More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Pablo Alvarado

Pablo Alvarado

GET UPDATES FROM Pablo Alvarado

When War is Peace and 'Secure Communities' Means 'Deportation': Orwell as Advisor to the President

Posted: 03/28/11 11:01 AM ET

When President Obama visited my native country of El Salvador he spoke of legalization while back in the US Salvadorans like Maria BolaƱos face deportation.

Maria, like too many others, may be deported because of backward police work that booked her into a Prince George's County Jail in Maryland after she called for help during a domestic violence dispute.

She has no charges against her and has not been conviction of any crime. Yet, the County's participation in a finger-print sharing program that the federal government promotes as its primary tool to remove "high-level threats" is the reason she's now threatened with being separated from her infant daughter.

2011-03-28-Picture2.png

In a recent report, Prince George's County ranked #2 for counties deporting people with no criminal convictions via the "secure communities" program. In seeing those numbers, lawyer Bridget Kessler at Cardozo School of Law says they "raise how S-Comm may allow local police to cover up profiling and circumvent due process."

The President and the immigration agency under his authority have promoted themselves as the smarter, more focused enforcers. ICE came before Congress in 2008 to ask for funds for the newly minted "secure communities" program to "prioritize enforcement actions on those posing the greatest threat to public safety." On March 9th, 2011 ICE issued its latest press release about the program to announce that several counties in Iowa would benefit from their new ability to "remove aliens convicted of a crime."

The facts, however, show their emphasis is more on spin than safety. Just two days after the Iowa announcement, Director of the program, John Morton testified to Congress, "We do in fact remove non-criminals through Secure Communities."

Contrary to ICE's claims, a program that drives domestic violence survivors to stay with abusers rather than risk deportation at the hands of local law enforcement has nothing to do with improving our public safety.

The dishonest double-speak of Immigration and Customs Enforcement may not be new but it is consistent and costly.

In places like Boston, Massachusetts 1 in 2 people deported under the secure communities program have no criminal convictions whatsoever. Yet Congress is considering $64 million dollars of funding in next year's budget on the basis of its criminal-focused precision.

And last week, President Obama advocated for legalization to Salvadorans abroad, saying that the undocumented in the Unites States should have a pathway "to get right with the law." Yet, the program he champions results in the law sending chills through immigrant communities that wall us off from needed services and erodes public safety for all Americans.

While George Bush was advised by Dick Cheney, it seems like President Obama has been reading 1984.

If the President wishes for his platform to be anything other than Orwellian double-speak, he needs his domestic policies to match his statements abroad. To start, he should take a page from the bills in California and Illinois. Those states are moving legislation that would reign in the rogue enforcement agency, protect juveniles and victims of crimes, and prevent racial profiling. Even better, do as the Mayor of Providence and decide to opt-out of the program all together. He could use his executive authority to end the police/ICE collaborations that empower bogeymen turned Sheriffs to haunt our communities like Arpaio in Maricopa County.

Studies have shown that immigrant communities are among the safest in the country. We are honest, hard working people proud to contribute our work and our cultures to take the country forward. It turns out it is not immigrants who need to get "right with the law," its our President and his harmful policies that make us all less secure.

 

Follow Pablo Alvarado on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ndlon

 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
spytheweb
04:50 AM on 03/31/2011
These "illegals" know crossing the border is illegal, why else would they sneak across? They are rolling the dice and when they lose they get deported. When i go to Las Vegas and bet, and i lose i don't ask for my money back, because guess what? I ain't gettin it.

ICE is doing a good job and they will only get better. America has not the money to support foreigners and their children. If you do not have a passport and visa or proper paperwork, you will be deported, what's not to understand?
12:27 PM on 03/29/2011
If Secure Communities really wanted to focus on removing serious criminals from the US, it would focus on people who'd been convicted of something. Certainly not on women seeking help in situations of domestic violence. Undocumented presence is a civil offense, not a crime per se. Many of those present without docs might well have been admitted as refugees, if our gov't had its priorities on straight. What Obama said in El Salvador is right: We're all safer when our neighbors are decently treated and not living in fear. We need to do the just and human thing, and reform our immigration system. S. Comm is a big step in the wrong direction.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
spytheweb
04:58 AM on 03/31/2011
"reform our immigratioĀ­n system"? Mexico has twice as many of their citizens naturalized as US citizens than any other country, is this the part of immigration you want to reform? Or do you want to just let more in just because they don't feel like going through the paperwork or be inspected by health inspectors.

We should have national ID cards for all US citizens and anyone with one or passport and visa should be deported.
02:07 AM on 03/29/2011
I must add.......this guy is talking about no criminal convictions?

Being in a country illegally is a crime.

Okay, you don't need draconian punishments. But deportation for the crime of illegally entering America is quite fair and reasonable.

Just let somebody enter El Salvador illegally........
02:03 AM on 03/29/2011
IF she is here illegally, then she has no right to stay.

What don't you understand about being in a country illegally?

BTW: My family is part Hispanic with several immigrants.
All people should be treated fairly and decently.
Even illegal aliens deserve to be well treated and have access to legal representation.

But, why should illegal aliens be allowed to stay? Other countries, including Latin American countries deport illegal aliens. Why should America be any different?

Yes, even Hispanics can be against illegal immigration.
Though we may be sympathetic to their poverty.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sibyl9
Cloaking Device Engaged
09:46 PM on 03/28/2011
"Secure Communities" appears to be working. Considering that most women are killed or seriously harmed when they try to leave an abusive relationship, ICE is doing this woman a favor by getting her safely away and back to her family. Once this woman is back in El Salvador, where she belongs, she can request her government to assist her in getting back her child. One wonders why the illegals don't consider the ramifications of their actions before entering this country illegally.
07:19 PM on 03/28/2011
Someone in the country illegally was deported. That's what's supposed to happen.
06:19 PM on 03/28/2011
It should not matter whether there are criminal convictions against the person being deported, that they are illegally in this country is enough reason. Good for Secure Communities, now if we can just get e-verify mandated, it will help even more with getting people here illegally out of this country.