iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Sharnoff

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Sharnoff
 

Global March to Jerusalem Is Not All About Palestinian Rights

Posted: 03/27/2012 9:35 pm

As I have mentioned in previous articles, in the absence of a political settlement, Palestinians will undertake unilateral measures to pressure Israel for concessions and recognition. On March 30, the Global March to Jerusalem (GMJ), a nongovernmental organization comprised primarily of Palestinian, Arab and Muslim supporters but also from notable American personalities including Dr. Cornel West and Rev. Jeremiah Wright, will commemorate Land Day - a day in which six Israeli Arabs were killed thirty-six years ago for protesting what they viewed as discriminatory measures by the government. Peaceful marches are scheduled to occur along Israel's borders in Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria, throughout the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and before Israeli embassies worldwide.

The GMJ aims to eliminate "the Apartheid, ethnic cleansing and Judaisation policies affecting the people, land and sanctity of Jerusalem" and insists that that its solidarity mission will be conducted nonviolently. The GMJ does not advocate a military solution to achieve their goals like Hamas and Hezbollah; however their militant agenda may certainly be implied.

The organization's logo shows a map of Palestine in place of Israel. They view Israel as an illegitimate, neo-colonial and racist entity which must be liberated. The GMJ rejects a two-state solution and peaceful coexistence with the Jewish state. Instead, it insists on "renewing the struggle to liberate Palestine," a common euphemism for the destruction of Israel.

It is unclear how many activists will participate. If social media is any indicator, there are dozens of Facebook pages supporting the protests, with over 9,200 "likes" on the GMJ fan page. However, many supporters could be "armchair activists" primarily in Europe and North America. The actual number of participants may be significantly lower. We shall soon see.

Nonetheless, protests in support of the GMJ have already occurred throughout the Arab world. On March 25, David Saranga, an Israeli diplomat visiting Morocco, was evacuated after 100,000 demonstrators protested his presence by hoisting Palestinian flags and shouting "the people want to free al-Aqsa" and "a million martyrs are going to Jerusalem." Saranga also witnessed swastika symbols and the burning of Israeli flags.

Last weekend, dozens of activists from the GMJ rallied before the Israeli Embassy in Turkey. One protestor allegedly asserted, "Millions of people will gather at the borders of Palestine and will be willing to die for the cause and for Jerusalem." Other members chanted "death to Israel" and "death to America."

Jordanian officials confirmed on March 25 that they will allow protestors to march in the Jordan Valley as long as protestors do not infiltrate the West Bank. For its part, Israel is taking these actions seriously and will deploy riot control soldiers, although some intelligence officers believe West Bank Palestinians will not actively participate because they do not wish to jeopardize their relative economic and security prosperity.

If Palestinian rights were truly the GMJ's raison d'etre, it would organize rallies and protests against Palestinian discrimination in Lebanon where 300,000 Palestinian refugees live in overcrowded camps and dire social and economic conditions. They are also legally barred from owning property and from working in certain areas.

During the last decade, Jordanian authorities arbitrarily rescinded more than 2,700 Palestinians of their Jordanian citizenship, depriving them of basic access to health care and education. In Syria, more than 5,000 Palestinians have been displaced from their camps in Latakia after government forces bombarded the city.

While some GMJ activists may genuinely support Palestinian rights, there is a large component which advocates Israel's liquidation. Moreover, the movement should be discredited for its own hypocrisy of proclaiming to champion Palestinian rights and singling out Israel, while ignoring the abuses taking place on a daily basis in the Arab world.

 

Follow Michael Sharnoff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MichaelSharnoff

 
 
  • Comments
  • 125
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:01 AM on 03/30/2012
A Sheckel that was minted in 66AD in Jerusalem sold for over a million dollars & is one of many historic items that shows Jews were there way before Islam or Christ & is not far from what was called Samaria & JUDEA which is now called the West Bank in which the arabs claim as theirs . All were Jewish, Christ was a Jew & Ishmael was the son of Abraham and the forefather of Muhammad. Other then idols & such Judaism was the first religion that believed in God. I don't see this March as being peaceful, hopefully I am wrong.
For decades The only True friend in the middle east the United States had was Israel, The only true friend Israel had was The United States & Obama is not a friend & I am pretty sure Netanyahu feels that as well.
Michelle Obama had said we need to change our traditions & history & it seems to be here & if this administration & Islam gets it's way our planet will be living a lie, propaganda.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
07:12 AM on 03/30/2012
I was following your thesis until you brought Obama into it, which nullifed your entire argument. If Republicans have been such dandy friends of Israel, why wasn't the US embassy moved to Jerusalem under the administration of one of those presidents?

Besides, Jews aren't one issue voters; we always vote Democrat and always will (I'm proud to say).
10:52 AM on 03/30/2012
Maybe you mean that Jews for Jesus like yourself will always vote democrat. I, on the other hand, am proud to be a Jew and not a Christian
07:34 PM on 03/28/2012
Prime Minister of P.A. Salaam Fayyad should do the right thing and publicly condemn and distance the P.A. from these antiZionist organizations which cloak themselves under the progressive veneer of Palestinian human right's activists, in a similar way that he condemned the murderer of the Toulouse incident.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gui Montag
Former Palestinian Supporter
03:16 PM on 03/28/2012
An imagine from the global march's facebook page:

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-WB6EfuNDZWQ/T3LsC0zPA4I/AAAAAAAAG_M/atsnMJ1aBrQ/s640/gaza+antisem.jpg

Nothing anti-Semitic about that right?
07:23 PM on 03/28/2012
When i read at the very beginning of the article that Rev.Jeremiah Wright was part of this 'non violent' campaign to delegitimize Israel's existence, i knew all credibility of this org'n was lost.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
08:00 PM on 03/28/2012
No there is nothing anti-semitic about the cartoon. It is telling the truth.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gui Montag
Former Palestinian Supporter
10:14 PM on 03/28/2012
Palestinians are Christ? *That's* the truth?
02:30 PM on 03/28/2012
Time to march on Mecca!
06:22 PM on 03/29/2012
why' what have you lost there?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gibranII
seeking peace through equality
01:22 PM on 03/28/2012
While Palestinians have suffered greatly in Lebanon (as a result of the inability to return to their homes and as political pawns in the game that is this conflict) to blame Arabs only is a) poor understanding of the conflict and b) bias in the authors research (which should be acknowledged). We have to get to the point where we respect each narrative. I suggest you read Rabbi Michael Lerners solution.. or if you are so concerned about the plight of teh Palestinians in Arba refugee camps.. help give the a ROAD back home to Israel... let them go home.. that would go a long way to solve this wouldnt it? (wink wink)
07:38 PM on 03/28/2012
Nearly all those descendants in Arab land, who are forced to remain there because of Arab Nations refusal to allow them to resettle or become naturalized in those Arab States, never set foot in Israel. And Israel has allowed many to join their family's under their reunification program. Israel will not commit suicide and let in millions of people who seek it's destruction.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gibranII
seeking peace through equality
11:22 AM on 03/29/2012
simple hav ethos ewho lived in the west bank return to the west bank... have those who lived in the shining democracy become full citizens of Israel and have the same benefits to build and live in the areas that they were forced to give up (for whatever reaosn)... follow th eoriginal UN plan to have them return.. Let them pledge support to Israel as it exists and become a minority in their old country... have them hold office vote .. that take care of that.. since you think the Arabs are such monsters.. why if you have the power to rescue these poor suffering people that lived in Palestine (before it was unsucessfully divided) shouldnt you help them...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Relpo Miraculous
Psychobiological Anthropology
12:57 PM on 03/28/2012
The Arabs have cynically and deliberately scheduled this "march" on Israel's borders to coincide with Passover. The IDF has just cancelled all Passover leave for soldiers.
02:58 PM on 03/28/2012
Of course... but you have to admit, getting Israel to implement discriminatory policies 36 years ago just so their annaversary would coincide with Passover in 2012 shows quite a bit of moxie.
Rosin the Bow
Palestine doesn't want peace. Meshaal said so
04:10 PM on 03/28/2012
How dare Israel discriminate between its own people and the people trying to massacre them.
03:27 PM on 03/28/2012
Thx for pointing this out. I feel bad for the soldiers and their families. You're more than a little right wing for my taste, but still mishpacha.

F&F
photo
Anybodyseenthepopos
אני כלום בלעדיהם
04:14 PM on 03/29/2012
It's a struggle not to go completely right wing. And the posts in this blog are rarely helpful.
12:31 PM on 03/28/2012
It was one form of irony to read the article, yet a whole another to read the comments. Mr. Sharnoff - the fact that Palestinians are suffering in many Arab countries (not limited to your list) does not in any way exonerate Israel, as you indirectly argue. Having the Israeli Apartheid as the target does not mean the Arab states are innocent, it just means Israel is 2-heads deep guilty, proven and documented in volumes, and you are complicit in their crimes by advocating such ideas.

As for the commentators, before speaking about the "partition plan" and "Israel made Palestinian Refugees its citizens" and much more of this completely baseless argumentation, please learn history. Israel did not make "refugees" citizens, it allowed "natives" to stay in their land after expelling the bigger half of the population. The partition plan ends actually with an "s", so which one are you talking about? and which one actually went into final vote in 1947?..

Either way, everyone has the right for an opinion, and in mine, within a decade if not less Palestinians will be referred to as the "natives" and the Israelis as the "colonizers" within the one state that will exist for the two nations, and history books will be speaking of the 7 decades of zionist state-led terrorism and apartheid... mark my words.
photo
MelissaGoldman
One moment in time--RIP Whitney
12:59 PM on 03/28/2012
does your crystal ball also predict lotto numbers?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HistoryBuffBU
05:48 PM on 03/28/2012
55% of Israeli Jews are from arab countries, their citizenship and property confiscated by Arab government, this was a population exchange, that's it and that was really common at the time
08:26 PM on 03/28/2012
A year earlier there was a much bigger- and bloodier- population exchange between India and Pakistan, which the world conveniently forgets...because it didn't involve Jews, and because Moslems forced that partition.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cynthia Rays
peace in the valley seeker
11:17 AM on 03/28/2012
Israel has not offered the 3/4 of a million Palestinians reparations for taking their land in 1948. The map shown was the land of Palestine. The marchers are asking for human rights and opportunity for Palestinians.
As for Israeli leaders being heckled all over the world, that will continue until there is justice for Palestinians. It would be prudent for Israel to stop building more settlements and end the occupation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoOne18
What're YOU lookin' at?
02:05 AM on 03/29/2012
This is a lie. For DECADES Israel had a special government office for *just that*. There are only 2 reasons people did not get an exorbitant amount of money for whatever property they *LEFT BEHIND* (that's right - almost 70 percent of those who left did so without ever even seeing a Jew!): either they didn't have any proof that they actually owned anything, or they refused to take the money because they wanted to be let back in. Israel actually did let back in around 1/7th of the people who left, because they had family in Israel. Otherwise, she is under no obligation to let them back in - especially when they REFUSE to *acknowledge* her!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gibranII
seeking peace through equality
10:50 AM on 03/29/2012
wrong... 75oooo people were forced out by many different reasons... some out of fear, some under the understanding that the war would effect them, some because thei rleaders were telling them to get out o fthe way. Many because of the pyschological unit and the underground saying that if tehy don t leave there would be another Deir yassin... The UN in th elate 1940's and early 50's tried to get the people back under international laws.. and it was blocked.. but nice hasbra.. many people always say it was only Palestine fault not taking into account the realities on both sides,.
06:25 PM on 03/29/2012
and Israel will offer the 48 palis nothing... there was a war the palis could stay out of it. they chose to take a part and they lost.
that simple.
Israel is in a very good palce our days... much better then 60 years ago.

and the building of the land is gonna continue...at the end the Palis will have a state with large nice jewish minority...
photo
notmisaacm
Speaking truth to power
10:33 AM on 03/28/2012
GMJ is just another attempt to destroy Israel to make up for Arab failures on the battle field. This is why there is no chance for peace in the middle east; the Arabs still haven't reconciled themselves to the existence of Israel, in any borders.

They show this daily by their refusal to allow the descendants of the refugees from the failed Arab wars of 1948 and 67 to attain citizenship. Can you imagine if the US had locked up Cuban refugees in camps for 50+ years until we "liberated" Cuba? Can you imagine if the Arab refugees who fled to the US in 1948 had been denied US citizenship until the conflict was settled? Of course not.

Of tens of millions of refugees caused by the hundreds of conflicts around the globe these past several decades, only the Arabs lock up people for 6 decades. They continue to punish the Palestinians because the Palestinians represent the shame of the Arab nation. They are a reminder that 300+ million Arabs, to their humiliation, couldn't kill a couple of million Jews. And until they can find a way to regain their manhood, they will continue to hate Israel, and punish the Palestinians.
12:49 PM on 03/28/2012
I agree with notmisaacm period.
01:01 PM on 03/28/2012
Grow up - how can a march destroy anything.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gui Montag
Former Palestinian Supporter
01:18 PM on 03/28/2012
He said attempt to.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
10:24 AM on 03/28/2012
I assume that Michael is also supporting China in its stance that the blame for the death of Jampa Yeshi should be laid at the door of the Dali Lama, and that anyone who wants to discuss human rights needs to first make it clear that they must vigourously condemn India for not granting the refugees from the parts of Tibet now known as China Indian citizenship, and every other human rights issue throughout the globe before they can legitimately talk about any alleged human rights issue involving China.
Rosin the Bow
Palestine doesn't want peace. Meshaal said so
10:48 AM on 03/28/2012
"I assume"

One of your many mistakes.
01:02 PM on 03/28/2012
You wish.
RP leves you standing Rosin.
10:50 AM on 03/28/2012
The blame for creating the refugees lies initially with the Palestinians and Arabs for rejecting Partition and starting a war to destroy Israel, and secondarily with Israel for evicting about 300,000 villagers in the Galillee to establish necessary defense lines.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
11:53 AM on 03/28/2012
And the blame for the problems in South Africa lay initially with the Blacks, according to the history that the Africaaners and their supporters insisted was the whole story.
12:30 PM on 03/28/2012
Myopinion2,

You continue to make it sound like that the Palestinians had no reason to "reject partition," and that such rejection somehow implicitly justifies their continued dispossession. Please recognize that repeating this Zionist talking-point does nothing to further peace.

While there certainly was/is an argument to be made for a Jewish safe haven following the horrors of the Holocaust, why was/is the onus of this placed exclusivel­y on the Palestinia­ns, and only on their land, to the exclusion of the very Europeans responsibl­e for the persecutio­n in the first place?

Or, the other European countries’ abominably restrictiv­e immigratio­n policies barring the entry of fleeing Jewish refugees into their own countries (including sadly the US as well)?

Or, the Zionists who were fanning the flames of fear in Palestine by openly advocating the forcible creation of a Jewish State?

The answer is simple. Of the all the entities involved in this catch-22, the Palestinia­ns were the weakest and easiest upon which to impose, despite having the least to do with the European pogroms against Jews in the first place.

This is the context in which Palestinia­ns find being awarded half of their own land in 1948, by the very Europeans responsibl­e for the pogroms no less, not just hypocritic­al but offensive.

Again, this is not to say there should not be an Israel, but to properly frame the issue. We will not acheive peace by repeatedly ignoring or belittling the legitimate grievances of the dispossess­ed.
09:47 AM on 03/28/2012
If you go to their website, http://gm2j.com/main/blog/2012/03/27/does-the-global-march-to-jerusalem-delegitimize-israel-not-at-all/ claim to not be challenging the right to Israel to exist, but rather are working to defend the human rights of people in Jerusalem and Palestine.

You seem to be reading a lot into a logo! I've heard plenty of Israeli's refer to Judea and Samaria, rather than the West Bank, and create plenty of maps not recognizing the status of Palestine. It's easy to attack these "messages" without knowing more.

What about the underlying issues here, of the loss of land of these people? That is the substance here, rather than the rhetoric. The reality of life for Palestinians, in Israel Jerusalem and the West Bank, no one seems to be grappling with those questions.
09:54 AM on 03/28/2012
x2
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gui Montag
Former Palestinian Supporter
10:11 AM on 03/28/2012
Here's another good website to go to find the truth, not propaganda:

http://gm2j.co/
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
07:03 AM on 03/30/2012
Thanks for that link as well.
08:11 AM on 03/28/2012
Regarding Morocco, it always amazes me that people thousands of miles away from a conflict can call for the death and destruction of people they have never met. It appears that the human being is capable of dehumanization at a distance.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
07:06 AM on 03/30/2012
There were many Jews living in Morrocco for many centuries, until life was made so unpleasant for them, as well as the rest of the Jews living in North Africa, that most of them fled to Israel and France.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:07 AM on 03/28/2012
The cosmic irony of the Middle Eastern Arab-Jewish conflict is this.
the ONLY country that adopted their Palestinian Arab refugees and made them fully fledged citizens is-- Israel!!!
The Arab countries, while paying lip service to Palestinian Arabs, keeps millions of them languishing in camps and denying them citizenship and often even basic human rights.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
09:54 AM on 03/28/2012
The only irony in your post is that you are completely oblivious to the irony of condemning others for treating the refugees from the parts of Palestine now called Israel as refugees from Israel, while proclaiming that Israel is the one place that refugees from the Palestine were granted citizenship. If Israel were indeed to allow the refugees to return to their homes, the whole issue would have been resolved, but instead it takes the position that these refugees who's home IS ISRAEL are from someplace else.
Rosin the Bow
Palestine doesn't want peace. Meshaal said so
10:12 AM on 03/28/2012
"If Israel were indeed to allow the refugees to return to their homes, the whole issue would have been resolved, "

Yes, resolved with Israel's destruction. You must have been like those people who thought that letting Germany annexed Czechoslovakia would "resolve the issue."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gibranII
seeking peace through equality
01:08 PM on 03/28/2012
Then Take them back and problem resolved.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:55 PM on 03/28/2012
What you mean "back?!"

These people are Lebanese, Syrians, Egyptians, Jordanians, Americans. They belong in the countries they were born and raised in.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoOne18
What're YOU lookin' at?
02:14 AM on 03/29/2012
Very wrong: they don;t want to live in Israel, they want to live in *Palestine". They refuse to recognize Israel.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:03 AM on 03/28/2012
Muslim Arabs, in their attachment to their former imperialist glories, are incapable of accepting self-determination effort by any non-Muslim group. This is the reality.
Severe oppression of Muslims by other Muslims doesn't interest them much.
Various flotilla moored within sight of dilapidated Palestinian camps in Lebanon, the inhabitants of which daily suffer oppression and denial of basic human rights.
Not a SINGLE reporter visited these camps!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:58 PM on 03/28/2012
Notice how c-a-r-e-f-u-l-l-y the usually vociferous and allegedly pro-Palestinian camp ( pun intended) are avoiding this subject.
Rosin the Bow
Palestine doesn't want peace. Meshaal said so
07:59 AM on 03/28/2012
Great essay. Thank you for writing it.