iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Neal M. Blitz, D.P.M., F.A.C.F.A.S.

GET UPDATES FROM Neal M. Blitz, D.P.M., F.A.C.F.A.S.
 

Bunions: When Do They Become Something To Worry About?

Posted: 07/05/11 09:36 AM ET

Look down at your feet -- would you know if you have a bunion?

Many people know the term 'bunion' and that it occurs on a foot, but don't know exactly what a bunion is.

Most people think a bunion is an abnormal growth of bone at the base of the big toe. This is incorrect (at least in most cases). A bunion is actually a structural problem where the big toe joint becomes subluxed and drifts towards the smaller toes. A displaced bone, called a metatarsal, becomes prominent on the inside of the foot. The bunion simply refers to the enlarged prominent 'knobby' area.

2011-07-03-DrNealBlitzHuffPoBunionBlogPic1Final.jpg

Bunions may progress in size and severity. A bunion may start of as minor issue and, over time, may develop into a severe disfiguring foot deformity. See below:

2011-07-03-DrNealBlitzBunionProgressionHuffPoFINAL.jpg


So if you have bunion, here are 10 important things you should know, as you consider treatment:

  1. Not all bunions are painful.
  2. The medical term is hallux abducto valgus.
  3. They come in different sizes: small, medium, large or severe.
  4. Genetics. You may have inherited your grandmothers feet.
  5. They occur more often in women than men.
  6. Pointy-toed shoes and high heels may result in bunions.
  7. Bunions may get bigger over time, or not.
  8. The bunion may cause problems with the lesser toes.
  9. Non-operative treatments are mostly aimed at treating the symptoms.
  10. Surgical treatment goals are to realign the natural position of the toe.

When to seek treatment?

There is not a specific point when bunion sufferers 'must' start treatment despite the bunion severity. Some people begin treatment with the smallest bunion while others neglect the condition until severe. Reasons to seek medical treatment are:

  • Presence of Pain? Pain and discomfort is the most common reason to seek treatment. Pain directly on the bunion is a symptom of direct shoe pressure. Joint pain suggests arthritic degeneration. Pain on the ball of the foot is concerning for altered foot biomechanics and a sign of a bigger problem. Pain should not be ignored.
  • Interference with Activity? Some people wait until a bunion interferes with activities before seeking medical treatment and I think this is a mistake. Impact activities (such as running, tennis) may be more challenging to perform. If left ignored, simple everyday walking may become problematic. You should take measures that keep you active and healthy.
  • Inability to Wear Certain Shoes? In this subset of patients, it's the sheer size of the bunion preventing fashionable shoes that motivates treatment -- not pain. These patients have learned to live with discomfort but chose fashion over foot health. Clearly, inability to wear shoes is a valid reason for intervention.
  • An Unsightly Bunion? Foot care experts are less concerned with cosmetic appearance as they are about pain, activity restrictions and overall foot function. Often insurance companies only cover medical bunion treatments if pain is present, regardless of size.
  • Overlapping toes? When the second toe has overlapped the big toe, it's an obvious indicator of a global foot problem, and is often associated with collapse of the foot. Interestingly, these problems are not always painful as the condition develops overtime and the pain may be muted, or patients have accepted a certain amount of foot discomfort. The driving force for treatment becomes secondary problems such as metatarsal stress fractures or inability to fit shoes.
  • How to limit progression of a bunion?

    It is important to understand that not all bunions become worse (or bigger). Some bunions never change in size. Others may progress onto a major foot deformity. Genetics play a big role and you may be 'destined' to develop a 'bad' bunion. Below are non-surgical measures to mitigate pain as well as limit the progression.

  • Smart Shoe Selection: Avoiding shoes that are bad for your foot health may be the best preventive measure you can take. Pointy toes shoes directly pushes on the big toe inappropriately, and in my opinion are 'bunion formers.' If the bunion becomes irritated, then spot stretching the shoe limits symptoms. High heels may also contribute to bunions due to altered foot mechanics -- so limit time in them. Flip flops are considered a "poor footwear" choice by most health care professionals. Minimalist shoes seem to be a better lightweight alternative.
  • Counteract Muscle Spasms: Muscle spasms within the foot are often due to a muscular imbalance, and an important warning sign that muscles are trying to stabilize bone structure. Strained muscles are less effective at stabilizing the foot and a bunion may progress. Deep massage and mineral foot soaks ease tension in the foot.
  • Foot Strengthening: It's important to keep your foot muscles strong to counteract the muscular imbalance. Perform simple toe exercises daily -- such as picking up marbles (or a handkerchief) with your toes. Commercially available toe exercising devices may have therapeutic benefits but studies do not exist demonstrating efficacy.
  • Arch Supports: Bunions and foot deformities tend to occur in people with flat feet and/or ligamentous laxity. Arch supports provide extrinsic structure and promote a more 'proper' alignment and may limit bunions from getting bigger. Over the counter inserts are a good first start. Doctor-prescribed molded orthotics have the benefit of being custom to your foot and therapeutically tweaked.
  • Pain Medication (Oral & Topical): Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medication is commonly recommended to decrease pain and inflammation. Topical treatments also help manage inflammation and pain symptoms. Capsaicin cream/ointment (derived from spicy chili peppers) is a potent pain reliever that works via a neurochemical pathway. Be sure that the skin overlying the bunion is intact, otherwise capsaicin will cause an intense burning sensation. Topical products containing methyl salicylate distract the pain perception by causing cooling/warming skin sensations. Topical corticosteroid cream may temporarily reduce inflammation and should be used intermittently because it may cause thinning of the skin as well as hypopigmentation.
  • Bunion Padding: A pad limits direct pressure and may prevent the pain cascade altogether. Chronic bunion inflammation can result in deeper bone problems, so prevention is beneficial. More importantly, a properly placed pad may provide a physical blockade that prevents the bunion from pushing out. Pads may be composed of felt, moleskin or gel.
  • Toe Spacers & Bunion Splints: The purpose of this intervention is to physically place the big toe in a more normal position. A toe spacer (often made of silicone) is worn while walking. A bunion splint is a useful device (worn while sleeping) to physically realign the big toe.
  • If you have a bunion, do what it takes to take care of your feet and prevent progression. If the above measures don't help, then surgery may be inevitable.

    ~ Dr. Neal M. Blitz

    To learn more about Dr. Blitz, please visit www.nealblitz.com

     

    Follow Neal M. Blitz, D.P.M., F.A.C.F.A.S. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrNealBlitz

    Look down at your feet -- would you know if you have a bunion? Many people know the term 'bunion' and that it occurs on a foot, but don't know exactly what a bunion is. Most people think a bunion...
    Look down at your feet -- would you know if you have a bunion? Many people know the term 'bunion' and that it occurs on a foot, but don't know exactly what a bunion is. Most people think a bunion...
     
     
    • Comments
    • 49
    • Pending Comments
    • 0
    • View FAQ
    Comments are closed for this entry
    View All
    Favorites
    Recency  | 
    Popularity
    Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
    12:22 PM on 07/10/2011
    This is an informative article; I thank Dr. Blitz for it. Solid information on foot health is needed, especially since the fashion industry has deemed Gaga-esque shoes fashionable. However, the surgeon has written an example of the old saw "to a hammer, everything looks like a nail..." Dr. Blitz sticks to facts, yet downplays the effectiveness of non-surgical treatments. Hence, he writes, "Studies do not exist demonstrating efficacy [of foot exercising devices]" without mentioning the true value of rigorous, well-designed physical therapy to correct gait and posture problems and condition the muscles that control sideways movement of the big toe. Physical therapy can not only limit progression of a bunion, but reverse foot dysfunction. And Dr. Blitz neglects to mention that muscle spasms are also a healthy, temporary discomfort that you may suffer as atrophied muscles in your foot gradually regain function, not just a "warning sign". "Non-operative treatments are mostly aimed at treating the symptoms" may be factual, but is also lawyer-ly misdirection. Surgery is expensive, entails risk, and may be necessary and helpful. But as I can attest, it's not inevitable.
    This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
    09:25 AM on 07/10/2011
    Here in Wisconsin, the simplest way to get rid of bUNIONS is to inflame "Don't Read on Me" tea partyers into passing a law against them.
    photo
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    Peter Boehringer
    Dona nobis pacem
    07:34 AM on 07/10/2011
    There is an M.D. in Kingston, NY who pioneered a new surgery to realign the toe, worked great.
    photo
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    alafonse
    It's definitely a crap-shoot.
    05:56 AM on 07/10/2011
    My mother (and all her brothers and sisters) had bunions. Mom decided to get hers fixed but by the time she was able to have it done, her circulation had deteriorated and the doctor said her feet would not heal and he refused to do surgery.
    If you think you want your feet operated on "someday", don't put it off too long. As you age, the pressure of toes against other toes can be difficult to deal with especially if poor circulation develops.
    I didn't have bunions but did have hallux rigidus on my right foot—my right foot was swelling and my right great toe was getting numb. It impaired my walking and I had it operated on. Best thing I ever did. The swelling in my foot went down and my toe isn't numb any more.
    hagenjr
    Shovel ready freeborn son of the Republic
    05:22 AM on 07/10/2011
    My goodness, them images will hunt me as i try to sleep.
    photo
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    katmeyster
    We don't have a spending problem.
    01:10 AM on 07/10/2011
    I developed bunions in my twenties after going out dancing for a few years in high heels. They are fairly mild, though, and never got any worse because I gave up those high heels. Now I wear Crocs and Birkenstocks. They might not be cute, but I can walk around all day long and my feet never hurt. But most regular shoes with backs are worthless -- if you buy a wide shoe with a nice wide toebox, the heel never fits, is too big, and slides up and down creating blisters. Maybe they should make shoes in WB (wide for bunions).
    09:54 AM on 07/08/2011
    This was a great article. I am currently recovering from bunion surgery. For a while, I didn't realize I even had bunions until one of them started to become very painful. Hopefully this article can educate people and help them seek the treatment they need to relieve their pain.
    photo
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    SilentSolidarity
    So what do you need? Besides a miracle.
    04:25 AM on 07/08/2011
    Woa! No. Thank goodness I don't have that.
    11:27 PM on 07/07/2011
    with the help of the internet, i diagnosed myself with bunions only last nite! today when i went to my family doctor for another concern, i showed him my bunions.

    that's not a bunion, he said. it's classic gout! you've got all the symptoms: it came on suddenly in the middle of the nite, it's excruciating and you can barely walk.

    he prescribed a course of prednisone and said it was okay to take my emergency percoset.
    considerthis
    I try my best
    08:50 AM on 07/08/2011
    Gout and bunions are entirely different. I think you should question the dr' diagnosis. Prednisone is a powerful drug -- if you do not have a medical need to take it - DON'T!
    04:27 PM on 08/24/2011
    Bunions and bunion pain doesn't come on suddenly in the middle of the night. Gout comes on suddenly in the big toe, I'm sure her MD took a blood test for uric acid which would be high causing gout---big difference between the two things. This is why it's dangerous to self-diagnose on the internet, or for her to stop taking her prescribed prednisone on a commenter's word--why scare someone for nothing? really! Prednisone in controlled packs of decreasing doses will take safely down the inflammation while the medication for high uric acid starts working to prevent future attacks, percocet for pain these are common in an acute gout attack. Good luck to Ruth and pls stop trying to self diagnose! from old hospital RN
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    Ozark Homesteader
    http://ozarkhomesteader.wordpress.com
    10:58 PM on 07/07/2011
    Buy wide flats and low-heeled shoes. My understanding from reading studies and talking to my own primary care physician is that more foot surgeries for bunions, Morton's neuroma, etc. have poor outcomes than good ones. Buy good shoes that are kind to your feet. Make walking pain free a fashion!
    photo
    undrgrndgirl
    what's so funny 'bout peace, love & understanding?
    10:05 PM on 07/07/2011
    there are other kinds of bunions as well...known as tailor's bunions which most often occur on the 5th metatarsal, but i have one on the third or fourth metatarsal.
    owlbreath
    When you seek it, you cannot find it.
    09:00 PM on 07/07/2011
    I developed a painful bunion on my right foot. I noticed after I ate red meat, the bunion was more painful. After eliminating red meat from my diet, the bunion decreased and the pain completely stopped and I have been pain free for 4 years.
    photo
    undrgrndgirl
    what's so funny 'bout peace, love & understanding?
    10:06 PM on 07/07/2011
    that sound more like gout than a bunion.
    photo
    HUFFPOST BLOGGER
    Neal M. Blitz
    11:11 PM on 07/07/2011
    Yes, gout seems very likely.

    Gout is a condition from hyperuricemia (too much uric acid in the blood stream) resulting in deposition of uric acid crystals inside of a joint. Gout commonly occurs in the big toe joint and can mimic a bunion and/or occur in conjunction. An xray can be helpful in making a diagnosis if the gout has eroded the big toe joint - causing gouty arthritis. A blood test may identify if you have elevated uric acid, but the result may be equivocal. Sometimes, the only way to get a definitive diagnosis is to place a needle into the joint and pull out some fluid - gouty joint fluid had crystals seen under a microscope.

    Nonetheless, it is worthwhile to have a medical evaluation to make sure that the kidneys are functioning properly. Sometimes poor kidney function can result in gout. Other conditions cause gout.

    Lastly, foods such as red meat are known to trigger gout: see a list a food s to avoid can be found here http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?uid=132284080161998&topic=83

    ~Dr. Blitz
    07:40 PM on 07/07/2011
    my mom got these from wearing high heels her whole life
    07:11 PM on 07/07/2011
    I don't think I would ever let my foot get to the point of the overlapping toes!!!
    05:48 PM on 07/07/2011
    where does this notion of "arch support" come from? if you look at the anatomy of a foot youll find dozens of ligaments, muscles, tendons, and bones that make up our arches. the way arches are shaped makes them perfectly designed to bear weight, thats why weve used the design to build bridges and other structures for centuries. the easiest way to destroy an arch shape is by lifting it from the bottom, thats exactly the design that "arch support" promotes.
    photo
    undrgrndgirl
    what's so funny 'bout peace, love & understanding?
    10:08 PM on 07/07/2011
    because that arch fails frequently. fallen arches and plantar fasciitis are painful conditions...
    01:39 PM on 07/08/2011
    if your arch has "failed" its because its too weak to support the weight being put on it. orthotics dont make it stronger, they do the opposite. so really all that treatment does is cover up the problem, if you really want to fix it you need to do strengthening exercises.