More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Pat LaMarche

Pat LaMarche

Posted: March 8, 2011 02:54 PM

Domestic Violence Victim Battles Fear After Attacker Released Early


Miranda walks everywhere she goes, and the whole while she holds her left arm out in front of her and across her face. Strapped to her wrist is a pepper spray atomizer. She doesn't put her arm down if she can help it -- no matter how many miles she needs to go.

The hardest part of writing stories about violence is interviewing the victims and knowing that there's nothing anyone can do to change the past.

The second hardest thing is picking the fake names.

I chose Miranda's name because of Shakespeare's The Tempest. Miranda's dad wanted to protect her from the harm that too often finds ordinary people. After a wild course of events, Miranda and her dad are marooned on an island. To the dad, the upside of their isolation is that Miranda seems safe from harm.

My Miranda has developmental delays. She's possibly the sweetest most darling fiftyish woman on the planet. If you believe in God -- and Miranda believes in him with all her heart -- then the argument could be made that Miranda's heavenly father isolated her from ordinary folks by marooning her on an intellectual island. She's permanently middle school-aged.

Miranda was a good kid both as a child and as an adult. She knew right from wrong, obeyed her parents and treated folks in a loving manner. The problem with the guiltless is that they don't always understand the guilty. Miranda became friends with Brutus, a boy younger in years but aged by cunning and venom.

Miranda believed that Brutus loved her right up until the day that he nearly beat her to death.

Miranda and Brutus met at work. She never thought her job was tedious. She liked packing boxes and getting them ready for shipment and her contentment with these mundane tasks gave her something many ordinary folks didn't have: a job with benefits. She even had health insurance and a savings account.

Brutus was an ex-con when he met Miranda. Miranda didn't know. She didn't ask him what he'd done in the past. And anyway, if she had wondered where he'd been all those years before they met he might have lied -- but the truth remained -- Brutus had been in and out of prison for beating women.

Brutus first attacked Miranda when they were at the car wash. A few months earlier Miranda had purchased the car and given it to him. Suddenly, unexpectedly, Brutus began choking her. He told her that he intended to kill her.

Something made him stop. Miranda doesn't remember what it was, but the car wash was a public place and now that she thinks back she thinks that he must've been afraid of being caught.

They returned to Brutus Mom's house where he lived. During my interview with Miranda, she tried to apologize for going back there with him. She explained that she "cared deeply" for him. And she certainly didn't expect to wake up the next day -- lying in bed with him -- with him slamming his fist into her face.

The beating coincided to the sound of the alarm clock ringing. So Miranda knew that Brutus started punching the left side of her face at exactly 6:15 a.m.

He started punching at 6:15 and didn't stop until he'd fractured her cheekbone. Miranda remembers vividly that he wanted her to stop screaming. To get her to stop Brutus pulled her up, got behind her and cupped her mouth and nose in the inside of his elbow. She thought he was trying to smother her. She dug her fingernails into his skin as hard as she could.

He let go and childlike Miranda, worried that she'd be late, washed her face and got ready for work.

Miranda's beating left her so dizzy she was barely able to walk. Brutus drove her to work and dropped her off. Within moments of punching the time clock, her floor manager told another employee to take Miranda to the emergency room. An hour later she was transported to nearest hospital with a head trauma unit.

Miranda was brave. She testified against her attacker in open court. Brutus received three years for the beating that permanently damaged her face. Miranda felt good about standing up for herself, and she didn't live in fear. Not until she saw Brutus on the street -- out on early release -- but no one had told Miranda.

That's when she got the pepper spray. When she knew that she couldn't trust the system any more than she could trust Brutus.

 
 
 
Miranda walks everywhere she goes, and the whole while she holds her left arm out in front of her and across her face. Strapped to her wrist is a pepper spray atomizer. She doesn't put her arm down if...
Miranda walks everywhere she goes, and the whole while she holds her left arm out in front of her and across her face. Strapped to her wrist is a pepper spray atomizer. She doesn't put her arm down if...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:04 AM on 03/09/2011
Domestic violence doesn't hurt just the victim. The hurt goes much deeper. The victim hurts for much longer after the fractures and bruises heal. Where does the blame go? How often does the victim internalize it? What about the family, parents, siblings, and especially, children. Children are the abuser's other victims. Just ask a child who grows up watching one parent use the other parent as a punching bag. That vision is permanently ingrained in the memory and impacts choices all life long. Our patriachal society needs to be less so and intervene to the same degree as if a man beats a stranger or another man.
03:33 PM on 03/08/2011
PS - I also told the Chief of Police that I had worked on the Governor's Council on Domestic Violence, and would be happy to contact both the state AG, whom I knew, as well as the state newspaper editor, whom I also knew. You shouldn't need clout to stop beatings.
03:32 PM on 03/08/2011
[con't] So did my daughter after her soon-to-be ex-husband beat her with his fists as he drove down country roads, finally threw her out on the side of the road and drove off. He came back 30 min later, hit her again, threw her into the car and drove home. She didn't leave him because he wouldn't move out of her house. What finally brought on the light was when he started punching her face at a local tavern and his workmate pulled him away and outside and told him that it wasn't ok. That isn't the end of it. She finally DID call the police to come get him and a new cop in town talked him out of the house and away...but didn't jail him.

The isn't the first time and he is out of the house. But I will tell you that I called the Chief of Police and told him that if he didn't get a cop to my daughter's house, I would sue him, the town and everyone I could find. He sent the cop.
03:31 PM on 03/08/2011
How easy it is to talk about false accusations and how women 'should be smarter' not that men shouldn't beat women. In fact, the detris of domestic violence begins with bullying and continues on its way through dating and socialization of women that men are 'just misunderstood.'

Wrong. What it takes is GOOD men, talking to any and all men about domestic violence. WHEN to intervene and HOW to intervene and that it is ok to tell you best buddy that he needs to quit slapping his girlfriend around; and it's ok to tell him that it makes him look weaker, that he beats women rather than confronting men. and last of all - training needs to be in junior high and high school, and funding shouldn't be cut so the football team can get a bus for out-of-town games. Because the remains of women like Miranda are everywhere and anywhere.

Ask me. I'm the parent of a daughter whose father rejected her because she 'wasn't a boy.' So every man she dated and both men she married pounded on her like she was a punching bag. And she got up, just like Miranda, washed her face, covered up her bruises and went to work. She lives in a small town with the same attitude as the one in MN that allowed a batterer to slit his ex-wife's throat and refused to jail him. That woman lived. [con't]
03:56 PM on 03/09/2011
Dear Figerre it so true men need to be taught that hands are not for hitting anyone ... especially women and children on the fl;ip side there are women who do this to people need to be taught that hitting others is not acceptable PERIOD!! BTDT as a child and as an adult .. not getting into my story toough I am msotly over it how aften does a person relive it ?? almost daily and definately after reading about more peopel it has happend to.. a victum of abuse never completely gets "over it". no amount of counseling willchange that. however great friends and couseling helps us move on.
11:02 PM on 03/10/2011
I think your right about education. Fixing every couples problems just isn't reasonable. We need to teach men that it isn't ok to hit women. We also need to teach women that being hit isn't ok. Unfortunatley most of the causes of violence of this nature stem from bad childhood experiences. If a childs parents arn't going to teach them these lessons, who will?