Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nick Balamaci

GET UPDATES FROM Nick Balamaci
 

Missing from Ground Zero: St. Nicholas Church

Posted: 09/03/10 04:14 PM ET

After 10 years, I am back downtown. I worked in the Municipal Building, City Hall, One World Trade Center, and Two World Financial Center before taking a job in midtown, the land of lawyers, bankers, real estate barons, and upscale shops and restaurants. Downtown is more like the New York I grew up in -- 99₵ Stores, municipal employees, high-end bookstores, million-dollar-traders, fried egg breakfast joints, and the Capitol Grille all crammed into the area of the similarly diverse Dutch colony that started it all. I love it.

The window of my office offers only one view: directly into the pit that we euphemistically call Ground Zero. For me it's the World Trade Center and I still see the buildings in which I once worked, shopped, ate, and made and lost friends. I am struck by the progress being made finally to close the wound - One World Trade Center is climbing furiously toward the sky with Four not far behind, and the footprint of the Memorial is now becoming clear.

But one building is conspicuously absent: the Greek Orthodox Church of St. Nicholas.

I knew it well. While other churches in the area became tourist hotspots over the years due to their age and history, tiny St. Nicholas was the anomaly: a quiet spiritual sanctuary located alongside two of the tallest buildings in the world. I spent many hours there before and after my mother's passing in 1998 and noticed that it drew not only Orthodox Christians of every ethnicity, but also Catholics, Protestants, and even the unaffiliated who simply needed some peace.

Like most Orthodox Churches, St. Nicholas held relics of saints, including its namesake. St. Nicholas of Myra (270-346 AD) was known for his love of children and was especially beloved by the Dutch, who called him Sinterklaas and believed that he delivered treats to children on a special night every December. He was the patron saint of Amsterdam and it must have seemed only natural when in 1809 the New-York Historical Society retroactively named St. Nicholas the patron saint of Nieuw Amsterdam, i.e., New York City.

I find it amazing that holy relics of the saint arguably best known by people throughout the world regardless of faith were preserved for almost 1,700 years and then transported 5,000 miles to a small church in the extraordinary New World city of which he happened to be patron saint. And I like to believe that, when the Towers collapsed into the soil of lower Manhattan, crushing and incinerating St. Nicholas Church almost without a trace, those relics helped to sanctify that small piece of land in New Amsterdam now known as Ground Zero along with the thousands who died there.

Soon after the Towers fell, Port Authority officials joined Governor Pataki in a vow to build a new St. Nicholas on the World Trade Center site. Eventually a location was agreed at 130 Liberty Street that would allow a larger structure - a wise idea, since the church is likely to attract many of the thousands of pilgrims to the World Trade Center site who may appreciate the secular memorial but who also thirst for a spiritual memorial. If the raising of the World Trade Center is meaningful to us, the resurrection of the site's only sacred structure will also be especially poignant.

Sadly, the Port Authority and the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese were not able to agree on all details before the Port Authority, after many years of delay, suddenly kicked the WTC reconstruction project into gear and in the process unilaterally withdrew from talks with the Church. Former Governor Pataki held a press conference at the WTC site last week and called upon Chris Ward, Executive Director of the Port Authority, to uphold the commitment of the Port Authority and State of New York to help the Archdiocese raise a new, larger, and more accommodating St. Nicholas at the Liberty Street location. (The Archdiocese says it will cover all construction costs - all it asks is the site all parties agreed to.)

I hope that, instead of hardening against people of good will, Mr. Ward's heart will soften and one day soon I will look out my window and see religious leaders of all faiths celebrating the consecration of St. Nicholas of the Towers at 130 Liberty Street.

***

Nick Balamaci has worked in communications roles for the Office of the Mayor of the City of New York, the Port Authority of NY & NJ, Merrill Lynch, and Citigroup.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:54 AM on 09/06/2010
As a former worker in the WTC, I have also thought about when/how this church would be restored and rebuilt. But in the interest of consistency, should we not be applying the same standard of care to this question as we are to the question of whether a Mosque can be built within X yards of Ground Zero? Now, to be clear, I personally think that both should be built and that the Constitution clearly gives each religious group the right to do so. But, unless we're going to own up to the religious discrimination we're expressing against the Muslim group looking to build their downtown Mosque, then I think we must apply the same standards to both cases, no?
01:40 PM on 09/06/2010
Yes, but the church had been there since 1916.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
godwithin
03:38 PM on 09/06/2010
Muslims have been here much longer.
05:15 PM on 09/06/2010
I doubt whether the majority of Americans would care if the Muslim group in question were building a new Mosque or rebuilding one that had been destroyed. It's the religion that's in question. The edifice is just the pretext.
05:35 PM on 09/09/2010
No they are two completely different issues. The mosque NEVER existed in the area before. The church was there for almost 100 years. It was a part of the community. The church was promised a new location which was well documented both in the plan for the area and according to the leadership at the time of planning, etc. Also as an aside which is my own opinion, when was the last time you were afraid of being bombed by Greek Orthodox Christian terrorists? The Russian Orthodox were just bombed today by Islamist terrorists. The President publicized that if a Quran were burned that Pakistani & Afghan forces were put at risk because of retaliatory measures (typical - right!)...I mean we aren't talking about isolated cases of Islamic violence, but a consistent pandemic loooong history of violence by adherents of Islam against people who don't espouse their own religion. Do we need other examples? Look at Turkey vis a vis its own ancient Christian minority. I think Muslims need to look at their own community and realize that until they stop treating non-muslims as cannon fodder or at best second class citizens educated Westernized people will not want them anywhere near their own backyard.
05:23 PM on 09/05/2010
Why is the Port Authority being uncooperative with the Greek Orthodox Church. Who is their boss?
08:10 PM on 09/06/2010
The Port Authority offered the Greek Church 60 million dollars to rebuild....and they declined, stating they wanted more $.
11:59 AM on 09/07/2010
From what I have read, the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese says this is inaccurate. Regardless, I think the point of the article is that you don’t play hardball with churches as you do with banks, real estate developers, and other government agencies – you listen and talk and educate and reach an understanding with people of good will, rather than walk away, treat them as if they didn’t exist, and start doing other things to the site you promised them.
05:39 PM on 09/09/2010
That is just not true. They offered them another more suitable location based on the fact that the original one didn't fit into the new design and that the new church would need to be larger in order to accommodate more people because of the need to have an ecumenical place for people to remember their loved ones, etc.
09:18 AM on 09/05/2010
A building that has taken Architects and politicians 10 years to figure out needs to put Frank Lloyd Wright to shame.
12:51 AM on 09/05/2010
"One World Trade Center is climbing furiously toward the sky..."

What an exaggeration!

"Climbing Furiously toward the sky...", really, I saw the site last week and they were only on the fourth or fifth floor.
Remember, the Empire State building was built in about 10 months starting in October 1929.
01:42 PM on 09/06/2010
Actually in the last year it has been going up furiously.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
daho
GOP: "Kollege is for snobs."
10:59 PM on 09/06/2010
Photos of the site beg to differ...

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/09/05/nyregion/20100905-Zer0-SS.html?ref=nyregion
07:09 PM on 09/04/2010
Thank you for the wonderful article. St. Nicholas was open to all. Let's pray and hope that the Church is rebuilt.
10:35 AM on 09/04/2010
Bravo, Nick. You've made your patron saint smile with what you have so beautifully written. May it be as you have hoped.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OldeTymeLiberalDude
10:32 AM on 09/04/2010
Profits before people.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
02:13 AM on 09/04/2010
I really hope that St. Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church will get rebuilt.