iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dr. Peggy Drexler

GET UPDATES FROM Dr. Peggy Drexler
 

The Scarlet Manifesto: The Rise of the Adulterous Woman

Posted: 10/13/2012 9:40 am

Back when I was in college, there were rules for the female students. We had to wear skirts to meals. Curfew was strict, broken under threat of expulsion -- or worse. Naturally, boys were not allowed into our rooms. These maxims were designed to "protect" us women -- we who were so easily taken advantage of, so at risk of being romantically duped -- not to mention reinforce the idea that we were expected to act in a certain way.

Which was fine. In those days, many girls, and their parents, thought of college as a means to a husband. (So many of my contemporaries who achieved that end are now divorced, some more than once.) Now, although finding a mate at college is still common -- and there are certainly Ivy League graduates who decide to make their lives as mothers and homemakers -- it's no longer what secondary education is about. Away at college, young people live in dorms in which male and female students share common areas, bathrooms, and even, at times, sleeping rooms. Sex is not necessarily part of the equation. And when it is? Well, we are, after all, talking about adults. But the bigger shift is one of perception: If there is any sort of expectation of "propriety," it is imposed on the guys as much as on the girls.

After years of raising boys to think more like women and women to think more like men, we are now witnessing a generation of adults who fall less into traditional gender roles than ever before. Today's young men, as a whole, are more sensitive than their fathers were. The women are more independent than their mothers. There's been a trickle-up effect: The older generations are witnessing these changes, these freedoms, as they show up in their children and grandchildren, causing a culture-wide shift that transcends age.

Research supports this: According to a study conducted earlier this year by biological anthropologist Dr. Helen Fisher for the dating site Match.com, women are getting less traditional about relationships. Men, interestingly, are getting more so. Men want marriage, babies, and stability; women want personal space and regular nights out with friends. More poignantly, women view their sexuality based on notions of what they want to do, versus what they're told they should do.

In my work and in my life, I had been hearing more from women who were both having extramarital affairs and actively seeking them out. While they weren't necessarily proud of their actions, neither were they ashamed. Unlike men, whose cheating often follows an impulse, these women had considered their affairs. They had reasons for them. Like Samantha, who was married to -- and co-owner of a thriving business with -- her high school sweetheart. Twelve years into the marriage, she felt as if she'd wed her brother. Heavy with responsibility for work and kids, she embarked on an affair with a married friend. She had no intention of leaving her spouse, to whom she felt extremely attached, and knew the fling would never leave his wife, either. But Samantha saw the sex as a way to reconnect with herself after a mastectomy and breast reconstruction, and find the attention she craved after long days of kowtowing to clients, making sure her husband's shirts came back from the cleaners, and ministering to her kids' needs.

And there were others: The 30-something model-turned-soccer mom whose sex life with her provider husband was mediocre at best, nonexistent at worse. Out of the bedroom, they were exceedingly compatible: Both loved to ski and travel, and shared similar core values on religion and raising children. But because he refused to talk about the issue, she was left feeling marginal and deprived. And lonely. When we last spoke, she was looking for a satisfying sexual partner, though didn't know how to go about meeting him. Or the 28-year-old rising ad executive whose husband longed for a family while she was still eagerly working 80-hour weeks. Sex was no less important to her. But her reasons for wanting it were different than his. When she ended up engaging in an affair with an unmarried and similarly career-driven co-worker ten years her senior, she barely surprised herself.

Interestingly, studies corroborated what I was seeing. In a study published last year in the Archives of Sexual Behavior, researchers at the Kinsey Institute found that it's no longer true that men cheat far more often than women do. In fact, they found that women and men cheat at about the same rate -- though, yes, for different reasons. Women tended to cheat because they were unhappy in a relationship or felt their partner didn't hold similar sexual beliefs. For men, the biggest factor was sexual excitement. That is, women are far choosier about why, and with whom, they cheat.

A different study, this one conducted by AARP, found that divorce among couples married for a long time is up -- at a time when divorce in general is down. The bigger surprise: Wives are now more likely to initiate the split than husbands. In two out of every three marriages longer than 20 years, it's the woman who leaves the man. This particular study did not look at third party involvement. But the takeaway is the same: Women have more choices, and they are acting on them.

That's not to say the rise of the adulterous woman signals a victory in the battle between the sexes, and that men have replaced women as the faithful, as it were, underdogs. It's not a contest, and there's no winner. What's 'good' for women needn't be 'bad' for men. The media have been inclined to point out shifts between the sexes, as they arise, in a gender competitive way: Women Are the New Men, The End of Men, and so forth. But what really is happening is that we're finally seeing -- through the last incontrovertible boundary, at least for women, that of the marriage bond -- a society that is more equal than ever before. Women are becoming more confident about making choices. Sexual exploration -- and, yes, at times infidelity -- is just one example.

Is this a good thing? It sure is. For these women, marriage is important, but it doesn't define them. If it doesn't last, they won't be destroyed. For a woman, the ability to realize that she's not happy -- and she's going to do something about it, rather than be passive and accept whatever comes -- is empowering. She is claiming her right to feel fulfilled in relationships and sex, regardless of what society may expect of her.

When I was growing up, my mother talked to me about marriage and fidelity as something absolute and inviolable. Back then, a woman who cheated truly was an outcast; whatever reasons she might have had mattered not at all. But the far more common scenario back then was that of the unsatisfied wife being left behind as her husband moved on sexually or emotionally, or both.

I am not advocating for being unfaithful. Good sex is important but so is being in a solid, trusting relationship. Choices can't be impulsive or made haphazardly; they need to come out of who you are and what you desire and how you aim to conduct your life.

But, of course, women these days already know this.

 
 
 

Follow Dr. Peggy Drexler on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drpeggydrexler

FOLLOW WOMEN
Back when I was in college, there were rules for the female students. We had to wear skirts to meals. Curfew was strict, broken under threat of expulsion -- or worse. Naturally, boys were not allowed ...
Back when I was in college, there were rules for the female students. We had to wear skirts to meals. Curfew was strict, broken under threat of expulsion -- or worse. Naturally, boys were not allowed ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,109
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (25 total)
03:21 AM on 10/31/2012
No one talks about how people are more selfish than ever. That's what it all boils down to.
05:09 AM on 10/24/2012
"Is this a good thing? It sure is. "

"I am not advocating for being unfaithful. Good sex is important but so is being in a solid, trusting relationship."

"Advocating" definition has changed? Perhaps "not endorsing unfaithfulness" is more suitable phrase, but even there the article seems to straddling the fence by promoting this choice as a form of empowerment.
05:07 PM on 10/18/2012
This IS serious, not a joke. Every time someone does something "wrong", everyone asks the question WHY. The author is merely giving an explanation, an answer to the question WHY. Thank you, Dr. Drexler.
08:42 AM on 10/17/2012
This cannot be serious, gotta be a joke.
03:09 PM on 10/21/2012
Oh it's serious, about a serious as the erosion of society.
08:38 AM on 10/17/2012
its all fun and games until someone comes home with Herpes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:50 AM on 10/17/2012
"The 30-something model-turned-soccer mom whose sex life with her provider husband was mediocre at best"

Probably the highlight of the whole piece. Provider husband.
photo
NobleTry
More ground is in the middle than at either end.
07:01 PM on 10/20/2012
It's how women look at men. Providers.

On the obverse side of the coin, how do men look at women? As takers.
05:40 AM on 10/17/2012
I like how the author paints cheating men as just mindlessly driven by sexual desire while trying to excuse female infidelity with inane excuses about being neglected.
03:24 AM on 10/17/2012
Ah I see that the cultural Marxis...ahem gendered studies scholars don't even hide their desire to destroy western society any more.
10:52 PM on 10/16/2012
So men are horrible for cheating, but we should celebrate that women cheat? I know Dr. Drexler says at the end she is not advocating cheating, but she spends the entire article celebrating female cheating. So, if a man's wife has a child with another man it's fine because she is empowering herself?
photo
NobleTry
More ground is in the middle than at either end.
07:03 PM on 10/20/2012
You hit the nail on the head but you don't know it. When you write: "I know Dr. Drexler says at the end she is not advocating cheating, but she spends the entire article celebrating female cheating."

This is called having your cake and eating it, too.

Question: What do women want?
Answer: They don't know; and they want men to guess.
03:17 PM on 10/21/2012
Yes, because the child support system will make her husband support the child; God forbid he should question his wife's fidelity in orer to get out of supporting another child.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Vicki Larson
Journalist, mom, always questioning
05:40 PM on 10/16/2012
I'm not sure why the fact that women now appear to be cheating as much as men are is to be celebrated or that it has anything to do with "empowering women" (God, I hate that word!) or realizing that marriage doesn't define women. You can be empowered and not defined by being a Mrs. and still not cheat — or am I missing something?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Voltairine
Courtesy counts
01:36 PM on 10/16/2012
Is it adultery if both partners agree to have their sexual needs satisfied outside of the marriage? I'm curious about open relationships that remain strong over the years. This article discusses adultery where the partners have been deceptive. Seems there could be another way ... well, life's not a Heinlein novel, so probably not.
01:15 PM on 10/16/2012
Aurora1920. I care not about adulterous women (or men either)--didn't read past first paragraph of the article--but PLEASE DON'T HAVE ANY CHILDREN! !
12:19 PM on 10/16/2012
Just another reason the marriage rate is dropping like a stone. Why bother if adultery is so rampant and accepted.

Better to stay single and not face a asset split down the road when someone gets bored with being married.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:45 AM on 10/17/2012
Split down the middle is probably the best case scenario for a man.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glory Mooncalled
10:53 AM on 10/16/2012
So you believe that no women ever cheated until recently? Have you ever wondered why the Jewish religion is passed down from the maternal line? In ancient Greece, why did everyone want to win the hand of Helen and the throne of Sparta? Because you could always prove your mother but the father, well, that's a crap shoot. And that ain't new. And a doctor of psychology and gender should darn well know this.
photo
Terence Manuel
Talk sense to a fool and he calls you foolish.
03:41 PM on 10/18/2012
Even today, it is estimated as high as 1 in 5 kids born into marriages have biological fathers other than the husband. Do not know how reliable that stat is though.
photo
NobleTry
More ground is in the middle than at either end.
07:10 PM on 10/20/2012
The stats are all over the place on that one, Terence. But you raise a good point. I remember one study I read. It was actually a blood typing experiment done in a small school somewhere in England, I think. Well, the science teacher was taking little blood samples and then sending his students home to get blood samples of both their "mom" and their "dad". That way, the teacher said, he could tell which blood type the student should have, based on his or her parents. Well, you guessed it, after awhile the teacher had to stop the blood typing because there were so many students who had "dads" that could not possibly be their dads, based on blood typing.

You girls.....
10:14 AM on 10/16/2012
That read like an elaborate justification on the part of Dr. Drexler here. Hmm...