I didn't love the way the race for governor in my state (New York) went this past November. The GOP didn't put up a fight, and Andrew Cuomo, the son of former Governor Mario Cuomo, sailed into office without needing to trouble himself over actually mounting a campaign.
It was hard for me to get excited about Cuomo in November of last year, but all of that changed when I read the New York Daily News today.
I like how he went to church on the Roman Catholic Feast of the Epiphany.
Let me be clear: I like how he went to church, not that he went.
For people who celebrate Christmas in a non-secular way, the Feast of the Epiphany, which Roman Catholics celebrated on January 2nd this year, can function as a slightly more spiritually authentic Christmas. Called "Little Christmas" in some cultures, the Feast of the Epiphany comes after presents have been opened, after Christmas music on the radio has stopped, after discarded pine trees have begun to be kicked to the curb and (though not so this year) after the children have gone back to school. The Feast of the Epiphany lacks the fanfare of Christmas Day, and captures some of the easily lost (or trampled) solemnity of the last days of Advent and Christmas Day.
I often think of the liturgy of the Feast of the Epiphany as a poet's liturgy. The word "epiphany" has artistic connotations and literary applications, and is thought to suggest a great imaginative leap in the aftermath of which nothing in the mind or soul remains the same. In every case, epiphany suggests the occurrence of a philosophical or spiritual shakeup.
The Feast of the Epiphany recalls to Christian minds an odyssey, a mysterious light, a flying in the face of reason. The Feast of the Epiphany is about reversals, shifts and dreams. Kings voyage on foot to laud the infant son of a refugee.
During the years I wrestled with my metaphysical selves as I declined to practice any religion, I used to listen to former Governor Mario Cuomo on the radio early on Sunday mornings. His topics were several. He'd talk about movies, government, the Constitution, his family and his dog. Sometimes Governor (Mario) Cuomo would depart from keeping things light as he elected to discuss, in brief, his opposition to the death penalty and support for legal and safe abortion. These words, always spoken in (and out from) the context of his Catholicism, had a great influence on my own way of thinking about Roman Catholicism. I have always shared Mario Cuomo's view that capital punishment is under all and any circumstances a grave sin, and have always sensed that this ostensibly political conviction came from a mysterious and possibly religious part of my being.
Though I was a rather fervent agnostic who dipped in and out of religious observance while Governor Cuomo the elder was in office, I paid rather close attention to the way Mario Cuomo comported himself as a Catholic. So impressed was I by his actions and words as a Catholic, that I began to revise how I looked at Catholicism.
In other words, I began to notice that the first Governor Cuomo as a walking advertisement for being what I've since come to think of as a "devout Roman Catholic under protest."
And now, I am glad to note that my new governor appears to have learned a thing or two about worshipping his (so-called) "Heavenly Father" from his earthly one.
Yesterday, a divorced Governor Cuomo, who makes no secret of the fact that he lives with a woman who is not his wife, approached the altar of "the Lord" to receive the sacrament of the Eucharist in a Roman Catholic Church and was not turned away.
It is probably safe to assume that Cuomo's three daughters have been taught, at home and in the course of their catechesis, that both devotion and discernment are vital to informed and conscientious Catholic faith formation. This family knows their church leadership is flawed, weakened by scandal, propped up by corruption and tyranny. They know their church was built, in part, by hegemony and brutality. It is entirely possible that all three of Cuomo's daughters and the woman who will sleep beside Cuomo in the governor's mansion may find the papacy's sexist teachings and misogynist policies un-Christian and unjust. (The teenaged Cuomos are, after all, daughters of Kerry Kennedy who has spoken publicly about her Roman Catholic ambivalence in the anthology she edited, Being Catholic Now, a fine collection of first-person perspectives on being Catholic.) Despite whatever dissent may exist in the governor's family, love for the Church, it would seem, persists.
I love that my new governor stepped up to the altar of the Lord with confidence and received the Sacrament of the Eucharist with his beloved and three daughters in tow.
Thus, he received what we Catholics call grace.
And while he was at it, the governor dispensed a bit of grace. He announced that he will not be told by men how to be Catholic.
He announced his intention to trust God -- and not a cabal of men in miters and lace -- to decide whether he was worthy to receive Holy Communion.
Whether he planned it that way, Andrew Cuomo sent a Feast of the Epiphany message about lockstep Catholicism, and I, for one, am delighted to see my fellow Catholic and new governor come out of the gate fighting this fight.
Whether it was his intention to do so, Cuomo made a statement about being "Roman Catholic under protest." For those who, like me, have come to believe there is no other morally responsible way to be Roman Catholic, this is a gift.
A gift, though bestowed by a mere governor, befitting a "newborn king."
Follow Michele Somerville on Twitter: www.twitter.com/NYpoet
Jim Lichtman: 2010: A Shellacking in Poor Judgment and Bad Behavior
Mario Cuomo --"Religious Belief and Public Morality (A Catholic ...
Pew Forum: Religious Belief and Public Morality: A Catholic ...
Andrew Cuomo, Sandra Lee: In sign of times, no one really cares ...
Meet Sandra Lee, The Soon-To-Be First Girlfriend Of NY « CBS New ...
Thus, he received what we Catholics call grace.
And while he was at it, the governor dispensed a bit of grace. He announced that he will not be told by men how to be Catholic.
He announced his intention to trust God -- and not a cabal of men in miters and lace -- to decide whether he was worthy to receive Holy Communion. "
What nonsense coming from one who is supposed Catholic. The entire piece is rubbish and would require an extensive write to refute everything that is that rubbish. If the governor is living [sleeping] with a women not his wife and receives the Holy Eucharist he has not received "grace" but rather has put his soul in mortal danger.
What the writer and others who think her her would have the Catholic Church do is to bow to the morals the world has adopted rather than remain with their faith established by Christ. Yes, yes, everybody should adopt the new "morals" of the times. In this regard I quote an infinitely better writer and philosopher who said: "What a man can believe depends upon his philosophy, not upon the clock or the century." Good advice,
Thus, he received what we Catholics call grace."
Your statement is sadly mistaken. St. Paul, in his First Letter to the Corinthians, spoke clearly about how we are to receive the Eucharist:
"Therefore whoever eats this bread or drinks this cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord. But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy manner eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord’s body. - 1 Corinthians 10:27-32
Receiving the Eucharist while in a state of sin brings judgment on oneself - not grace. Governor Cuomo, who is living with a woman not his wife, has thus brought judgment down upon himself.
This is not being "told by men how to be Catholic". These are the words of the Apostle Paul from the New Testament - the inspired word of God and foundation of our faith.
Governor Cuomo has not "trusted God", but rather publicly flaunted God's Word. He can choose to abide by that Word or reject it - but one cannot claim his is acting righteously when the very words of the New Testament say otherwise.
The words in 1 Corinthians like all of the words in the Bible are meant to be interpreted, which in no way means they are not holy.
I don't doubt that the governor does examine his conscience before he receives Communion.
The words of Paul are words recorded by men.
It is the truth nestled in the words not their strict construction wherein the revelation is found.
Catholics are called to discern, not to blind obedience.
Thanks for writing.
MMS
This article by Mary Beth Kremski might help you to understand better the nature of the Church: http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0502fea1.asp. Please let me know what you think.
Thanks for writing. I went to (Feast of the Epiphany) mass on Sunday, but I always celebrate the Epiphany on the 12th day of Christmas (Tres Reyes!) too!
MMS