger question that must also be asked is "Who is Florida?" We could ask a question about the direction America is headed on race and violence but let's stick to Florida for a moment. While race is a fundamental factor in this case, and rightly stirring a national furor, I want to draw attention to levels of violence in Florida.

Florida is the fourth most violent state in the U.S. It is in America's Top 10 for most violent crimes per 100,000 people. It is also in the Top 10 for incarceration rates and police employees per 100,000 and near the top 10 for homicides per capita. In our U.S. Peace Index, it ranked near the bottom at 47th. Only Nevada, Tennessee and Louisiana are more violent. In short, there is a culture of violence in Florida that must be addressed when looking at George Zimmerman. He is not alone.

Florida does not understand how to keep the peace, despite its high numbers of police per capita. What we know from our index's strongest correlations, is that a state's ability to provide for its population in the following areas dramatically increases its capacity to lower its levels of violence: Graduate your students, insure your residents, provide access to basic services, lower poverty and inequality rates, and increase labor participation rates, and the less prevalent and pervasive violent crime, homicide, incarceration, policing and small arms trafficking will be.

Florida, then, must rethink its latest budget cuts, which have eaten away at education, health care, basic services and economic opportunity. If it wants to save money, there is another way -- by reducing violence. For example, if Florida reduced its violence by a mere 25 percent, savings would surpass $9.3 billion. Those are monies that state budget desperately needs. The equation is simple: Reduce violence, save money. But for some reason, Florida's state legislature remains undeterred in its efforts to cut policies that will ultimately prevent violence.

This tragedy must not only refocus America's attention on its pervasive racism but also refocus Florida's attention on preventing violence.

Michael Shank is the US Vice President at the Institute for Economics and Peace. Michael is an Associate at the Global Partnership for the Prevention of Armed Conflict, serves on the board of the National Peace Academy, and is in the PhD Program at George Mason University's School for Conflict Analysis and Resolution.

 

Follow Michael Shank on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Michael_Shank

To ask "Who is George Zimmerman?" -- as many are now asking -- is perhaps the wrong question. Undoubtedly, Zimmerman needs to be brought to justice in the tragic and unjust killing of Trayvon Martin. ...
To ask "Who is George Zimmerman?" -- as many are now asking -- is perhaps the wrong question. Undoubtedly, Zimmerman needs to be brought to justice in the tragic and unjust killing of Trayvon Martin. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 139
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
02:31 AM on 05/07/2012
You can see Zimmermans bloody head here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMQo3YrEniU
Martin was beating Zimmerman badly, appears Zimmerman was gonna die it it didn't stop.
02:17 AM on 05/07/2012
Two points to mention,
The first point: The writer of this article obviously didn't see all the Blood pouring from the back of Zimmermans head prior to the medic's cleaning him up for the TV camera's. Did he take the time to research why Martin was staying with his grandmother instead of back in south Florida going to school like he was suppose to? Martin was a bully and caused this unfortunate incident.
Your second point: Living in Florida, you would quickly understand why there is a problem with crime in this state. Our Federal government has totally failed to protect our coastal boarders. There are so many drug related incidents that the local news media doesn’t even report on most of the criminal activity. Many times in the case of a car accident, one or both of the drivers will leave the scene because they are illegally in this country. I’ve worked here for over 50 years and never seen a INS agent at any of my jobs and there’s illegal’s working all over the place. The shame is that the local police departments can’t do anything with the illegal’s, They arrest them for crimes and then they have to let them out. They just change their names and their back to their usual.
08:58 AM on 04/12/2012
Michael, I'm a good friend of your sister from our college days, and while I appreciate your right to express your opinion, I strongly disagree with the following statement: "The killing of Trayvon Martin demonstrates how insidiously pervasive racism remains in this country and reminds us how truly far we are from achieving racial justice."

The killing of Trayvon demonstrates no such thing, because you simply can't prove someone's intent was "racist" strictly based on him/her being of a different skin color. How do you know for sure that Zimmerman shot Trayvon because Trayvon was black? Where is the definitive proof? What about the fact that Zimmerman's good friend, a black man, stated unequivocally that Zimmerman is *not* a racist? What about the fact that Zimmerman was apparently a mentor of young black men? What about the fact that Zimmerman's neighborhood had apparently already experienced a string of robberies in the previously year or so, all committed by young black males? Is it possible that Zimmerman was using prior evidence in his suspicion of Trayvon, which is, after all, a basic human tendency--we use past experiences to help inform our present observations and perceptions.

My point is, what about the alternative explanations for why Zimmerman shot Trayvon that aren't steeped in race? Why continue to convict Zimmerman in the court of public opinion without all of the facts?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
WeAlwaysKnewIt
Give Snout To It
04:31 PM on 04/13/2012
Time out!

This gibberish sounds borderline-to-sociopathic.
02:23 PM on 03/27/2012
Newsflash this law is not exclusive to Florida there is a Stand Your Ground Law in over 20 states, so stop picking on Florida.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Snell
10:53 PM on 03/26/2012
At first I called for Zimmerman's arrest along with all the others but as facts are comming out I may owe the man an apology...

If the witnesses are now to be believed Mr. Zimmerman acted no differently than I would......EXCEPT.....If I were told not to follow I wouldn't.....BUT....now witnesses say Zimmerman was returning to his truck when Martin jumped him...

OF COURSE Martin's family will defend him....they wouldnt be much of a family if they didn't believe the 17 yr old was good...of course there could also be a darker side to thier protests...millions of dollars in a settlement would surely motivate most of us these days...

The true villans here just may be the anti-gun people and the politicos trying to use this in an election year and claimimg racial motivations.....which I did not believe to begin with....Zmmerman may have been on a power trip from first look but it had nothing to do with race.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
truthosaurus1
08:55 PM on 03/26/2012
to say Zimmerman was overzealous would be an understatement. all you have to do is look how many times he called police in the past 3 years. for whatever reason he decided to take the law into his own hands and confronted Martin as he was walking down the street. the "stand your ground" law does not apply if you are the aggressor. if he had minded his own business, NONE OF THIS WOULD HAVE HAPPENED! if I walk down a street minding my own business and somebody confronts me in a threatening manner I will put a beat-down on their ass just as Martin did (according to a witness). Zimmerman should absolutely be charged and then let the courts decide his fate.
11:32 AM on 03/27/2012
He was captain of the neighborhood watch, that's why he called the police so many times, there had also been a string of robberies in this neighborhood, yes committed by young black men. Maybe stereotypes would go away if the stereotyped people would stop falling into the stereotype.
photo
Weeweed Up
YOU have a drink with Mitch McConnell!
11:23 PM on 03/27/2012
He was only captain of the Capt.. Crunch club. He was in no official capacity at that complex. He had no business carrying a loaded weapon because when he went after this kid, he didn't feel threatened. That is because cowards don't go after people that scare them.
08:44 PM on 03/26/2012
Predators will be heading to Florida in droves. After all, murder is legal in Florida
photo
bubo909
This comment has been removed
07:31 PM on 03/26/2012
You don't really want to look up the crime statistics in Florida. You won't like what you see. Miami, Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa, St. Pete, Tallahassee, Sarasota are all extremely violent places. You are a sitting target if you can't fight back. That's why we have SYG.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
anneeger
Per aspera ad astra
10:29 AM on 03/27/2012
Well, I hope the world takes notice of your comment and stops vacationing in Florida. Who would want to come to a violent place to relax?
04:10 PM on 03/26/2012
I live in Florida and everybody is nice down here , we're all nice, the beaches are nice ,so is the country, it's nice all my neighbors nice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hsspringman
We can cure fundamentalist.
03:56 AM on 03/27/2012
Are you sure that you live in Florida? or maybe you never get out of the Villages.
11:34 AM on 03/27/2012
In Florida, especially South Florida is all about where you are at. Everyone knows what neighborhoods not to go into, if you stay away from these places you are safe. Most attractions here in South Florida are relatively safe.
itolduso
lateral thinker
12:59 PM on 03/26/2012
I'm still stunned that much of the nation is debating whether or not the victim's 'hoodie' is considered 'threatening' while completely ignoring the fact that the only one 'dressed' like a dangerous criminal was the guy wearing a gun.
photo
pciorlandosales
have come to chew bubble gum and kick ash
05:11 PM on 03/26/2012
That's your opinion.
photo
Weeweed Up
YOU have a drink with Mitch McConnell!
11:26 PM on 03/27/2012
So someone coming at you wearing a hoodie and no weapon scares you more than an ugly guy following you while carrying a gun?
11:16 AM on 03/26/2012
You article is fraught with errors in Florida the high crime rate is mostly in the Miami metro area and your call for justice is selective, Zimmerman is Hispanic and he has the right to due process which is a right everybody has in this country. Instead you are calling for justice as determined by you. This fuels a lynch mob mentality which is wrong regardless of the crime.
12:35 PM on 03/26/2012
Miami may have a high crime rate but so do other parts of Florida.
photo
Peter Combs
Amused by the illogical..no, NOT a Republican
01:26 PM on 03/26/2012
FLorida's overall crime rate is nearly average nationally...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Donald Chase
11:09 AM on 03/26/2012
In addition to my former comments, answer this; Why was the press posting pictures of martin fromwhen he was 13 years old? Why were the later pictures photoshopped to make him look younger and softer? Why were his gang sign pictures ignored by you in the left wing propaganda press?
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
01:43 PM on 03/26/2012
Are you taking the position that Martin was a proper target of Zimmerman because he was 17? You must be a conservative Republican.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edgySF
I am as God created me
01:45 PM on 03/26/2012
Skittles vs. a gun

which will win?

not an even fight. the man with the gun had all the power.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Donald Chase
03:02 PM on 03/26/2012
Attacked from behind with Martin pinning him to the ground while he beat on Zimmerman? That is the way one of the eye witnesses describes the scene and Zimmermans wounds and grass stains support that story! Again and again let the law do it's job and let's see where it actually leads.
photo
pciorlandosales
have come to chew bubble gum and kick ash
05:21 PM on 03/26/2012
Strange: yet the man with the gun was the one with a broken nose, gash to the back of his head. The man with the gun was on the grass on his back while skittles boy was beating on him. This was a witness statement (John) given to Sanford Police on the night of the event. Throw a beat down on me if I have a gun and a license to use it in the state of Florida and you will get the same. I prefer to defend myself.
photo
HelloFunnyWorld
In Times Of Sorry Leadership.... Cry or Manage Up?
10:54 AM on 03/26/2012
When we think of Florida..... It's usually: The circus-y World of Disney, gullible kids and their parents..... Old white retirees and assorted rich people, partying, golfing, sunbathing..... Or ...... the 2000 Presidential Election and Hangin' Chads!!

May be these - Stand Your Ground/ALEC - Laws were requested by them/these groups/and their security people and they are the ones who most need to listen to what you have to say/read this article....??
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
daveat1910
10:25 AM on 03/26/2012
I spent 3 months in a large Florida city recently. I was surprised at the poverty and wealth, lack of good jobs, unfriendly, paranoid people, hundreds of gated and walled communities but the main streets were wide and full of strip malls with few customers. I can see why castle laws would fit right in. Not returning.
10:15 AM on 03/26/2012
It is the job of a volunteer watchman to question a person they consider to be out of place or suspicious. If assaulted and in fear of their lives watchmen have been known to use deadly force. But the job of a watchman is a dangerous one, and should only be taken if trained in the martial arts.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
01:46 PM on 03/26/2012
Shouldn't questioning a person be the job of the police after a 911 call? In Massachusetts, we cannot simply stop people on the street for curbside interrogations. That job is for the police.

Zimmerman did not need martial arts training, he just shot a young man, instead.
photo
pciorlandosales
have come to chew bubble gum and kick ash
05:35 PM on 03/26/2012
In and around Orlando these are many gated communities. Much like the Twin Oaks which has it's own HOA. It was through meeting with the HOA and the Sanford Police that a neighborhood watch was started at Twin Oaks. Mr. Zimmerman was not self appointed. He was trained by the Sanford Police department in regarding the nature of the neighborhood watch program. Sanford Police gave instructions and training as well as posted signs in the that subdivision. Further evidence of this is the fact that the Martin family has wasted no time in filing a suit against the HOA. In addition to all of this Mr. Zimmerman was receiving his degree in law enforcement and working full time. Mr. Zimmerman did do the right thing, as instructed to do he called the Sanford Police. He had already exited his vehicle when his call was placed (he states this in his call). He then did as instructed and stopped following the suspicious unknown male. But by this time the unknown male turned and approached Zimmerman. Then Zimmerman was attacked. Instead of attacking Zimmerman all Martin had to do was explain his presence.