More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peniel E. Joseph

GET UPDATES FROM Peniel E. Joseph
 

Give 'Em Hell, Barry!': Political Rebirth and the Obama White House

Posted: 09/09/11 07:43 PM ET

President Obama gave a brilliant, potentially career saving, speech on Thursday night that unveiled a $450 billion dollar stimulus package designed as a last-ditch effort to boost America's faltering economy and his increasingly dismal re-election hopes. It was a remarkable display of passion, tough talk, and a fighting spirit and combative tone that, to the chagrin of increasing numbers of liberals, has been largely missing from Obama's White House. A president elected on the combined strength of dazzling oratory and improbable personal biography has proved more deft at saving his political career in times of great crisis, such as the now iconic "race speech" from March 2008, rather than crafting a bold vision of American democracy in the 21st century.

Part of Obama's current political troubles reflects a larger crisis in American democracy. Some of the president's most vocal critics on the left, such as Tavis Smiley and Cornel West, have excoriated the White House for ignoring the poor and turning a blind eye to the increasing misery facing the black community, whose unemployment rate has reached depression era levels in many areas. Environmentalists point to Obama's capitulation to corporate lobbyists and oil companies as an unexpected betrayal while unions are still waiting for the president to offer more than symbolic signs of robust support. Obama defenders, including MSNBC host Reverend Al Sharpton and public intellectual Melissa Harris-Perry, highlight the unprecedented levels of assault waged against the nation's first black president while urging the White House to adopt a more robust posture of social and economic justice advocacy.

African-Americans, despite the administration's relative silence on issues of mass incarceration and the ongoing crisis of institutional racism, have remained Obama's staunchest supporters. This counterintuitive posture owes as much to feeling of racial pride and solidarity as to a sophisticated understanding of the racial animus behind the Tea Party phenomenon, right-wing activists and powerbrokers such as the Koch brothers, and Republican politicians who have allowed a major American political party to be hijacked by a small group of extremists unconcerned about the responsibility of governing.

How did it come to this? Fourteen months before the 2012 presidential election, Obama's approval rating hovers at 43 percent, Republicans are emboldened by their debt-ceiling victory, and millions who were inspired to join our democratic process in 2008 stand disappointed and disillusioned. Eulogies for the Obama presidency are already being discussed in major newspapers, political blogs, and cable news shows. The standard allegations suggest that Obama lacks the three B's: Boldness, Brains, and Balls. Liberals have pointed to the president's timidity after the election and reluctance to confront right-wing politicians while Fox News conservatives have questioned the Harvard Law School graduate's intellectual credentials as part of bizarre strategy to bolster the political chances of Texas Governor Rick Perry.

Obama's proposed American Jobs Acts may be too little to late, but at least hints at the bold, New Deal inspired programs that many of his supporters expected in the wake of his watershed presidential election. But the very pragmatism that helped Obama win the presidency has helped to undermine his administration, both in terms of public policy and political optics. Obama's efforts to become a Democratic counterpart to Ronald Reagan have faltered due to the end of the style of legislative bi-partisanship and political comity that allowed the "Gipper" to become a transformative president during the 1980s. Bill Clinton massaged the dawn of the new Gingrich-led Republican partisanship in the 1990s by embracing welfare reform and benefiting from the unexpected dotcom bubble that created millions of new jobs. Part of the president's current predicament stems from Tea Party politics that insist on political purity at the expense of governing compromise. At least some of this is the result of unspoken discomfort surrounding the president's racial identity.

Obama's own political timidity, almost religious belief in the intelligence and political sophistication of elite experts, and cautious governing philosophy has helped undermine an administration that has struggled to articulate a coherent vision for the nation's future. Obama concluded the toughest and most combative political speech he has given as president by channeling a spirit of American optimism that helped get him elected. After acknowledging the difficult years that the country has recently faced, he looked toward the future, noting that Americans were "tougher than the times we live in" and "bigger than our politics have been," only lacking in the inspiration to meet our current historical reckoning. If last night's speech was a start, we have a long collective journey ahead of us.

 
President Obama gave a brilliant, potentially career saving, speech on Thursday night that unveiled a $450 billion dollar stimulus package designed as a last-ditch effort to boost America's faltering ...
President Obama gave a brilliant, potentially career saving, speech on Thursday night that unveiled a $450 billion dollar stimulus package designed as a last-ditch effort to boost America's faltering ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 39
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:07 AM on 09/12/2011
Didn't the GOP do the same thing when they were compaigning to win the house? Well they also made speeches and campaigned on jobs jobs jobs and haven't done anything. They are not even willing to work the President. Seems to me this is not the President's doing, the GOP haven't came with any plans to created jobs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wayne the pain
11:17 AM on 09/11/2011
Obama gave his jobs speech, nothing changes! The Republicans are talking nicer, that have read the polls. McConnell and Boehner are giving him nothing! Going to Cantors district and telling the crowd to text, call, email, was lame beyond belief. The only thing he said that the Republicans will agree too are cuts in taxes, Medicare, and Social Security! He is banking on a backlash against the Republicans if they don't give him a few crumbs! The backlash is going to be against him in November 2012 for four years of selling out his base and doing nothing he promised in 2008!
photo
Felix99
Born to be mild!!!!
08:08 PM on 09/28/2011
Sad but true, Wayne!!! Has he finally put on his Walking boots to get the work done, or knee pads for more folding in front of the opposition!!! I do hope he's putting on big boots!!!!!!
11:04 AM on 09/11/2011
All the hype, all the build up, and President Obama proposed more of the same.
Where's the Hope and Change you promised?
Oh yeah, I forgot, that was in a prior campain speech.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:17 AM on 09/11/2011
Too late Mr. President. Too late Democrats. You lost me. The political process is rigged and needs to be brought to accountability by revolt.
photo
colah
Sometimes I sit & think. Sometimes I just sit.
07:23 AM on 09/14/2011
Go ahead.
Be stupid.
(I doubt you ever supported Obama in the 1st place)
There are plenty of realists left that will take your place.
See how you "feel" after you cast a losing vote for ___________ (fill in the generic republicant here).
BTW.
Lots of other people have already posted these same Karl Rove talking points for the tea bagging right.
You are way late.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:16 PM on 09/14/2011
Comparing my sentiments to Karl Rove (that rogue) is obnoxious. The current two parties are bought and sold at the top. As hard as we worked for OB and the dems over these years, we didn't get a return. We got a national capital overrun by special interests (not just "influenced" but bought and sold). I don't imagine you have your head in the sand about this matter.

As for Obama, the platform he ran on and the social network he created were on track. He just decided later that his base could be abused like this without political repercussion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:19 PM on 09/14/2011
Looking at all of your previous posts, you have a serious chip on your shoulder but you have no positive contribution to anything. The American revolution doesn't need you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarkInEugene
A blasphemy a day keeps the deities away.
08:23 PM on 09/10/2011
The volleys coming from the right have been increasing since the beginning of this year. I only hope that the American people can see that the smear campaign is in full swing right now. The collusion and strategic political warfare during the 24 months leading up to an election in this country, now more than ever, supersedes all the pressing problems faced by this country.

The lying, cheating, subverting, sabotaging, maligning, gerrymandering, and disenfranchisement has begun. I'm sorry if I sound cynical, but at my age, I know better. Never have I seen such viciousness in politics like I do today. Mark my word, the priority is winning, and the billion dollar corporate sponsored campaigns are positioning themselves to grab the reins of power to ultimately enrich their supporters. The needs of the country are secondary to whatever is required to win!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GirlInNYC
A girl in NYC
11:41 PM on 09/10/2011
Perfectly put, MarkInEugene.
09:36 PM on 09/11/2011
Obviously "MarkinEugene".....you weren't around when NIXON was President. What is happening with Obama is a boat ride compared to those times. In addition we didn't have the internet, yet what was done in the media of the time would blow your mind.
Oh yeah....so the poor Pres is suffering from "disenfranchisement"....??? Hey....a former community organizer who barely got his seat warm as a freshman Senator is suddenly thrust into the big leagues. And since the "State of the Union" (a boldfaced campaign speech like all the ones since !!!)...he wants More Cowbell......and the wealth of the top 15 % of Americans and corporate profits would fund the Federal Government less than a regular workweek.
AND if it WEREN'T for CORPORATIONS you would not have your computer with which to make your comments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gryphon87
Tax The Rich at 91%
06:19 PM on 09/12/2011
This comment brought to you by ExxonMobile's Citizen-to-Tool program.
P.S. If it weren't for government you wouldn't have 911, the infrastructure to log onto this comment section, or the expensive Medical Care you are no doubt receiving which is funded by my tax dollars. And since I'm a patriotic liberal and not a bigoted conservative, to you I say, you're welcome.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
buc
10:10 AM on 09/13/2011
Paul Brewer...I was around during that time and believe me, there's no comparison to the hell this President has endured, and his family...Stop trying to sugar coat the despicable attitude of our racist society, it's people like you that give power to such craziness. And in closing you should really leave that stuff alone, it make's you sound silly...
06:26 PM on 09/10/2011
Sorry, I can't get thrilled at a speech anymore. Not when Obama has been in office for two years and managed to do little except appease the Republicans and give them their every wish, almost before they can articulate it themselves. Between Obama and the ineffectual Harry Reid, we have extended Bush era tax cuts which resulted in the so-called deficit crisis, which resulted in the beginnings of the dismantling of the social security system by underfunding it by 2% so far this year and proposing increasing the under funding of it by up to 50% once Congress passes (hopefully not) Obama's Thursday plan. This underfunding of social security and linking it to the General Fund -- which was explicitly not to happen when social security was conceived -- begins the realization of the Republicans' ultimate dream of killing FDR's great innovation. Great job, Obama -- not.
photo
Felix99
Born to be mild!!!!
08:13 PM on 09/28/2011
Great post, JHKH!!! Sad but true!!!
photo
massjim
Dem? Repub? Is there a difference?
03:02 PM on 09/10/2011
If Americans were confident about their government and the future, they might spend that extra few dollars in their paycheck from the payroll tax cut. Consumer confidence is at record lows though, expect them to save it and pay down debt.
02:44 PM on 09/10/2011
As a progressive critic of the president I really appreciate this thoughtful and nuanced picture and especially your description of the president's ideology and governing philosophy from which I believe his problems stems but I also recognize what he has been up against from the democratic primaries onward. I would only to add that I find his continued support for the doomed mission in Afghanistan at great cost in lives and money while he puts medicare and medicaid on the chopping block is a very bad idea. Thanks very much for your intelligent analysis.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donasanya
01:46 PM on 09/10/2011
I'll be first to admit he gave a good speech - as he always does. But I need more than a speech to believe him. Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. I've been fooled one too many times.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
The Lone Stranger
Yes, I am a lousy typist. OK!
01:36 PM on 09/10/2011
Obamas actual problem is not his lack of support from the GOP. His actual problem is that he is doing the wrong things.

By constantly trying to appease his enemies (the GOP) Obama continues to let them frame issues even when that framework has been revealed to be a complete sham. Tax cuts do not create jobs. If they did we 'd have zero unemploym­­ent right now.

Cutting government spending also does nothing to create jobs.

The correct medicine for what ails our nation is that taxes need to go up on the very rich and they need to go up a lot. I think they need to go as high as 35 % which for some of the very richest means their taxes would experience a 7-fold increase since they are only paying 5%. Admittedly many are paying 10% but this still is far less than what the rest of us pay when you include payroll taxes, as well you should.

With these increased tax revenues we can have serious ramped up short term spending to the tune of a about a trillion to 1.5 trillion dollars of extra spending. The key is you don't spend it on permanent government programs, like Bush and his new Homeland Securuty apparatus, and for god sake you don't blow it on tax cuts. You spend it on goods and services and you insist that these be produced here in the USA. made by private American businesses.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
buc
10:13 AM on 09/13/2011
The Lone Stranger, You're no longer alone...Spot on with your write up...
12:43 PM on 09/10/2011
The author got one thing right: This is about saving Obama's political career and nothing more. We have learned that much about the man.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cheryl tobin
Alpha Dog with my pack!
12:56 PM on 09/10/2011
Obama fooled me once with his rousing speeches he makes during campaign season.
01:16 PM on 09/10/2011
He is an excellent speech giver. I used to believe what he said, but have learned to be less trusting with him.
photo
studioh!
just.words.
12:15 PM on 09/10/2011
can't fault the man for trying; you surely can fault him for NOT trying.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
The Lone Stranger
Yes, I am a lousy typist. OK!
01:37 PM on 09/10/2011
he hasn't been trying.
11:56 AM on 09/10/2011
"Obama's efforts to become a Democratic counterpart to Ronald Reagan . . . "

There was no such effort. Obama asked the Republicans what he could do and capitulated. Can anyone imagine Reagan asking Tip O'Neil, friendly relationship or not, how much he could ask for in legislation? Reagan would laugh anyone who suggested that out of the room.

When Obama made no serious attempt (and I include HCR in that) to keep any of the big bold campaign promises that led people to believe he would be a transformative president, he doomed himself. He knows Americans don't respect wimps and that Republicans don't compromise. He surely knows that bullies who win only increase their contempt for the victim and bully them more mercilessly.

You can't ask for respect. You have to earn it. And he didn't.

He gave a great speech Tuesday that should have been given by Feb 09 and followed up on while he had the power to accomplish at least something. Now Obama doesn't have the power to do anything legislative.

Yes, we must throw out the Republicans who play with our country and people as if we are their personal political tools.

But we must also replace the President who has proven himself completely incapable of accomplishing anything and too timid or obtuse to fight for anything. We can't survive 4 more years of stalemate in Congress and passivity and capitulation in the WH.
photo
colah
Sometimes I sit & think. Sometimes I just sit.
10:22 AM on 09/10/2011
Jump on the wagon with the rest of the cry-babys.
Just like the republicants, you would never be satisfied with what Obama has done, seeing as how you placed more expectations on him than jeebus himself.
Your whining solves nothing & I doubt you win any "awards" for this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sharkcellar
support your local library.
12:53 PM on 09/10/2011
Oh, zip it.
lightnessandjoy
Is micro-bio a new disease?
03:58 PM on 09/10/2011
Because he hasn't done much of anything.
photo
aacme
My micro-bio is on a strict need-to-know basis.
05:20 AM on 09/10/2011
Throwing a too-little too-late bone to the people who actually put him there isn't going to save Obama's bacon. What might save his bacon is Perry.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
buc
10:18 AM on 09/13/2011
aacme, I don't know about that Perry thing...There's some sick people in this country, remember they put W in the big house. What make you think they wouldn't put P in also?
photo
Felix99
Born to be mild!!!!
08:23 PM on 09/28/2011
True, true, true, Buc!!! Some posters still believe you need to speak some form of English, and have a measure of civility, to be electable!!!!