More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Shaw

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Shaw
 

Reading the Pictures: Media's Weiner Pictures: Who's Getting Dirty Now?

Posted: 06/08/11 10:41 AM ET

Weiner elevator 1

Weiner elevator 2

Somehow, adults are supposed to be scandalized by normal, unoffensive behavior that has no bearing on a lawmaker's ability to do his job. Which is to say that from where I sit, this press frenzy looks less like a drive for accountability and more like an exercise in shaming.  (from: Media Takes Time Out of Its Day to Shame Anthony Weiner -- Jamelle Bouie/Tapped)
You left Ensign alone. You left Vitter alone. Hell, you barely even reported it when Ensign resigned. But for weeks you've been hounding a comparative nobody. Why?  (from: "Hey, Media" Boo Man)

One one level, I actually admire the pair of photos of Weiner shot the day before his public confession about his not-so-secret sexting life. To the extent Weiner was lying about his behavior, visual media was spot-on here in using the backdrop of a Congressional elevator to help articulate how Weiner -- like a perp caught red handed when the lights came on -- was, yes, a man absolutely cornered.

Still, what's bothers me is how much the story, and, particularly, the pictures seem to be serving the media's own interests more than the public's or even the other principals involved. It seems, in fact, there is even something of a parallel process in play in which the visual media -- Weiner having come clean with good prospects for riding this out -- gets to take over the fetishizing of the Congressman, it's own prurient interests driving their own creating and posting of tawdry pictures of him.

Wiener statement 3

One all-too-easy way to do that is simply to catch an angle with a lot of dark shadows and some harsh light (when it wasn't all that dark). This particular photo taken at Weiner's press conference draws on those elements (just like the elevator shots did) to conjure the vibe you'd get of the Congressman slinking around the cocktail lounge of some podunk hotel.

Wiener statement 4

Then of course, "the ring shot" (probably the most prominent one since the '08 Republican convention) represents another way to administer a flogging, allowing the media to directly interject itself into Weiner's domestic life, which would include his bedroom, and, yes, dole out the shame (reinforced in the corresponding caption 3 below).

Weiner post announcement 5  NYT

Finally, although I didn't hear that Weiner was facing any charges, I'm also taken by this day-after-the-confession "we're going to follow you around the neighborhood" shot in the NYT in which the press not only frames Weiner as someone officials would call "a person of interest," but, like a guy out on bail, we see the visual media starting to own not just the title of paparazzi, but also the "lurker" role.

(photo 1 & 2: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images caption: Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-NY) steps onto an elevator after leaving his office in the Rayburn House Office Building on Capitol Hill June 2, 2011 in Washington, DC. Weiner declined to comment further this morning on the recent incident involving his Twitter account and a photograph that was sent from that account..photo 3: Andrew Burton/Getty Image. caption: Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-NY) admits to sending a lewd Twitter photo of himself to a woman and then lying about it during a press conference at the Sheraton Hotel on 7th Avenue on June 6, 2011 in New York City. Weiner said he had not met any of the women in person but had numerous sexual relationships online while married.. photo 4: Andrew Burton/Getty Images caption: The wedding ring of Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-NY) is seen as he admits to sending a lewd Twitter photo of himself to a woman and then lying about it during a press conference at the Sheraton Hotel on 7th Avenue on June 6, 2011 in New York City. Weiner said he had not met any of the women in person but had numerous sexual relationships online while married. photo 5: Michael Kirby Smith for The New York Times caption: Representative Anthony D. Weiner, a Democrat, in Queens, on Tuesday. He has been apologizing for salacious online behavior.)

 

Follow Michael Shaw on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bagnewsnotes

 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Zorabedian
I'm a writer living in Mass.
09:32 AM on 06/09/2011
Nice shots.
06:25 PM on 06/08/2011
"the visual media ... it's own prurient interests driving their own creating and posting of tawdry pictures of him."

First, the word is "its," not "it's".

Second, you used "media" as both singular (its) and plural (their) in the same sentence. You need to make up your mind.

Third, your entire premise is weak. Since when are we supposed to be surprised that the media are voyeuristic, opportunistic paparazzi?
06:07 PM on 06/08/2011
I think that his name is a bit unfortunate which just made fodder for endless headline puns.
08:14 PM on 06/08/2011
I am cocksure of this!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ICarr
I hope Orwell is getting residuals
03:37 PM on 06/08/2011
With the advent of 24-hour news cycles, the MSM has gotten lazy. There is very little journalism that happens today - it's mostly "soundbite" reporting. So this scandal is right up their alley - sensational and lurid without the need to do any investigating. A sex scandal without any sex - who'd a thunk it.

How many soldiers were killed this week in Iraq and Afghanistan? Exactly.
08:21 PM on 06/08/2011
And they are becoming rapidly irrelevant. For the consumers. The rather interesting aspect
is that they are somewhat suicidal when looking at the market and financial data.
The newspapers for instance never learn, just keep declining, going down.
http://newspaperdeathwatch.com/
photo
Ponderus
Enriched with lanolin.
02:13 PM on 06/08/2011
The media is getting off on private pictures and by publishing them is making money off porn.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Soylent Green is coming
01:32 PM on 06/08/2011
Like Rachel Maddow said yesterday something like : It is only okay if republicans do it. The media coverage has really shown their right wing bias on this issue. Nothing fair and balanced on the coverage. I don't condone what Weiner has done but ALL have to be held accountable not just some and not based on party affiliation.
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
03:51 PM on 06/08/2011
i think a lot of the left has shown their right wing bias on this issue as well .

i am also amazed at all the toilet humor -- parents don't want kids to have facebook accounts but you can get plenty of raunch out of sensationalist news headlines.

mostly i think we just learned what we already knew -- our country is messed up.
apoyo
Micro-bio? Sounds serious.
06:56 PM on 06/08/2011
Too true!
07:38 PM on 06/08/2011
That is ridiculous, of course. For every Dem who lost his position over a sex scandal, I can list an Rep who also did. For every Rep who was permitted to keep his position, I can list a Dem who also did. As always, it's about power - the expendable ones are thrown under the bus, and the nonexpendable ones are allowed to stay in.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Diagoras
01:32 AM on 06/10/2011
Not all sex scandals are the same. For one, this one doesn't have any actual sex in it! Vitter broke the law by hiring prostitutes and kept his job. Nobody but Mrs. Weiner should care about this so-called "sex" scandal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjtaylor22
01:25 PM on 06/11/2011
nah it is not that balanced not at all. republicans dont lose their positions look at ensign....he resigned years after his scandal broke......
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bettany23
12:40 PM on 06/08/2011
The Anthony Weiner incident have made it very clear that the media is really one of the biggest obstacle to solving the major problems facing Americans, amidst growing high unemployment and looming double dip recession their focus is non-stop coverage of politcal scandals. In one of worst modern day depression the republican majority have been able to stand back and watch with their hands folded, while Americans suffer from the economic mess they left behind. Republicans have benefited from it, criticize it and promote bills and policies that would heighten the effects of the recession. The media reports daily on the severe hardship many of us are going threw. Not one media outlet have really looked into and report about the obstruction coming from the eye of the beast (Republicans ) given them autonomy to further damage us and they are going about it methodically. The republicans to date have not produced not one bill addressing what is happening to the people who elected them, not one. Housing, unemployment, and jobs it's flabbergasting, unbelievable that the republicans can get away with sitting on the fence while promoting counter-productive solutions, and the media focus and talk non-stop about scandals.
10:35 AM on 06/08/2011
He sowed the wind. Now let him reap it.
04:48 PM on 06/08/2011
Did you mean "Inherit" or "Reap"? Both were great movies.
06:35 PM on 06/08/2011
That sequence of verses (in the book of Hosea, chapter 8) are indeed appropriate. They are about people who "have rejected what is good." They say that those people "have sown the wind, and will reap the whirlwind." Beautiful prose, and accurate reality.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anabelle Whitepaws
Bin Laden's Dead; General Motors is Alive!
10:34 AM on 06/08/2011
You'd think the media were the opposing party the way we're being bombarded by this...
*whispering to Weiner*
Just stay out of the spotlight a little longer and this will all blow over...
08:24 PM on 06/08/2011
next to impossible. he craves attention.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anabelle Whitepaws
Bin Laden's Dead; General Motors is Alive!
07:52 AM on 06/09/2011
most, if not all, in the public eye (politicians, movie stars, musicians, etc.) crave attention. some of 'em feel any attention is good attention...
must be something in the psychie.
10:32 AM on 06/08/2011
The author wrote: What's bothersome about the Anthony Weiner story is that the pictures seem to be serving the media's own interests more than the public's.
________________________________________________________________________________

I would have thought a media critic would have understood the nature of for-profit media before now.
06:40 PM on 06/08/2011
True that!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
asnevitt
09:51 AM on 06/08/2011
I've yet to see why we're supposed to care about Weiner's personal exchanges. Nothing illegal. Nothing which has anything to do with his job. Yawn. Can we move on now? People don't have jobs in the US. Health insurance companies are insuring your health, they're insuring their bottom lines. People are dying and being tortured simply for criticizing their governments, all over the Arab world. Can we focus on something which is actually, you know, meaningful?