iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nicholas Campion

GET UPDATES FROM Nicholas Campion
 

Astrology and Cosmology in the World's Religions

Posted: 07/01/2012 9:32 am

It's a shocking fact that there has never been a human culture which has not related its myths, institutions and identity to the stars. This is as true of the modern West as it was of our stone-age ancestors, and is as relevant to the last, surviving, indigenous inhabitants of Amazonia, as it is of today's American astronomers. After all, no scientist spends cold nights scanning the sky in search of new stars, or long hours decoding data from deep space, if the exercise is completely meaningless. Actually, it is profoundly meaningful and the last hundred years' worth of discoveries of the immense, incomprehensible size of our universe, combined with the sheer wonder of recent color-enhanced images of distance galaxies has proved as enchanting as any ancient story of star gods and goddesses, or of saviors descending to earth from the sky.

The name we normally give to the quest for meaning in the sky is astrology, from the Greek logos -- 'word' or 'logic' of the stars -- as opposed to astronomy, the 'law' of the stars. Astrology in the modern world has a somewhat problematic relationship with the prevailing culture. Its most familiar form is the horoscope column, relying on 12 zodiac signs, divisions of the sky invented in Babylon sometime before 500 BCE, but perhaps with origins which predate the invention of writing. The system is a familiar part of mass culture but arouses peculiar ire amongst some fundamentalist Christians, who regard it as demonic, and a small but vocal coterie of skeptics, who regard it as a barbaric affront to Enlightenment values. In the modern religious wars secular atheists find themselves in an unholy alliance with born-again evangelicals against the representatives of a tradition which can be traced to before recorded history.

The word "astrology" with all its attendant baggage is, though, thoroughly Greek. The Arabic equivalent would be Ahkam al-Nudium, literally, "the decrees of the stars," and in India we talk about Jyotish, the "science of light." The Chinese might study tian wen, or sky patterns, while the Japanese base their practices on onmyodo, the "Yin-Yang way," the endless interplay of subtle forces in the cosmos. To the historian of religion, modern astrology is actually a remarkable survival from the pre-scientific, pre-Christian near east. Filtered through classical Greece, the Babylonian system became a universal language which could do anything from finding lost slaves, working out the most fortunate time to get married, making financial deals, or assisting in the soul's ascent to the afterlife. At the pinnacle of the system stood the mighty planetary deities -- Zeus, king of Olympus, for the planet Jupiter, Aphrodite, goddess of love, for Venus, and so on.

The Greek philosophers, being philosophers, couldn't help tinkering with the underlying rationale. Having capricious gods and goddesses sending messages to humanity via the stars wasn't good enough for rationally-minded Athenian intellectuals. They secularized the system, introducing notions of celestial influence, in which the planets might be hot or cold, wet or dry, with environmental conditions on earth shaped by celestial patterns. Time was installed as an organizing principle, almost a deity itself, in which astrology worked because planets and people moved together in a beautiful, synchronized ballet, experiencing periods of tension or relaxation at exactly the same moments. (The Greek Cosmos, the root of our word "cosmetic," is best translated as "beautiful order"). Intricate systems of causation were formulated in which the cause of present events might lie in the future -- backward causation as we would now know it. Such notions flourish today in India as an integral part of Hinduism, complimented by ancient Vedic teachings and, in the West they survive amongst a very small number of enthusiastic practitioners.

That the impulse to develop meaningful relationships between sky and society is universal is suggested by the evolution of completely distinct, sophisticated, systems of astrology in two other civilizations, the one in China and the other amongst the Maya and Aztecs of Mesoamerica. In both cultures astrology existed as a complex aid to management of the state, and as a simple means of fortune-telling: to be able to work out one's fortune -- one's prospects for success or failure, were as important then as they are now. There, as in the West, astrology could be chiefly seen as a form of risk-management.

Every human society relates the shapes (usually animals) it sees in the sky, along with the repetitive motions of sun, moon and stars, to every-day life. Amongst the First Nations of North America, the living, moving structure of the cosmos was -- and is -- enacted in rituals designed to harmonize with the greater life-field of which humans are a part. The Australian Aborigines promote their well-being by engaging with the Dreaming, the primeval but ever-present timeless dimension which can be expressed through such events as the rising and setting of stars, or the brilliant appearance of the New Moon in the evening sky, as much as in primeval patterns etched in the landscape. For the Polynesians, who sailed thousands of dangerous miles between small islands in tiny craft, the stars were an aid to navigation precisely because they were set in the sky by a friendly creator.

Astrology is central to religious practice on account of the opportunity it presents to contact celestial deities, or to synchronize human affairs with eternal truths. The most important features of devotional astrology are the sacred calendars which were established up long ago in order to identify the most auspicious dates -- and often times -- to perform religious rituals. The legacy is clear in Christmas, which dramatically borrowed 25th Dec., the Roman festival of the Unconquered Sun. Easter, adapting an ancient Babylonian festival, has Christ resurrected on the first Sunday -- the day sacred to the Sun -- after the first full moon following the spring equinox -- when day and night, light and dark, are equally balanced. The Hebrew rules, set out in the Old Testament could not be clearer: God will only take notice of such rituals if they are properly coordinated with the sun and moon. To do otherwise is to risk divine wrath.

The ancient zodiac signs survive in the modern West because, uniquely, in an age of aggressive consumerism, media-overload and scientific materialism, they encourage people to reflect on themselves and their inner worlds; their hopes, fears and secret motivations. In mass culture, astrology replaces the remote scientific language of relativity and light-years with stories of love and luck. In an era when we are now aware that we live on an insignificant planet on the edge of a minor galaxy, astrology restores each individual to the center of their own cosmos. According to its practitioners it provides a sense of personal meaning and purpose and, sometimes, a guide to action. Both astrology's advocates and its critics find rare agreement on this point. This has nothing to do with the truth of astrology's claims, but it does explain its survival in the 21st century.

 
 
 
FOLLOW RELIGION
It's a shocking fact that there has never been a human culture which has not related its myths, institutions and identity to the stars. This is as true of the modern West as it was of our stone-age an...
It's a shocking fact that there has never been a human culture which has not related its myths, institutions and identity to the stars. This is as true of the modern West as it was of our stone-age an...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 344
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
erebus99
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
11:02 PM on 07/15/2012
I always thought "...on earth, as it is in heaven", pretty well summed up the astrological underpinnings of organized religion. The priesthoods of the earliest city-states built the first observatories and were the appointed translators of the order of the heavens. Astronomy was a natural spin-off, since making a mistake or failing to predict something like an eclipse could get you killed.
Astrology was a good business about 6,000 years ago - it's been downhill ever since.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
QuietProfessional
Recovering Jedi
05:20 PM on 07/12/2012
"The legacy is clear in Christmas, which dramatically borrowed 25th Dec., the Roman festival of the Unconquered Sun. Easter, adapting an ancient Babylonian festival, has Christ resurrected on the first Sunday -- the day sacred to the Sun -- after the first full moon following the spring equinox -- when day and night, light and dark, are equally balanced."

Or maybe it wasn't all made up.
10:39 AM on 07/07/2012
One of the best short articles I have read on the subject. The magi who visited the child, Jesus, were astrologers. Jesus pointed to the movement of the stars, as did the prophets of the Old Testament. This is deep in our collective unconscious and can be brought into awareness in our current life path, which is also part of the story the stars tell...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:56 AM on 07/23/2012
you are a very positive spirit... God bless you....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:59 PM on 07/05/2012
Meaning in the stars? Why not read a decent science book on the subject? Carl Sagan's Cosmos comes to mind as a good one to start with. There are many other choices, some more accessible than others: http://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show/cosmology.
photo
Trube
Your television is a monster.
01:31 PM on 07/05/2012
We find meaning in the stars the old fashioned way .. we make it up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:01 AM on 07/23/2012
waves... cycles... math... biorhythms.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
10YearTeacher
12:53 PM on 07/05/2012
Astronomy owes its birth to astrology, but that's where the connection ends. The methods, in their base sense, of astronomy come from the practice of astrology. But that's like saying AP Chem owes its existence to curious elementary school kids mixing baking soda and vinegar. Actually, the connection is even looser than that.
Astrology is pseudo-scientific nonsense. The amount of energy that stars, or even reflected light from planets, impart on the Earth is nearly unmeasurable because it is so small. For things to affect each other, there must be some sort of energetic connection. The sun heats the earth, a refrigerator sucks the heat out of the matter we put inside it, etc...The connection there is obvious.

The light from stars affecting me? Hardly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NYC123
12:16 PM on 07/05/2012
We earthlings marvel at the celestial universe ..its complexity, beauty and purpose; all three not fully comprehendible -- marvel is a constant subtext. And on top, we marvel at our earth -- and all it's life forms both inanimate to animate. And man, stewards of this earth -- with great potential, and little results.

Still we must marvel at the "power and mind" of our God and Father in Heaven! Hallelujah!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tmiley
Science is the greatest accomplishment of man.
11:55 AM on 07/05/2012
The God particle proves their is no God!,,
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NYC123
12:18 PM on 07/05/2012
Lol............where the god particles come from?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tylerious
My mom thinks I'm awesome
02:20 PM on 07/05/2012
Obviously God. Where did God come from? Obviously GOD. Where did GOD come from then? Obviously MAN.
03:13 AM on 07/06/2012
>

We don't know where they come from. It's OK not to know. We are not compelled to make up explanations. Not knowing things we wish to know is useful because it stimulates curiosity and, unlike religious dogma curiosity, moves us forward. But wait, there’s more: The "Where does X come from?" questions lead only to infinite regressions. If god particles come from god the next question is where does god come from? There's no getting around it. If a god can be without cause then so can the universe. Talking as if god is an explanation is useless -- with an interesting exception. The exception is that if you take all of the natural laws & processes we know about, evolution included, to be the mechanisms that god actually uses to create the universe, then fine. You've got an
excellent explanatory framework and you can use every bit of modern science to support your belief in god's mechanisms. That's not a bad solution. Oddly, however, you can then drop the god idea and guess what? Nothing changes. You've still got the best explanatory framework around and it works just dandy without god. Actually it works even better to drop the god idea because then you no longer have to explain away all the really nasty things that he lets happen, like letting babies burn up in real fires without taking the trouble to rescue them. Lol.
04:09 PM on 07/04/2012
Astrology is a part of hermetic philosophy and is a language of symbols. It deals with the dynamics of the unconscious mind, and the conscious analytical mind cannot understand the nature of this right hemispheric reality. Through a balance of conscious and unconscious mind a greater understanding of the whole of existence is accomplished.
photo
Trube
Your television is a monster.
01:31 PM on 07/05/2012
Another way of saying "I am base and you can't get me here."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:25 PM on 07/05/2012
interesting, can you elaborate?
12:56 PM on 07/04/2012
One would hope that people who label astrology as a 'pseudo' science have in fact tested some of the principles of astrology for themselves to determine whether there is any truth there or not.

Dismissing astrology out of hand sounds more like superstition than science.
09:26 PM on 07/04/2012
What are these principles? Where is the data they are based on?
02:44 AM on 07/05/2012
The principles have been preserved in ancient texts from the Greeks, Arabs, Hindus and others. The basic western astrological 'bible' is a second century AD text called the "Tetrabiblos" written by Alexandrian scholar Claudius Ptolemy. The most well known Hindu classical text is called the "Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra" by the sage Parashara Muni. Both texts can be read on-line at no charge in e-book form. These books however are very complex and not exactly meant for a layperson. There are numerous modern books that expand on these basic principles. You might want to start with 'History of Astrology' at Wikipedia and go from there.

The best way to prove astrology for oneself is to start with your own chart and adopt an empirical approach. Again, go to Wikipedia for these separate topics: astrological aspects, astrological transits and planets in astrology. Observing daily aspects of current transiting planets and their interactions with your birth or natal planets is a very good way to decide if astrology has any validity or not. Naturally this will take a certain commitment and patient objectivity to prove or disprove for oneself.
photo
Newfoundlander
I'm a pessimist, an optimist with experience!
01:23 AM on 07/05/2012
I have noted that current astrologers are careful to include Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto for accuracy's sake when they cast horoscopes. They defend the accuracy of astrology by pointing to the fact that astrology has made "accurate" predicitions for hundreds, if not thousands, of years. But since the existence of the three named planets was not known until 1781 in the case of Uranus, 1846 in the case of Neptune, and 1930 in the case of Pluto, we are left with these problems:
1). If these planets are included in horoscopes now for the sake of accuracy, then ALL horoscopes cast before their discoveries MUST have been inaccurate, and there goes the argument of historical accuracy. Or
2). If, in an attempt to preserve historical accuracy, the inclusion of the trans-Saturn planets is dismissed, then ALL horoscopes that include them and their supposed "influence" MUST be inaccurate. So much for the claims of accuracy!
03:00 AM on 07/05/2012
Excellent point. And if they include Pluto, why not include Eris, Ceres, Makemake, and Haumea?
03:13 AM on 07/05/2012
Adding the trans-Saturn planets may give a more accurate read when delineating one's natal horoscope and for predictive work for current events but leaving them out does not mean that 'all' predictions must be inaccurate.
For instance if one is born with a Mercury/Mars conjunction (both planets within a few degrees of one another), then one is expected to be impatient, very direct in speech, quick-witted and argumentative. Adding Uranus into the equation may exaggerate all of those mentioned characteristics, but it won't take anything away from them. Adding Neptune might tend to drive those same propensities inward and therefore could create conflicts with asserting oneself or expressing anger in a healthy way, but impatience and anger issues may still be there.
Same thing applies to predictions--if the transiting or current Mars in the sky forms a square or 90 degree aspect with one's natal or birth Mercury, then there are possibilities of getting in an argument, having an accident, being very impatient, having troubles with computers or other forms of communications etc. Adding Uranus along with Mars could increase the chance of those same things happening but some form of the basic Mars to Mercury aspect will still express itself, with or without the trans-Saturn planets.
photo
LittleFish31617
God shall be all in all.
02:23 PM on 07/03/2012
When the churches of the time met and set the Emperor of Rome over themselves in the position of Pope, it led to a number of unfortunate events on multiple fronts.

One of these was the movement of the celebrations of Christs' birth and Resurrection to coincide with pagan festivals. This was done to appease the pagan masses in the Roman empire, and to help Rome with her goals for Christianity.

I don't know of any Christians who consider the alignment of the stars to be in any way related to the celebration of these events. We celebrate those things not to garner faith with God, for we are saved through grace. No, we celebrate those things in order to remember Christ and celebrate his life and his love for us.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:31 AM on 07/03/2012
Woo Woo
Gobbledygook
Gibberish
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
01:18 PM on 07/03/2012
Are you sure it's got that much credibility?
photo
everybody only
what fresh hell is this?
11:41 PM on 07/02/2012
Interesting timing on this article, in light of the pending Higgs Boson discovery. I do follow astrology, not the daily calendars, but as a Gemini woman happily married to an Aries male (considered my best match, and only coincidental) I have found that I have cluster friends. I wonder if many people looked at their calendars, especially of friends, if you would find that many of your friends fall under specific sun signs. This is extremely cursory, as a rising sun and moon play a huge role, and I am not even skimming the surface, and am not well educated in astrology to begin to expound. However, I am surrounded by Aries, Capricorns, Sag's with a sprinkling of Pisces, Scorpios and Aquarius people. I was at dinner recently with 4 couples, all of the husbands work on Wall Street, are proper, well groomed, and the women are smart. All 4 men were Aries...one of the women at the table who is extremely conservative spoke about her father who was a NASA physicist, and the fact that he believed in astrology. It is fascinating....However, I can usually guess within two sun signs what someone is, I have never confused a Virgo with a Gemini, or a Pisces with a Leo....so cool.
12:33 AM on 07/03/2012
i cannot believe people still believe in this crap...
06:36 AM on 07/03/2012
It doesn't work in bars anymore.
photo
everybody only
what fresh hell is this?
08:03 AM on 07/03/2012
And I can't believe people spend time playing games on a tv, but that's what makes to world so interesting and rich.
01:00 AM on 07/03/2012
From the Vedic perspective, an individual's sun sign is but one component of said individual's astrological 'make-up.' The moon sign and ascendant play a much larger role (and one needs to know coordinates of the planets at the time of birth, the time of birth and exact location).
photo
everybody only
what fresh hell is this?
08:08 AM on 07/03/2012
Yes, I know I am a novice. I have an extremely intelligent friend in NYC who is studying full time and we have long discussions, but it is so complex, it leaves me agog.  That's why I am so frustrated that my mother doesn't know my exact birth time, because when I just enter the date, well you know.  My friend doesn't think I am Cancer rising, but I don't think I have any fire in my chart. I am intelligent but not a self starter..you sound like you have studied quite a bit, it is fascinating to me.  My daughter is on the cusp of Sag/Cap but she was one week late and I had to be induced, she is soooo much more of a Sag, is there a thought among the community about due dates versus actual birth dates?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
H S
Muscley liberal gay Greek Orthodox guy in SF
12:27 PM on 07/03/2012
Absolutely correct. I see it like this: your sun sign reflects the charactaristics you display to the world. Your ascendant is how you truly are on the inside.

For example, my natal sun is in Scorpio - and that's how people see me. My ascendant is Virgo - and that's how I am with regards to my "true self".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:28 PM on 07/02/2012
I find this article ironic because of all the conversations I have had with Christians, that deny there is any astrology in the bible....even though there so clearly is. I'm not just talking evangelicals or conservatives. Liberals are just as likely to argue on this issue. VERY few will admit the obvious.

To me it is the same issue with the clear belief that the world was flat, according to the authors of the bible. You can't find very many believers that will admit this obvious fact. It is just too embarrassing, I guess, to associate the perfect word of god with such blatant ignorance regarding the universe.
photo
michelesda
My micro-bio is empty.
08:51 AM on 07/04/2012
There is indeed lots of astrology in the Bible. Considering the era in which the Bible was written, the big surprise would be if there weren't. One of the most telling examples is the birth of Jesus himself, with the Bible's talk about a "star in the east," etc. Christians typically think of this as the appearance in the sky of a new star, planet, comet, whatever, as if to make the story more intelligible to modern rationality, but, in the original Koine, that's not what the story is saying at all. "Maji" back then meant "Persian astrologers." "Star in the east" is astrology lingo, referring to a given planet rising "orientally." What the story is saying is that some majus cast a horoscope that indicated (not by a new star, but by an arrangement of the same old usual ones) that a great world saving king was born on a certain day in a certain place, so supposedly all the greatest maji got on their camels and trotted off to the place where the horoscope said it happened (Jerusalem or whatever; the story isn't clear) to check it out. Not that any of this actually happened, of course; like the subsequent "slaughter of the innocents," the story is a fable. It does seem interesting, though, to consider the tweaking of the fable over time, in the public consciousness, from what it meant back in the day to what so many people believe it means now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rodger leMonde
I call them as I see them.
06:05 PM on 07/02/2012
From the ancient observations we established calendars and methods of time reference. The stars share immortality with the gods and a precision that reeks of certainty and purpose. It is little wonder that ancient civilizations revered this and sought to study the heavens for revealed truth in this orderly display.
12:37 AM on 07/03/2012
stars are not immortal nor precise in any way
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rodger leMonde
I call them as I see them.
09:58 AM on 07/03/2012
They were close enough for people at the dawn of civilization.
photo
ivsciguy
Engineer
11:23 AM on 07/03/2012
Actually their movements are very easy to calculate with astrophysics. Although the ancients did not know physics, they were still able to calculate that movements of the starts, due to repeating patterns, very precisely. Now these pasterns would eventually get off a bit without an understanding of gravity, but they would just sync them back up on solstices and such.