More

Peter Clothier

Peter Clothier

Posted: May 28, 2009 06:20 PM

Are We Stupid?


In one corner of my mind, I have been watching the threat of the imminent meltdown of the California economy. What was once amongst the most thriving of states with an enviable infrastructure and an education system to rival any other is now approaching bankruptcy. Our once-vaunted system of schools, colleges and universities, already sinking low in comparison to other states, is now facing massive budget cuts that will ensure its further deterioration. Hospitals and medical clinics will likely be forced to cut back on already inadequate staff and services. The poor, the unemployed, the homeless will have fewer resources to protect them. Children, in this affluent society we have created, will go hungry every day because their pitiful lunch programs will be cut.

So the question is, are we stupid? The taxpayer's revolt that started in the 1970s and brought us Ronald Reagan has now become an unquestioned axiom of our political culture. Our Schwarzenegger was elected on the promise that he would never raise taxes. He would listen to "the people" and obey their wishes. Now that "the people" have roundly rejected his last hope for budgetary salvation, he swears that he will listen again, and start making cuts into the last lean meat of surviving social programs.

Friends, we have brought this on ourselves. We have chosen to believe, collectively, those who assured us that we could have all the services we need without paying for them. We have indulged in an absurd system of propositions and initiatives that purports to give voice to the people, without educating those same people to understand the simple connection between what we pay for and what we can expect to receive. We have kidded ourselves that this is true democracy, when it is in fact no better than mob rule. We have allowed greed and prejudice to substitute for reason and sane policy.

Democracy is nothing without education. The capacity for critical thought and responsible, sometimes selfless action is its most essential ingredient. The ability to see further than the day after tomorrow is also a useful attribute. Sheer, blind, thoughtless, self-first stupidity is a poison that has slowly been killing it here in California and throughout the country. I had hopes, with the election of our new president, to have finally perceived a glimmer of electoral intelligence. Now I wonder if I was simply kidding myself again.

In one corner of my mind, I have been watching the threat of the imminent meltdown of the California economy. What was once amongst the most thriving of states with an enviable infrastructure and an ...
In one corner of my mind, I have been watching the threat of the imminent meltdown of the California economy. What was once amongst the most thriving of states with an enviable infrastructure and an ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
missviv
04:19 PM on 05/29/2009
I caught myself watching "Idiocracy" on Comedy Central last week. The movie takes place in a future in which everyone is so stupid that they water plants with gatorade-like liquid, thus creating a massive famine, and all of civilization is going down the drain because everyone is too stupid, selfish and lazy... and sad thing is, it's not that much of an exaggeration. :(
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mobedda
12:43 PM on 05/29/2009
Hear hear. Does anyone remember why they moved to CA? It had nothing to do with the taxes, did it? You'll miss your green state when it's eroding into the ocean.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
allenosuno
Just me being myself
06:57 PM on 05/31/2009
Don't worry, what happens to our green state today will happen to yours tomorrow.....you're next.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:56 AM on 05/29/2009
Twitter has me spoiled. Now after about 100 words into an article, I get restless and move to the next headline.
photo
vincefango
Savior of Lost Kittens and Generally Thirsty
01:33 PM on 05/29/2009
I believe you just answered the author's question.
11:05 AM on 05/29/2009
Most of the problem in California, and the country, is not amount in taxes the individual pays, but the amount corporations pay. In 1954, corporations paid around 40-45% of the tax burden, compare this to the 7% percent of that burden they pay now. Politicians always run a platform of lowering taxes and the electorate falls for it every time. They don't seem to understand the fact that they are not talking about the average taxpayer, they are talking about the rich and corporate elite. Corporations use the commons at a much higher percentage than the individual, therefore they should pay a higher share of the taxes that support those commons. The higher courts out clogged with corporate cases, the trucks that tear up the roadways are corporate trucks, the people that work for the corporations, at inadequate wages, were educated in the public school system, they all drive to work on public roads. All of these services are used, and profited on by the corporations more than any individual. Yet when the bill comes due individual taxpayers get stuck paying for over 90% of the burden. So next time some one says corporate taxes in the U.S. are some of the highest in the world at a top marginal rate of 35%, understand thats the rate before all the tax right offs and subsidies they receive courtesy of the individual taxpayer.
09:58 AM on 05/29/2009
TANSTAAFL
12:47 AM on 05/29/2009
We Californians still pay some of the highest taxes in any state-- property tax and state income and sales taxes, but we have some of the worst schools and social services. Where does the money go? We have excellent prisons-- & lots of them! Spending on the CA Corrections system has grown to rival all other categories of expense.
If Californians were smart, they would give up on imprisoning non-violent drug offenders. End the prohibition on marijuana and institute treatment programs for all other drug offenses.
The one good thing that might come out of this budget catastrophe is that even stupid as we are, we might have no choice but to end the prohibition and close some prisons.
09:49 AM on 05/30/2009
I did note federal and state taxes were low compared to other countries. The property taxes were outrageous. We were shelling out 8k per year for a crappy two bedroom bungalow in San Mateo. I was even more floored when I found out that little to none of that money went to local public education coffers.

What I could not understand was unnatural real estate gains - tax free, out of this world, inflated gains based on a huge supply and demand misalignment. I am surprised the state government did not clue into this...people got rich quickly while the going was good....the gains were unnatural....sort of like .com valuations and tech stock share prices. Taxing real estate gains might have helped keep prices relatively in check and reduced unnatural borrowing practices that mortgage brokers and finance people got drunk on. Taxing gains could have solved two issues....funding down stream deficit spending and keeping people out of lending trouble...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:17 AM on 05/29/2009
Well Peter, we can start by releasing ALL non-violent drug convicts, decriminalize drugs, and start taxing the heII out of marijuana like 10% per ounce. Viola, there is at least half of our budget deficit.
photo
ranchero42
...not bound to please thee with my answer...
11:00 PM on 05/28/2009
Are we stupid? We ARE stupid if we believe Ronald Reagan has any more answers. The Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, on the other hand, may have part of the answer. Republican supporters paid for it. Everybody knows Republicans LOVE prisons. They think it helps solve their problems to hammer on that whole law-and-order thing. Fair enough. California needs housing for prisoners, the Library is probably designed to withstand a shockwave from a close nuclear airburst (it's just that important a building) so let's set up some cots and bring in the prisoners. It's not like we asked Ronnie to do anything else for us recently.
08:32 PM on 05/28/2009
We will certainly have to wise up to the fact that money cannot be everything. As it is, money is necessary to survive, and on the flip side, money can get you anything regardless of the actual cost. If I want to burn down a rainforest to raise cattle, I can do that if I have enough money. It doesn't matter that trees are the lungs of the planet or that thousands of varieties of animal life depend on the rainforest or that we need oxygen to breathe--all that matters is money. Until now. The way we've been doing things is breaking down, giving us the chance to reevaluate what actually has value and how best to use our resources. It is also freeing us from the endless fleecing by financial giants who, in their greed, have brought the end of this system much faster than if fair and reasonable practices had been in place. How long would it have lasted without usury, without the massive interest rates, endless fees, and ballooning mortgages? Probably a lot longer. Maybe it's for the best.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:48 PM on 05/28/2009
Yes We Is.