It is rare that anything related to the Middle East makes me laugh at loud. But the new film, Just Like Us starring and directed by the Egyptian-American comedian and actor Ahmed Ahmed, had me laughing until it hurt.
The film, a comic documentary, is about a bunch of stand-up comics who took their act to Saudi Arabia, Dubai, Egypt and Lebanon essentially to determine if Arabs have a sense of humor.
Obviously, they do. All people do. But the kind of comedy we know as stand-up is unknown there. In Saudi Arabia, in particular, the state actually has "religious police"on the street. In Ahmed's words, "public entertainment of any kind is strictly forbidden and the consequences of being caught can be severe"
At the same time, 25% of the 24 million Saudis are under 25, and, as Cyndi Lauper would put it, "Saudis just wanna have fun."
In fact, my favorite part of this delightful film took place in Riyadh. The fact is that I have seen very little film footage of Saudi Arabia so, I have to admit, seeing a Saudi city with actual young Saudis actually driving around in motorcycles and flirting discreetly with potential hookups was like seeing Beijing in 1972 when President Nixon visited China, kind of like the moon..
Actually, it didn't seem so much like the moon as like any place where young people try to have a good time, although in this rigidly religious and conservative place, having a good time takes ingenuity. So did putting on a comedy show there.
One of the recurring themes of the film is how hard it is for American comedians to do stand-up without using the "f-bomb" or referring to sex. But that is how it has to be done in the more conservative Muslim countries. As a Jew, I could not help but compare it to putting on a comedy show for Hassidim. I mean, there are no limits in Manhattan or Tel Aviv, but Borough Park in Brooklyn would be a challenge!
Of course, it's harder to do good comedy without obscenity which can often produce laughs even when there really is no humor. But the ten comedians - including the sweet-natured and hilarious, Ahmed Ahmed himself - are really good. So they can skirt around the edges of the more "delicate" subjects and make them even more funny than if they addressed them head-on.
As I said, Saudi Arabia was a particular challenge (it is not clear how the kids - many, in traditional garb) even found the event).
But find it they did.
The comics rose to the occasion and more. There was even a quite hilarious Saudi performer - a young woman - who intends to pursue a career doing stand-up in her homeland. Her parents' reaction is that she is nuts. 'What does it mean? This stand-up''' "Funny is good. But you can't make a living on funny."
But the woman is a Saudi soul possessed. Innately funny, she is also one of those creatures who become truly alive on a stage.
Muich of the comedy is reminiscent of Jewish comedy. The comedians mock their faith but from within, not with the incomprehensibility of the bemused outsider. They shout out to acclaim the achievements of their fellow Arabs (in this case, Egyptian). "We build the pyraminds. Yeah!." A rumble in the crowd, "Okay, the Jews may have built them but we designed them -- and then they built them."
There are even jokes about the perception of Arab males under age 30 as terrorists, and the mayhem that sometimes ensues over various cases of mistaken identity. (Ahmed Ahmed is kind of a bad name if you want to escape being pulled to the side at the airport gate. I mean, the last famous double-named Arab was Sirhan Sirhan).
But I'd have to say that my favorite part was watching religious Saudi women, in full traditional garb, laughing hysterically about men, sex (a little), Islamic traditions, and even over such absurdies as the paradoxical joy of being driven everywhere because they aren't permitted to drive.
It's crazy and it's funny. But what culture isn't?
I am reminded of my son, Nick, during Passover at "Dean & Deluca," food store being offered a sample ham and cracker sandwich, but throwing away the bread (we don't eat bread during Passover) but gobbling down the ham (which we Jews are never supposed to eat).
A semblance of that spirit pervades this film. Yes, Muslims observe their traditions. Yes, many deviate in ways that make sense to them but seem crazy to us, and they laugh about it.
And that includes those Saudi women in black who seem about as amused by life as the people who conducted the Salem witch trials until you see them laughing at a (slightly) filthy joke.
Last point. This film has no politics. Palestinians and Israelis have a strong comedic sense (both peoples are dominated by seculars) but their conflict is tragic. So they aren't in the film -- which invites partisans of either side, both sides, or no side -- to simply sit back and crack-up. Loud.
After all, the film has only one message, taken from that old Art Linkletter Show "People... Are... Funny." And that includes Arabs. Who knew?
Just Like Us opens at the Tribeca Film Festival on April 24th.
Follow MJ Rosenberg on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mjmediamatters
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCujBGTotiA&feature=related
Don't miss 1:00
And a woman standup dunno how she could possibly 'make a living' being funny in SA.
Sorry but I still have this impression that much of that part of the world is still a cheerless unfunny place.
Esp. SA. but someone must be funny there I guess
The film, a comic documentary, is about a bunch of stand-up comics who took their act to Saudi Arabia, Dubai, Egypt and Lebanon essentially to determine if Arabs have a sense of humor."
Hollywood has long ridiculed the Arab people, perpetuating cruel stereotypes. Now it appears that films can act in the reverse. Why not see the film, judge for yourself?
Now the crowds are huge in the thousands and the comics come from all different backgrounds and religions...
Here's a great clip about it from CNN
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VLNPUmb1wEc
Dean Obeidallah who is an HP blogger just did the first Public show in Saudi (the prince was involved) and the crowd was over 1000 and mixed men and women.
Prior to that the shows in yucky SA were private hopefully comedy can bring change.
'Public' shows in the true sense of the word do not yet exist. We have been producing large private shows for the last two years
Smile Productions
Riyadh
Yes, Arabs laugh. There are sooo many hilarious TV shows in Arabic, from back in the day before America discovered Arabia via "Terrism".
Are we trying to make it look like this a novelty?
Its not. In fact an annual Comedy festival is held in Amman (www.ascf.jo) and there is a huge Arab comedy movement. If you check this link www.arabcomedy.org you can read about a huge Comedy festival in NYC that features over 100 Arab American and Arab performers regardless of their religion or gender.
These cats even performed in Ramallah and Haifa and were a huge success.
MJ Rosenberg,
Your usual detractors aren't going to be any happier with this piece that depicts Saudis (or any Arabs) without the demonization, mockery or downright hatefulness that is frequently exhibited by many who should know better. I enjoyed this article & will hope to see the film. Some things are universal, esp. the ways all of us abide, live within & sometimes manage to evade our customs & obligations. That is very funny about human nature in that we can be so serious about that which we sometimes love to flout.
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/21/nyregion/21ink.html?fta=y
and do comedy with Israelis
http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2010/03/humor-where-it’s-rarely-found/
Nothing is toooo tragic for comedy :) Obviously I'm a huge fan :)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8378483.stm
http://www.amnestyusa.org/all-countries/saudi-arabia/human-rights-concerns/page.do?id=1101942
http://www.amnestyusa.org/document.php?id=ENGNAU2010012215102&lang=e
http://www.amnestyusa.org/death-penalty/rizana-nafeek/page.do?id=1011394
Not so funny...
It takes a true (albeit hidden) bigot to "discover" that (surprize!!) Saudis are like any other people. It takes a really dishonest politician to pretend that everything is fine - it's only a bit dark and covered, just like Borough Park!
Except that Saudis live under a backward, despotic regime, which intolerably oppresses women (do you know that female genital mutilation is still practiced in Saudi Arabia, Rosenberg?), foreigners, non-Muslims, Shia and (slightly less) Saudi males. A regime which is about to "legally" and publicly behead a foreign national for the crime of sorcery – in the 21st century. In short, a regime which belongs in the Middle Ages, not the Middle East.
Based on the documentary called Inside the Koran, female circumcision is a recent introduction to the Koran courtesy, you got it, Saudi Clerics.
Even young women covered in cloth. Warm, engaging, intelligent -- some very and some not so. Just like everywhere else in the world
Heck you can even play golf in Saudi.
http://www.saudiarabia-travel.org/golf.html
Ignorance feeds on ignorance and our complete lack of interest in other cultures and peoples explains in part our eagerness to kill foreigners in phony wars. The people we kill mean nothing to us.
I don't disagree with the sentiments you expressed but they seem at odds with your pleas for multicultural sensitivity re Arab culture. You can't really believe that the Saudis are more reasonable and socially responsible than the rednecks you vilify, who also have senses of humor - though I prefer Lewis Black to Larry the Cable Guy myself.