iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nick Sagan

GET UPDATES FROM Nick Sagan
 

Are We Alone?

Posted: 03/12/2012 9:45 am

It goes back to the starfish. That's when the light bulb really popped over my head. We'd found one on the beach and I was struck by what astonishing creatures they are, talking with Dad about how they regenerate. I'd learned in school how severed fragments could grow into new adults and it seemed so utterly removed from the human experience. Lose a limb and it becomes another you? What would that be like? Dad smiled and said, "Nick, you and that starfish come from the same planet. Imagine how different a creature from another planet might be."

Mind blown.

A few years before then, I'd recorded a message for potential extraterrestrial civilizations to discover. Surreal to say, but that sort of thing was normal in my household. Dad was a world-famous astronomer; Mom was the artist who drew the iconic Pioneer plaque. Together with Frank Drake, Ann Druyan, Tim Ferris and Jon Lomberg, they'd been working on the Voyager Golden Record -- a time capsule of Earthly sights, sounds, music and greetings for the Voyager 1 and 2 spacecraft to ferry to the enormous vastness of interstellar space. So that the aliens wouldn't mistakenly conclude that we're all full-grown adults down here, Mom and Dad decided it would be a good idea to have a child deliver one of the spoken language greetings. And there I was with all the necessary prerequisites: a six-year-old child who spoke English. They drove me to Cornell University, plopped me down in front of a microphone and asked me what I wanted to say.

It's fair to say I didn't fully understand what aliens were at the time. I mean I got the concept but I had trouble separating the fact from the fiction. Spock seemed cool. Marvin the Martian seemed harmless enough, aside from his interest in blasting Earth with an Illudium Q-36 Explosive Space Modulator. And Dad, who suffered from achalasia, would sometimes adopt the persona of a "Freenie" from one of Jupiter's moons, making a game of hopping around so he could amuse me and keep food down and not scare me with the seriousness of his condition. I thought the Freenie was fantastic, pretending he didn't quite understand human customs, giving me a chance to explain what was what. Is that what first contact would be like?

Now, all these years later, I'm a science fiction writer, having explored the dynamics of making contact with alien civilizations in episodes of Star Trek, one of my novels, and most recently a show at Chicago's Adler Planetarium. But science fiction only speaks to who WE are -- a projection of our hopes and fears about The Other. It can't really tell us who might be out there because no one knows yet. There have been claims, of course, but as Dad was fond of saying, "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." We've yet to find any. Dr. Jill Tarter and her fellow SETI astronomers have been listening diligently for signals but so far no dice.

Of course, that could all change in an instant.

Are we alone? It's possible but looking increasingly unlikely. Life is proving to be wonderfully resilient and tenacious. Here on Earth, we've found organisms that thrive in environmental conditions we would have once thought uninhabitable. The presence of these extremophiles suggests that life could potentially take hold on worlds other than our own. Perhaps worlds very different from our own. Likewise, when I was a child, the existence of planets beyond our solar system was theorized but unproven -- now we understand there to be a staggering number of them, including an approximate half billion in the so-called "Goldilocks zone" where conditions are such that water might exist on a planet's surface. And that's just in our galaxy alone. Consider all the planets and stars in the many billion galaxies beyond our Milky Way.

With so many places for life to exist, we may be closer to finding E.T. than ever before. Imagine what we'd glean from that encounter. How much more we'll come to know -- not only about life in the cosmos but also about ourselves. Will we be ready for it? Will it become the transcendent moment for our species or the beginning of the end? We don't know but, undeniably, this is a thrilling time to be alive.

This month, I'm delighted to help bring attention to the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence through a two-part special, Alien Encounters, which will air on Discovery's Science Channel March 13th and March 20th at 10 p.m. Hypothesizing how events might unfold were we to receive a message and then a visit from an alien civilization, these shows feature interviews with luminaries such as astronomers Jill Tarter, Frank Drake, Seth Shostak and Neil deGrasse Tyson, and science fiction writers John Scalzi and David Brin. Science has partnered with SETI and TED to explore the question, "Are We Alone?" via a month of programming that will spread the word about the exciting new SETI Live platform, which will allow anyone -- scientist or non-scientist -- to help search for intelligent life in the universe.

Maybe together we'll find the answer.

Alien Encounters Part 1- March 13 at 10PM ET/PT and Alien Encounters Part 2- March 20 at 10 p.m. ET/PT Visit SCIENCECHANNEL.com for more information.

 

Follow Nick Sagan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/nicksagan

It goes back to the starfish. That's when the light bulb really popped over my head. We'd found one on the beach and I was struck by what astonishing creatures they are, talking with Dad about how the...
It goes back to the starfish. That's when the light bulb really popped over my head. We'd found one on the beach and I was struck by what astonishing creatures they are, talking with Dad about how the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 60
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:26 AM on 04/10/2012
Yeah, we're probably not alone. Why is science fiction author David Brin listed as a "futurist" or an "astronomer" on the "Alien Encounter" specials?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oldwolf49
Religion is a tool of the evil.
05:56 PM on 03/20/2012
No we are not alone but I think they are waiting to see if we get out sh*t together before any contact. But I could tell you stories.
photo
BluePhantom2
The Blacksmith & the Artist reflected in their art
04:16 PM on 03/19/2012
No the odds of us being along in the universe or better yet multiverse are slim statistically. But the vast distances involved mean that man will probably live out our forseable future alone even if we attain space or even interstellar travel. The expanding universe almost ensures that we will not encounter inteligent life.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Publius67
11:51 AM on 03/19/2012
That sounds like a fascinating special. A good article, touching on a very important question - just what would an alien species be like? Would we even recognize it AS life? Or would we even have any common frame of reference by which to communicate at all (ex. Solaris). Explorations of this, at the least to prepare ourselves for the eventual meeting, are a value of SciFi - which, as Mr Sagan says, it is (unavoidably) about Us. "will we be ready for it?" No - but getting more familiar with the idea is a place where scifi can help

I'd toss in other concerns, based on our own history - such as a species' broadcast life? Between cable, fiber optics & the like we may not be generating as much signal as we once did, though we've not yet obliterated ourselves. So that might complicate matters of SETI detection.
MayaBeach
Tower of Babble
06:37 PM on 03/18/2012
It's probably likely that there is other intelligent life in our universe, but considering the distances involved, it's likewise improbable that we'll ever get to meet. That is unless a faster than light means of travel is employed. I don't discount the possibility of that though. It might have to do with utilizing dark energy from what I've read, but for now physicists know next to nothing about it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
farmerlady
Blonde, Democratic socialist, and unwilling expat
05:45 PM on 03/18/2012
For all practical purposes we are alone, given the fact of interstellar distances.

So we better take care of this planet because we are stuck on it.

Now, as to space exploration, I agree with other posters that we are far behind where we should be--we could do much with proper funding but our governments would rather spend money elsewhere.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dsws
No owning ideas. Limit only commercial use.
02:52 AM on 03/20/2012
I think in the long run if we're stuck on this planet, it will be because we choose to be. I don't know whether we'll ever get beyond this solar system or not, but there are lots of resources elsewhere in the solar system. If we want to, we can live in flying cities on the outer planets. Jupiter's gravity is too much, but Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune have comfortable g's. If we want to, we can live on various moons, or in habitats built from asteroids and Kuiper belt objects.
photo
Joeyjackal
A small varmint that barks 47% of the time!
01:11 PM on 03/18/2012
I will make a point of viewing the programs you mentioned in your very noteworthy article. I personally hope that I'm alive when we verify that we're indeed not the only place in the cosmos that harbors life. Your father remains a very inspiring figure to me and had a remarkable ability to explain science in an appealing and inspiring fashion. I believe myself lucky insofar as my father was something of an iconoclast when I was a youth and as a result, I was exposed to reading materials that broadened my mind early on to the possibilities of extraterrestrial life.
iflew
Pro Publiae Bonae
10:34 PM on 03/16/2012
(Given a very small likelihood) X (an infinite number of possibilities) = a value greater than unity.
Are (were) they contemporaries of ours? Since we have trouble reaching other planets in our solar system it could be a long time or take a major breakthrough before we could likely travel to them.

Would any other race want to come? Can we communicate? Would they want to?

Personally I think we are an experiment like wildlife in a preserve. Let us go our own way and the watchers laugh at the humans here. Some historic names appllied to more than one. Lots of really large and unusual skeletons around have been hidden and finders hushed up. Greys show up from time to time, and the Pascagoula upside down walking rutabaga was around about 1970. Our limited technology has cloaking by LED devices, we can't imagine what technology superior to ours has developed.
04:40 AM on 03/16/2012
We? alone? It depends on the aliens and whether some of them could be remotely regarded as "chicks".

Considering the vast geography of physical space and the technical requirements needed to physically traverse it, the aliens will be oblige to break the ice, first.

But in the Greenwich mean-time it could take to overcome such materially concievably material constraints, may amount to close enough the time it would take to evolve into a non physical type being of pure consciousness, whose options go untethered in subordination to the mundane mechanical mandates, tedium of time and supercillious space

but until then, we? Alone? Hmmmm.

I can't speak for you but at this rate, for me...it's quite possible.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
djekizian
Freelancer
01:58 AM on 03/16/2012
This self-congratulatory article reminds me of the balloon appearing over the head of a dog interpreting the words of his master in a Far Side cartoon from many years ago that read as follows: "blah, blah, Ginger, blah, blah, blah, Ginger, blah, blah."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hikerguy22
This is your carbon footprint
08:17 PM on 03/15/2012
If they find us before we find them, they will see what a mess we have made of Earth, and hopefully help us clean up our act.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:51 PM on 03/15/2012
Hmmmmmm . . . I have to say I am with Stephen Hawking's opinion that it is best we not call attention to ourselves; let me explain:

. . . many, many years ago my college roommates and I decided to host our very first kegger. We were so excited! The big night arrived but imagine our concern growing as in addition to those invited, others came too . . . and keep coming, and coming and coming . . . the noise of our festivities having reached far beyond the immediate neighborhood! These "guests" ate all the food in the refrigerator, raided the freezer, clogged the plumbing, and made hundreds of dollars in long distance phone calls! Catch my drift? =/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:02 PM on 03/15/2012
. . . maybe what we need is a sort of intergalactic/multidimensional Denny's where we could all get aquainted before we deciding if we 1) want to go home with them, or 2) invite them home with us . . . oh, and don't forget to set up a safe call! LOL
07:03 PM on 03/15/2012
If there is intelligent life out there, they should be smart enough to know how violent,untrustworthy and prejudice humans are and to STAY AWAY!!!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:28 PM on 03/15/2012
we cannot even communicate with the life here on earth. Most scientists even deny the obvious: that all multicellular life has language (down to the cellular level). are we actively looking for the shadow ecosystem on earth?

I like that NASA astrobiologists are looking for extremid bioengineering solutions to spacecraft fabrication.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
djekizian
Freelancer
02:04 AM on 03/16/2012
Not until we're able to conversations with highly vocal, audio-based whales and dolphins will I even entertain the possibility of the human species interpreting radio signals from the Andromeda Galaxy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:47 AM on 03/15/2012
Thank you for the article. I enjoyed it very much.

I think of us and any aliens in terms of the history of interactions between aborigines and colonizers here on our own planet. In most cases, the populations of the aborigines were decimated, if not exterminated, after contact with outsiders. A rational and moral alien intelligence would, I believe, be aware of such a threat from contact, and so would wish to observe without two-way interaction. To observe us without open contact would require a high level (by our standards) of stealth technology, as was portrayed in the movie "Star Trek: Insurrection."

Along this line of reasoning, I think it likely that the many thousands of reports of unexplained sightings of UFOs have behind them the likelihood that aliens are already among us, but not routinely observed by us. While the author foresees a golden age of human development after the opening of contact, I think that at our current level of development the opposite is much more likely. Until we evolve both genetically and societally, to the point that we can cope on a more or less equal footing with ETs, it is in our own best interests to be observed but not openly interacted with.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gmikejake
resist evil
03:23 PM on 03/15/2012
They are here ... among us ... carefully observing ... learning our cultural ways and native languages before the BIG REVEAL ... at major malls on weekends.