iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Paul Harvey
 
GET UPDATES FROM Edward J. Blum
 

Why No One Cares About the White Jesus of Mitt Romney's Mormonism

Posted: 09/09/2012 9:25 am

During the middle of the Civil Rights movement, Mormons placed an 11-foot-tall white Jesus with an exposed powerful chest at the center of Salt Lake City. Christus, as he was originally called, was raised in 1966, but he was based upon an old Danish statue from 1821. Since '66, Christus has become a staple of Mormon iconography placed primarily in "welcome centers" all throughout the nation. He became even more poignant of a symbol after 1978, the year Mormon leadership lifted its bans on people of color from the priesthood. Blacks, Pacific Islanders and others were technically welcome in the church, but they first had to pass by the powerful white Christus.

In 2008, Jeremiah Wright's sermons about a black Jesus killed by white Romans (and its obvious analogues to present-day politics) nearly derailed his former parishioner Barack Obama's candidacy. The white Jesus of Mitt Romney's Mormon culture, by contrast, has raised no cultural firestorm. It is hardly even noticed.

So why doesn't the history of Mormonism's white Jesus spark controversy as Wright's claims about Jesus being black? Why aren't there reporters scoping about trying to understand the particular looks of Mormon Christ figures. Why did Jeremiah Wright's jeremiads and visions of a black Jesus so terrify Americans in 2008, and denunciations of black liberation theology and Obama's supposed connection to it continue to be a staple of conservative talk radio to the present day, while the powerful white imagery of the Jesus of Romney's Mormon faith arouse no interest?

Simply put: the black Jesus of American history historically has been threatening, while white Jesus imagery, at least since about the 1830s, has been so normative and dominant that it is assumed to be accurate. Historically, America's Jesus has been white without words, because whiteness needs no description. It is blackness, of the kind so prominently displayed by Jeremiah Wright's sermons replayed in 2008, that anger and trouble people, and thus need explanation.

Yet just as Wright's black Jesus had a history the media explored and tied to black liberation theology, Mormonism's white Jesus has a history connected not only to European-American assumptions that Jesus was white, but also to Mormonism's particular history. Joseph Smith didn't just translate the Book of Mormon, which contained prophecies and stories of Jesus that went well beyond traditional Christianity and that brought Christ to the Americas 1,400 years before Christopher Columbus. The young prophet also wrote of visions he had of God and Jesus. Throughout the 1830s and early 1840s, he strained to find the most accurate phrases to describe his visions In 1832, Smith recorded how he saw an "indescribable" Jesus who came in a pillar of fire and a blinding light. By the mid-1840s, the indescribable became describable. Blinding light was edited into pristine white. Smith told a follower in 1844 that Jesus had a "light complexion [and] blue eyes."

Even though Smith was in many ways an outsider in his times, his rendering of Jesus as a white man was part of a broad and sweeping transformation in pre-Civil War. He and his new church were present at and participated in the birth of the white American Christ, a move that defied the Puritan's iconoclasm of the decades and centuries before.

During the initial years of the 19th century, Americans for the first time mass-produced images of Jesus and sent them throughout the young and expanding nation. A robust industry of Jesus imagery emerged. The pictures stamped onto American minds the notion of an embodied, white Jesus. It was in these years that Jesus was first born as a sacred symbol within the United States.

From those years through the 20th century, Mormons and most white Americans depicted Jesus as white. Even after the Civil Rights Movement and globalization have forced Americans to recognize that Jesus was not white, it has not stopped the Son of God from being depicted as white on books, posters, air balloons, T-shirts and movies. In the decades since the 1960s, white Christians have been able to divorce word from image. In essence, they could sanctify whiteness with their white Jesus without saying a word.

No group performed the rhetoric-vs.-image magic better than the LDS. In 1978, they finally caved in to civil rights demands to desegregate the church and opened the priesthood to blacks. Ostensibly, this meant that blacks could become members of the church and hold positions of authority. But as it gave with one hand, the Mormon leadership took with another. In 1969, John Scott painted his "Jesus Christ visits the Americas." It was an instant hit that featured Jesus with blond hair and fair skin. He showed his wounded hands to Anglo-looking Native Americans who bowed, wept and marveled at his power. The women wore skirts and dresses that came straight from the 1960s, while the men displayed their muscular physiques. This presentation of the white Jesus and his relationship to white Native Americans became so popular that Mormon leadership had it featured in The Book of Mormon they put in hotel room dresser drawers. This was also the time when the Christus became popular.

Once born as a sacred symbol during the same years Joseph Smith and his Mormon church developed their image of Christ, the white Jesus grew to be an omnipresent part of 20th-century American popular culture. Founded (in part) by Puritans who opposed any envisioning or imagery of Jesus, America later became the greatest exporter of Jesus imagery in the world. And that imagery historically has been of the same kind of white Jesus envisioned by Smith and reproduced in countless lithographs, paintings and .jpg files since.

Even in the age of multiculturalism and a plethora of challenges to the historic iconography of the American Jesus, the white Jesus remains the norm, unnoticed and uncontroversial. For many, by contrast, the black Jesus remains the outsider, the threat, one that required Obama's full persuasive talents in reassurance in 2008 to overcome. Mitt Romney will be spared any such media firestorm.

Edward J. Blum and Paul Harvey are the authors of 'The Color of Christ: The Son of God and the Saga of Race in America' (2012).

 
 
 
FOLLOW RELIGION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 300
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
11:04 PM on 10/16/2012
The Christus statues are white because they are made of marble. (Well, duh!) No-one, except perhaps a few really unimaginative Huffers, genuinely believes that they are supposed to represent His actual skin colour, any more than thousands of other marble sculptures, mostly hewn by olive-skinned Mediterranean sculptors, are supposed to represent the colours of their subjects.

The Christus statues are, as the authors almost but not quite managed to avoid mentioning, copies of a famous original by Danish sculptor Bertel Thorvaldsen.

No-one has to "pass by" any of those statues to join the Church. "Blacks, Pacific Islanders and others" are not merely "technically welcome in the church," they are welcome, period. And in fact, they are the majority where I live.
02:11 AM on 10/03/2012
The notion that the denunciation of Jeremiah Wright comes from his advocacy of a black Jesus is nonsense. It's because of his summary statement "G-D America."
Pastor Wright's summation resonates - not because of race but because we are a nation of violence and might makes right, on all fronts.
07:19 AM on 09/18/2012
It's a historic fact that Jesus Christ was a Jew, which meant that he was not black. As much as the author is enamoured with a black Jesus, it doesn't make it so. Perhaps Jesus' skin was brown from spending so much time outdoors, but he was not African. The fact that the Mormon statue of Jesus is white is a moot point. What about all the other Jesus statues in the world, from hundreds of other Christian religions? You can criticize Mitt for being Mormon, but if this is the best you can come up with, then you haven't dug very deep.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dave dbo
the truth needs no varnish
09:33 AM on 10/21/2012
I was waiting to read the authors argue that jesus was black; they didn't. The farthest they went was imply that we don't know his skin color. We do. He was a Jew. And as far as I can see, Jews are NOT black. At least, not the Jews who lived in Israel at the time of Jesus.
We ought to stop this nonsense of seeing racism behind every work of art.
Having said that, very few Caucasians are white in the real sense of the term; most are pink in color. In the same vein, most black people are, in fact brown, not black. But we all understand what we mean when we call people Whites or Blacks. In that context, Jesus was white. And Cristus, apart from being made of marble, bears the closest approximation to the color of Jesus' skin.
05:44 PM on 10/21/2012
Agreed. Some people want to find racism in everything, or anti-feminism or whatever is the fashionable *ism to hate at the time. I heard a quote yesterday: "Jesus was too conservative for the liberals & too liberal for the conservatives. He was neither liberal or conservative, because he was spiritual." Let's keep our facts straight and recognize him who he was, that he did not come here to identify with or promote a political party or cause. He simply wanted to tell people about his Father, and show us what he was like.
04:36 PM on 09/17/2012
BTW, This should not be referenced on the Christianity page.
10:12 PM on 09/15/2012
While I wouldn't agree with the titular hyperbole "why no one cares" (obviously at a bare minimum the author cares or he wouldn't have written the piece), I would say that unless you are affected by the fringe cults of Jeremiah Wright on the one side or Mormonism on the other, it really doesn't matter how they portray Jesus. From an iconographic standpoint, Jesus has been portrayed as an African in the early Ethiopian, Coptic and Sudanese(Meroe) churches since the first Milenium. At the time of the Roman empire, Jesus was portrayed in all shades and colors (a reflection of the Roman Empire's ethnic makeup itself, which an uneducated Jeremiah Wright fails to understand). The blond Jesus has been a staple of Northern European iconography (look at any painting on this theme by Durer) since the early middle-ages, so contrary to this article, it certainly predates the 19th century. The point SHOULD be that the message of Jesus is universal; we (meaning all of humanity) can claim Him as "one of ours" in renditions in iconography, however historically innacurate.
07:36 AM on 09/25/2012
Your comments are right on point. If you go to any church, the image of Jesus reflects their ethnicity or culture. There is nothing inherently wrong with that of course unless the image is used to encourage racial equality/inequality.
Your last point is the most important, "Jesus is universal", he came into the world for all of humanity, seeking to save the lost,the message of love and peace and the gift of salvation. PEACE
05:40 PM on 09/15/2012
Every Religious Belief in the world have an uneasiness that something is about to happen. Most have the thought of THE END. Mormons believe that Mitt Romney will be the one to welcome Jesus Christ back to earth , as he is in the Priesthood, and that The New Jerusalem will be in Independence USA also they will then be the Chosen People . [ Doctrine and Covenants 57: 3-19 Book of Mormon Ether 13: 3-18] The Moon Empire Financial Empire is pale in comparison to this one that has been growing since the 1800's. This Cult has fooled people by it's "nice people" mentality Brain washing at it;s finest.
05:25 PM on 09/15/2012
True most Mormons are "nice" deceived people. This has been the secret to their thriving. Different from other Cults they are deceived people with this peace loving group. They have grained their Wealth from these people by brain washing about tithing. it went from ONE Tithe 10% to many different Tithes. Tithes such as Tithing in Kind for Tax evasion from the Government. Tithing REQUIRED to be up to date if you want to enjoy Temple benefits. The worst thing our Government has ever done was allow Churches have access to Tax Free status. You have to be Mormon to go to their store houses . Other Big Churches have have people donate their time to help the poor and beg for donations for food and clothing . WHERE'S the Money ? In the Leaders Pocket.
12:24 AM on 09/14/2012
Mormonism, Jehovah Witnesses, Scientology, they are all cults. They do not worship the same Jesus that Christians do. They love to twist to confuse people. However, Mormons are nice people.
12:43 AM on 09/13/2012
Was this article originally written in crayon? They shouldn't have left out the stick figure drawings that, I'm sure, came with it. I'll bet they were enlightening.

Of course, HuffPo probably had put a big smiley face and an "Awesome" written in red pen at the top. Maybe even a gold star.
02:07 AM on 09/12/2012
white guy in the middle east how did that happen?
09:13 AM on 09/13/2012
Miracle birth.
02:04 AM on 09/12/2012
it took two fools to write this
photo
xxixpines
Truth often causes wailing and gnashing of teeth
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arcanumseeker
Is it schizoid paranoia or just existential blues?
01:32 AM on 09/12/2012
That Mormon Jesus sure isn't anything like the Jesus from the New Testament. Hmmm.... I wonder why that is?
photo
xxixpines
Truth often causes wailing and gnashing of teeth
09:02 AM on 09/12/2012
They are not one and the same,but in the attempt to go mainstream, mormon will insist they are the same.
sugacan1
Expect the BS, but NEVER accept it!
01:38 AM on 09/12/2012
Wow! Unbelievable that this is not being talked about more. Really makes me wonder about all those people of color in the "I'm a Mormon" commercials. Thanks for the link. F&F!
photo
xxixpines
Truth often causes wailing and gnashing of teeth
09:01 AM on 09/12/2012
One does wonder.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cheryl tobin
Alpha Dog with my pack!
12:07 PM on 09/11/2012
Not only is Jesus white he now only likes rich people and thinks the poor, the sick and the elderly should go get a job!
10:03 AM on 09/11/2012
All religions have sftuff that seems weird and goofy to those that don't adhere to it. Did Jesus really walk on water? Did Mohammed really fly off to Jerusalem on a winged horse? Did wild animals really line up to lap milk from Buddha's bowl? The Mormons have some hard to swallow beliefs for us agnostics, but no stranger than any other religion.

Trying to establish the meme that they are teetotaling racist polygamist weirdos in order to paint Romney as "the other" is a disgraceful and hypocritical tactic, especially from people who have (rightly) made a cottage industry of decrying similar behavior when it's aimed at Obama.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlairCase
09:23 AM on 09/11/2012
The American public was angered at Jeremiah Wright's anti-American statements, not his vision of Jesus, but their condemnation of Wright was mild to their comdemnation of Joseph Smith. An angry mob murdered Smith in 1844.
photo
xxixpines
Truth often causes wailing and gnashing of teeth
09:09 AM on 09/12/2012
Oh please do tell us more of that flowery verbal martyr story!
09:17 AM on 09/13/2012
Chased down after messing around.