More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paula Crossfield

GET UPDATES FROM Paula Crossfield
 

Controversial Animal Drug at the Heart of International Trade Dispute

Posted: 01/25/2012 10:25 am

According to recent numbers, 80 percent of antibiotics on the market today are being administered to animals, much of which is given non-therapeutically to promote growth. A new report today on msnbc.com by Helena Bottemiller reveals that ractopamine hydrochloride, a growth promoting drug, has become the focus of an international trade dispute concerning its potential effects on human health.

"Although few Americans outside of the livestock industry have ever heard of ractopamine, the drug is controversial," Bottemiller writes. "Fed to an estimated 60 to 80 percent of pigs in the United States, it has sickened or killed more of them than any other livestock drug on the market, Food and Drug Administration records show. Cattle and turkeys have also suffered high numbers of illnesses from the drug."

According to the story, USDA meat inspectors have reported an increase in "downer pigs"-livestock that is unable to walk-who have been fed ractopamine. On Monday, the Supreme Court unanimously voted down a California ban on "downer" livestock being used in the food supply, on the basis of a federal preemption.

Bottemiller explains that ractopomine acts like a stress hormone, increasing heart rate and relaxing blood vessels. Its use in livestock agriculture produces up to 10 percent more meat, raising profits $2 per head. Though the drug has not been considered for human use, it is administered up until slaughter, and minute traces have been found in meat.

While these amounts have not exceeded the threshold the FDA has deemed safe, there is no allowance for the drug in the E.U. and China, where 70 percent of the world's pork is consumed, and where the drug is currently banned. Acceptance of meat from animals raised on ractopamine in world markets has become a focus for U.S. trade officials. Bottemiller writes: "Resolving the impasse is now a top agricultural trade priority for the Obama administration, which is trying to boost exports and help revive the economy."

At the heart of the trade dispute lies questions about the safety of the drug. Elanco, the maker of ractopamine, sold under the name Paylean, conducted the studies considered before approval of the drug in 2000, and has reported "no averse effects were observed for any treatments." However, within a few years of the drug's approval, the FDA received hundreds of reports from farmers, veterinarians, and USDA inspectors of sickened pigs.

Now the issue remains at an impasse at the U.N.'s Codex Alimentarius Commission, which sets global food-safety guidelines. The commission has sought to set a standard for residue levels of ractopamine in meat. With such standards in place, Washington would be in a position to challenge countries with bans on ractopamine at the World Trade Organization. China and the E.U. are the main countries blocking the residue limit at Codex. In China, organ meats, which contain the highest traces of the drug, are popular fare, and in the E.U. officials do not want to risk public outcry by importing meat raised with growth-promoting drugs, which are illegal there.

Bottemiller reported this story in conjunction with the Food & Environment Reporting Network, the first and only independent, non-profit news organization that produces investigative journalism in the critically underreported areas of food, agriculture, and environmental health. This is the second story of the Food & Environment Reporting Network, previous stories can be found here. [Full disclosure: I am the Managing Editor of that venture.]

You can read the full report here at MSNBC.com. You can also find additional reporting here on testing of ractopamine as well as more details about the process underway at Codex here on the Food & Environment Reporting Network's Web site.

Originally published on Civil Eats

 

Follow Paula Crossfield on Twitter: www.twitter.com/civileater

According to recent numbers, 80 percent of antibiotics on the market today are being administered to animals, much of which is given non-therapeutically to promote growth. A new report today on msnbc...
According to recent numbers, 80 percent of antibiotics on the market today are being administered to animals, much of which is given non-therapeutically to promote growth. A new report today on msnbc...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 50
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
adamben
yes i said yes i will yes
11:26 AM on 01/30/2012
paula, i've noticed that a lot of respondents here have opted out of the food industrial complex because of these additives, and many more. it would be interesting for you, and huff in general, to put some perspective on the non-hormone/non-antibiotic industry. say, things like how its been growing over the past few years? i know i can google it but i, and many others, would expect it in an article about the majority of our food supply being poisoned and what people are doing about it, briefly. just sayin'.
photo
OdinsEye
Korean-Latino cop and combat vet
10:32 PM on 01/28/2012
"According to recent numbers, 80 percent of antibiotics on the market today are being administered to animals, much of which is given non-therapeutically to promote growth. A new report today on msnbc.com by Helena Bottemiller reveals that ractopamine hydrochloride"

Ractopamine hydrochloride is not an antibiotic.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stonesoup
12:31 PM on 01/28/2012
I am seriously considering become a vegetarian, but I know that all animal products are contaminated so I need to really become a vegan. I think I will start with vegetarian first and learn to eat right and then slowly progress. I have been on an only fish and chicken for the past month and I have officially lost 15 lbs. I am totally changing my eating habits and it's about time. I feel better than I have in several years and I am going to continue this for the rest of my life, however long that may be. I am 63. And, I want to add that I am so thankful to Huffington Post for being hear for all to read and make good decisions about everything. It has made me a very aware person.
09:56 AM on 01/29/2012
Good for you, Stonesoup. You will be healthier and feel so much better in the near future if you make these diet changes. My family has been vegetarian for around 14 years and vegan for 4 years and we are very healthy. Being a vegan is the fountain of youth as far as I am concerned. My unsolicited advice to you is to be sure and incorporate lots of raw veggies and fruits (smoothies in the AM are great!). Don't overcompensate with too many soy products (we did that in the beginning). Learn to love the process of chopping veggies and preparing your own food, rather than going the processed route. Best of luck to you!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stonesoup
12:14 PM on 01/30/2012
Thanks for the advice. I am working on it now.
09:56 AM on 01/27/2012
seems the FDA is working for the global profiteers, and all this time I thought they were to protect the citizens from those profiteers
photo
Proximate Cause
The GOP helps those that don't need it!
05:30 PM on 01/26/2012
Poisoning Americans for Profit! Brought to you by the US Congress and the USDA! Wake up people!!!!
05:21 PM on 01/26/2012
we need to update our food standards -- I'm always appalled by the crap we Americans are subjected to in our food.
03:55 PM on 01/26/2012
I no longer eat processed food of any kind as I consider it all toxic. What little meat I get is from local farmers and is grass fed and free range. The FDA is a joke they are owned and operated by big food and big pharma. Their standard is food companies can put whatever they want in our food and if you eat it and dont drop dead within minutes they deem it safe. It took me two years to change my eating and life style but I don't for a minute regret it. I feel better than i ever have lost 60 pounds and have blood pressure and cholestrol of a teenager. Not bad for a 62 year old.
Until we as a society realize what the food and drug companie are doing to us and our kids they will not change. When people stop buying their poisonous garbage they will stop producing it.
02:24 AM on 01/27/2012
Good for you! I think that pharmaceutical companies are in bed with the industrial food complex - they are so good at developing drugs to fix symptoms, not the cause. That's up to us and how we use our $$. See Jamie Oliver on TED -- he hits the nail right on the head. Buy local.
Kali03
Obama/Biden 2012
08:27 PM on 01/27/2012
First fan, and I am with you on the eating plan. I don't touch meat that is not local and free-range.
02:27 PM on 01/26/2012
Went vegan. Don't have to deal with this s**t but I hope they keep the tainted manure off veggie fields, too.

If you don't think the above stuff in the article is scary, then you also need to read up on L-Cysteine (dough conditioner in most commercial breads - made of ground up duck/chicken feathers or commonly "human hair." google.) or you need to research what is actually in Gelatin (disgusting) and or in your hot dog or the chemicals, antibiotics, vaccines and diseases that are actually legally allowed in the majority of your milk, eggs and meat. Scientific American, The NY Times, The entire U.N.'s body of ag scientists and more and more respected entities out there are writing of the benefits of a plant based diet - for human health, the environment and for freak's sake, the animals who right now suffer endlessly and terribly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidMG
OWS Senior Citizen
01:53 PM on 01/26/2012
It was the antibiotics (and other feed additives) in meat that led my nutritionist wife and myself to become vegetarians and to write about it. Our cookbook, "American Wholefoods Cuisime" has come to be considered the 'vegetarian Joy of Cooking"and has been making people happy since 1983.
photo
Redhunteur
If I damn yer POV will u turn the other cheek?
03:10 AM on 01/30/2012
Hopefully your typo didn't make the cover.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidMG
OWS Senior Citizen
07:51 AM on 01/30/2012
We are thankful for copy editors. (Actually, in one printing of the NAL edition of 'American Wholefoods Cuisine' thousands of copies have our name misspelled on the hardcover.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidMG
OWS Senior Citizen
08:30 AM on 01/31/2012
You might want to know that they removed your reply to my below comment. I can't figure out why. You might want to check. My reply was: When my publisher showed it to me he said " I would be angry." Actually, with all the stupid things they had done over the years I just laughed.
01:49 PM on 01/26/2012
Forks over knives! This is scary stuff!
12:34 PM on 01/26/2012
I won't buy any dairy product unless it is labeled rBHT free. I don't buy meat unless it's labeled hormone and antibiotic free. I buy organic produce when it's economically reasonable. Once I went rBHT- and antibiotic- free, I lost nearly 1/2" fat off my entire body, sleep better and haven't been sick for over two years.

And those labels on rBHT free foods that say "the FDA research shows there is no difference between rBHT free and rBHT injected milk" is a load of crap. Maybe if Monsanto didn't practically own the FDA and USDA, we could get this garbage out of our food supply. Canada was smart - they rejected rBHT years ago, same with the EU.
photo
Halsey
"There is a price to pay for speaking the truth. T
11:12 AM on 01/26/2012
Think..80% of antibiotics go into edible animals. THIS in a country where people want anti-biotics for every little cold and still 80% go into animals..to get an extra $2 a head. Domesticated, gentle beasts existing in horrid conditions and some euphemistically called "downer" animals. Is a burger really worth that? WTF is wrong with our country that we use something even the CHINESE won't allow?..and face it, China is not on the forefront of animal kindness or food safety. If this scares them..hellooo. I don't WANT obama to convince the EU or Asia to buy this crap; it's shaming. Better WE raise our standards of care and feeding and if beef/pork cost a little more..so be it..eat less.. What a corrupt mess huge-agri and huge Pharma have created..and we tsk tsk and do nothing.
If you can, try to support local, small and humane farmers. I know urban dwellers have a much harder time..and those at the poverty level are stuck. Everything "we" do..seems to indicate a self-imposed end to what was a potentially wonderful land. Power, money, greed inevitably lead to corruption.
08:33 AM on 01/26/2012
Come on guys, even the Chinese ban this drug. Take control of your food.
Oginikwe
I think therefore I'm dangerous
02:41 AM on 01/26/2012
Eating agri-business meat is playing Russian roulette with a fork.
photo
mlaiuppa
Pres. Sarcasm Society. Like we need your approval.
09:26 PM on 01/25/2012
I suppose Bill Gates is going to tell us nothing wrong with eating these downer animals too.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JScott
John Galt's last name is McGuffin-Smithee
11:00 AM on 01/26/2012
Remember that line from Judge Dredd-'eat recycled food'
Or from that other movie-'soylent green is people'

BG has taken the kool aid.
photo
adamben
yes i said yes i will yes
11:56 AM on 01/30/2012
i think i missed something; what does bill gates have to do with downer animals?