iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ocean Robbins

GET UPDATES FROM Ocean Robbins
 

Is Animal Cruelty Doomed?

Posted: 11/26/2012 7:52 pm

In one of history's most stunning victories for humane farming, Australia's largest supermarket chain, Coles, will as of January 1 stop selling company branded pork and eggs from animals kept in factory farms. As an immediate result, 34,000 mother pigs will no longer be kept in stalls for long periods of their lives, and 350,000 hens will be freed from cages.

Not to be outdone, the nation's other dominant supermarket chain, Woolworths, has already begun phasing out factory farmed animal products. In fact all of Woolworth's house brand eggs are now cage-free, and by mid-2013 all of their pork will come from farmers who operate stall-free farms.

Coles and Woolworths together account for a dominant 80 percent of all supermarket sales in Australia.

The move to open up the cages was fueled by "consumer sentiment," and it has been synchronous with a major campaign against factory farming of animals led by Animals Australia. The campaign features a TV ad, titled "When Pigs Fly," in which an adorable piglet tells the story of animals sentenced to life in cramped cages, and then flies to freedom.

Meanwhile, in the United States, egg factory farms cram more than 90 percent of the country's 280 million egg-laying hens into barren cages so small the birds can't even spread their wings. Each bird spends her entire life given less space than a sheet of paper. And in a reality that does not please fans of Wilber or Babe, between 60 to 70 percent of the more than five million breeding pigs in the United States are kept in crates too small for them to so much as turn around.

There are laws against cruelty to animals in the United States, but most states specifically exempt animals destined for human consumption. The result is that the animal agriculture industry routinely does things to animals that, if you did them to a dog or a cat, would get you put in jail.

Gene Baur, president of Farm Sanctuary, explains: "Most of the anti-cruelty laws exempt farm animals as long as the practices are considered to be normal by the agriculture industry. What has happened is that bad has become normal, and no matter how cruel it is, normal is legal."

But here, too, change is coming. Undercover investigations have led to a $497 million judgment against the now defunct Hallmark Meat Packing company, and to the recent temporary shutdown of Central Valley Meat Company over what federal investigators termed "egregious, inhumane handling and treatment of livestock." California and Michigan have passed laws that will phase in a ban on battery cages for hens, and nine U.S. states have joined the entire European Union in heading towards a ban on confining pigs in gestation crates.

Worried that consumers are starting to find out the truth about treatment of modern farm animals and will demand further changes, industry leaders are pushing for "ag gag" laws that would hide factory farming and slaughterhouse abuses from public scrutiny. Recently passed laws in Iowa and Utah threaten jail time for anyone working undercover and taking pictures or video of animals in factory farms without permission.

What don't they want us to know? What are they trying to hide? What would happen if the veil was lifted and we saw the level of cruelty that has become the norm in U.S. industrial meat production?

A poll conducted by Lake Research partners found that 94 percent of Americans agree that animals raised for food on farms deserve to be free from abuse and cruelty, and that 71 percent of Americans support undercover investigative efforts by animal welfare organizations to expose animal abuse on industrial farms.

Most farmers don't try to be cruel to animals, but they do worry about how to cut costs. And so long as consumers are kept in the dark about the real source of their food, farm owners have no economic incentive to do more than the minimum necessary to appease regulatory authorities.

Want to take action? Join the Food Revolution Network, an online community dedicated to healthy, sustainable, humane and delicious food for all.

Or join the Humane Society's campaign for farm animal protection, or Farm Sanctuary's work for animal welfare legislation. Or if you want to save 100 animals per year, you can sign up for PETA's free veg starter kit.


Ocean Robbins serves as adjunct professor at Chapman University and as founder and co-host (with best-selling author John Robbins) of the 75,000 member Food Revolution Network. Find out more and sign up for free here.

What Caused So Much Fuss? Here's The "Pigs Fly" Ad From Animals Australia

Animals Australia - Pigs fly. And sing. With chickens. from FSM on Vimeo.

 
 
 

Follow Ocean Robbins on Twitter: www.twitter.com/oceanrobbins

FOLLOW GREEN
 
 
  • Comments
  • 72
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
06:19 PM on 12/17/2012
This is why I love Australia and shop at both Coles and Woolworths, good on ya!
12:50 PM on 12/09/2012
Good job Australia!! Hopefully more countries will follow your lead. What's happening in the food industry these days should make you think twice before you buy/eat anything. Eat responsible!
02:59 PM on 12/01/2012
My God...I had no idea animals were kept in these conditions...plain wrong...if this video and article doesn't cause you to do further research and avoid factory farm products, I don't know what will.
02:04 PM on 11/28/2012
The animals singing broke my heart. Very nicely done. A very clever campaign.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
06:49 AM on 11/29/2012
if you want real singing animals look at mice. the babies sing for their mothers.

http://theconversation.edu.au/ordering-the-vegetarian-meal-theres-more-animal-blood-on-your-hands-4659
10:27 AM on 11/28/2012
Since learning of factory-farming, I have changed my food purchasing entirely. I can't ever support the torture of these poor animals. It makes me sick. I only buy eggs from a local farm where I can see the chickens running around, and I only buy meat from a small farm in Iowa that I trust is not torturing the animals. I pay a little bit more, but not a whole lot. If you don't know where your food is coming from, or what factory-farming is, please do the research on it. This is very important! We cannot accept treating animals in this manner. It is so wrong.
photo
Aarchon
from first principle
09:09 AM on 11/28/2012
Sunlight's the best disinfectant. Any time you see a group trying to keep what they're doing a secret, it's a sure sign they're up to something they know they shouldn't be.

What I don't understand is why the 'free market' types aren't the loudest when it comes to clear labeling and open practices. If the free market's supposed to decide, shouldn't it have access to all of the information?
photo
wisewiccan
Respect Existence or Expect Resistance
08:35 AM on 11/28/2012
PETA, what hypocrites! They are so worried about the farm animals, but they put 90% of the pets in their shelters asleep. They are against no-kill shelters, but when it comes to hogs and chickens being killed for food, they are totally against it.
07:03 AM on 12/03/2012
seriously? you see 'PETA' as the last thing listed (note - it was to download the veg starter kit, which helps your health, the environment and animals) and you latch onto that alone? this article is about factory farming, public attitudes toward horrendous cruelty to animals and a very special campaign by Animals Australia. Not PETA.

alot of people already know what you have pointed out. its why i support Mercy For Animals (in the US) instead of PETA, but why is this relevant to anything in the article? PETA had nothing (NOTHING) to do with this campaign.

perhaps reading beyond the word PETA next time will help you to see actual content rather than what fits your anti-PETA myopia.
08:30 AM on 11/28/2012
Doomed? Perhaps things are looking brighter on the Australian continent but in the US, profit will likely always dictate how we treat animals for consumption and......have you ever been to Asia? If you think anglos in Western society are calloused you haven't seen the indifference that most of the world treats their food with. Food animals are treated without sentimentality whatsoever in Asia, and that's the bigger picture
12:07 PM on 11/28/2012
All of it is the bigger picture. If the Western world wishes to help transform other countries into a democracy then they should start practicing what they preach. That most certainly means being more transparent. The "ag-gag" laws are not sound decisions. The public needs to see what is going on and what kind of treatment these animals are getting. Big business is out for profit no matter how it gets there. That is the most sad part is to be a "Christian" nation the love of the dollar takes precedence over how we treat each other (human) and our animals. All these weird laws - stand your ground, ag-gag etc are cold, dehumanizing laws that need to go from our society. Next stop employing people who have anger issues taking it out on defenseless beings.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Briteleaf
08:29 AM on 11/28/2012
Many people have not yet developed respect for other beings. Most don't know that pigs are the smartest domestic animals. They are more intelligent than dogs and horses. Like every other corporate ethic, profit rules that world. Aren't we naive to think that corporations that work people for minimum wage with no benefits and no retirement plans would care about the lives of animals?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frank
My last name is FRANK so thats what I am..
07:14 AM on 11/28/2012
If anyone wants to know how animals are treated watch the video "earthlings" available online for free viewing narrated by Joaquin Phoenix.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frank
My last name is FRANK so thats what I am..
07:12 AM on 11/28/2012
Factory farms are a disgrace to the human race and should all be closed, likewise all fur-farms should also be closed and using an animal for fur or skin should be illegal
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:17 AM on 11/28/2012
I agree about factory farms and fur farms in the West.

However, in parts of Russia it is fur farming or hunting. People live there and that is now the ONLY work, There are many completely broke, unemployed communities. The situation there is much more difficult. And in their winters, they need the fur they wear.
12:10 PM on 11/28/2012
I fanned and faved your comment! However, even for those who don't want to give up meat, at least employ better practices and conditions in the care of the animal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frank
My last name is FRANK so thats what I am..
12:19 PM on 11/28/2012
I agree. although I no longer eat meat it was hard to quit. Some people live in the middle of nowhere and have to hunt to live I understand that but most people do not need to eat meat. Respect for animals even if you are going to eat them is the key
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Ferris
05:42 AM on 11/28/2012
This is good news. Regardless of where you stand on meat (there's a tendency for this issue to get muddied by the issue of whether people should eat meat at all), everyone should agree that this is a step in the right direction.
The best way to get big companies to tow the line when it comes to animal welfare is to make it plain that it's a priority. People should be aware where their meat is coming from, and choose humane sources, even if that means paying more.
05:04 AM on 11/28/2012
I am so pleased to see Australia's premier supermarkets doing this.Funny the first news is in an American newspaper!
photo
averagezoe
Don't breed or buy while homeless animals die!
11:53 PM on 11/27/2012
Ocean Robbins, you are sadly mistaken when you claim that the cruelty inflicted on farm animals would lead to jail time if perpetrated upon a pet. Cruelty to animals is alive and well and runs rampant all across the United States and very few people ever get so much as a slap on the wrist. I have witnessed unspeakable animal abuse during the 28 years I've operated rescue groups - there is no recourse and no consequences and nothing is changing. So if abusing dogs and cats is an accepted and condoned practice, farm animals don't have a hope in hell to ever be treated humanely.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ocean Robbins
Author and speaker, www.oceanrobbins.com
01:05 AM on 11/28/2012
Well I am sad to hear that you are seeing so much cruelty. Of course, pets have no means to tell anyone what's happened to them, so I am sure that the vast majority of crimes go unpunished. But the laws are on the books, and at least that counts for something. http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/free-books/dog-book/chapter13-3.html We have to keep creating change for all the animals, including dogs and cats as well as farm animals. Thanks for doing what you can.
12:13 PM on 11/28/2012
What needs to be done in order for us to repeal the ag-gag laws on the books in the states mentioned in your article? Also how do we prevent other states from enacting those laws?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frank
My last name is FRANK so thats what I am..
07:18 AM on 11/28/2012
so true all animal cruelty should be an automatic felony with automatic prison time of at least a year AND also mental-health evaluations mandatory it makes me so sick and beyond rage to know what happens to so many animals (I've seen fur-farm video's, puppy torture, factory farm footage, etc..) If I could kill the people responsible I would happily do it to save the animals, no joke

.fanned and faved..
photo
averagezoe
Don't breed or buy while homeless animals die!
02:11 PM on 11/28/2012
If only that were so. Animal cruelty laws are on the books in every state; however, only a few of those states actually have organizations necessary for enforcement. If you've ever watched the show "Animal Cops," you get a pretty good idea where and who the enforcers are and also how limited their powers are. But I really appreciate your sentiments and I also agree with you about the usefulness of the bible. Fanned back.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VeganVal
Way too micro! Can't begin to tell you anything!
11:28 PM on 11/27/2012
I'm so glad that Australia is making all the wonderful changes that we can only dream of for now in the US. Livestock are not just property, they are living, breathing animals and deserve to be treated humanely. Just because you choose to eat meat, doesn't mean you choose for the animals to be treated inhumanely, do you ? But we do. You vote with what you eat, what you purchase, what you wear ..... And when we're ignorant to the issues affecting animals considered livestock, agri-business wins, and animals suffer. Let's speak out against cruelty to animals. Just because you eat meat, doesn't mean you're ok with the cruelty inflicted upon innocent animals. So let's join the organizations suggested by the author Ocean Robbins, and let's vow to help improve the lives of farm animals.
12:18 PM on 11/28/2012
Fanned and Faved.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:10 PM on 11/28/2012
Now if only my country (Australia) can do something real about the live animal export trade. The horrors inflicted upon sheep and cattle that leave our shores is almost unimaginable. Its bad enough that these animals suffer horribly en route to other countries, but on arrival they are tortured and mistreated. Anyone with any compassion should voice their concerns at every opportunity. I live on a main road where livestock pass regularly on their way to port and I am reduced to tears when I see how these animals suffer without having left our shores.