More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul Abrams

Paul Abrams

Posted: October 14, 2010 01:39 PM

Chilean Miners vs. Wall Street

What's Your Reaction:

Although President Obama describes the Republicans has having driven the car of the US economy into a ditch, perhaps a more apt analogy is a collapse of a gold/copper mine. The miners (Wall Street but without its culpability) were rescued by a massive effort, with everyone working together and with appropriate oversight.

The miners patiently waited for nearly 70 days. As rescue approached, they argued over who would be -- last. The miners and families demonstrated solidarity and deep appreciation.

While waiting for rescue, they decided to make a pact. No one would benefit from their experience without all the others benefiting as well. They even had a legal document prepared that they each signed.

Contrast Wall Street. Just for starters, has a single major bank or banker ever even thanked the people of the United States for their rescue? If so, it has escaped my eyes and ears.

Wall Street's behavior has certainly not provided any evidence of gratitude. They even thought it was proper to pay themselves large bonuses with US taxpayers' money. Using taxpayers' money to pay an army of lobbyists, Wall Street fought financial reform designed to reduce the chances that their behavior could tank the entire economy again. And, of course, they successfully fought a tiny "FAT" (financial activities tax) that would have provided money from their enormous profits to reduce our budget deficit, or invest in long-term projects that would have enduring value (like the Grand Coulee Dam in Washington State, built during the Great Depression).

Had the Koch Boys or Lloyd Blankfein been with the trapped miners, would either of them have tried to be rescued last? Would they have signed a pact so that they all benefited from subsequent "deals"? Would they have agreed to limit their food intake so that everyone could survive?

On the other hand, just think of where the US could be now if Wall Street, and people like the Koch Boys, had the same character as the Chilean miners.

America could be at work on building a solid foundation for its future, rather than hurtling toward a mythic view of its past. And, no, to knee-jerk rightwingers, this is not a suggestion for "communism", the Koch Boys' fortune arose from Daddy's relationship with Josef Stalin, so that is hardly a direction I suggest we head. Just a "new deal" for the American middle class is all I am talking about.

Before voting this November, Americans ought to give serious thought to whether they want to elect people who will operate in the spirit of the Chilean miners, or of Wall Street and the Koch Boys.

If it is the latter, than one wonders just why you cheer the Chilean miners.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Cactusman
Persons of Cactus, Unite!
04:38 AM on 10/15/2010
"Contrast Wall Street. Just for starters, has a single major bank or banker ever even thanked the people of the United States for their rescue? If so, it has escaped my eyes and ears."

NPR's program "This American Life" did a segment a few weeks ago titled "Crybabies" about just exactly this phenomenon. The Planet Money Team went into a few bars in NYC to interview Wall Street financiers in their off time on the public perception of their profession, after they'd consumed a few beers. Apparently the hoi-polloi are treating them "like pinatas."

The consensus amongst all the interviewees featured was that they'd kept their banking/finance jobs because they were smarter, better, and more deserving than the average person. It was pointedly NOT because they were bailed out by taxpayers who propped up their banks, businesses, and brokerages, rescuing them from certain doom in the so-called "free market with negative consequences" that the rest of us must negotiate with decreasing amounts of help and minimal to no resources. Nope. They kept their jobs because they're blessed. Unbeeffinlievable.

The "Crybabies" title came because these parasites are unhappy with the fact that the rest of the nation sees them as sickening warts, cancerously draining energy and resources from the real economy most of us live in and concentrating it at the top.

No gratitude needed or implied by the Wall Streeters. They're doing God's work after all. The rest of us can go...
03:04 AM on 10/15/2010
"Had the Koch Boys or Lloyd Blankfein been with the trapped miners, would either of them have tried to be rescued last?"

Gee I don't know. But what if it had been George Soros? (Oh wait, we already know what he's made of from his time as a kapo in the concentration camps, selling out his own people.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edward Standley
opinionated jerk
11:30 PM on 10/14/2010
Speaking of Wall Streeters and the Koch bros., has that hole been welded shut yet?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marcello Rollando
The Reasonable Voice
07:53 PM on 10/14/2010
It’s the wrong time for the “Right†road of Michelle Malkin, thumping our national chest in self-adulation, better to turn to road less travelled by us as a nation. The honest and gracious choice is to share this moment as an equal with the world, for “No Man is an Island,†neither Chile nor a Divided States of America. Canada, Germany, Argentina, Spain and South Africa stood beside us in this international finest hour, in which Chileans and all of humankind married faith in God, human decency & ingenuity and Medical Science, in a triumvirate Katrina victims needed in place of a fly-over. Ah, if only President Sebastian Pinera had been in the Big-Easy. Like Haitians singing praises amidst the rubble, our “little brown brothers†have shown all who see without conceit, global unity begins with National unity and International citizenship is victory over national self-delusions.

A Nation’s honor is defined whether it saves lives or wars for profit. Let’s grow up to be like General Don Luis, Jeff Hart, President Pinera and Michelle Rhee who rescues children’s lives in DC. Being too “Right†does not a Great America, make.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cleverboots
04:02 PM on 10/14/2010
For rapacious, dirty tricks brigade, think Boehner, McConnell, Tea Party and vote "no."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul Abrams
02:08 AM on 10/15/2010
Boehner hands out tobacco lobbying checks to his colleagues, and funds "Nazi dress up" candidates for Congress.
And, this person may be Speaker! What a desecration of that job.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cleverboots
09:00 AM on 10/15/2010
John Boehner's behavior is disgraceful. While I don't like Nancy Pelosi(for taking impeachment off the table for Bush & Cheney among other things) I don't know that she is representing lobbyists while on the public paroll. I'm not a Pelosi fan, but hope she rather than Boehner is Speaker of the House. Thanks for your response to my post! Cleverboots
photo
dfranz
With Liberty and Justice for all
03:45 PM on 10/14/2010
The Koch brothers were raise by a father who was one of the founders of the John Birch Society. It was so fringe back then that it was considered a joke by most people. Using the money and power they inherited they are doing everything they can to make his dream of a government free country a reality. That's why their support of the Tea Party was a no brainer for them. All they needed to do was throw money at a bunch of bigots and some American flags and presto, the John Birch Society is a reality.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edward Standley
opinionated jerk
11:37 PM on 10/14/2010
Found the Birch Society manifesto in a $2.00 box of garage sale books. Crazy stuff.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul Abrams
02:15 AM on 10/15/2010
From what I have read about the history of the time, they were not so isolated as you say, until William F Buckley Jr, who wanted an honest conservatism, basically had them booted to the fringe. When a KKKer was running for office as a Republican, the Party denounced him and distanced themselves from him.
I truly wonder what WFB,Jr, would say if he were alive today. Although I think he was nearly wrong about nearly everything, I would like to believe that he would have found the modern-day John Birchers, aka Tea Party leaders, to be unacceptable, unless he could justify a faustian bargain that would accept intelletual dishonesty to achieve what he called the purpose of conservatism, "to stand athwart history".
The Koch Boys' father made their initial fortune helping Josef Stalin. Switching to Birchism is not a surprise. Studies of fanatical left and fanatical right wingers show they are quite similar. The ideas are of less importance than the blind faith to which one can adhere to them, the comaraderie that one can feel, and the ability to spin conspiratorial yarns about the rest of the world arrayed against them.