iOS app Android app

Patricia Zohn
GET UPDATES FROM Patricia Zohn
Patricia Zohn, Culture Columnist of the Huffington Post, is now in her ninth year of reporting from the CultureZohn.

Entries by Patricia Zohn

CultureZohn: The 2014 Venice Architecture Biennale, Parte Due

(0) Comments | Posted June 10, 2014 | 3:52 PM

Once you leave the main pavilion of the 2014 Architecture Biennale in Venice, all bets are off. Rem Koolhaas, the architect-curator, challenged the 66-plus countries that entered to respond to the prompt of absorbing Modernity 1914-2014, a giant mouthful of world wars and their spoils, and the hot potatoes of...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Fundamentals: The 2014 Biennale Strips Down

(0) Comments | Posted June 4, 2014 | 12:19 PM

I am staying in a Venetian hotel once the home of Alma Mahler, the woman who sent many talented hearts reeling and walking along the narrow often slightly off-fragrant Venetian streets that writer Mary McCarthy prowled when her love life was also a shambles so an invitation to write about...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Do All Women Really Behave That Way? Cosi Fan Tutte at the LA Philharmonic

(0) Comments | Posted May 28, 2014 | 11:58 AM

For the last three years, Gustavo Dudamel has been engaged in a project about architecture and opera that in any other city besides Los Angeles would cause a stampede at the box office. Even after years, many residents -- especially younger ones -- don't realize how hip things have gotten...

Read Post

CultureZohn: I Spent New Year's Eve With Richard Burton

(7) Comments | Posted January 10, 2013 | 9:32 AM

I spent New Year's Eve in bed with Richard Burton.

2013-01-06-Burton_Bookjacket.jpg

It had taken all fall to try to set this up and I even had to take a back seat to Lindsay Lohan but it was worth the wait. Still, it was awfully crowded...

Read Post

A Tale of Two Brides

(4) Comments | Posted October 9, 2012 | 3:07 PM

Last week, for the first time I can recall, the New York Times accepted and ran a wedding announcement with an image of a woman of Indian heritage displaying her navel and other comely attributes in a glittery, Bollywood-style gown.

Read Post

Culture Zohn: Don't Occupy: Dance!

(6) Comments | Posted August 14, 2012 | 8:43 AM

A man stands at the top of some steps and begins to sing a mournful tune. A wrist turns in on itself, fingers splayed like bird wings. Arms round high overhead, chest high, hips steady. First a heel, then a toe, then a whole foot set down on a small...

Read Post

Belle de Jour: Catherine Deneuve and Her Shades of Grey

(29) Comments | Posted April 2, 2012 | 10:46 AM

Catherine Deneuve was not, at the outset, my favorite French actress. Not as playful or sexy as Brigitte Bardot or soulful and Everywoman as Jeanne Moreau, she seemed much harder to connect with in her icy perfection. It was impossible to imagine acquiring Deneuve's carefully constructed beauty even...

Read Post

Jules and Jim -- and Catherine

(10) Comments | Posted January 23, 2012 | 7:16 AM

"You said to me: 'I love you.'
I said to you: 'Wait.'
I was going to say: 'Take me.'
You said to me: 'Go away.'"


A woman's voice -- urgent, husky and siren-like all at once -- is heard over a black screen. Suddenly cheerful music reveals a gay turn-of-the-century world. The wild mood swings of the first minute of Jules and Jim, Francois Truffaut's beloved New Wave creation hint at the complex tale about to unfold. The film, which has its 50th anniversary today, is as much a celebration of the unconventional love story as it is of film itself: the romantic pull of its triangle was matched with pure filmmaking panache, a valentine to love and friendship in all their complicated messiness.

2012-01-22-JulesandJim_image_1_600400.jpg

Oskar Werner as Jules (r), Jeanne Moreau as Catherine (c) and Henri Serre as Jim (l); Credit: Jules and Jim, Courtesy of the Criterion Collection

I first saw Jules and Jim at the Cinematheque in Paris where vintage films were shown strictly uncut and undubbed as their directors, or auteurs, originally envisioned them. I was in flight from my previous alt-selves -- sorority girl, political activist, rock and roller -- on a semester abroad. For two francs -- then around 20 cents -- I studied the New Wave cinema heroines, none more intriguing than Truffaut's Catherine, the earthy, pouty-lipped enigma who knew how to keep two men dangling simultaneously, hoping for clues to my own version original. Why, in Paris, even your knee had possibilities. (Eric Rohmer's Claire's Knee).

Truffaut called his film Jules and Jim after a novel he had fallen in love with which followed the volatile friendship of the men over the course of two decades, but I entered it through the portal of Catherine, who was its dangerous spark. It was Catherine who most drew your attention -- not just because of her sensual beauty but for the simple fact that you never knew what she was going to do next. Catherine was a modern woman who double-dared her lovers to meet her in a "no-woman's" land where she set the rules. How did Jeanne Moreau, the actress Truffaut said helped inspire him to make the film, infuse so much mystery and charm into the smallest look and gesture?

2012-01-22-JulesandJim_image_2_600400_2.jpg
Oskar Werner as Jules (r), Henri Serre as Jim (c), and Jeanne Moreau as Catherine (l); Credit: Jules and Jim, Courtesy of the Criterion Collection

Catherine and Patricia (from Jean-Luc Godard's Breathless) film-ended my stay in Paris -- one the essential Frenchwoman, the other the essential American girl (Truffaut had actually come up with the story for Breathless and given it to Godard). Truffaut and Godard believed that women could be powerful, independent and the object of grand desire, for whom men were willing to check their own needs at the door. But both heroines suffered from a malaise that also stalked me at the time: the fear of being shut inside a relationship and thus deprived of the possibilities of the rest of life.

Catherine was a new kind of femme fatale, not a blatant sex kitten like La Bardot, but one who could get away with wearing men's clothes and painting a mustache on her face and still be intensely feminine and sexually provocative. Like the character she admires in a play, she invents her life at every moment.



Perhaps, I fantasized along with thousands of other young women, by cutting bangs, wearing a rakish newsboy cap or a wide headband and an oversized boyfriend sweater I would somehow be infused with the essence of Catherine and could learn how to be in charge of my own destiny.

We learn the story of Jules, Jim and Catherine in the grisaille of grainy black and white still unmatched for its allure. The two men, writers, meet over the search for a costume. They bond over poetry and art, indifference to money, and especially over their love for women. Wrapped up in conversation with each other, they reclaim the possibilities of male friendship, as deep and engaging as that of any female BFFs. Catherine enters their life as a friend of a cousin of Jules (Oscar Werner), the German. It all begins playfully enough as the trio retreat to the sea and share other adventures. Jules adores her, and she marries him, but soon, Catherine's need for both men's undivided attention bubbles up. If they play cards, or talk late into the night, or in any way ignore her, she creates a disturbance -- jumping into the water, dressing up like a man, or playing tag. The thing is: she is never "it" but always the object of the chase. Jim (Henri Soule) wins her for a time, but it cannot last. Over the course of two decades until the eve of World War II, Catherine moves in and out of their affections -- and ours -- without regard for consequences. How did she get away with it, I asked myself? Truffaut didn't want the public to judge his characters but to show that sometimes, nobody is right. Still, at times Catherine seems horribly callous, playing with their affection for her.

2012-01-22-JulesandJim_image_600400_3.jpg
Jeanne Moreau as Catherine and Henri Serre as Jim; Credit: Jules and Jim, Courtesy of the Criterion Collection


"Man never owns anything for a very long time," Moreau later said in a remarkably candid Film Comment interview. "You lose everything, good and bad. If you have something that makes you happy, you'll lose it. If something happens to you that's painful, it won't last either."

A cache of letters released by the French Cinematheque from the book's author Henri Pierre Roche to Truffaut as well as annotated text including scripts, outlines, treatments, production images and video segments makes plain that just about everything in the long gestation of Jules and Jim was meticulously planned. The visually exciting archive shows Jeanne Moreau to be every inch the seductive actress and documents how much she, the novelist Roche, the screenwriter Jean Gruault, and the cinematographer Raoul Coutard were emotionally invested in the project and Truffaut's vision.

Truffaut, barely 30 when the film was released, describes a coup de foudre he had upon discovering the novel in a second hand shop, a thinly veiled story of Roche's relationship with a German couple, Helen and Franz Hessel, who had left a profound mark on the life of this renaissance-man/collector/artist/writer. He seems to also have fallen for Moreau, tracking her career and staying in regular touch with her for this and other projects.

Moreau -- who once told an interviewer sleeping with people was one of the best ways to get to know them -- was already recognized for her work in the theater and had played perfidious wives in Elevator to the Gallows and Les Amants (both films directed by Louis Malle with whom she was involved). After meeting Truffaut with Malle at Cannes, actor Jean Claude Brialy brought Moreau to the set of The 400 Hundred Blows as a surprise since he knew Truffaut admired her. Truffaut gave her a spontaneous walk-on in the film and gave her the Jules and Jim novel soon after for her reaction. She merely answered, "When do you wish to begin," becoming the project's muse.

"She gave me courage each time I was overwhelmed by doubt," said Truffaut. "Her qualities as an actress and a woman made Catherine real in our eyes, plausible, crazy, abusive, passionate, but above all loveable, in other words, worthy of adoration."

When she's not busy being a goddess, Catherine can be like like a willful child who uses sex and love instead of tantrums to test limits. Early on, Jules claims a woman's fidelity is the most important thing in any relationship. She reassures him after they marry that since she is very experienced with men and Jules less so with women, they will "cancel each other out." Yet later he gives her the freedom to do whatever she wishes as long as she stays in range; he can't bear the thought of her going away forever.

Jules: She is a force of nature, she expresses herself in cataclysms. Wherever she is, she lives surrounded by her own brightness and harmony, guided by the conviction of her own innocence.

Jim: You talk of her as if she were a queen.

Jules: But she is a queen. Catherine is neither particularly beautiful nor intelligent nor sincere but she is a real woman and she is woman we love and whom all men desire...

2012-01-22-JulesandJim_image_4_600400_4.jpg
Jeanne Moreau as Catherine; Credit: Jules and Jim, Courtesy of the Criterion Collection

Catherine has one child with Jules but wants another with Jim, something to anchor anew her restless spirit. Despite all this, Truffaut makes it believable: that two smart men would give over to this "force of nature" and tiptoe around her and try to accommodate her every wish because of their love and reverence for her as a wellspring of creativity -- and because they are petrified that something disastrous will happen.

Which it inevitably does.

Finally her testing the limits goes to its extreme and she invites Jim into her car and drives them off the bridge (supposedly the inspiration for Thelma and Louise's iconic ending).

Truffaut and the other directors of the New Wave were determined to move the needle away from the conventions of the 50s and gave their female characters the torch of independence, experimentation -- and a certain selfishness too -- to carry. He understood: these women were "easy to get, but hard to keep." I was not yet a wife or mother when I saw the film and so its message was particularly seductive.

Moreau told Film Comment, "Through me, Francois learned about women and through him I learned about cinema." Truffaut's instinct for great female characters was unerring, but he later ran from the rigid categorizations of the early feminists, "the way things are now would more likely make me want to chuck it all."


2012-01-22-CINETRUFFAUT1.jpg

Francois Truffaut and Jeanne Moreau; Photo copyright Raymond Cauchetier, courtesy of the photographer


I sought out Jeanne Moreau, whose 84th birthday is also today, for a recent comment about the film, but she demurred.

She wrote me, "I am very sorry but I am working on three projects and my mind is not going back to the past."

In the Film Comment interview, however, when she was trying to separate out her career from the famous auteur for whom she had been a muse and make her own way as a director -- she was less reticent.

"When I made Jules and Jim, said Moreau: "I was at that age where one lives very egocentrically; I saw it as the chance of a lifetime a chance to escape the 'star' style... all of a sudden we were filming in the street with very little makeup, costumes you found yourself. No one was telling me anymore, "You have circles under your eyes, your face is lopsided" -- suddenly it was life. And I felt that if I was going to thrive and have fun working in front of the camera, it would be like this."


2012-01-22-CINJJ_2.jpg

Francois Truffaut and Jeanne Moreau; Photo copyright Raymond Cauchetier, courtesy of the photographer


Moreau said that the communication between herself and Truffaut "was very intimate, but we didn't use words."

"Real directors don't try to influence you," she claimed, "but allow you to flourish."

Raymond Cauchetier, now 92, the talented on-set photographer of many of the most important New Wave films whose name is regrettably less known, captured this intimacy in these previously unpublished photographs. An exhibition of his iconic images will appear in Los Angeles in March at the Motion Picture Academy.


2012-01-22-CINJJ_3.jpg

Francois Truffaut and Jeanne Moreau; Photo copyright Raymond Cauchetier, courtesy of the photographer


Catherine and Patricia and the other New Wave heroines lingered in my imagination. One of my very first assignments at The New York Film Festival was to pick Truffaut up at the airport with my mentor -- and best friend -- from the office. We wore pleated mini skirts, remembering that in La Peau Douce, one of Truffaut's earliest films, Nicole (Francoise Dorelac, Catherine Deneuve's younger sister who died tragically young in a car accident) changes into a skirt when her lover Pierre tells her he prefers them. We primped and giggled all the way out to JFK in the back of the limo, but the prospect of Truffaut's discerning eye on me made me both nervous and hopeful: would he be able to tell if one day I could be a force of nature too?


At one point when the men who love her are thrust together again, Catherine sings a song -- "Le Tourbillion de la Vie" -- to the assembled hopefuls, each of whom hangs on her every word.

"We escaped from each other,
We lost each other,
We found each other again,
It's the whirlwind of life."

I sing this song to myself when I want to remember too, the no-holds-barred spirit of Jules and Jim and Catherine that once propelled me forward into life.

The marvelous double disk set from Criterion is a worthy investment for those who wish to discover or rediscover the film. The extraordinary Zoom on the film on the website of the Cinematheque Francaise, is a gift for those who can read French; this site is the most elegant and informative website of ANY I have consulted; the book by Henri Pierre Roche is available on Amazon; Two in the Wave, a touching documentary about Truffaut and Godard is now streaming on Netflix. Raymond Cauchetier's more recent work is discussed in this article (also in French). My own story about Breathless and Godard appears here on the Huffington Post.


...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Rebekah Brooks and the Cult of Power

(2) Comments | Posted July 19, 2011 | 6:16 PM

2011-07-19-1860_rossetti_bocca_1000.jpg2011-07-19-rebekahbrooks.jpg
Image : Dante Gabriel Rossetti, Bocca Baciata, courtesy of Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

If life can be said to imitate art, then sometimes it takes your breath away.

Take, for example, the recent exhibit of The...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Tina Fey Is the New Harry Potter

(1) Comments | Posted April 26, 2011 | 5:14 PM

2011-04-26-12647947001454311303boyreadingmd.jpgLast night after a long weekend with two of my boys and their families in Seattle, I got on the plane, ready to collapse from too many carb bombs (purple and green jello eggs, coconut bunny cake with whiskers etc). As...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Jane Eyre, a Heroine for the Ages

(24) Comments | Posted March 10, 2011 | 9:22 AM

2011-03-09-new1.jpg



Another version of Jane Eyre is an occasion for celebration, both an opportunity to revisit the previous versions and even more delightfully, the complicated, romantic novel by Charlotte Bronte that is their dramatic underpinning. What an excellent reminder that certain historical heroines...

Read Post

Culture Zohn Off the C(H)uff: David Seidler Protects and Defends The King's Speech

(18) Comments | Posted February 11, 2011 | 9:22 AM

David Seidler has been mother and nursemaid to The King's Speech, a project he began thinking about while in college and which finally came to theaters in 2010, over 50 years later; he is still fiercely protective of it.

And the history of the film as he tells it...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Poser, My Life in Twenty-Three Yoga Poses

(3) Comments | Posted January 28, 2011 | 10:12 AM

2011-01-26-poser.jpgIt was when Claire Dederer, author of Poser, My Life in Twenty-Three Yoga Poses, was shaking in the Lord of the Dance pose that our spirits finally joined together on the blonde wood floors that had become her proving ground: suffering...

Read Post

Broadcast News: Love, Truth and Television

(20) Comments | Posted January 18, 2011 | 9:58 AM

2011-01-18-broadcastnews1.jpg
"Albert Brooks, Holly Hunter and William Hurt in Broadcast News."


Broadcast News, the 1987 film that captured the battle over the soul of news and the women and men who delivered it, enters the Criterion Collection as the...

Read Post

CultureZohn: I Spent New Year's Eve in Bed With Keith Richards

(30) Comments | Posted January 5, 2011 | 2:40 PM

I spent New Year's Eve in bed with Keith Richards.

2011-01-05-keith2.jpg


It was so cozy. The monsoon-like rain was coming down outside but there we were under my white down duvet getting it on like it was 1970 all over again.

Every once...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Fathers and Daughters Meet in Newer Wave Somewhere

(4) Comments | Posted December 16, 2010 | 10:12 AM

2010-12-15-oneShtMD.jpg

Though ostensibly from the perspective of Johnny (Stephen Dorff), a successful but dissipated actor who lets life happen to him, Somewhere is in truth another welcome, clear-eyed view of a girl's coming-of-age, something of a Sofia Coppola specialty, showcasing the alternately powerful and powerless...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Balenciaga at the Spanish Institute

(2) Comments | Posted December 10, 2010 | 9:27 AM

You ascend to the first floor of the Spanish Institute and enter a hushed, carpeted salon, the pale gray of the walls and an even paler wainscoting a serene respite from worrying about tax cuts extensions, transporting you from the wind chill of a blustery December...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Black Swan, Or Letting Your Inner Bad Girl Out

(0) Comments | Posted December 3, 2010 | 9:31 AM

2010-12-02-prance.jpg

Natalie Portman as Nina in Black Swan by Niko Tavernise.


At the heart of Darren Aronofsky's melodrama Black Swan about a desperate ballerina is not so much a movie about winning and competition, though it is partially that, but more...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Sarah Palin, Ain't no mountain high enough

(36) Comments | Posted November 15, 2010 | 7:30 AM


Twice before I have had to claim Sarah Palin as a cultural icon to get her into my column, but now that she is a new reality star, a...

Read Post

CultureZohn: Johnny STOP!

(3) Comments | Posted November 12, 2010 | 9:10 AM

It is more than fitting that Larry Gagosian's exhibition of Johnny Pigozzi's Johnny STOP! sits atop the dealer's Madison Avenue gallery's exhibitions of John Currin and Pablo Picasso, as there is something kindred in these three men who obviously love women and are not...

Read Post