iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul Rieckhoff

GET UPDATES FROM Paul Rieckhoff
 

If the Giants or Pats Get a Parade, Shouldn't Iraq Vets?

Posted: 02/02/2012 7:03 pm

The ticker-tape parade is a slice of Americana as old as the Statue of Liberty. It's an honor reserved for a select few (sort of), from astronauts returning from space to military heroes to beloved politicians like Teddy Roosevelt. It's also happened for baseball player Sammy Sosa, and even the President of Indonesia. This weekend, either the New England Patriots or New York Giants will earn the title "champion" at the Super Bowl, and be treated to a victory parade in Boston or New York City as a result.

Getting Super Bowl-champ football players a parade in their hometowns is never an issue. But Iraq War veterans? They deserve a little praise, too. They answered our country's call, and in the least, they survived. But for some reason, they're running into all kinds of resistance. Last week, New York City's Mayor Bloomberg said that a parade "would be premature while so many troops are still in harm's way around the world."

After eight years of war there that saw over 4,400 American troops killed and over 32,000 wounded-in-action physically, the Iraq War finally ended on December 31, 2011. Yet, only St. Louis has held a "Welcome Home Our Heroes"parade to date -- and solely because two guys launched a Facebook page and motivated a grassroots group of citizens. In less than a week it morphed into an incredibly inspiring event. And it definitely lit a spark. Ever since then, we've been inundated with notes and emails from folks from San Francisco to Portland, Maine who want to do the same thing for the Iraq veterans in their communities.

That's why today IAVA is calling on the president, New York Mayor Bloomberg and Boston Mayor Menino, and mayors and government officials nationwide to coordinate a National Day of Action to not only welcome home Iraq veterans but to channel critical jobs, education and transition resources to them and their families. It's a chance for all of us to work together -- just like we do on Veterans Day. Let's tap into the tremendous Sea of Goodwill that exists in the hearts of millions of Americans. Let's use some of our military experience to "coordinate fires." And instead of cities nationwide promoting events at different times over the next few years, let's all work together to coordinate a single, historic, transformative day to unite communities nationwide. If you stand with us, and want to see a welcome home parade in your area, stand with our veterans and sign our petition here.

For the mayors of New York and Boston: are you really okay with your football teams getting ticker-tape parades and not your new veterans? I am as big a fan as they come, but why do the Giants get a parade in the Canyon of Heroes and not our nation's military? If that does happen, what does that say about us as a society and our priorities?

Yes, Iraq and Afghanistan are two different wars. Americans know the Afghanistan front still rages on, with the end of combat operations not expected until 2013. But that doesn't mean our country can't start welcoming home those who have already returned and pave the way for those still to come. It will also show our troops in Afghanistan now that they won't be forgotten when that war ends too. And the expense should not be an issue. Just like in St Louis, sponsors should step up, and local people can chip in to donate goods, time and money.

If we can afford two wars, we can afford two welcome home parades.

But this effort is about more than just a parade. It is what parades represent -- a celebration, a commemoration, and an expression of gratitude by a community that has finally learned to separate the war from warriors. It is about creating a day to remember those we've lost, respect those who have served, and respond to their needs as returning veterans. After a decade at war, with the burden of so many carried by so few, who deserves a parade more than the brave men and women who have deployed two, three, four times since 9/11?

The New Greatest Generation has proven time and time again that they are dedicated to service. Now, it's on us to return the favor.

Even if you don't have skin in this Super Bowl game, sign IAVA's petition to the president and mayors nationwide before kickoff this Sunday at 6:30pm EST, calling for a national day to honor and celebrate the service of some real heroes -- the over 1 million veterans who have served our country in Iraq.

No matter who you root for this Super Bowl Sunday, our veterans are one team every American can and must get behind.

Crossposted at IAVA.org

 
 
 

Follow Paul Rieckhoff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/PaulRieckhoff

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 274
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
10:00 PM on 02/24/2012
The fact of the matter is veterans don’t need parade, or any sort of celebration, they need help with medical bills, finding jobs, and any kind of support we can give them. Veterans have sacrificed a lot for this country and no matter if you like or dislike the Iraq war you have to respect them for what they have done. But not only give that respect they desire but we must help them by assisting them with any kind of resource they need to adjust back into some sort of normal life. The issue isn’t where or not we can afford a parade but can we afford to give something back to the all the returning Iraq war veterans. I agree with a few of the readers on the points I just made because it makes more sense to help veterans beyond a simple parade.
photo
68Namvet
Sioux, French, German, Jew, American mutt
05:23 PM on 02/04/2012
"If we can afford two wars, we can afford two welcome home parades."

Surely you jest. We could not and did not "afford" two wars. We borrowed money and cut taxes while sending our men and women into harms way. We will be paying interest on those loans for decades to come.

And, just as surely, no one wants to pay to see our service members at their work as we are willing to pay to see football players at their work. We don't want to see the brutality and ugliness of war.

And, just as surely, we should not be encouraging our government to invade and occupy other nations (that have done nothing to our country) by celebrating such actions.

What we should be doing, surely, is taking care of our veterans, providing them with educational opportunities, good paying jobs, healthcare and insuring no veterans wander the streets of America homeless.

But please, let us not celebrate unnecessary unfunded wars. Want to have a war? PAY FOR IT! Raise EVERYONE'S taxes. Have all Americans shoulder the burden! Pass a law that ALL wars must be financed by increased taxes, specifically called a WAR TAX! Include full benefits for returning veterans in all financing! Then, see how quickly we give up fighting unnecessary wars of choice!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wkillpatri
12:12 PM on 02/04/2012
This is a tough one. Many opposing posts make sense. So let me raise a different issue that perhaps everyone can agree on.

For the first time in history, Iraq War veterans were treated like corporate employees by Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld. Young, often naive vets were given a chance to "sell" their lifetime VA Health Benefits for a one-time payment of $15,000. Many, unable to conceive of such a vast sum, and equally unable to understand the value of lifetime health care, agreed. The darker underbelly? Discharge officers had quotas and pressured retiring vets to sell their benefits, assuring them, "You'll get a job with far better benefits than the VA offers."

My grandson was one of these young men -- only he didn't sign the document. He didn't sell his VA benefits. But when he needed them, suffering from hearing loss, shrapnel in one eye and PTSD, the VA kept saying, "You sold your benefits. Go away."

Not until family members with the resources to fight the military got involved was our grandson granted access to VA health care. To date, the military has not been able to provide a copy of the document he signed selling his benefits. Out of all his discharge documents, that ONE page was missing. Odd, eh?

Parade or no parade, it's time to forgive those coerced benefit sales payments and restore health care to ALL veterans.
12:01 PM on 02/04/2012
It seems to me that these vets, once they are out of service, would be perfect for kicking off a decade of "nation building" here in the USA. Haven't they been working in small groups, being flexible and creative with only basic supplies? Couldn't they coordinate thousands of small infrastructure repairs and improvements across the country, and oversee and mentor countless of other workers at the same time? Aren't they prime candidates for doing mass retrofitting and "greening" projects?

Is this perhaps going on already in a small and/or unpublicized way?
08:48 AM on 02/04/2012
Agree, I'd attend and we should also support these vets in other ways (jobs, etc.) for making the ultimate sacrifice whether you were for the war or against it(as I was).
photo
ewldest
I don't care "whose" war it is - end it now
08:37 AM on 02/04/2012
I respect our returning troops for their dedication and service, and I believe we owe them medical care, jobs, compensation, that is only just.
But the fact remains that an offensive war to aquire profit fo multinational corporations is nothing to celebrate, it is a shame to the history of this nation.
Once the military-industrial government committed itself to a program of neocolonial world dominance, all honor and glory for the military evaporated.
We once had a 'citizens army.' Now we have a government supported mercenary army.
Let Exxon-Mobile and Haliburton throw the parades - I want none of it.
photo
Dredd
Our government is a wartocracy.
08:11 AM on 02/04/2012
Paul,

I think that depends on whether war is an art or a disease. We already have more people in military marching bands than are in the foreign service working for diplomacy. Wartocracy?

http://blogdredd.blogspot.com/2011/06/is-war-art-or-is-war-disease.html
photo
RollaJones
Is there a Robespierre in the house?
08:06 AM on 02/04/2012
A parade would be a nice start.

But it does go against the strategy pursued by Bush-Cheney (and to a lesser extent, Obama), i.e. to hide the war from the American people.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
Free your mind and your ass will follow.
07:57 AM on 02/04/2012
Parades are of the utmost importantance in hard economic times.
07:30 AM on 02/04/2012
Something less hollow would be more meaningful for the actual vets-- expanded funding for the VA, college tuition, jobs, at federal government program scale and direction not out-sourced to private sector skm artists.
photo
bd7769
I am so often right, that I am a progressive
07:27 AM on 02/04/2012
A parade would be nice and I happy to see that the veterans today are being treated far better than the generation before them
Linda from Deerfield
Paying attention
07:17 AM on 02/04/2012
I'm so tickled / impressed / moved by St. Louis having that parade. It would have been so easy to say that there's not enough money right now. There was never enough money or support to have a war, either, but that didn't stop politicians.

St. Louis is one of those places with character that makes me wonder why somebody smart who appreciates the value of money doesn't start something there instead of adding to the crowd and outrageous real estate prices in New York, and then another one, then another one, ,,,, until eventually there would not be the excuse that there's nothing there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
be practical
I'll Never Understand the GOP Mind
06:40 AM on 02/04/2012
The Vets do get a parade, every year in most towns and cities in the United States of America. It's called Veterans Day, and in fact it is a holiday that many people get as a day off from work. To equate that 1 city in the whole of the USA has a parade to celebrate the win of their favorite team is a slap at our veterans is absolutely ludicrous. Parties are always held when units return to their home base and are open to the public to join in the celebration. Maybe more people should join in those celebrations.
06:10 AM on 02/04/2012
I think that military veterans who have risked life and limb for us are much more deserving of a parade than a bunch of overpaid prima donnas who take time out from their careers advertising leaisure wear to throw a ball around a field.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dzadzey
Afflicting the comfortable
05:54 AM on 02/04/2012
In the past, ticker tape parades for our returning troops were symbolic of the shared sacrifice on the part of the whole country for the war effort. In the case of Iraq and Afghanistan, Americans weren't asked, or even expected to make any sacrifices on the part of the war effort and in support of our troops. We were told, at the outset, to go shopping by the Bush administration. What shared sacrifice then, would be symbolized by a ticker tape parade.

The sacrifices made during the war in Iraq as well as in Afghanistan...past and current...have been born solely by the men and women of our active duty military, the National Guard, and reservists as well as their families. Thus, a ticker tape parade seems...inadequate. We can find better, more meaningful tributes to those who made such great sacrifices and to the families of those who made the ultimate sacrifice.