Yesterday, in Geneva, the United Nations Human Rights Council had a very important discussion about two reports it received on the situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory: the report of the independent fact finding mission on the Gaza conflict, led by Justice Goldstone, and my own report, also requested by the Council, on human rights violations in the Occupied Palestinian Territory.
These two reports complement other reports about Gaza, including those by 10 independent UN experts and several other investigations by both inter-governmental entities and NGOs such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch. Taken together, these reports present a comprehensive and remarkably consistent picture of what happened in Gaza.
My own report notes that significant prima facie evidence indicated the commission of serious violations of international humanitarian law, as well as gross human rights violations, by both Israel and Hamas during the military operations that were carried out in Gaza from 27 December 2008 to 18 January 2009.
This situation was exacerbated by the blockade that the population of Gaza endured in the months prior to these military operations. It has continued ever since, and is now entering its third year. As a result conditions on the ground continue to deteriorate.
In particular, the Gaza population's freedom of movement is denied. A wall runs along all land borders with Israel and Egypt. At sea, Israeli gunboats prevent Palestinian boats from sailing more than three nautical miles from the coastline. With very few exceptions, Gaza's 1.5 million inhabitants are trapped. They cannot exit the 45 km-long Strip.
In addition to the curtailment of Gazans' freedom of movement, heavy import restrictions and near total prohibition of exports have severely impaired the realization of a wide range of economic, social and cultural rights, as well as many civil and political rights, of the Gaza population. Restrictions include the unacceptable curtailment of Gazans' right to work, their right to access water, food, adequate housing and education, as well as their entitlement to the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health.
Funds to remedy the situation are available. However, the blockade is preventing the disbursement of the nearly $5 billion pledged by donors at Sharm el Sheikh in March 2009 for recovery and reconstruction efforts in Gaza.
The blockade, and its effect of collective punishment, must stop. Causing such hardships for the civilian population cannot possibly serve the interests of peace and security in the region.
I recommend in my report that all allegations of breaches of international humanitarian law and human rights violations during the Gaza military operations and their aftermath -- whether through attacks on civilians and civilian objects in Gaza or indiscriminate rocket attacks into Israel by Hamas or other armed Palestinian groups -- must be thoroughly investigated by credible, independent and transparent accountability mechanisms, respectful of international standards of due process. Equally crucial is upholding the right of victims to receive compensation.
The recommendations of Justice Goldstone's fact-finding mission should be followed up by the Human Rights Council in order to fulfill its responsibility to promote universal respect for the protection of all human rights and fundamental freedoms for all. The interest of all victims and respect for international law must be the central focus of the Council's action. This body's impartiality and an even-handed approach on the part of the international community as a whole are indispensable to help prevent future human rights violations and to establish a solid base for peace and security.
Last July, the Government of Israel issued a report called "The Operation in Gaza 27 December 2008 - 18 January 2009: Factual and Legal Aspects." It states that the Israel Defense Forces were conducting at that time "comprehensive field and criminal investigations into allegations regarding the conduct of its forces during the Operation."
I urge the Israeli Government to ensure that any investigation be conducted in a credible and independent manner and in conformity with all relevant international standards.
My report also documents the situation in the West Bank and East Jerusalem where international calls for a stop to settlements have so far not been heeded. Violent acts by settlers against Palestinians continue, coupled with a near total impunity for such acts.
As pointed out in my report, the existence of the settlements represents severe obstacles for freedom of movement in East Jerusalem and the West Bank. These include checkpoints, road blocks and segregated roads, the vast majority of which are located far away from the Green Line. And so is the wall which extends far into the West Bank. In turn, these obstacles undermine the enjoyment of other human rights, such as the right to education, access to health and the freedom to worship. The settlement expansion policy also spawns the rising number of forced evictions and demolitions of homes in East Jerusalem and the West Bank. In this sense, settlements are not only illegal under international humanitarian law, but also generate violations of international human rights law.
Since April, the dire situation of thousands of detainees and prisoners has not improved. Israel currently holds approximately 8,000 Palestinians in detention under conditions that contravene international human rights and humanitarian law. In Gaza, the de facto administration holds an estimated one hundred political detainees in unknown locations which are off-limits to both the families of the detainees and to their legal counsel. The Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit has been held incommunicado in an undisclosed location for more than three years, and not even the International Committee of the Red Cross has been given access to him. Allegations of torture and degrading treatment of detainees held in centers under the control of the Palestinian Authority, Hamas and Israel all need to be investigated.
The widespread recourse by all parties to military justice systems, which do not meet international standards of due process, is a matter of grave concern.
I lend my full support to Justice Goldstone's report and its recommendations. I fully agree with him that the prevailing impunity for human rights violations in the Middle East conflict must end.
Such impunity encourages and helps perpetuate human rights abuses. Bringing perpetrators to account is not only necessary to ensure justice and protection to the affected populations, but also to enhance prospects of peace in the region. All parties to the conflict, as well as the international community, should extend full support and cooperation to accountability efforts.
It is essential that the international community anchors its efforts to broker a durable political solution in international law, including the important 9 July 2004 advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice on the legality of the wall being built by Israel.
It should be clear by now that there can be no lasting peace without accountability for human rights violations and breaches of international humanitarian law.
Arianna Huffington: Israel Diary: Voices of Peace, Stories of Conflict
My last day in Israel was a whirlwind of visits -- and points of view. I met with people on both sides of the conflict, all hoping to break through old paradigms that no longer work. READ MORE Meet the HuffPost Game Changers We've announced the top ten Game Changers in Entertainment and Green, and now it's up to you to pick the Ultimate Game Changer in each category. READ MORE WATCH: Arianna Discusses "Pigs at the Trough" on The View WATCH: Arianna Talks Iran, the GOP, and Polanski on Morning Joe WATCH: Arianna Defends Rep. Alan Grayson on Countdown WATCH: Arianna Takes on Red State Blogger on Dylan Ratigan's Show WATCH: Arianna Talks Letterman, KFC, Jiggling Breasts, and the Olympics on Leno
I am sure she is right now investigating the human rights abuses and war crimes which Lebanese are committing against Palestinian refugees. No question this is what she's doing...
Prima facie evidence. A witness says "Joe hit me." That is prima facie evidence. Did Joe hit him? Don't know.
Is that how the UN lawyers work these days, implying judgment without trial? This opens up to attacks of being a anti-Jewish witchunt.
Good that you mention Gaza has a border with Egypt too. I will take the UN seriously when it investigates human rights violations in Iran.
the Israelis appear instead to be heading for the high ground, looking to seize strategic hilltops that would allow them to better control those parts of Gaza in which Hamas fighters are mingling with the civilian population."
http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1869441,00.html
too bad Ms, Pillay refuses to read press or interview witnesses who are not petrified of Hamas vengeance.
Not Obama. Not Ahmadinejad. Not Ms. Pillay.
Here's a recepy for calm.
Step One for Palestinians: Take Gaza back from terrorists,
Step Two: Stop virulent antisemitic and anti- Israeli propaganda in your schools, TVs, government pronouncements and sermons. .
Step Three: Convince Israeli electorate that you actually want peace. At least try.
If these three steps are taken, Israeli peace camp destroyed by Arafat sponsored terrorism will re-emerge.
Until then, you will see nothing but hawkish governments from Israeli people of all faiths. Including Israeli Arabs who abhor Palestinian governance.
Hint: Sladin is not coming. Overpopulation will only bring misery. Fighting will only brin more defeats.
Convince Israel of your peaceful intentions and statehood will follow.
Everything else is empty propaganda.
The current state of reality is that Israel has a jewish majority, and they should be free to continue living there, holding elections and taking political office. There is also a significant population of people of other religions. Their rights must be respected and their grievances must be heard.
Do you also accept the United States as a Christian nation? I, for one, do not.
What is a mystery is Israel not investigating and punishing these serious charges. They have no excuses. Just as the Palestinians have no excuses in their provocative rocket attacks or torturing. Both sides should stop whining and just cut it out.
Wrong.
At this time Israeli IDF is conducting a series of investigations into various allegations raised by some Israeli organizations and soldiers themselves. this has been ongoing for month..
"We appointed special commissions to review the matter and are dealing with complaints."
Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Gabi Ashkenazi
At this time Palestinains have ZERO investigations. How can they,. They themselves ordered it! LOL.
How many times do you need to be told that.
If that were the case, the Palestinians could say "No peace at all until the Israelis get rid of Netanyahu." Rejoin the conversation after digesting that comparison, please.
But you get to marginalize and/or ignore them and/or fight them.
Or all of the above.
No peace, no state.
Take it or leave it.
The author would've done well to research such well documented facts as:
Hamas encouraging and forcing Gazans to act as human shields to protect Hamas leaders property.
Gaza military using medical, press and U.N.- labeled vehicles transport militants and arms and attack Israelis. Gaza military booby-trapping civilian buildings in Gaza.
Hamas children interview.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YjyfR_ObFcs&feature=related
The discussion of numerous and outrageous Hamas violations of human rights, war crimes and violations of laws of war— three sentences. Even in those three, the author wanted to make sure some reference to Israel is included.. Just to show impartiality, of course.
The rest in dedicated to a systematic and wide ranging attack. on Israel encompassing military conflict refugees, settlements, funds and every possible matter conjured up.
Ever-so short discussion of Palestinian misdeeds are exclusively limited to last two years (naturally), whereas the attack on Israel ranges far and wide of that time span and issue.
So what's new.
Both neighbors of Gazastan agree on this.
Hamas fired ten thousand rockets at Israel since 2001. You (the UNHCR) did nothing.
Hams declared war on Israel in 2008, punctuating this with more than 40 rockets and mortars. You did nothing.
Israel sent more than fifty letters to the UN pleading for help. You still did nothing.
Israel said that if Hamas did not stop they would use force. You *still* did nothing.
So you see, if you and the UNHCR had *done your job* and ended the impunity that the Palestinian terrorist groups enjoyed so much, Cast Lead would never have happened and all those people would still be alive. And *now* you claim that this impunity must stop?
Why do you only step in when Israel defends itself? How is that *not* hypocritical?
Israel is not sincere about any kind of reconciliation with Palestine, this is the same strategy that has been followed since the late 1930s and it has continued without abatement...
You can't defend the indefensible.
"When we say that the Arabs are the aggressors and we defend ourselves ---- that is only half the truth. As regards our security and life we defend ourselves. . . . But the fighting is only one aspect of the conflict, which is in its essence a political one. And politically we are the aggressors and they defend themselves." (Righteous Victims, p. 652)
David ben Gurian in reference to the First Intifada 1938
Palestinians are allowed to fight Israel.
Israelis are allowed to defend themselves.
But they both need to do it within the rules of law, right? Except that when Palestinians break the rules, they get a free pass. Because people like you will always be there to apologize for them and justify their crimes. When Israel breaks the rules, suddenly it's a problem.
It's the UNHCR's fault for not treating the two sides equally. If they had done what they were supposed to, this never would have happened. And you know this, so you are trying to change the subject by blindly blaming Israel (rule #16).
BTW: David Ben Gurion has been dead for decades. He doesn't run Israel anymore.
Bring the war criminals in the US, Israel and Gaza to justice. We are a smaller world now and we need to see that there is justice and accountability.
Your detractors will be out in force, but thank you for giving voice to the outrageous offenses against Palestinian families in Gaza, the West Bank & Jerusalem. The whole of the international community is behind you with very few exceptions, with the US Congress & what now appears to be weakness in the Obama adm as well, being among them. You need to know, however, that many Americans do support you & your efforts for humanity.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Y3BWYiLvn8
It is fair to ensure that Palestinians are ensured basic food, health and shelter resources. Except for building materials, it appears that the PALESTINIANS have their basic needs met. While opposition to the blockade on humanitarian grounds is not wrong per se, Israel has a legitimate national security interest in maintaining the blockade against an enemy with which it is at war against.
The Gazans are not being killed or deprived of basic necessities. "Punish" is a label you choose for ideological purposes. It is not a neutral, factual description without judgment. In a war, civilians always bear hardship. America, based on a one-time event from people located on the other side of theplanet who had tro plan for several years to make the attack, lauched an invasion that resulted in thousands of civilian deaths and hundreds of thousands of refugees. If your security personally was threatened, you'd be the first one screaning for the government to take military action to secure your freedom from risk or threat.
You are free to call it assinine. But you merely reveal your partisan passion and your lack of reasoned consideration. One can object and oppose it in a rational matter, but that is not what you are doing with your emotional screed.
Palestinian have chosen to fight it out and lost at every step of the way.
One would think that they would consider a way of co- existence. If no other reason than constant military defeats.
But it seems to be difficult, when so many outsiders far more interested in attacking Israel then Palestinian welfare.
"Fighting Israel until the last Palestinian" is still the predominant slogan among many Muslims of the world.
Now reality: Small peaceful demilitarized state, or nothing at all. Take it or leave it.
That's the deal. And nothing else will be available.
or are you forgetting the Luhi gang and their introduction of air piracy/ highjacking to the world?
I am sure that if you were a Palestinian who was driven from his home you would fight back... Israel shows no mercy and considers itself the "Holy Exception". How does this serve anyone but Israel? What entitiles you to ethincally cleans and oppress people in ghettos particularly after the sorry treatment Jews received at the hands of the NAZIS... That was also ethnic cleansing and it wasn't just Jews or have you forgotten?
You can bluster all you want to , it doesn't invite respect.
-Palestinians have been expelled from Tunisia, Jordan and Kuwait. When was the last time one of those countries got hit by a rocket or suicide bomb? Newsflash: Their hatred of Israel is not motivated by "expulsions" 60 years ago.
"What entitiles you to ethincally cleans and oppress people in ghettos particularly..."
1. Distortion. And you know it.
2. What entitles Israel to take actions against the Palestinians? The many wars and murders the Palestinians committed against Israel. That's what.
Hey why not, as long he himself is safely in the West.